The biggest sin is that we're supposed to believe that Drake never once mentioned Sam between all 3 original games.

Shouldn't Nathan be the most hated man in archaeology and treasure hunting since he never brings anything back and destroys everything he touches?

10 sins off for the jeep scene in "For better or worse" alone. No dialogue, no action, just music. So unexpected, and very emotional.

"Nolan North is good at Game Sins. Just please don't start up your own channel." Cut to two years later: Nolan and Troy have an own channel :D

I could have sworn Elena wasn't mad that Drake was back into adventuring but that he LIED TO HER.

I just realized that he basic premise of every Uncharted game is pretty much the same: -Nate finds traces of a treasure hunt voyage -Nate brings a guy or two to hunt the treasure with -Nate discovers a group that tries to find the same treasure he hunts -The group always has someone Nate or the other main character knows for a long time as a leader or high ranking member -Nate will always fight the group and goes on a wild goose chase to the treasure for the whole game -Every clue Nathan finds will always lead to another clue, and yet another clue, and still another clue, resulting in a goose chase to the treasure -For some reason even though Nate discovers each clue first, the villain group will always be to the other clue's location first despite Nate found it first and the crew should actually have a longer time transporting their army, weapons, and resources to the location compared to Nate's group, which only contains 4 people max and only carrying pistols -Except U4, the treasure Nate is looking for isn't actually a treasure, rather some supernatural bullshit that can be very dangerous if used by the wrong people and Nate would actually fight the supernatural creatures that is a product of the "treasure" (in U3's case, the Djinns are only hallucination) -Nate ends up destroying the lost city, killed the main villans in it, escape the lost city, and walk out with little treasure or nothing at all Despite these facts can't be denied by any Uncharted fans, I still can't help but love the whole series because they're excellent masterpieces :)

“How many times does this make that Laura Bailey’s character has beat the crap out of Troy Baker’s character in a game?” aaaaaaanndd they did that again in TLOU 2

Remember guys, sin videos aren't meant to be taken seriously.

There's literally a kid in my school named Samuel Drake :p

The twist was actually so good, it caught me off my guard.

*Three times they used the character death when they're actually alive Sully in Uncharted Sully again in Uncharted 3 Sam in Uncharted 4

"How many times are we gonna see Laura Bailey portray a character that beats the shit out of Troy Baker's character?" Well, after playing tlou 2, this aged well

Wait! There's no sins for the random wooden boxes with wheels that are everywhere??

A few corrections: - Actually the giant's causeway is in both Scotland and Northern Ireland - Nadine is South African not English - You probably should have retracted all the sins you gave for the Alcazar scene after it was revealed he was dead

For sin 43, Chloe also knows that Nate was hanging from the train in Uncharted 2, and in Lost Legacy, they say that Chloe is close to the Drakes, so Chloe could’ve told Sam those details, not just Sully and Elena.

is it just me... or does rafe look like Jake Gyllenhaal?

THAT INTRO WAS AWESOME

So many people getting upset and defending this game from harmless sins this guy gives it like it's the best thing ever created. I love the Uncharted series, but honestly any game EVER made could be used for an episode of game sins. No game is perfect, and I'd love to see a game sins of my favorite game of all time.

1:06, I kinda like to think that after Sam’s supposed “Death” Nate probably didn’t like using the grappling hook because it reminded him of Sam. It fits in with his whole wanting to forget Sam thing

26:20 "How many times does this make that Laura Bailey's character has beat the crap out of Troy Baker's character in a game." This man predicted The Last of Us 2, 4 years ago.

10:33 - 13:02 Why are this sins? That flashback was all made up by Sam.

Every time they said I will look for something to drop down so you can climb up...I said "Rope", " You have a rope", "Why are you not using that rope".

My favorite character in every game that I play is the guy who paints climbable ledges... who also adds his own touch to each game to make it different every time...

20:40 I like how Sully says "try not to drop anything else on me" and Nate proceeds to drop EVERYTHING

to be fair at least most of libertalia is still in good condition by the end

"i guess Rafe had access to the internet, that cunning fiend" God damn it that deserves a like, a sub, and maybe 15 more videos

Honestly one of my favorite things about this game is the way Nate’s love for history and archeology is animated and acted.

Maybe he never mentioned his brother to anyone because he had ptsd from the trauma of losing him.

