Haley didn't cover or sing the song. She painted that song as a beautiful portrait. Stunning.

Hailey Reinhart: “You’re so very special” Jamel: “It’s my birthday” 3:50

They shot this all on the first take. She's amazing.

And she came in 3rd! YES THIRD in American Idol. One of the all time best singers. And i saw her live and she sang like that for over 2 hours!!! Should be a legend

Lol!!! I don’t know why...but I get such a kick out of watching guys review Haley’s version of Creep! I t never fails...she does something to every red blooded man with her natural sexiness. Your reaction was the cutest!

Haley has one of the MOST incredible voices I've ever heard. And she emotes so well it's like listening to audio drama - an amazing performer. I would definitely watch the her with PMJ performing 'Seven Nation Army' or 'Oops I Did It Again' It's like being transported back in time.

She did that in one take!

It is criminal that this girl isn’t crowned the world’s greatest singer!

One of the best things to come out of American Idol.

Thank you for reacting to this. Haley Reinhart is such an underrated vocalist. She is amazing!!

that feeling your feeling is what falling in love is. embrace it!

Yeah man you're gonna have to do some more post modern jukebox. They take popular songs and turn them into classic vintage versions of them and it's always a good ass performance especially with Haley. If you're wanting to react to more Haley I'd have to recommend both Seven Nation Army and Oops I Did it Again. They're both amazing in their own ways. With Seven Nation Army being in a New Orleans Dirge style and Oops I Did it Again in the style of Marilyn Monroe

Postmodern Jukebox is the creation of Scott Bradlee, genius arranger/pianist. PMJ tours the WORLD to packed houses. They'll be in Australia/New Zealand this fall Scott has an ensemble of musicians/singers that flow in and out depending on their schedules and he arranges songs that highlight their skills PMJ has 4m subs on KZfaq and PMJ produces its own EP/Albums PLEASE react to MORGAN JAMES cover of "MAPS" as a 70's Motown song BE PREPARED!!

I am so glad you found her!!! One word PHENOMENAL!!! Do Seven Nation Army next! You will love her even more!!👍👍👍👍👍

I thought Haley Reinhardt was special when I first heard her on America’s got talent several years ago...she slayed “House of the Rising Sun” on that show

I don't know how often I've heard this cover, and it still sends shivers through my entire body

Haley is great. In addition to the wonderful voice she is a fantastic performer. I was lucky enough to see her in concert back in April, fantastic.

Postmodern Jukebox takes current songs and transforms them into different classic styles. The ladies of PMJ are all amazing ... Haley, Morgan James, Aubrey Logan to name three stellar singers. Soloists rotate through. You've seen Morgan. Check out Aubrey Logan's version of "Can't Touch This" and her originals like "Pity Party". The girl is a phenomenal singer / writer / trombonist (yes, the trombone). You're in for a fun ride.

First of All: Happy Birthday+ Best wishes from Hungary. Haley Reinhart is one of the most talented singer i've ever seen. The Band is the Postmodern Jukebox is a group of amazing musicians and singers.

Best Haley Reinhart: Seven Nation Army Baby It's You These Boots Are Made for Walking The Letter Let's Start Time of The Season Sunny Afternoon White Rabbit Free

Beautiful Haley Reinhart what an artist with vocals straight out of heaven

I watch Hundreds of Reactions and Dozens of THIS Particular Song, as it`s so Good...Your reaction was THE BEST OF ALL My Reactions...My new Number 1 reactor. Cool JJ

PMJ's "My Heart Will Go On" is such a great flip of a song you've heard a million times.

Omg I knew you would love this. I’ve never clicked on anything so fast lol. I don’t know why more people don’t react to her. She’s a beast. Happy birthday :)

Jamal. Haley can sing it ALL. From Janis Joplin to Jazz !!!!!!!!! She is as what you’ve heard so far AMAZING.

I want an out-of-the-way table with a martini and cigar and just bask in her talent. 😎 Oh, and happy (belated) birthday. 😊

HAPPY Birthday Jamel. You finally found Haley. Any performance by her on PMJ. She is amazing. Do not know why she is not a huge star. There are hundreds of video's of PMJ on you tube sung in many different genres, and by many artists.

