Cummins Repower Roadblock: Our Propeller Shaft is PITTED [Ep. 146]

No video

Cummins Repower Roadblock: Our Propeller Shaft is PITTED [Ep. 146]

Рет қаралды 12,146

Ай бұрын

We hit a bit of a snag with our Cummins Repower project today. Everything was going great until we discovered some propeller shaft issues that might cost us more than we expected. It’s a bit of a curveball, but we’re figuring it out! Come along with us to see how we tackle this bump in the road. #cumminsrepower #boatrefit #propeller
We’re also super excited because we’re only 500 subscribers away from hitting 10,000! When we get there, we’re giving away a Great Canadian Care Package to one lucky winner. Want in on the action? Just join us on Patreon here - we even have a free tier, so everyone can join in. And don’t worry, if you’re already a patron, you’re automatically entered into the contest!
/ onboardtangaroa1969
We’d love it if you could like this video, subscribe to our channel, and ring the notification bell. Every bit of support helps us keep sharing our boat adventures with you.
Thanks for being part of our journey - can’t wait to see you onboard!
➡️To see where it all began - check out this playlist: • A SUPERYACHT ROMANCE -...
Welcome aboard Tangaroa, where we're gearing up for the adventure of a lifetime!
Join us as we prep our aluminum beauty to set sail for Alaska, Siberia, and Japan. Don't miss out on the excitement! Subscribe now and be part of our journey.
If you want to know more about our boat and us - visit our website www.onboardtan..., and hey, why not become a valued crew member on Patreon?
For just $5 - $25 a month, you'll snag an Official Onboard Tangaroa Challenge Coin and an open invite to hop aboard for bevvies and a visit whenever our paths cross. We also have a FREE membership!
Click here to see everything on Patreon: / onboardtangaroa1969
But wait, there's more! We have purchased, tested and reviewed quite a few products during our live onboard Tangaroa. Check out our storefront here to see what we recommend:
kit.co/onboard...
To keep up with our adventure, follow us on Facebook! 📢👍 Join us here: / onboardtangaroa
And here: / onboardtangaroa
Our big journey is coming! We'll go all around places like Alaska, Japan, and more! It's going to be awesome and we encourage everyone to come along for the ride.
From Blaine, Janis, Josh, Izzie, and Maggie the #boatdog
Listen to our cool music here: share.epidemic...
And make your social media awesome with Smarterqueue! Try it here: smarterqueue.c... 🚀
#trawlerlife #boatlife #boatrefit #aluminumboat #aluminumtrawler #liveaboard #boatlife

Пікірлер: 77

@OnboardTangaroa 12 күн бұрын

If you have any questions or comments about what we are doing - make them. Blaine tries to answer every one of them over coffee in the morning. It's kinda his thing and I personally think he enjoys it! So please keep him happy and make a comment.

@lepowell9095 27 күн бұрын

Thanks for sharing your story i truly enjoy it much Love from South Texas

@OnboardTangaroa 27 күн бұрын

Glad you are enjoying it! Plenty more to come. Thanks for watching!

@brucebrown5863 Ай бұрын

You guys are doing a traffic job and I’m learning so much. Thanks You! Bruce

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Glad you are enjoying the videos!

@samfeuster4673 Ай бұрын

Another excellent video. Never heard of twisting the wires. Makes perfect sense.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

It is a very common technique in the controls trade. Works very well for cancelling out EMI. Thanks for watching!

@heatherbella Ай бұрын

Roller the wall! Cheaper and no overspray! (sorry Blaine! 😂)

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

I realize that I have lost this one at this point. 😂

@heatherbella Ай бұрын

@@OnboardTangaroa Ha ha ha! Honestly though sometimes for me it's whichever way I don't have to do the work! :P

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

I feel ya there!

@MsJon52 Ай бұрын

For a good finish it would have to spray, not with cans but air, but the overspray would be a nightmare so the roller gets my vote, lol

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Looks like Janis may be winning this one. 😂

@sethbarnes7608 Ай бұрын

Use an HVLP sprayer, and overspray will be very minimal

@sethbarnes7608 Ай бұрын

Also, when masking things like wiring harnesses, using aluminum foil works well, and it's much easier to remove from such things than sticky masking tape.

@sethbarnes7608 Ай бұрын

Prop glide is very good on the props and rudders

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Thanks for the tips! Will certainly have to try the foil method. Prop glide appears to maybe be a bit less costly?

@sourkraut911 Ай бұрын

Seaboard marine is great. I went with the same fuel filtration system a few years ago. you will not be disappointed.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

The filtration system seems quite nice. I am tempted to add an FS20000 for a third filter for the lubricity benefits but I have not spoken with them about its merits. Seems like anything to increase lubricity in a modern common rail diesel would be worth it. I am so impressed with the fact that Tony has compiled his life of experience with marine diesel and posted it for the world to benefit from. Even experienced techs could learn a thing or two from there. Thanks for watching!

