Custer's Last Stand - from the Lakota perspective

  Рет қаралды 119,275

Smarthistory

Smarthistory

5 жыл бұрын

Henry Oscar One Bull/Tȟatȟáŋka Waŋžíla (Hunkpapa Lakota), Custer's War, c. 1900, 39 x 69 inches (irregular), pigments, ink on muslin (Minneapolis Institute of Art)
A Seeing America video
Speakers: Dr. Jill Ahlberg Yohe, Associate Curator of Native American Art, Minneapolis Institute of Art and Dr. Steven Zucker

Пікірлер: 107
@nicholashenkelman4095
@nicholashenkelman4095 2 жыл бұрын
there used to be a saying about the battle of the Little Big Horn-"there were no survivors"-then I read this by a Native American-"there were survivors, they were called Indians'
@kakuto500
@kakuto500 2 жыл бұрын
Rofl
@jamesyoung6379
@jamesyoung6379 Жыл бұрын
Well yeah...
@marshallfalconberry5187
@marshallfalconberry5187 Жыл бұрын
So here again a white man misrepresents the event when it is billed as the indians version.
@zipperpillow
@zipperpillow Жыл бұрын
Huh. Did you think everyone died? OR were you just not thinking?
@USARonin
@USARonin Жыл бұрын
Many soldiers survived the battle and would live to tell the tale.
@radiantrey
@radiantrey 3 жыл бұрын
"The Indians were camped along the west side of the Big Horn in a flat valley. We saw a dust but did not know what caused it. Some Indians said it was the soldiers coming. The chief saw a flag on a pole on the hill. "The soldiers made a long line and fired into our tepees among our women and children. That was the first we knew of any trouble. The women got their children by the hand and caught up their babies and ran in every direction. "The Indian men got their horses and guns as quick as they could and went after the soldiers. Kicking Bear and Crazy Horse were in the lead. There was thick timber and when they got out of the timber there was where the first of the fight was. "The dust was thick and we could hardly see. We got right among the soldiers and killed a lot with our bows and arrows and tomahawks. Crazy Horse was ahead of all, and he killed a lot of them with his war-club; he pulled them off their horses when they tried to get across the river where the bank was steep. Kicking Bear was right beside him and he killed many too in the water. "This fight was in the upper part of the valley where most of the Indians were camped. It was some of the Reno soldiers that came after us there. It was in 'the day just before dinner when the soldiers attacked us. When we went after them they tried to run into the timber and get over the water where they had left their wagons. The bank was about this high (12 ft. indicated) and steep, and they got off their horses and tried to climb out of the water on their hands and knees, but we killed nearly all of them when they were running through the woods and in the water. The ones that got across the river and up the hill dug holes and stayed in them. "The soldiers that were on the hill with the pack-horses began to fire on us. About this time all the Indians had got their horses and guns and bows and arrows and war-clubs, and they charged the soldiers in the east and north on top of the hill. Custer was farther north than these soldiers were then. He was going to attack the lower end of the village. We drove nearly all that got away from us down the hill along the ridge where another lot of soldiers were trying to make a stand. "Crazy Horse and I left the crowd and rode down along the river. We came to a ravine; then we followed up the gulch to a place in the rear of the soldiers that were making the stand on the hill. Crazy Horse gave his horse to me to hold along with my 'horse. He crawled up the ravine to where he could see the soldiers. He shot them as fast as he could load his gun. They fell off their horses as fast as he could shoot. (Here the chief swayed rapidly back and forth to show how fast they fell). When they found they were being killed so fast, the ones that were left broke and ran as fast as their horses could go to some other soldiers that were further along the ridge toward Custer. Here they tried to make another stand and fired some shots, but we rushed them on along the ridge to where Custer was. Then they made another stand (the third) and rallied a few minutes. Then they went on along the ridge and got with Custer's men. "Other Indians came to us after we got most of the men at the ravine. We all kept after them until they got to where Custer was. There was only a few of them left then. "By that time all the Indians in the village had got their horses and guns and watched Custer. When Custer got nearly to the lower end of the camp, he started to go down a gulch, but the Indians were surrounding him, and he tried to fight. They got off their horses and made a stand but it was no use. Their horses ran down the ravine right into the village. The squaws caught them as fast as they came. One of them was a sorrel with white stocking. Long time after some of our relatives told us they had seen Custer on that kind of a horse when he was on .the way to the Big Horn. "When we got them surrounded the fight was over in one hour. There was so much dust we could not see much, but the Indians rode around and yelled the war-whoop and shot into the soldiers as fast as they could until they were all dead. One soldier was running away to the east but Crazy Horse saw him and jumped on his pony and went after him. He got him about half a mile from the place where the others were lying dead. The smoke was lifted so we could see a little. We got off our horses and went and took the rings and money and watches from the soldiers. We took some clothes off too, and all the guns and pistols. We got seven hundred guns and pistols. Then we went back to the women and children and got them together that were not killed or hurt. Flying Hawk. Lakota.