It's like 2023 in this epilogue and Nate and Elena' daughter is stuck with an old Playstation and a copy of Crash Bandicoot. At least get her a PS5 or something. - HAHAHAHHAHAHAA

There was obviously a connection to this entire story hinted in Drakes fortune at the start when the pirates are attacking them, Nate tells Elena its either fight back or a panamanian jail, she asks whats worse and he replies "you've obviously never been inside a panamanian jail.." im guessing that was hinting to this incident. I could be wrong

"Nate has killed thousands at this point". love this line

7:17 add a sin because the devs literally didn’t put the correct answer in the dialogue options.

Despite this game being amazing, I need to agree to 70 % of those sins... This is a comedy people, don't dislike!

The ending of the game is interesting, his daughter becomes Tomb Raider AND HE IS THE LOST FATHER WE NEVER SEE, OMFGMMFMGMMDGM

ppl, remember: this is for fun a game lacks of sins are boring one. so knock it off fanboys, I luv uncharted & it is the 10/10 game for me but still, i want to see this video & laugh & have fun

Dartigan: 26:20 The Last of Us 2: *hold my golf club*

this is a great video so i wont dislike it, still some of these sins are just bullshit

I´m surprised you didn´t call out the amazingly over used mechanic of the boxes with wheels.

Why do you sin Laura Bailey working with Troy and Nolan so often? She actually worked with Troy literally in more than 50 video games which is awesome since they are both such an awesome fucking duo. I'm surprised Laura and Troy didn't get married in real life?!

You sinned the game for Nate not dying when he fell off the cliff, then less than 2 minutes later sin the game for Rafe not "safely assuming" Nate was alive because the fall wasn't that far. Tf.

Nadine is South African....

9:27, wrong. Sully did know about Sam because Nate met Sully at 16 years old and Sam and Nate went to the Panamanian jail in their 20s or 30s. It is even referenced many times later in the game that Sully and Sam already met previously.

Comments seem largely from people who don’t understand sins videos are a joke, satire if you will, and want to react violently when they watch a channel they don’t understand. I would suggest starting by looking up the word ‘satire’ and watching a few episodes of Have I Got News For You. Or spending time in Great Britain where we take the piss out of things we like...especially our mates.

My big question is why didnt they just go back and get the rest of the treasure? The ship blew up but the gold didnt go anywhere. Just come back with some equipment to open up a hole into the cave and some diving gear.

Elena isn't mad about Nate doing illegal stuff, she's mad about him lying to her.

The story of Sam in prison shouldn't count because he made itt all up

31:13 I know I'm late but I'm gonna give you a sin for not realizing this section being a parallel of CRASH BANDICOOT lol

25:33 made me laugh so hard I cried 🤣🤣

That Nathan got beaten the shit out of him is quit realistic. Nate is propably 40 While Nadine looks younger. Also she knews martial arts and presumbley does a regular Training While Nate hasnt fought since Uncharted 3 (I think) and only has "street style" Combat skills.

ohhh shit PRODUCTION VALUE WENT UP IN THE FIRST 30 SECONDS

Dartigan: Nolan North is good at game sins. Just please don't start up your own channel. I can't compete with that. Nolan North: Starts up Retro Replay with Troy Baker.

I'm sinning you for not knowing a South African accent

I found it weird that Nadine had trouble finding English speakers at the auction yet the announcer holding the auction spoke in English to everyone.

"Straight up dead." 2 minutes later "Why didn't they check if he was alive, he probably was after that."

1:06 Nate even used a grappling hook in number 2 with tenzin while looking for Schaefer’s expedition, and he even said that using a grappling hook was hard to use. I don’t think they thought this through, or they just forgot.

26:54 - The REAL sin here is that the whole Alcazar flashback is rendered pointless now that we know it's fake.

I can't believe you missed the fact that Nate is literally Wolverine. He gets shot a bunch of times, then after a few seconds, heals up

NOTHING is wrong with Uncharted 4... NOTHING!!!

13:57- because Nate hasn’t seen Sully in 2 years. Were you listening to Elena on the couch in Chapter 4 unlike Nate?

24:55 Discount argument Nate and Elena had in Uncharted 1.

You could also add two more sins here . (1) they add a stealth mechanic but no stealth weapon even uncharted 2 had a silenced pistol . And (2) Nadine just escapes with no trace of her in the future you would think by the epilogue cassie would see a news article saying something along the lines of '' Rich woman finds lost treasure ''

I really like these videos, but this one feels very rushed. Many of the sins are simply wrong and can be easily dismissed.

10:38 You later learn Sam made up this entire prisonbreak flashback. So how do you die during something that never happened? 32:20 Didn't Avery and the other pirate captains kill all the other colonists to keep the treasure for themselves? Then Avery poisoned the other pirate captains to keep all the money for himself? So who would follow him? He'd still need a skeleton crew on his ship to go anywhere.