@cornnutzgazpacho-libre3555 Ай бұрын

Sorry Blaine, Rolling the paint "Better". OMG, I'm freaking out 😄Good luck with the shaft.If I had one, I'd give you the shaft.😗

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

I can't believe I am going to have to give this one to Janis. I guess she is right sometimes 🤣. The shaft should be fine until we get the boat funds back up again. We will likely replace two more sections in Alaska. At that point they will all be perfect.

@jeffreygilchrist1330 Ай бұрын

I’m just amazed at how much smaller the two new Cummins engines are, is that how far we’ve come in regards to power to weight and efficiency or am I missing something I see other boats far smaller in size than yours with huge engines about the same vintage just love your channel and the restoration process cheers from Australia

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

It is quite comical really. The new engines are definitely way more efficient in power to weight. Engineering has come a long way and they have figured out how to make engines last even in a much smaller package. Tons of Iron is no longer necessary to make them last. The engines also very much depend on the usage of the boat. Slow displacement or semi-displacement hull forms don't need much power to push. Back in the day when fuel was super cheap the mentality of bigger is better ruled everything. Even the slower boats got massive engines because back then high speed small displacement powerful diesel engines did not exist, at least no to the level they exist today. The Detroits were the go to because they were able to produce great power levels from their displacement. They were yesteryears high speed diesels and they had a really good run. One type of boat I like to point people toward when I am questioned about my sanity is the FPB 78. They are world renowned aluminum world cruisers. Pretty amazing pieces of engineering. They cross oceans easily and there are some really good photos as well as video of them cruising Antarctica. They weigh over 25% more than us, are 3ft wider and are a displacement vessel. They are powered by two 230HP Deere 6.8L common rail diesel engines. At the end of the day its not that the new high speed diesels are too small, its just that the old iron was just too big. Glad you are enjoying the channel!

@MrJgame Ай бұрын

love seaboard marine, they have all the parts for QSB 6.7’s we run! super helpful

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

They definitely have some good stuff and Tony's website is a wealth of information. Thanks for watching!

@kaygeemusic5077 Ай бұрын

Yay Team! You guys are awesome

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

We are pushing pretty hard at this point.

@Graveltrucking Ай бұрын

Your guys boat has had a lot of haywire in its life. What a pain to fix stuff that should have been done properly to start with. Proper electrical system on steel and aluminum boats is a must. Your zincs would be justa cooking then once they are gone the hull is taking the hit. Slow and steady along with a lot of patience when working on an old boat having deep pockets helps lol.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

It's pretty crazy how much crap I have found and removed and I just keep finding more. Just like an old classic car that has gone through multiple owners with no proper maintenance. The engine room wiring is going to be my next big project. So far I have fixed any stray voltage issues or it seems. Hull zincs have lasted for 3.5 years and still look almost new so I am feeling confident there. Slow and steady seems to be working. Definitely no deep pockets here. We have to carefully budget for projects for sure. Would be nice to have more of a budget but we have what we have. Take care!

@MotorboatToo Ай бұрын

Rolling looks way better than spraying, for sure..

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Darn, one more vote for Janis. 😂

@va7dgp Ай бұрын

You make a good radio operator. Twisting your cable getting rid of EMI on your HF SSB radio. :)

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

I do my best! 😁 Thanks!

@rogerreed905 Ай бұрын

Great video team . Are you having a blackwater treatment system . . Till next time . Bye from NZ🍻👋🇳🇿twa

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

We are fortunate to be right next to the washrooms at the yard. They also have great showers. The toilets aboard are only flushed once daily and are used sparingly. So far we haven't filled the tank however I imagine we are getting close. No treatment system yet but I have looked into them. Possibly in the future? Take care!

@mitchhill345 Ай бұрын

Hi Blaine, just wondering why you are having to make up the injector harnesses. Didn't those new Engines come with a complete ECM harness. I could see you having to make up a harness for the power feed to the ECM and the twisted CAN network J1939.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

They did indeed come with harnesses and ecm's but these were originally truck engines from 2012 so the original harnesses were already 12 years old and filthy. They were also based around the truck sensor package which is completely different from what I am running for these now. There are sensors that are no longer needed and a few I will be running that the original engine never had such as turbocharger speed, wideband air/fuel sensor, EGT, etc. I am also running aftermarket laptop programmable ECM's as they allow me to much better integrate the engines into the boat and give me the flexibility to really make the whole system function better as a whole. The new units have user configurable CAN messaging so I can add data to my engine displays that is not typically availabe even on the j1939 stream. I decided it was easier just to build new harnesses. Besides, the new harnesses are considerably "cleaner" than the original harnesses. Thanks for watching!

