frrrr like this is amazing

thought its same director from off the record. the cinematography, transitions and camerawork are similar

AMAZING.

I think Gaeul already knew the mission before hand the rest of the girls find out with the ticket. i think thats why they are technically protecting Gaeul? When I tell you.. I'm too invested in this anime. I am too invested in this anime..

YESSSS

in my opinion it seems more like the witches were performing some type of spell to affect the real ive, but gaeul isn't affected so she goes and gets the wand or what ever to stop it

Or maybe the evil IVE was doing some ritual to turn normal ive to evil side, in the pool scene, other girls in the water try to make Gaeul join them but Gaeul find out and run away, then Gaeul come to the forbidden garden and steal the wand to stop the ritual and turn normal IVE to Fairy/Magic girls so they can fight back.

@@cawewe oh yeah, i read it on twitter that when the dark ive casting spell, it affect the real ive via water. gaeul isnt in the water so shes not affect by it. she ran bcs she saw the real ive seems off when theyre in the water

And thats why they probably were chanting some incantation. The moment they noticed the wand was gone that's when the IVE members probably went back to normal

Nahhhh u wrong

i actually like this MV analysis for Accendio by @/aidollze. it's actually makes so much sense: The music video motif is mirror and reflections which can be seen in DOPPELGANGER and WATER themes. "ACCENDIO" is a singular of "Accendium" which mean "a setting on fire", following the motif, just as there is a dark and good version of IVE the mirror opposite of FIRE is WATER. WATER is the MAIN DOMAIN of these entities, dark!Yujin creates a portal to a place to fight magic!IVE where it's surrounded by an endless ocean. The MV begins with Leeseo ascending from the WATER, as if she was being 'REBORN' into a different person and Wonyoung urges Gaeul to join them. They all look at Gaeul with indifference like she's a prey, but Gaeul notices that something is wrong with the water and these are not her friends. As soon as they notice that she knows their identities, they hide in their domain. Rei counts the seconds to undo the possession since they've been caught and needs to flee. They can't complete their motive if someone knows their real identities. The girls seem to return to normal after leaving the water. Not having any recollection of being possessed, the girls look for Gaeul as she just disappeared from their perspective. The DOPPELGANGERS' motive is to replace the real IVE girls. There may be two versions but in front of a MIRROR, only one is a REAL person and the other is just a REFLECTION. Gaeul sets out to find a solution to protect themselves and sees dark!IVE summoning an item that will grant their desires. This magic wand turns them into magic girls, now their hearts are shielded and protected, but it's only effective as long as they have the wand in their possession. So the fight begins... Just as magic!IVE has a time limit to get the magic force, it's the same for dark!IVE who has a limit of until when they can keep their human forms. magic!IVE couldn't gain the magic force but dark!IVE also couldn't get the magic wand. And so they return to their original forms (rats). Since the limit time passed, the wand has no bearer hence teleports to the ocean (it's domain). This wand only grants the desire of the bearer. Since children are pure and innocent, they possess no threat to their safety and no longer need to protect themselves. The magic fades and the IVE girls return to normal. ---------------------------------------- There's also someone pointed out that the MV might be the reinterpretation of korean folktale 'The Mouse that Ate Fingernails' where the mice ate the man's fingernails and stole his shadow and life.

@@MrAresxy07 he's right

i actually like this MV analysis for Accendio by @/aidollze. it's actually makes so much sense: The music video motif is mirror and reflections which can be seen in DOPPELGANGER and WATER themes. "ACCENDIO" is a singular of "Accendium" which mean "a setting on fire", following the motif, just as there is a dark and good version of IVE the mirror opposite of FIRE is WATER. WATER is the MAIN DOMAIN of these entities, dark!Yujin creates a portal to a place to fight magic!IVE where it's surrounded by an endless ocean. The MV begins with Leeseo ascending from the WATER, as if she was being 'REBORN' into a different person and Wonyoung urges Gaeul to join them. They all look at Gaeul with indifference like she's a prey, but Gaeul notices that something is wrong with the water and these are not her friends. As soon as they notice that she knows their identities, they hide in their domain. Rei counts the seconds to undo the possession since they've been caught and needs to flee. They can't complete their motive if someone knows their real identities. The girls seem to return to normal after leaving the water. Not having any recollection of being possessed, the girls look for Gaeul as she just disappeared from their perspective. The DOPPELGANGERS' motive is to replace the real IVE girls. There may be two versions but in front of a MIRROR, only one is a REAL person and the other is just a REFLECTION. Gaeul sets out to find a solution to protect themselves and sees dark!IVE summoning an item that will grant their desires. This magic wand turns them into magic girls, now their hearts are shielded and protected, but it's only effective as long as they have the wand in their possession. So the fight begins... Just as magic!IVE has a time limit to get the magic force, it's the same for dark!IVE who has a limit of until when they can keep their human forms. magic!IVE couldn't gain the magic force but dark!IVE also couldn't get the magic wand. And so they return to their original forms (rats). Since the limit time passed, the wand has no bearer hence teleports to the ocean (it's domain). This wand only grants the desire of the bearer. Since children are pure and innocent, they possess no threat to their safety and no longer need to protect themselves. The magic fades and the IVE girls return to normal. ---------------------------------------- There's also someone pointed out that the MV might be the reinterpretation of korean folktale 'The Mouse that Ate Fingernails' where the mice ate the man's fingernails and stole his shadow and life.

I like your theory!! Imo I think that in Either Way the room w/ the mirror was a portal between both worlds and the baddies decided to cross over because in OTR they seem to be enjoying the new world, doing rituals/spells and good IVE can notice it. They failed because they weren’t the real baddies, since they turned into rats and in the Baddies MV they are identified as cat humans + Yujin having cat eyes, gaeul+rei being inside a cat tree, i’m gonna go with they can only be cats imo and now with the wand disappearing they have to get it before the real baddies find it.

@@BETO00 okayyyy I like it I like it :D

Dude you are the only one that makes sense 😂😂 Yes apparently at the start Ive girls were already taken over by the rats/evil IVE. NOW i understand

😂😂