國外聲樂老師點評

Рет қаралды 393,205

Ай бұрын

Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on KZfaq: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #周深 #陈楚生 #孙燕姿 #zhoushen #charliezhoushen #stefaniesun #zhoushenreaction #声生不息

Пікірлер: 926

@hueemily6220 Ай бұрын

老師描述孫燕姿真得很精準，略帶脆弱卻又勇敢灑脫，他的歌路確實如此。兩千年初的歌手都有把說故事的嗓音，各種類型的唱進心底深處。不愧是老師👍👍

@leevincent1238 Ай бұрын

老师有点评过孙燕姿吗？

@quanlai2628 Ай бұрын

@@leevincent1238 看后半段

@ts6820520 Ай бұрын

@@leevincent1238 這影片你是沒看就留言嗎🥲

@Francis97630 27 күн бұрын

應該說本人也是這樣在最紅的時候引退…幾年後復出又爆紅…過幾年又引退

@asd81827795 26 күн бұрын

@@Francis97630也沒有一直反覆復出啦，這次影片的她只是唱給粉絲聽的線上演唱會，復出是只有出來活躍、上節目、記者會什麼的

@loveloveQy Ай бұрын

哇，好感謝這集。透過老師評論燕姿才讓我知道自己對各種唱歌技巧的執著跟不自信有多沒必要，還以為唱歌一定要多會轉多會滑才稱得上好聽，也現在才知道孫燕姿唱得好聽的原因不是多有技巧，而是她自成的藝術特質以及熟知自己所擁有的，然後發揮到最好。

@yatkwonchin-db9vk Ай бұрын

恭喜妳和自己世紀大和解

@yizhongchen5219 29 күн бұрын

嗯嗯，同感😊

@allen5690 25 күн бұрын

應該說孫燕姿的音色相當有辨識度跟天生好音色！音色真的就是天生的！

@lk1872 Ай бұрын

燕姿就是大咖，逆光，天黑黑，我不難過，我懷念的，開始懂了~ 隨手拈來的，都是經典退休多年後的逆光，與當年不同，演繹方式少了年輕時的澎湃，多了成熟的歷練老師要是喜歡，真的要聽聽全盛時期的她，把歌詞唱入心坎，不知唱哭了多少人~

@lucern543 Ай бұрын

向左向右

@xlchen3631 Ай бұрын

冷門歌手孫燕姿😂我覺得年輕時候的她和現在的味道不一樣啦，現在也好聽

@user-bg7jt1wr4r Ай бұрын

我很喜歡孫燕姿但她真的沒有很大咖（紅）她的歌就是大家都聽過結果都不知道是她唱的這樣我也不知道為什麼😂

@Eric_448.6 Ай бұрын

@@user-bg7jt1wr4r 就像年少的同桌同學或是青梅竹馬，可能雖然已經記不清長相(歌名)，但是那些懷念的事物永遠都在

@andy19980101 Ай бұрын

@@user-bg7jt1wr4r 孫燕姿沒有很大咖….？我猜你年紀一定很輕，她當年的人氣可是跟周杰倫、蔡依林、張惠妹並駕齊驅的！人稱「男周女孫」～還在2000年金曲獎打敗周、戴佩妮、范瑋琪、林凡等一眾神級歌手拿下最佳新人獎，怎麼被你講得好像歌紅人不紅一樣哈哈哈哈😂人家只是不愛炒新聞後期又把演藝重心轉為家庭而已～～

@nchubawin Ай бұрын

孫燕姿真的唱歌有種讓人膽戰心驚的飄飄感，但其實大部分的音又很準，聽的心癢癢的😂

@brucelu5115 Ай бұрын

燕姿是華語樂壇的寶，一開口，她的音色、她的獨特唱腔、她與歌的結合、那個氛圍，馬上就抓住聽眾。從來不需要飆高音、不用唱到驚天地泣鬼神，就是用她的方式唱歌。我記得燕姿說過，她不是那種唱將型歌手，所以她從不參加歌唱比賽，沒錯，她不需要！

