No video

Defeating Communal Politics: Can Post-Election India Be Made Secular Again? | Dr. Vivek Monteiro

  Рет қаралды 9,966

The Black Hole

The Black Hole

Күн бұрын

The astonishing setback for Narendra Modi’s BJP in the Indian elections has raised the intriguing question of whether Indian voters have rejected the communal narrative targeting India’s non-Hindu minorities, particularly Muslims. How will the results affect India’s direction both internally and externally? Are there lessons that Pakistan needs to learn?
● About the Speaker:
» Dr. Vivek Monteiro is the State Secretary of CITU (Centre of Indian Trade Unions) for Maharashtra and joint coordinator of the Trade Union Joint Action Committee in the state. With a background in theoretical physics, he earned his BSc from Bombay University, MS from Caltech, and PhD from SUNY Stony Brook, USA. His activism began during the anti-Vietnam War movement in the USA, and upon returning to India in 1974, he became a full-time trade unionist in 1977. Dr. Monteiro is also involved in the people’s science movement and has received awards for his contributions to math and science education, along with being a member of the Maharashtra state committee of the Communist Party of India (Marxist).
» The session is moderated by Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy.

Пікірлер: 75
@pramodofindia
@pramodofindia Ай бұрын
It is ironical that a "kattar" Islamic republic is concerned about India losing its secularism. 😅
@chakdeamerica
@chakdeamerica Ай бұрын
India is secular because it is 80% Hindu majority. India would be a Islamic Country if India were a 80% Muslims majority.
@atulkumar-pr4yo
@atulkumar-pr4yo Ай бұрын
Why do you want secular India not Pakistan?
@srinum6774
@srinum6774 Ай бұрын
To remove communal politics the first step would be UCC Second would be Abolishing Waqf act Are you secular enough to contemplate that? Don’t worry BJP is spineless they won’t do both !
@sagarsansare572
@sagarsansare572 Ай бұрын
Who defines the secular country? Surely not a Pakistani
@GoluKr-hn3lb
@GoluKr-hn3lb Ай бұрын
Plz make a separate video on condition of minorities in Pakistan
@Troll24_365
@Troll24_365 Ай бұрын
Why are you worried about india..why not make secular pakistan first😂😂
@p-a-a-r-o
@p-a-a-r-o Ай бұрын
How about talking Ways to make a SECULAR PAKISTAN ?? How about finding ways to save the innocent Christian Boy given De ath penalty recently for Blasphemy ?? You want a Secular India but will go to any extent to preserve Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Let that sink in.
@ashokhariharan1243
@ashokhariharan1243 Ай бұрын
Absolutely hypocritical this view on secularism from Pakistan-those who live in glass houses don’t throw stones
@vish1080
@vish1080 Ай бұрын
Under Nehru, Indira, Sonia, Manmohan, India was non secular and shariat sympathetic, Today under modi, India is secular and broken this appeasement politics.. So hosh kro rediklon
@JaiShivrai
@JaiShivrai Ай бұрын
Why is Pakistan an Islamic country worried abt India's Secularism😂😂😂
@SuspectUsual
@SuspectUsual Ай бұрын
*Before 2014* : Bharat was forcibly made Sickular! *After 2014* : Bharat is trying to become truly Secular!
@appuss1
@appuss1 Ай бұрын
Isn’t it ironic that a “progressive” from Pakistan like hoodbhoy is mainly focusing on the communal/secular angle of bjp’s defeat. It’s not even in the top 3 issues of this election on which bjp lost on. Otherwise it would be a clean sweep for bjp.
@1008apocalypse1008
@1008apocalypse1008 Ай бұрын
"India's muslim personal laws are more regressive than Pakistan's" 💕
@satya1465
@satya1465 Ай бұрын
Savarkar was the first leader who opened temples for Dalit. Muslim cap is Arabic & Turkic dress. Modi wears Sikh pagadi and regional caps which are native to Bharat.
@IMRAN.AFRIDI
@IMRAN.AFRIDI Ай бұрын
Non of your suedo liberals has given even a single statement about the state of human rights for the past 2 years. Indians has shown you that democracy is still prevailing in their country.
@devrajjhingta2310
@devrajjhingta2310 Ай бұрын