@daviddougan6961
@daviddougan6961 Жыл бұрын
Very interesting. At that time, most Indian accounts were not considered as valid but this sounds very authentic and more or less dove tails with all the factual information developed since the battle, particularly when the historians scanned the whole battlefield after a large grass fire in 1989.
@maureenberra16
@maureenberra16 Жыл бұрын
@@larryjessee6504 This was war against "The People" and rightful caretakers of this country. White people were attacking women and children. White mutilated Native American women and children by cutting off the private parts ! This was a great win for Native Americans. Our Gov. wanted to wipe Native Americans off the face of the Earth. I am so glad we failed. Native Americans still suffer from our greed.
@danisch7731
@danisch7731 Жыл бұрын
yes,it was Major Reno and three companies that got routed and had to escape by climbing to the top of the bluffs
@q.russell505rc6
@q.russell505rc6 2 жыл бұрын
I'm Navajo born for Apache. We respect Lakota and Cheyenne. You are strong people.
@khaaleliilighntingcoronado9009
@khaaleliilighntingcoronado9009 2 жыл бұрын
Yes they are brother! I respect the Lakota so much! I'm apache on father's side, comanche on my mothers side. I respect the lakotas resistance like many other tribes but the lakota to me were so damn strong and ready to fight!
@robbabcock_
@robbabcock_ 4 жыл бұрын
Great video! In the US only one side of history is taught. But there was a forgotten nation here before Europeans ever arrived- The First Nations. Our treatment of those that already lived here was disgraceful then and continues to be so to this day.
@TheWolphEffect
@TheWolphEffect 3 жыл бұрын
Facts."
@UncleRobsGarage
@UncleRobsGarage 3 жыл бұрын
@Lemmon Maust murdering people over land is not glorious.
@simonyip5978
@simonyip5978 2 жыл бұрын
Well said.
@rizon72
@rizon72 Жыл бұрын
The moment European countries continued to explore and set up cities in North America the Native Americans had lost. Instead we had a long drawn out war which they were not going to win.
@NolanFriedline
@NolanFriedline 5 жыл бұрын
Thank you for this video! This is a very important piece of art and history that feels like the real story of what happened. I would love to see this on display at MIA.
@risingwolf5368
@risingwolf5368 3 ай бұрын
Excellent depiction and detailed explanation. 👏🤳😎
@KernowekTim
@KernowekTim 3 жыл бұрын
Wonderful. Simply wonderful. I was struck by the hands and wrists of One Bull. He has huge, powerful hands and thick wrists; the hands of a man who has really used them: similar to the hands of most men, and women, who have worked with horses from an early age. If one looks at the hands and wrists of a professional jockey, or 'painted horse' person, these same powerful appendages may be seen.
@lordofthewasteland4525
@lordofthewasteland4525 2 жыл бұрын
You so very much right. One bull looks like a big man long arms . And his 1000 yard stare is a testament to his trophy. Custer.
@johnc4774
@johnc4774 4 жыл бұрын
thank you
@meanhe8702
@meanhe8702 Жыл бұрын
Hewáŋžiča, One Horn is who I descend from, he is my g+ great grandfather.
@Odonanmarg
@Odonanmarg 2 жыл бұрын
I like this. Major discovery for me. Let’s see more.