@uchidayang Ай бұрын

就像陶笛，聲音是很順的，沒那麼完美，然後也沒有那麼細膩，小小的，可以掛在脖子上。老粉應該都知道我這段說法的出處

@strawberryFifi Ай бұрын

他剛出道的第一場演唱會我有去，真的強大到，讓人膜拜，聽得非常陶醉，現場唱得比CD還好聽，幾乎一模一樣，至今都非常懷念！

@user-je4io7we1c Ай бұрын

孫燕姿的聲線也飆不了高音好嗎？

@uchidayang Ай бұрын

她也不需要好嗎?

@userhfhsiskjchh Ай бұрын

歌手最重要的其實是歌聲辨識度，不然以前很多唱功很好的歌手，但就是太普通沒特色

@cccowww Ай бұрын

孫燕姿太多經典歌，代表了一個年代，不用去跟人比較。

@lynn5846 15 күн бұрын

真的好愛孫燕姿，從國中到現在32歲了，只買過她的專輯，還當過奇摩家族的版主😍

@maggiel1368 15 күн бұрын

左右護法居然不知道是孫燕姿的歌、證明他們也挺年輕的😆😆

@accela56 9 күн бұрын

也让人wonder 他们选曲的过程是怎样的感觉好像没有做什么research..？

@hsiaosophia3390 Күн бұрын

讓我再繼續聽孫燕姿❤

@user-tk5th7nk8p Ай бұрын

最愛周深的歌，也愛老師的點評

@julieng264 Ай бұрын

很喜歡看到老師聽見周深唱歌時的心心眼❤❤

@lubis1991 Ай бұрын

老师对孙燕姿的讲评太准了。燕姿唱的就是一个氛围，一个口气，一个情感。她不是拥有华丽技巧的唱将，但她依然可以凭着独特的嗓音和真心的诠释深深打动我们的心。反而觉得这样有些瑕疵的燕姿，唱出的更是一种不完美的美。The critique of Stefanie Sun was SPOT ON. She is not a very 'technical' singer, and she doesn't rely too much on techniques, but she is so strong and raw and intimate with her delivery. And that tone is to die for. I love her perfect imperfections. It gives wabisabi.

@Truth2011sg Ай бұрын

Many like JJ and Sun as their singing is somewhere closer to Western, I suppose

@janiceleong3602 Ай бұрын

孙燕姿的嗓音很独特，很有feel..不用多余的装饰就很自然的感动人。

@lubis1991 Ай бұрын

老师，you MUST listen to her version of 我怀念的, it's a completely different feel from JJ's.

@misskogepon Ай бұрын

Great to hear a technical person reacting to Stephanie! She’s an icon among certain age group 😅 and I’ve loved her songs and tone but always wondered what makes her “stand out” from the rest of the Chinese pop artist that time. The tag line for her first album was something like 沒有一個女生像她這樣唱歌。

@lubis1991 Ай бұрын

@@misskogepon Exactly! Her taglines were: '没有一个22岁的女孩像他一样唱歌’ and ‘不是超美丽，而是超实力’, loosely translating to 'there ain't another 22-year-old girl who sings like her' and 'she's not the prettiest, but she's gonna be one of the best singers you'd hear'. Stefanie was a buck to the prevailing trend in mandopop at the time of her debut. She was a breath of fresh air. Most female singers in mandopop were dolling themselves up, promoting themselves through various controversies, singing cutesy tunes, or huge belty ballads. Then you have this unassuming young lady from Singapore, making her career in a foreign land (Taiwan), singing straight from her heart. She may not have the biggest voice, nor the prettiest face, but what you get from her is unadulterated authenticity, and the ability to tell a story.