@mitchhill345 Ай бұрын

Very interesting set up, will you be able to change your HP and torque rating also. No aftertreatment issues will make those Cummins worry free. Will the turbo be a fixed or Variable Geometry. Love watching a channel when people know what there doing like you two. No hack jobs here keep it going strong.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

I can theoretically change anything on the fly however I will be derating these engines for longevity. The main reason for the ecus was purely for flexibility with integration. Turbo will be fixed geometry purely for reliability. It would certainly help to have a variable for a broader efficiency range though. While occasionally I do things as a temporary quick solution. I always get back to it at some point to clean it up. Its never sketchy or unsafe, just sometimes not pretty. Glad you are enjoying the videos!

@dalecostich8794 Ай бұрын

Blaine needs to listen to the Mrs. the bulkhead aerosol approach was a wrong approach.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

I do listen to her.... sometimes🤣. Thanks for watching!

@HankFrederiks Ай бұрын

Man, I wish I lived closer, I'd come lend a hand ( free, of course ) just for the experience.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Its the thought that counts! Thanks for watching!

@kaygeemusic5077 Ай бұрын

Love Maggie!

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

She is awesome!

@Vagabond1209 Ай бұрын

Roll it

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

It looks like Janis is winning this one. 😂 Thanks for the vote.

@JustinTurnerman Ай бұрын

4500$ for 1 shift Wow. Save it if at all possible. Boats ate super expensive. How's the heat at the boat yard. It's crazy hot here in Burnaby. Also Blaine, sorry but Janis won. Roll over spray for that location for sure haha.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

We have saved it for now. It will likely be replace on the next haulout when the budget has recovered a bit. I am getting the feeling Janis has won this one.

@dadejazzba402 Ай бұрын

Power Drum Auger

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Thanks! I didn't even think of that but we have one kicking around somewhere. May be back in Victoria though.

@Adam-en4zm Ай бұрын

So for the shaft with pitting, are you getting a welder to just fill it in? How is Bracewell gonna handle that? Great guys to work with, BTW, only good things to say about them.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

We are going to run it as is. Stainless has a pretty aggressive heat expansion rate. If we tried to fill it there is a good chance it would bend the shaft. Don't want to risk it at this point. Bracewell did fit the new coupler on the starboard shaft though. They were great albeit a bit more expensive than I would have expected.

@Adam-en4zm Ай бұрын

@@OnboardTangaroa Are you worried about the cavities throwing off the balance? I suppose they're so close to the center of rotation it won't matter. Bracewell definitely isn't cheap, that's for sure.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Not really concerned about the balance. As you said the diameter is small, it's not a massive divot and the shaft speed is so slow it really has no effect.

@Adam-en4zm Ай бұрын

@@OnboardTangaroa You're running 3:1 gears on the ZF's, correct?

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Correct. They are 2.957:1 to be exact.

@joshuascally8065 Ай бұрын

Can the pitting in the shaft be welded up and then the shaft stress relieved? Also, did you replace the cutlass bushing in the prop struts? If you have it apart, I highly recommend it.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

I am always super leery about welding on stainless shafts. Stainless has such a huge heat expansion rate it would be very easy to induce a bend in the shaft. We have just taken note of the issue and we will likely be replacing two of the shaft sections on the next haulout. I checked all of the cutless bearings this time around as well as last time and all are in great shape with the exception of the port stern tube cutless. I have already replaced that one this time around. Thanks for watching!

@joshuascally8065 Ай бұрын

Awesome. Sounds like a good plan. I just started following, so some of this is catch-up.

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Enjoy the rest of the videos!

@user-oj1ri5ld3x Ай бұрын

What type of insulation do you but in for nose and for Werther

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

Sadly the insulation in many places is a bit rough on board. We have been experimenting a bit with the pink rigid insulation. Its been ok in the places we have used it so far but it could certainly be better.

@hubertfruzia1803 Ай бұрын

Spray 6 coats

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

You and I seem to be the few in this vote.

@petegreen3024 Ай бұрын

Big mistake with 160 therms. Please 180

@OnboardTangaroa Ай бұрын

One thing that I have noticed over the years of building engines is that if you run a thermostat close to desired operating temps on systems with more than adequate cooling sometimes on transient loading the thermostat may only be partially open and can cause temperature spikes. Running a lower temp thermostat and adjusting water flow to achieve desired temp is a better solution as you are guaranteed the thermostat is fully open at all times. On that note, I'm not sure why Cummins does it but 160 degree thermostats are standard on all new marine QSB 6.7 engines. Maybe they have discovered the same issue.