@elizabethhurtado2829
@elizabethhurtado2829 Жыл бұрын
❤amazing
@Idahoguy10157
@Idahoguy10157 2 жыл бұрын
Half the 7th Cavalry Regiment fell at the Battle of Greasy Grass. In 1791 the US Army under Major General Anthony StClair was defeated by native forces. Of 1,000 soldiers and militia only 24 escaped unharmed. StClair’s Defeat was a greater defeat than what occurred in 1876 under Custer
@zipperpillow
@zipperpillow Жыл бұрын
General Harmar had a similar outcome against the same Indians in 1790. 700 dead comes to mind, out of a force of 1500.
@Idahoguy10157
@Idahoguy10157 Жыл бұрын
@@zipperpillow … Haven’t found a reference to Harmar having that many troops to command, or that many casualties
@zipperpillow
@zipperpillow Жыл бұрын
@@Idahoguy10157 Keep searching. It's real. War against the Miami in Ohio, and their allies, Delawares, Shawnee and others.
@user-wi9rf1zx5b
@user-wi9rf1zx5b 9 ай бұрын
I agree, but Custer was a "hero" and did fit the US agenda
@flintrichards945
@flintrichards945 4 жыл бұрын
I have been to the Black Hills it is a wonderful place I would fight to if it was taken away.
@averyjarrett7299
@averyjarrett7299 3 жыл бұрын
It's my Homeland.
@mikearmbruster2171
@mikearmbruster2171 3 жыл бұрын
Beautiful land
@andrewlayton9760
@andrewlayton9760 2 жыл бұрын
@0:14 - Small point, but the worst defeat of US troops during the various Indian Wars was The Battle of the Wabash (1791).
@bevie29
@bevie29 2 жыл бұрын
There is an interesting Chief Two Moons account in his own words here on KZfaq.
@PeggyJame
@PeggyJame 4 жыл бұрын
Lakota, Cheyenne, and Chief Sitting Bull.
@mikearmbruster2171
@mikearmbruster2171 3 жыл бұрын
Crazy Horse
@tomburlington8058
@tomburlington8058 3 жыл бұрын
Even though the book I read as a boy shows Custer taking the last bullet on the top of the hill, I now believe (David Humphreys Miller's version in - Custer's Fall: The Indian Side of the Story) that he was shot crossing the river. What other reason would there be for his men to stop the attack and turn back. pp. 128 + in the paperback edition, 1957.
@bobporch
@bobporch Жыл бұрын
Custer led 11 cavalry charges during the Civil War, always in the front of his troops. From all I have been able to learn he was probably killed first attempting to cross the river. His troopers dragged his body away to where it was found after the battle.
@jamesyoung6379
@jamesyoung6379 Жыл бұрын
Well since no one survived (except for Indians) who knows for sure when Custer fell. Sure the white mans version is he was last to die, but in fact no one knows not even the Indians that survived and later told their version of events. See the book "Wooden Leg: A Warrior Who Fought Custer" is a 1931 book by Thomas Bailey Marquis about the life of a Northern Cheyenne Indian, Wooden Leg, who fought in several historic battles between United States forces and the Plains Indians, including the Battle of the Little Bighorn, where he faced the troops of George Armstrong Custer. The book is of great value to historians, not only for its eye-witness accounts of battles, but also for its detailed description of the way of life of 19th-century Plains Indians. The book was dictated to Marquis by Wooden Leg in Plains Indian Sign Language, their only common language. Marquis gathered the stories for the book from Wooden Leg and others while he was physician at the agency in Montana from 1922. They were reluctant to open up to him at first, but eventually Marquis gained their trust. Wooden Leg lived through some of the most turbulent times in Cheyenne history, but the book begins with his childhood and descriptions of Cheyenne customs. These include tribal organization, the warrior societies, sport, religion and mythology, their friendship and cooperation with the Sioux, arrow recognition, warbonnet entitlement, and much more. Wooden Leg was introduced to warfare at a very young age via conflict with the Crow and joined the Elk warrior society at age 14. There are two other history books worth reading, Empire of The Summer Moon, and The Heart of Everything That Is. These books are about great Indian war Chiefs who fought to preserve their way of life, well researched and written they don't read like a history book they read more like autobiographies.
@MichaelBadHand
@MichaelBadHand 5 ай бұрын
We know he was NOT shot at the river. He was found on Last Stand Hill with his rolling block rifle and fired cases from it under and around him. The Lakota account of Whie Cow Bull of shooting a man with a buckskin coat on, does not match Custer, because we know that day he was wearing a blue wool shirt and his jacket tied to his saddle. No serious students of the battle believe he was killed there. He had very competent officers with him that would not have stopped mid river an assault once begun.