@ssailea Ай бұрын

孫燕姿太多經典了老師喜歡的話一定要多聽❤

@bobowang3327 Ай бұрын

周深的歌聲真治愈

@user-zn3rh6pn3u 16 күн бұрын

終於知道為什麼我們這麼愛孫燕姿

@user-ud6yt7mj4u Ай бұрын

有深必進~老師專業的講解也很療癒~

@user-nr9cq2ww4x Ай бұрын

周深的合聲超優美，超療癒❤❤❤

@liyuhung4938 Ай бұрын

天啊很少看到老師這麼興奮了，孫燕姿是我從小到大最愛的華人女歌手!!!!

@kkman777 Ай бұрын

這位老師，真的太強大了，能快速找到燕姿的魅力的地方在哪，精準而且到位。我很慶幸我第一位而且到現在也依然喜歡燕姿並且身為粉絲而驕傲到不行

@patrickwang9776 28 күн бұрын

燕姿第一次在台灣的簽名會是辦在西門町，我就在現場，但因為太害羞了，就沒去排隊了。那時候燕姿才剛剛出道，所以現場沒有很多人。然後我非常後悔，在害羞什麼呀！

@cheungh4064 Ай бұрын

周深的歌聲好温暖又動聽，真棒👍👍❤❤

@ryokohirouse Ай бұрын

孫燕姿的歌真的有太多的情感和回憶在裡面我此生最愛的女藝人之一

@Ls-lt7sk Ай бұрын

老師跨越語言的障礙，聽出了歌聲中的溫暖，治癒人心的情感！❤❤❤

@wubin3783 20 күн бұрын

听周深唱，是一种享受。身心愉悦。听孙燕姿唱，是一种触动心弦的感觉，更能共情，被打动。真的难说谁优谁劣、

@becca_u 2 күн бұрын

This song is one of her famous songs

@user-xl7dv3dw4b 9 күн бұрын

真希望老師能聽聽更原始早期孫燕姿的版本，那歌聲裡堅毅灑脫帶有勇氣的力量。

@jckl88 Ай бұрын

有点惊讶老师喜欢燕姿，因为擅长的领域大不相同。但是！老师真的懂燕姿，句句都在点上。好棒好棒！也谢谢Flo帮我们安排上Silent all these years 的reaction！我超爱燕姿的版本。期待！❤

@solitudepanda5300 Ай бұрын

I never knew how to appreciate Stefanie Sun’s songs when I was younger because I felt it was just very ordinary and average. It was only until when I was older that I grew to like her voice and appreciate her singing. As what you have pointed out, she is unlike other typical pop singers. But if you can understand the language, you would be able to appreciate her singing even more because she brings out the emotion of the lyrics in her own special way. This song is written by a well-known Singaporean song writer. He and his twin brother wrote / tailored many songs for her, of which many became classics of her era. Her 天黑黑 was an award winning song. I love the simple arrangement of the song and the lyrics.

@Chun7715 18 күн бұрын

孫燕姿的神奇之處在於現在2024依舊沒有一個比她更深入人心的女歌手，10幾歲我聽，現在30幾歲我依舊想聽她

@yefelli Ай бұрын

李思松李偉菘幫孫寫了很多膾炙人口的好歌，到現在都還很耐聽！大推"我懷念的"，老師若聽這首歌一定要提一下歌詞，編排的很棒，層層堆疊的詞，真的是唱著滿滿的情感。當年的孫燕姿真的是青春無邪又天真的歌聲頂流啊，後來也找不到第二個同路線的歌手了！

@ezann Ай бұрын

真的老師真的要聽我懷念的

@user-vx4uo8dw7f Ай бұрын

燕姿太多歌該聽了😢😢😢😢

@user-id3om4fw4x 27 күн бұрын

有預告我懷念的 5/31會上喔～

@ericpan4799 28 күн бұрын

真的是老師🙏🏼太厲害了，非常認同那句，藝術不是這樣的，燕姿的那種純粹跟帶入感真的很棒，藝術並不是傳達完美而是情感感染，同樣我也很喜歡逆光副歌那個情感情緒堆疊的旋律，太有感染力了，在一段一段旋律一直打進心裡的感覺

