He was the original re-animator

Mckenzie .Latham Which made him perfect for the role.

That's the same reason that I love John Noble's voice as the Scarecrow

That's the same reason that I love John Noble's voice as the Scarecrow

Captain_Hat my opinion on it is I like John noble his voice is awesome by far my favorite I u can like whatever u want I won't judge its just my opinion like if u agree with Me people if u want though u don't haft 2 😄

Well... Croc did screw him up pretty bad... You see his face? That's his real face, sewn together via surgery. That's literally the best they could do.

Blatantly Heroic ya but I'm on about his voice , not how he looks like

Danny Flannery Ah, so you're the type to stay strictly to a specific conversation topic, gotcha. XD But damn... his face got ate up bad.

Blatantly Heroic That's his mask. It was torn up badly, hanging loosely. But he did get his face fucked up, revealing lots of his teeth.

Apparently, he has a tube in his throat.

No he could read blah blah blah and make it sound epic

I like Dino Andrande better idk why :/

IT IS PERFECTION!!!!!!!!!

+Austin Agar It is fear.

+Its_only_martin Too bad the game wasn't.

Simon Petrikov I didn't mind it, besides the forced batmobile sequences and the painfully obvious identity of the arkham knight I liked it

Its_only_martin I didn't like the boss fights in the game. Of course topping the Mr. Freeze fight would be hard, but not impossible. And also the two things you mentioned I didn't like. I thought the character was going to be someone you could go back into the previous games and see and say "Ohhh, so he is the one." but no. I also developed a different plot in my head for Scarecrow that I liked better.

He has a tube in his throat?

+MakaveliTheDon yeah he does

+MakaveliTheDon It was stated by random thugs that Scarecrow underwent facial reconstruction surgery following his mauling by Killer Croc at the end of Arkham Asylum, and that he most likely needed a respiratory bypass.

+Shawn McDaniel he does not laugh as much as in asylum anymore though

+starfuckerification People with tubes in their throat usually tend to laugh less

***** WRONG! detective the answer to the question would be John noble

1: Jeffrey Combs 2: Christopher S. Field Nobody else comes close. Cilian Murphy just doesn't sound scary and John Noble is too monologue-happy.

well john noble being too monologue happy would be more so a flaw with the script of arkham knight than the voice actor.

bigfatcarp93 👌👌👌👌

same

Of course he didn't talk the same because in universe his vocal cords had been damaged due to him being mauled by Croc and out of universe it was because of the voice actor change from Dino Andrade to John Noble. And he didn't act the same because he was more pissed off and ruthless and blamed Batman for what Croc did to him so he was determined to utterly break him and unmask him in front of the world before killing him. Apart from the speeches there were no similarities between Scarecrow in Knight and Strange in City. He wasn't a whole new character who just happened to be called Scarecrow. He was the same Scarecrow character. Hus character wasn't switched up. It was developed. No one in the game had any reaction to him coming back? What about the people he forced to evacuate Gotham? Andrade was a good Scarecrow but John Noble's is better.

Xehanort10 When I say that no one on the game reacted to him coming back, I don't mean that no one reacted at all. I mean that no one was surprised that he had survived his encounter with Croc. That whole ordeal was barely mentioned or acknowledged. And to be clear, I do like John Noble as Scarecrow. I just would have preferred him in some other Batman media, since Dino's version was already established in the Arkham universe. I get what Rocksteady was going for with him in Arkham Knight, and in many ways I really do enjoy it. But the whole "vocal chords damaged" thing? That was never told to us in the game. That's just what the fanbase (me included) has come up with since there's no real explanation. I don't see it as interesting character development. I see it as bad storytelling. If you enjoyed it though man, don't let me take that away from you. I just have my own opinion on this. And to me I think Dino Andrade got kinda screwed over in this whole thing. And that's just stupid.

The inconsistencies with the Arkhamverse Scarecrow are a bit weird but I think John Noble o his own could make for a fantastic Scarecrow voice actor outside of the Arkham verse

Bruce Deliso I agree

If u like him check out his work as the Worker of secrets

I assume being in killer cross digestive system would do that to you

True.

+J BAIN croc mauled scarecrow, he survived but got fucked up

Kitsey752 very fucked up

Kitsey752 I think that for a while, they were going for the angle of him being eaten because of the hole in crocs stomach in Arkham City

100% agree

Jeffrey combs sounds like he could voice zsass

Nikolai Kravchenko zsasz

They were for kids, they did not want to scare them

Alexander Cook I 100% agree :D

Agreed.

Oh god, I may have had a hand in creating the real life version of Scarecrow! D:

MrFirewolf18 Dammit, what have you done?!?

Aw hell, I gotta go into hidin'! Well hopefully if this does come to pass he'll take me on as one of his goons.