@Sasha0927
@Sasha0927 3 ай бұрын
Having had 3 interviews today, the last of which just ended, the idea of a last stand rings true to me, lol. 🥴 Dr. Zucker: "...one of the most famous battles in American history." Me: never heard of it 😅 I've never heard of "the Battle of Greasy Grass," but I love that name. "Custer's Last Stand" does sound vaguely familiar. Ledger style is also unique to me and I enjoyed hearing the details that I never would've understood just looking at this on my own (e.g. One Bull's relation to Sitting Bull or "counting coup"). It's amazing how people rewrite history to suit themselves and their agendas, but I'm glad to hear the truth about this battle - U.S. bicentennial or no.
@huns12345
@huns12345 3 жыл бұрын
Interesting work of ART
@evamarie2628
@evamarie2628 5 жыл бұрын
i know very little about US history, but is there a reason its written in english when it was drawn by a native american?
@r.wdubero3166
@r.wdubero3166 5 жыл бұрын
I think the native americans did not have any form of writing and adopted the writing of the europeans
@Lambonius
@Lambonius 5 жыл бұрын
The native Americans had been actively trading and communicating with Euro-Americans for more than 200 years by the time this object was made. Across the 19th Century, the American government made active attempts to assimilate Native American cultures--mandating that their children be taught English, educated in Christian schools, etc. It all needs to be understood in the context of the larger cultural genocide that was taking place in that period. I'm oversimplifying a bit, but anyway, by 1900, most native American groups were well-versed in English, some of the younger generations even having been taught English as their first language, so it's not at all unusual to see English writing in an indigenous piece like this.
@bobbilaval6171
@bobbilaval6171 3 жыл бұрын
One Bull did not speak more less write in English. Around 1900 he did a series of interviews about Sitting Bull focusing on his life between 1876 -1890. The interviews are in a collection at the University of Oklahoma. The interviews were done with interpreters and several different transcribers. He was asked to draw various things, such as Sitting Bull’s shield. This drawing may have very well been done in relation to these interviews, but that’s just my guess. One of the interviews was done by One Bull’s niece Cecile One Bull Brown who did know and write English. So it is possible this picture was annotated by his niece. There really isn’t enough information in the catalog about this piece to really know who might have annotated it.
@armybeef68
@armybeef68 3 жыл бұрын
@@SethTheOrigin "the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group" Sounds about right to me.
@SethTheOrigin
@SethTheOrigin 3 жыл бұрын
@@armybeef68 Why would they want to simultaneously 'assimilate' the Native population and destroy them (as per the definition you gave)?
@samuelparker9882
@samuelparker9882 3 жыл бұрын
What a PRICELESS piece of art, history. It's like a actual Hunkpapi encyclopedia book on and about, the Big horn/ Greasy grass battle. Written/ Drawn by one of the actual participants in the battle and hostilities!!! INCREDIBLE!!!!£
@jayscroggins.thunderboy3064
@jayscroggins.thunderboy3064 3 жыл бұрын
Tatanka iyotake, Tusunca Witko, Tunkasila,s Lakota Oyate ✊🏽 Aho heceitu, Mitakuye Oyasin ✌🏽⚡🇺🇸✌🏽⚡🇺🇸⚡✊🏽✌🏽
@deborahnorris4613
@deborahnorris4613 2 жыл бұрын
❤❤❤✊🏽❤❤❤
@mikearmbruster2171
@mikearmbruster2171 3 жыл бұрын
Could you do a show on Red clouds war Crazy Horse was a participant in the battle of the 100 slain Rumored that white trappers also sided with the Indians
@danielmontes7893
@danielmontes7893 5 жыл бұрын
The Lakota were the people of the land so sad the USA an the native Americans could not get along during those times.
@connieholthaus957
@connieholthaus957 4 жыл бұрын
The government made it a habit to give land to the Indians and then take it back ...I truly believe they sent Custer in to die in an attempt to conquer insurmountable numbers to get support in getting rid of all Indians just like it put a bounty on all buffalo because the Indians survived on them. There is no honor in this.