@ongxyz Ай бұрын

我滴深深寶寶阿❤❤❤

@klw5585 Ай бұрын

很意外竟然老師認識孫燕姿而且喜歡她😊因為我也是喜歡孫燕姿很開心老師也喜歡她❤

@sunnysignet099 Ай бұрын

我也很驚訝!老師叫的出燕姿名字是不是以前就聽過她唱歌?有的話,求連結🙏

@Emla100 Ай бұрын

孫燕姿剛在台灣發片就喜歡她(特別的音色)，現在又愛周深。開心今晚兩個一次看！好聽。

@user-mx9xl2gf6p 3 ай бұрын

太久沒有深深的點評了❤️ 望穿秋水

@stevenj3414 Ай бұрын

燕姿就是一直把最自然的一面從頭到尾從年輕到現在都在演繹,維持同樣的初衷

@kankanzhou6820 Ай бұрын

喜欢这个老师，总是无私地、真实地告诉我们哪里是好的，哪里是坏的，和她一起享受音乐

@cytseng7023 Ай бұрын

真的好愛老師對聲音的講解和見解❤❤

@kengipleong1184 Ай бұрын

老師厲害!聽一次就能點出歌手的魅力所在。很喜歡孫燕姿，以前沒有很常聽她的歌，從她被戲稱為"冷門歌手"後才慢慢了解她，真是相見恨晚。人好、歌好、聲音好，自身帶著一點傳奇色彩的女歌手。

@0953091788 29 күн бұрын

她第一首天黑黑不是出道即巔峰了嗎？當時我第一次聽到整個在客廳呆住

@weiwei7613 17 күн бұрын

你是不是很年輕🥹

@JoeChanTV Ай бұрын

I get goosebumps listening to this! Go Stefanie Sun from SINGAPORE!

@johnwong7562 Ай бұрын

I like their version so much, so powerful, watching the video was just like attending an evangelistic event, feeling warmth and hope!

@cavyyang1991 28 күн бұрын

oh god ～我超愛你們三人討論音樂的模樣～溫柔又激烈～又富於智性～ nice ！ brovo！

@Ilovesprings Ай бұрын

很喜歡他們很認真在討論發聲的過程。真的是很愛音樂的幾個人❤

@jilllee3800 Ай бұрын

Thank you for all your reactions to Shenshen. Looking forward to seeing more.😊

@wongman4585 Ай бұрын

我愛聽周深❤

@msmshappy1180 Ай бұрын

Àwesome Zhou Shen ❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉Amazing as always ❤️ 👏 ♥️ 💖 😍

@pfh5434 Ай бұрын

Again, it’s so enjoyable to watch your reaction and comments on Zhou Shen! He is so great! Shen Shen is going to publish his 2nd album and look forward to watching your reaction on his album’s songs one on one! ❤❤❤

@jckl88 Ай бұрын

Finally! Waited so long for Yanzi! Can’t wait to see Rozette’s reaction to Yanzi’s rendition of “Silent all these years”! Please don’t make us wait forever! 😂

@cheungh4064 Ай бұрын

等待周深❤❤

@rjs722 Ай бұрын

One of my favorite performances of Zhou Shen from this show. His duets were outstanding on this show. As usual, ZS nailed it.

@user-cx3yu2vv9x 11 күн бұрын

让老师听他们两个的凄美地，那才是精品！

@cheungh4064 3 ай бұрын

5月？等咁耐才有周深！希望早些🙏🙏

@s9310yoyoss Ай бұрын

其實孫燕姿有更多代表作可以剪她那獨特且有靈魂的歌聲是無可取代的!!