Here's a new comment... This lady has got it going on with that voice🎉. Been listening to her for years

I love this version. A masterpiece!!

Haley 's body while singing is like liquid gold framing every note she sings~!!

Check out Morgan James cover of Aerosmith's "Dream On." On Postmodern cover of the song. You will be blown away by her voice range. She is the Blond along with Haley Reinhart in "Its All About The Base." Peace!

When she was on American Idol I didn't like her but when she covered Can't Help Falling In Love, I realized how talented she was. Happy birthday!

What a terrific birthday present. Her voice soars.

YOU DISCOVERED PMJ ! ! ! It's a rabbit hole, get out now, while you still can!

Haley Reinhart has a tremendous voice, and is a key singer for Postmodern. She hits it out of the park here more so then when she sang as part of a trio in "Its All About The Base." She is awesome! Great reaction video...

Excellent! I could never have imagined a Radiohead song played like a bluesy jazz number. The brass section was brilliant and gave it a bit of Stax soul feel.

She's amazing. That voice is that of a goddess

Haley can sing anything. Rock, jazz, country, blues--she's does it all. When the world opens up again--u should try to see her live. She even sounds better live--if u can believe it. (Also, go see Steely Dan live too)

I love how she makes you dance with her from the screen

Every time I see this amazing version of creep, I have to have a long cold shower

Out of all the incredible stuff Postmodern Jukebox has put out this one still gives me chills more than any other. Astounding performance.

Another amazing performer !!!!!!!!!!!!! you have a great site here!!!!!

Yay!!! What a great birthday gift 🎁 !! Happiest birthday to you!!! Amazing rendition and reaction!

The Oxford online dictionary has officially inserted this video as the definition for "sultry."

easily one of my favorites

The fact Haley didn't win AI was a f-ing injustice

This is one of the best covers of Creep.

I've watched a LOT.of people reacting to this video and It always turns into Haley doing a "You never heard me before? TODAY. YOU. GON' LEARN." As always, love your reaction!

Happy Birthday to you my friend..you picked the right song that you will always remember where and what you were doing!!!!Judy D.

They are just amazing, you have so much to react from them 😊 Great reaction 💕💕 Happy BD, all the best to you 🍸🍸

Great performance. As mentioned below, you should put her rendition of "Seven Nation Army" on your to do list ASAP!

Just think if she had won Idol we might've missed this. We all win here!👏😘🌹

I really love the way this guy reacts.. His reaction is so funny. Love this song too!.

That is the definition of Sultry.

I just watched a couple of your Janis Joplin videos and was thinking nobody puts that much soul and emotion into a song like Janis did. Then I saw Haley and was blown away. A lot of my favorite musicians are dying off now. It's nice to have a new one that will outlive me.

One of the most talented artists to come from American Idol.

Every time I hear her voice I think of smokes, absinthe and New Orleans. Her voice takes you on one of those journeys that means long nights and half recalled memories and a tattoo you didn't have when you started.

Absolutely love her cover and your reaction to it.

"That was a great performance, and she didn't even move." Jamal, my friend, you are, without a doubt, a critic, a reviewer extraordinaire. The perfect summation of what Haley did on this video of this song. To repeat your critic: "That was a great performance, AND SHE DIDN'T EVEN MOVE." No one, ever, could say it better.

When you are just lovin' it and say "it's my birthday!", I just lost it. LOL

"wwwooowwwWWW....WOW!" Ha ha. I thought that too when I first heard this. :)

that was a perfect birthday present! i love your reaction :) i can see you can feel music and inhuman specifics. feels good to see someone feels the pecularities the way you feel it, thank you!

Haley does an amazing Seven Nation Army and Oops I Did It Again....also PMJ All About That Bass...is fire!!

Absolutely Fabulous!!!