And hopefully not as that one goon that the villain kills/makes an example of. Man, being a henchman is dangerous work if you think about it.

It's only REALLY dangerous if you work for The Joker *shivers*

Peyton Oliver I Second that!

I prefer his Arkham Knight appearance. I also prefer John Noble's voice but Combs is great also.

iReece4498 John Noble's has very similar vibes to Combs where he's quiet and creepy sounding and yeah that design is amazing.

ShadowofBatman The way Combs and Noble portray Scarecrow should be the way Scarecrow is portrayed all the time.

iReece4498 I agree.

Dino's voice didn't fit scarecrow at all

+Ted Brodhead Dino was an amazing cackling version of Scarecrow, and he's my personal favorite, as his sections in Asylum were absolutely terrifying and a thrill to experience. I'm fine with Noble's version for what it is, which is a more calm and calculating villain, but we already got that kind of main villain with Hugo Strange in City. And the whole switch-up of Scarecrow's character is just plain jarring and disrespectful. The Arkhamverse Scarecrow was already established, and fans like me had been anticipating his epic return with all the Easter eggs and clues in City, but the payoff for his return to the franchise was non-existent. No one in the game had any reaction to him coming back, so it was like his ambiguous death never even happened. And he didn't act or talk the same either, so really he was a whole new character that happened to also be called Scarecrow. I'm so happy Dino Andrade is back for Arkham Underworld. He finally gets to lend his amazing voice back to Scarecrow.

+Colton Phillips scarecrow is not supposed to be crazy

+Colton Phillips they need to keep a timeline with the voice actors after scarecrow was mauled by croc it changed his appearance and voice he could only play him in a prequel

+Ted Brodhead If they really wanted to keep that timeline consistent, then in Knight there would have been way more of a reference to him being mauled by Croc. Barely anyone in the game even reacts to his return like its a big deal, they act like he was always this way. And maybe to you Scarecrow is supposed to be a more calm demeanored villain, that's fine, you can have your opinion. But someone like me who really loved Dino's version were just jarred of because of how different he was from his established version in Asylum. And the same can be said for Oracle and Gordon. Both voice actors were suddenly changed seemingly only because Rocksteady wanted a "new artistic style." It's straight up disrespectful to the characters, the voice actors, and the fans.

Alabaster Stone murphy is not even close

Love both of them. Also Cillian is sexy... Another reason to love him as Scarecrow. I find Noble to be sexy too. Dino is awesome too. And the rest is not so bad.

@@barry2349 fuck off stupid

He looks like that creepy guy on steroids!

Agreed, when I heard that Scarecrow was going to be the main antagonist of Arkham Knight, I was disappointed…but then I heard John Noble's voice and I was amazed!!!

+Billy Siravo yes

+NICKatron MC Why was you disappointed about Scarecrow?

Andrade didn't fit scarecrow at all

@@linkheroofspiritsakatrains4812 I know I’m replying to a 4 year old comment but It fit perfectly for scarecrow

@@professorfreeman1648 it’s true

My excuse is that Killer Croc fucked up his voice box. LOL

+Tony Vercetti A lot of people seem fond of that idea.

+Tony Vercetti Which is probably why Scarecrow had to have a respirator attached to his throat.

TheGh0stKiller6 ' I'll never tell my secrets lol

I don't get it

Because in October 2014 the "all who follow" trailer was released

Omega_Gaming Actually it was the E3 demo, but it was still an early trailer.

+TheGenerationWest you used the batman arkham knight trailers to make the batman arkham knight one I know your secret/trick

It's always a pleasant surprise to find a comment with my exact thoughts on his ^^

Very true. Dino Andrade is a very underated Scarecrow. That guy nailed it. So maniacal. John Noble is like you said more like Hugo Strange with a Scarecrow outfit. You took the words right out of my mouth.

Same here ! 😁

The Joker John Noble is cool too, but Dino Andrade's laugh sends shivers down my spine every time.

Jeffrey is more insane John is more menacing

That signature is forged! Many batman fans prefer Dino Andrade

@@Zug8415 ye Dino Andrade better and John Noble too old.

Beware the Chaos Bringer!

+piplup2009 Cillian Murphy and Jeffery Combs I think nailed that most. I also like the "psychiatrist gone mad" Hannibal Lector version of Scarecrow best.

Megatron:Megatron belongs to nobody! Unicron: Perhaps I misjudged you... Proceed, on your way to oblivion.

Jeff Combs ftw!

***** I like John Noble, but I think he has too much of a 'cartoonish villain' voice.

Really his voice didn't fit scarecrow

Mine too!!!!

he would just end up doing Green Goblin again 😔

+pak _ tra (PAKTRA) yeah your right......Scarcrow is too small a role!! Dafoe needs to play Joker!!

That fat American Nation yep