@user-ts6no6qt1l Ай бұрын

周深棒棒❤❤❤陳楚生也是有實力的歌手😂😂

@harshybrown Ай бұрын

Stefanieeeeee❤❤❤❤❤❤ Singapore's national treasure

@thakhinmin6822 Ай бұрын

Love ZhouShen from Myanmar❤❤❤

@yuwei929 Ай бұрын

哇喔來看周深了 😊😊😊

@user-dw3ci9vx9p Ай бұрын

期待好久的深深

@sertoming10 29 күн бұрын

印象中老師每次聽周深唱歌都會笑😊

@rockerteers2 Ай бұрын

I love d vibe n d whole atmosphere created for this song... So heart warming😍

@crazypig4212 Ай бұрын

我最愛的周深沒有之一只有唯一❤

@wongman4585 Ай бұрын

我也是.... 沖著周深進來的❤

@meig3830 Ай бұрын

十1

@Li-np7js Ай бұрын

我也是

@user-mx9xl2gf6p Ай бұрын

只愛❤️深深❤️

@user-qc5sw6xb7o Ай бұрын

只愛❤❤周深❤❤

@LoveMikage 17 күн бұрын

超愛孫燕姿❤❤❤

@yvonne8035 Ай бұрын

喜歡老師對燕姿的講評非常準確很感動

@MT-ub7eg Ай бұрын

Yes fragility is what makes her songs attractive.

@samlin9097 Ай бұрын

孫燕姿是華語樂壇神的存在

@user-oy9ik9pk3k Ай бұрын

老師的評論在有語言隔閡的狀態之下依然說的非常精準燕姿的歌有陽光有歡樂有陰天有悲傷但是不管任何歌曲燕姿總讓人感受到在任何狀況下她依然保持著"希望" 也許這就是老師說的"療癒 " 那種精神會讓人有力量去面對明天的任何挑戰她也許不是歌唱技巧最好的但她是華語歌壇永遠不可替代的經典之前有內地觀眾說她是過氣歌手(翻白眼) 那是他們沒看過她有多紅連周杰倫在金曲獎最佳新人獎都敗在她的手下可見台灣金曲獎真的是海納百川沒有私心只要你夠好任何類型的歌手都能被看見在歌壇發光發熱

@amberzzzz4951 Ай бұрын

內地觀眾說她是過氣歌手是因为那群人还年轻哈哈，已经被其他内地观众嘲笑了。

@B1362li Ай бұрын

看著出老師很享受這首歌,從頭到尾都是笑容到最後深受感動

@user-hu5mo4wh4y Ай бұрын

深深❤❤❤

@tommy8056 Ай бұрын

周深的聲線加上重新編曲，真是棒

@D3adP03t Ай бұрын

Thank you so much ❤❤❤ and I love this episode so much for finally reviewing Stefanie. ❤❤❤

@yu-pinhsiao3714 Ай бұрын

超愛這首翻唱超愛的真高興老師也喜歡溫暖治癒這首不只要聽還要看看深深投入全身心的唱看生哥和他的配合默契現場小夥伴的投入神情完美! 溫暖到眼淚溢出心頭發熱

@yangtzeling7468 Ай бұрын

I love Stefanie Sun. Her vocals sound fragile and melancholic.