@yourangelinfleshorsackclot1523
@yourangelinfleshorsackclot1523 3 жыл бұрын
@@connieholthaus957 according to Cherokee history.. they knew before hand of a possible attack, im not sure if by prophecy or tipped off. ole custer might have been setup for big business agenda.
@garysicemore3907
@garysicemore3907 3 жыл бұрын
One of the reasons they couldn't get along was they would come on Indian land and would kill the buffalo. The Buffalo was the Indians way of life food clothing and huts.
@mikearmbruster2171
@mikearmbruster2171 3 жыл бұрын
Custer was just a damn glory hound did it wait for other 2 army columns that were coming
@louisavondart9178
@louisavondart9178 Жыл бұрын
They still can't get along. You have to remember that the USA was colonised by the dregs of Europe, not the intellectuals.
@jayscroggins.thunderboy3064
@jayscroggins.thunderboy3064 3 жыл бұрын
Oglala Lakota here ✊🏽
@kathybentley4190
@kathybentley4190 2 жыл бұрын
@Hokasila Wakinyan Thunder Boy, can you help me with a few words in Lakota to comfort a friend who is Lakota (he has cancer for the third time). I want to support him with some words in Lakota. Thanks!
@deborahnorris4613
@deborahnorris4613 2 жыл бұрын
Beautiful people, beautiful language love the oral history! 💜 ✌🏼💫
@jayscroggins.thunderboy3064
@jayscroggins.thunderboy3064 2 жыл бұрын
@@kathybentley4190 tell him that tunkasila, wakan tanka, will take him on his journey when he gets ready for him, and to remember the lakol wicoan , mention the topa, tate, and burn sage, it will sooth him Jesus christ, is tunkasila wakan tanka, and lakol wicoan is the indian way, it's our way of life, topa tate, is the four winds and directions and always mitakuye oyasin my relations, prayers for your friend mitakuye oyasin.
@shiverarts8284
@shiverarts8284 Жыл бұрын
These people are the masters of destiny
@calibreman
@calibreman 3 жыл бұрын
You didn't mention the Arapaho in this video, I thought they were also at the battle.
@henrythompson5224
@henrythompson5224 2 жыл бұрын
I know right, the Arapaho hardly get mentioned. They must of been great Warriors also. Especially being united with the fierce Cheyenne braves.
@calibreman
@calibreman 2 жыл бұрын
@@aidanjoelogan9358 Not savages at all, they were just people trying to defend their land which was being stolen from them by the white invaders. (I'm a European white person)
@wadetaylor1299
@wadetaylor1299 Жыл бұрын
@@henrythompson5224 they were great warriors
@MichaelBadHand
@MichaelBadHand 5 ай бұрын
That is because THERE WERE ONLY FIVE ARAPAHO THERE and the Lakota wanted to Kill them. The Arapaho tribe was NOT at Little Big Horn.
@deweywatts8456
@deweywatts8456 3 жыл бұрын
Another great book says: Man has dominated man to his own harm. ( That means both parties lose)
@michaellomax2
@michaellomax2 3 жыл бұрын
The Bible...
@hypervigilance6891
@hypervigilance6891 2 жыл бұрын
That's a beautiful thing five tribes like the five families
@raymondgravelle3931
@raymondgravelle3931 10 ай бұрын
They had it coming. Custer and his regiment. They thought they could just ride in🤨
@shawntailor5485
@shawntailor5485 Жыл бұрын
The ojibou did not fare as well . Honors to the Lakota ,oglala Sioux. My brother spud knew sitting bulls grandson . RIP Spud !