WOW

Happy Happy Birthday Big Guy🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂🌹

I can see that gave you a happy, happy birthday! She is great , she was one of my favorite American Idol contestant

Haley is such a versatile singer and has much more to offer than just her Post Modern Jukebox performances. Check out Blue, Bennie and the Jets, and What Is and What Should Never Be from her American Idol performances. Also HIGHLY recommended is her cover of Jefferson Airplane's "White Rabbit." Grace Slick would be proud and you're going to love it!

She made me feel like I’m 2 years old and she’s my mother singing me a lullaby that was beautiful

Happy Birthday Jamel... and your reactions always make my days like if they were my Birthday... ! 👍✅😎

The first song I heard her do was on American Idol. It was I'm YOUR BABY TONIGHT she had great boldness to sing Whitney but she pulled it off and then some.

And that beautiful voice is packed into the most gorgeous 5 foot nothing person you'll ever meet!! She is amazing! Check out her self-published album Lo-Fi Soul...your heart and soul will melt!

She is special. And Happy Birthday!

HAPPY BIRTHDAY!😉😂😊 You are going to love Postmodern Jukebox.

Happy belated birthday, Man! I'm jealous that you first saw this video on your birthday because it's such a great gift! If you love the song Creep, I bet you would also enjoy the Creep - Radiohead FUNK Cover! (by Scary Pockets- a group that does funk versions of popular songs). Singer India Carney is amazing in it! Great reactions!!!

This is one of the best and sexiest renditions of this songs I’ve heard. She reminds me of Amy Weinhouse.

HAHAHAHA!!!! When you went "It's my birthday!" LOL!

Just amazing!

You made my day. Greetings for you and your family from Amsterdam.

Other very good PMJ covers: Thriller All About That Bass Hey Ya We Can’t Stop these are all in different genres and singers they are all amazing!

That voice!

Haley Reinhardt is one of the best American singers period.

I could most definitely see you in the Jazz club just jamming out to her on stage. You seem to be the perfect fit for the audience. This arrangement makes me feel like I should be in the lounge listening too!

Happy Birthday J! She is a lot better to listen to and to look at than some chain smoking dude from Indonesia. lol

her voice gives me goosebumps

You found another great one! Excellent variety on your channel. Many reactors get stuck in a few genres and their channel becomes stale and predictable. I find myself going back to those channels only periodically. You, however, never disappoint! Kudos to you for opening yourself up to variety. Its been a great journey with you.

I'm gonna give it an A+ You're soooo very special!!! Haley

Happy Birthday!! Great video and reaction!

Happy birthday! She was one of my favorites on American Idol. She can sing her face off! You should go back and watch some of her Idol performances, just for your own enjoyment. I recommend "Benny and the Jets" and "House of the Rising Sun". Her father plays guitar, and she grew up going to his gigs, so it's in her blood. By the way, what happened to your thought bubbles? kzfaq.info/get/bejne/gc1yjcqendqZdKs.html

Love your reaction!

Happy, Happy Birthday...

I love Radiohead the original writer/performer of this song but this was amazing. Thank you for this.

Haley can make a diamond sweat with passion, WOW

"Its my birthday." *smiles at camera* 😂😂😂😂😂

FYI, this was recorded live--in ONE TAKE!

She is definitely the talent behind the mic, but PMJ has been selecting various artists, (the ones they feel will pair well with the song they've arranged), to sing various popular songs in the style of the 20's, 30's and 40's. And it's AMAZING! You should check out more of them, for sure! They are amazing! First discovered this at my brother-in-law's wedding reception. It played low in the background of the meal, ya know before the DJ started. And it gave it a nice atmosphere; like an upscale cocktail party. Anyways, half through 'All About That Bass, I realized I recognized the lyrics! I was freaking out. This was the very next song after we figured out what they were doing, and badgered the poor DJ until he found the playlist, which was ALL PMJ, so my hubby & I now listen to them all the time.

All about that bass... Is also greatness

This is something you can't forget.

Damn, Haley and her voice are so freaking sexy! I have been a fan of hers since she was on American Idol years ago.

I am really late to this party, but I just watched another reaction to Miss Haley stealing this song from Radiohead and making them love it, and yours popped up, Jamel. That other reactor said Haley sings this song like Marilyn Munroe looks.