@user-mz2sd9uj8n Ай бұрын

孫燕姿有自己獨特的風格跟很多膾炙人口的歌曲，真的很棒！

@sumcheung8851 Ай бұрын

期待下次周深的出現❤希望不要等太久

@envykiss31 Ай бұрын

音乐真的是强大的语言！虽然听不懂，但老师也能感觉到那束光的治愈力，神奇！❤ 老师很棒

@virginiacheung2905 Ай бұрын

这的确是一首很励志很正能量的歌曲

@yauyauluk Ай бұрын

來看周深❤❤

@zoeliu8381 Ай бұрын

橘老師好懂喔，這些技巧，真厲害呢!兩個版本我都喜歡。

@slam7130 Ай бұрын

老師點評得很精準“治愈世界”👍👍

@dasskabusk Ай бұрын

推薦老師聽聽看孫燕姿的我懷念的

@user-gw2po2ej6n Ай бұрын

雖然孫燕姿目前狀態還不錯，但還是想看看老師評家巔峰期的孫燕姿，讓老師知道當初我們迷戀著什麼❤

@user-xf7zi7op5e Ай бұрын

超級愛周深的“治愈感”❤❤❤

@user-fi3lz9rf4h Ай бұрын

《天黑黑》也是由这首歌同一曲的作曲家李偲菘和孙燕姿来演唱

@user-rl7tb9hm5d Ай бұрын

很推薦老師能聽孫燕姿。我懷念的

@ssailea Ай бұрын

silent all these year 絕對要聽！曲改編得很好❤️

@user-xy8pb1lc6z 5 сағат бұрын

聽孫燕姿會有一種想掉淚的感動

@shuian Ай бұрын

孫燕姿是00年後出道的藝人，近10年已經很少公開活動，老師們現在聽的版本是最近的網路直播音樂會。感覺比早期唱得更鬆弛，發音也比較不像早期被評論的那種鼻音，但也是這種歌唱方式使她的聲音更有辨識度。很多孫燕姿的歌其實旋律並不如表面看似容易詮釋，因為很容易被唱得＂平淡＂，這也是孫燕姿厲害的地方！

@CMilkshake Ай бұрын

沒錯，這版本是20週年無法現場演唱會的線上直播版🥹

@mattinadu Ай бұрын

老師分析得好棒，也期待評論陳楚生

@sunnysignet099 Ай бұрын

燕姿最愛,最愛燕姿,老師精闢入裡!

@sarachang9239 Ай бұрын

Love Shen Shen

@user-pd3pg6mp8b 3 ай бұрын

如果是早期燕姿，老師會很驚艷隨著歲月，現今聲音的穩定不再如前很高興能介紹這位華人才女天后以前金曲獎獲獎的歌后如王菲、莫文蔚、蔡健雅、林憶蓮、徐佳瑩、張惠妹... 如今狀態在線能有幾人，懷念神仙打架的年代

@user-uu5nm6qw9u Ай бұрын

神仙打架！形容的真好！

@D.T.1 21 күн бұрын

沒辦法不佩服林憶蓮，真的保持得太好

@user-tc2hg5is3i 19 күн бұрын

徐佳瑩比較後期了吧

@user-pg1hf7ve7s 2 ай бұрын

啊～！！這首太愛了❤

@aprilchen7871 Ай бұрын

老师听歌的时候嘴巴都是张的，好歌就是让人Cheerful，治愈开心的。

@janetoh9130 29 күн бұрын

Thank you for reacting to Stefanie Sun's singing! She is really big in the Chinese music world. 200+ million views and 600 million likes on her last online concert last year. Please do more!!

@SoIiceandFire Ай бұрын

周深❤❤

@maxinehan68 Ай бұрын

❤燕姿是我的最愛😍，希望可以多看到老師評論她的歌，他翻唱silient all these years跟That I would be good都很好聽❤，很少聽英文歌的我就是因為燕姿，知道這兩首歌😂

@minfu3951 Ай бұрын

我也是❤

@membliao Ай бұрын

還有Sometimes love just ain’t enough 跟Hey Jude 😍

@user-ni5ug4lr9m 3 күн бұрын

希望能讓老師多聽一些孫燕姿經典成名曲

@miawang520 25 күн бұрын

老帥真他很愛深深的聲音，每次聽到深深唱歌都是很享受開心的表情

@allenli1281 Ай бұрын

I had the same question as Flo did for so many years. I love Stephanie's art so much, but didn't know why until I watched this video. Great work, great review, and lots of love for Stepahnie's songs.