@bobporch
@bobporch Жыл бұрын
After the Civil War was over, Robert E. Lee was asked why the South lost the war. He replied to the effect that he thought the Yankees had something to do with. So why did Custer and his brigade get wiped out? Perhaps the Lakota and Cheyenne had something to do with it. George Custer was a true hero during the Civil War before he started shooting any wounded enemies. He saved the Union Army on the 3rd day at Gettysburg by attacking Stuart's Cavalry Corps. Later he closed Lees only route of escape, forcing his surrender to Grant in Virginia in 1865. In the West, Custer became a butcher and murderer. One of the worst blots on the record of the United States Army was the massacre he conducted on the Washita River of Black Kettle's village. Black Kettle was friendly to the US and flew the American Flag over his camp. Custer surrounded the sleeping village at dawn and attacked. Old men, women and children; it didn't matter. They were all shot down on Custer's orders. Black Kettle and his wife were shot in the back. All the wounded warriors were also killed. Custer took 53 women and children hostage and placed them in the center of his departing column as human shields to prevent Cheyenne warriors from camps up river from attacking. He also abandoned a Major and about a dozen troopers that chased after some escaping "hostiles." They were never heard of again. If Custer had retired after the Civil War I would be writing about what a hero he was. Instead he reminds me more of an Nazi SS Lt. Col just "following orders." By todays standards he would be a war criminal not a hero. But karma is a bitch. From everything I have been able to learn, he attacked the Cheyenne part of the camp and was likely the first killed in his column. He made no glorious last stand. His troopers dragged his body up to the hill where it was found. The winners write the history books, but eventually the truth sees the light of day.
@zipperpillow
@zipperpillow Жыл бұрын
Well done. You forgot 2 things. Custer died from a bullet to his temple from his own revolver that left powder burns (like Adolf Hitler). He also publicly accused President Grant of corruption (Grant was corrupt) and as a result was stripped of the leadership of the 1876 campaign against the free Indians in Montana. His glory seeking that day was an attempt to rehab his tarnished reputation. In the years since, his reputation has become even more unsavory.
@austoncurry1076
@austoncurry1076 2 жыл бұрын
Unfortunately, winning a battle can cause repercussions that can loose one a War.
@rizon72
@rizon72 Жыл бұрын
The Native Americans were never going to win the war. They lost when Europeans continued to make contact and created trade outposts and cities.
@user-br1ir9jk2p
@user-br1ir9jk2p 7 ай бұрын
im jus here for class
@andyanderson5326
@andyanderson5326 4 жыл бұрын
I’m calling it the battle of greasy grass from now on. Lakota true American heroes defending woman and children and their way of life. Respect for the soldiers who lost their lives who were only following orders.
@daryllebeau4333
@daryllebeau4333 Жыл бұрын
The truth.
@clumsydad7158
@clumsydad7158 Жыл бұрын
in propaganda wins are victories and losses are also victories, as the latter fuel the vengeance for the next engagement; the entrapping excuses for further bloodshed
@loanokaharbor8303
@loanokaharbor8303 3 жыл бұрын
War should never be celebrated as an "accomplishment". War is the last resort of man's failure to resolve their differences. Sometimes War is unavoidable, if one or more parties refuse to operate or negotiate in good faith. Although War is a failure, not an accomplishment, sometimes the ultimate and eventual outcome of War may provides a better place than before the war. War as a way of life in one's culture is a recipe for extinction. Maybe some day humans can rise above their own group self indulgences in order to live together in peace, however, that may not be possible.
@giannirocco7492
@giannirocco7492 2 жыл бұрын
The Native Americans,from the north,south,east or west,tried everything that they could,time and again,to make peace with the Whites but every time the Whites broke their promises and their written treaties and started new campaigns to eliminate the whole race of native inhabitants of this land we call home...
@glitch-pr3nr
@glitch-pr3nr 9 ай бұрын
Pre-european contact the americas had 100 million, after european contact 10 million.
@giannirocco7492
@giannirocco7492 2 жыл бұрын
"History is written by the victors",most times that's true,but this is the only instance I can think of where it's not!I find it strange,almost bizarre,how the Whites just can't seem to get over it!I mean,the subject has been beaten to death and then beaten some more!Custer and his men had every intention of going down there and killing every man,woman and child before looting and burning that village.The village inhabitants simply defended their village and families,period!The story should end there,and for me it does!
@spiderlegs50
@spiderlegs50 2 жыл бұрын
That evil bastard had no problem killing women and children....
@MichaelBadHand
@MichaelBadHand 5 ай бұрын
They had no intention of doing that and also had never done that before.
@daveybernard1056
@daveybernard1056 3 жыл бұрын
I guess I'm pre-literate-- I thought those were suns!