Bonus sin: How did Sam survive prison? -prisoners hate him for beating up Gustavo -he is a thief -the guards hate him for killing the head guard -he is white -compared to the oder prisoners in there he is puny -he is alone

how is Laura Bailey starring in a game with Troy and Nolan a sin?

18:38 Actually, the hardest country to infect in Plague Inc. is Greenland because it only has a seaport and ships rarely go there. If the seaport closes there, then you're screwed

28:53 should be an extra sin. Even if that headsmash into a rock wall while falling wouldn't kill you, it would most certainly not leave some kind of scratch mark.

"Just get her a PS5 or something" Looks like that is gonna happen soon....

Actually Nate said himself he could've just looked Alcazar up.

had to stop after 19, a lot sounded like nit picking.

"Please don't start up your own channel" *looks at Retro Replay* Welp...

13:50 well to be fair Elena mentions that Nate hasn't seen Sully in 2 years, and getting them together could have been done with a phone call, so it's plausible that this is in fact the first time Nate's seen Sully in years

"Way to be subtle, Rafe you might as well wear a sandwich board that says, me bad guy on it" I lost it 😂😂

Aww even Naughty Dog misses Crash.

24:48 _Tomb Raider just called. They'd like you to stop using their climbing mechanic."_ Should have added 100 sins right there.

The like to dislike ratio clearly shows how many people are new to sin channels. This is comedy. Nothing is without flaws.

Nadine is not English... that's a South African accent you're hearing, smarty! That's a sin for you.

Kudos to you for acknowledging that nice banter Nate and Elena had on the couch; when I got to that scene in the game, it was the first time I've ever been impressed by a video game's portrayal of a couple.

27:16 was seriously too funny

12:15 there's also the fact that he should've sent somebody along "with" Sam to "protect his investment." cuz what if Sam gets himself killed?

Gaming sin number 67 is explained as Nate making a phone call to Sully. CLEARLY a nitpick.

Why was I getting an Of Mice and Men vibe when Alkazar said he wanted Sam to talk about the treasure?

Did this guy really just call an Uncharted Game unrealistic. Bro... That's the point

7:05 My family has a generic, larger, framed picture of a forest in our living room

I am confuse why is he sinning the stuff relating to Sam's prison break, if we found out later in the game that Sam made it up.

The game just came out... Why so soon?

I'm amazed Nate isn't in prison given his status by the fourth game as a mass murderer of thousands.

I love the "just wait until I destroy this one too" line 😂

he never used the grappling Hook until the 4th game, because every time he used it, he was reminded of his brother. This is clearly visible in the level during the Panama jail level

the biggest thing I had a problem with in this game was the sword fight at the end; a couple of swords stuck in dead bodies and left in an underground ship to rot and rust for hundreds of years would NOT still be sharp

A missed sin could be when Elena asked if there was ever a Malaysia job yet Nate stays silent even though there was in fact a Malaysia job

Nate uses a flip phone to show how much he doesn’t rely on/ appreciate technology that much. That’s why later on when Sully and Sam fail to find signal on their phones, Drake exclaims that paper never loses signal and uses a map to navigate instead

Finally someone else notices the complete 180 with Elena's character.

13:26 But Nate has a Play Station 1, so it's olay for him to use a flip phone, but he has a flat screen TV and later on in the game he is using a touch screen phone... Wtf NaughtyDog?

I don't care how many sins this game will get. I still felt super empty after finishing this (in my opinion) best play station series. I felt like I had a hangover or something. I bloody love Uncharted.

13:57 Nate haven’t seen Sully in 2 years, so it would make sense for you to be happy to see your old partner again.

So many comments trying to defend the game from this guy. Does no one know that The everything wrong with series isn't meant to be taken seriously?

What I really don't get is Nate's childhood. In the 3rd (or 2nd?) game, Nate kinda lives on the streets somewhere in South America, keeping his head up by stealing. Sully then finds him in a museum and adopts him. Now in this game, Nate lives in an orphanage, all of the sudden there's a brother no one ever knew about, Sully is completely out of the story. Are there two different timelines? One where Sully adopted Nate and one where Nate grew up alone? I'm so confused :D

This will always be my favorite game. Nothing can even top it.

The biggest sin is that in new devon, when you go through (I think) Thomas Tew’s mansion, there is a massive current and you have to climb and do monkey shit to push a crate thingy to help Elena get up , then you have to lift a shelf out of the way to get through a door, now the bookshelf is on a barrel, if Nate just nudged the barrel he wouldn’t have to spend 10-15 seconds lifting a bookshelf