@richiemclaughlin6127
@richiemclaughlin6127 3 жыл бұрын
CUSTER WAS A COWARD HE ATTACKED WHEN ONLY WOMAN AND CHILDREN WERE IN THE VILLAGES HE GOT IS JUST REWARD
@rizon72
@rizon72 Жыл бұрын
Did Custer make it into the camp? I'm under the impression he never managed to cross the river. Reno did attack women and children though.
@cgdeery
@cgdeery Жыл бұрын
I believe that troopers volley fired into the camp killing non combatants..women..children and the elderly..
@josephdelatorre3751
@josephdelatorre3751 2 жыл бұрын
According to many of the Chiefs who fought that battle. Custer did not have to die with all those men. Simply custer Was A pompous ass!
@brian78045
@brian78045 2 жыл бұрын
Custer's presence was known to the hostiles, as such the dice was cast...Custer couldn't wait for Gibbons' and Crook's columns to hook up with Custer's column. Custer's men and horses were also exhausted after a forced march,* so it was a miracle that Custer's command performed as well as it did when it stumbled into a hornet's nest. Custer went into that valley in the knowledge that if he failed to capture the Indian women and children, he would be defeated...and these hostiles he was up against didn't take prisoners. Custer's Crow scouts informed Custer of the horrific sight they witnessed down in the valley, that's why he told the Crow scouts to leave the field. According to Private Peter Thompson, the only survivor of Custer's party that was looking for a fording location along the river, Custer was outside of his pickets searching alone for that fording location. Pvt. Thompson's horse was worn out and couldn't be mounted, so Thompson was on foot when he bumped into Custer alone. Also present were three Crow scouts who had captured a Sioux female, tethered by one of the Crows. Custer rode to the Crow, and while Pvt. Thompson didn't hear the conversation, the Crow subsequently cut loose the female, who moved back towards Pvt. Thompson. She was holding a large knife in her hand, heading straight for Pvt. Thompson. As she approached, Pvt. Thompson placed his hand on his revolver's holster. The female got the message, making a wide birth around Pvt. Thompson. Obviously, the Crow scouts were too looking for a location to ford the river, and came across the Sioux female. The Crow were interrogating the female, but, obviously, getting nowhere with the knife-wielding captive, so Custer ordered her release instead of torturing her into giving the fording location(s). Custer didn't get to be a brevet general during the Civil War because he was pompous. He achieved that distinction by knowing the enemy's next likely move, which during the Battle of Gettysburg (June 1863), Custer secured victory by repelling a pivotal Confederate assault led by J.E.B. Stuart. --------------------------- * Meaning a retreat wasn't possible, where rested hostiles and their fresh mounts could easily outmaneuver and annihilate the troopers.
@huscarl00
@huscarl00 10 ай бұрын
@@brian78045 😂Retreat wasn’t possible? Reno retreated, dug in and survived. It was more like: if Custer didn’t attack he would’ve lost a chance for the 7th to get “glory” in ambushing a village, using squaws and babies as human shields like his 1868 Washita massacre. That was his MO and it would negate his troops and horses being tired. So confident in his superiority, he brushed off his own intel and split his command against a vastly superior force. Seems pretty pompous. He gambled his life and his men repeatedly: his luck ran out on the Greasy Grass. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
Custer's Last Stand | Journey Through the Battle of the Little Bighorn
26:29
ДЕНЬ РОЖДЕНИЯ БАБУШКИ #shorts
00:19
Паша Осадчий
Рет қаралды 5 МЛН
The Last Survivors of Little Bighorn: Dewey Beard & a horse named Comanche
30:19
The Wild West Extravaganza
Рет қаралды 39 М.
Gilbert Stuart, The Skater
5:09
Smarthistory
Рет қаралды 4,6 М.
Chief Gall
8:28
Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument
Рет қаралды 19 М.
The Rise Of The Lakota Nation | Nations At War | Timeline
43:49
Timeline - World History Documentaries
Рет қаралды 471 М.
Streetcars in St. Paul and Minneapolis
4:42
Minnesota Historical Society
Рет қаралды 62 М.
Battle of the Little Bighorn, The Reno-Benteen Defense
15:38
TheDataMeister
Рет қаралды 706 М.
Thomas Cole, The Voyage of Life
8:14
Smarthistory
Рет қаралды 4,2 М.
LIFE LAKOTA | The Cheyenne River Reservation
15:15
VATIV
Рет қаралды 1,3 МЛН