Why don’t you pakistani make your country secular
@JaiShivrai
@JaiShivrai Ай бұрын
1:04 :12 Why will Modi a Hindu Sanatani wear a Muslim cap?? Will a Muslim Leaders n politicians apply a Tilak and do puja of our gods n Goddesses?? We Hindus follow all sects of our Santan dharma why do u expect a hindu to do rituals or anything regarding other religions???
@sumitsuri256
@sumitsuri256 Ай бұрын
Communal tumhari congress hai since independence..they keep pak happy and let Kashmir suffer or can't even control terrorist attacks elsewhere
@rajnishwarijha395
@rajnishwarijha395 Ай бұрын
Haaa For mushlim Secularism only ptevelled untill mushlim is in minority. In India all dhakosala secular political party work how Hindus makes minority as soon as. Dhakosala secular hindu also the agent of ishlamist and they strong the dhakosala secular political party how chane the Indian demography.
@ravichavan7513
@ravichavan7513 Ай бұрын
Wait and watch. Modi and his team will fix everything in his third term. He is elected for the third time because crores of Indians have trust in his capabilities and devotion in his work and his vision and mission for the growth of the country.
@JohnSmith-sl6eg
@JohnSmith-sl6eg Ай бұрын
To understand the result of Indian Elections it would have been better to invite a politically impartial person from India to explain rather than member of a political party CPM and INDI Alliance, whose opinion are colored with vested interest. Its like to understand the results of recent Pakistani Election we invite someone who is a member of PTI or JUI or PMLN.
@xzx255
@xzx255 Ай бұрын
Those who doesn't know about professor Hoodbhoy , please don't comment irrationally. He is hated by his countrymen in the same way that bhakts are doing here . Respect his knowledge. A fan from the secular part of India 🇮🇳
@KrishnaKumar-xb5om
@KrishnaKumar-xb5om Ай бұрын
First of all, thank you for drawing the india map correct on the board.
@SantoshMishra76
@SantoshMishra76 Ай бұрын
My request to organisers of blackhole is to invite a common citizen of india to talk to audience to get a clear picture .. and since Dr. Hoodbhoy is a scientist by training , he must also invite other leaders across the political spectrum in india to talk and get an clear picture. Nobody in India takes left seriously anymore , they are a relic of past and by 2029 , they will also be out of picture fully
@bittu3341
@bittu3341 Ай бұрын
One convert indian guy talking to Pakistan converts about secularism in india 😂
@vishalpandey1268
@vishalpandey1268 Ай бұрын
Funny these guys talk about secularism ,just tell us what happened to 26 percent Hindus and Sikhs which lived in Pakistan in 1947 ,then talk about secularism all you want
@bodhisattva6308
@bodhisattva6308 Ай бұрын
The funny thing is most closest to a secular state is France today. Indian secularist would not like a French secularism. It’s a complicated discussion actually
@kamalkant3192
@kamalkant3192 Ай бұрын
Kya baat hai, dekho Pakistani gyaan da rahe India ke secularism par, jo khud ek Islamic country hai.
@mohitkumarrai5536
@mohitkumarrai5536 24 күн бұрын
80 percent hindus ki wajah se hi India secular hai
@ShivamSoni-uz5xw
@ShivamSoni-uz5xw Ай бұрын
Kitna giroge??
@shortinformation6073
@shortinformation6073 Ай бұрын
No because now Congressi support islamic cammunalism and stand against UCC
@1008apocalypse1008
@1008apocalypse1008 Ай бұрын
Why there is no 'healthy divide' amongst Muslims of India?
@sumitmukherjee2
@sumitmukherjee2 27 күн бұрын
It's very disheartening to see so many Indians question why Pakistanis are bothered about the state of secularism in India, when it's quite evident from the tone of the conversation that this group of Pakistanis want a move towards secularism. It's quite shameful that we're raised to feel so much animosity towards Pakistanis, that we forget that it is also a large country with a diversity of viewpoints. Anyways, kudos the folks hosting these conversations. As an Indian with some Pakistani ancestry, I am rooting for y'all to have a healthy democracy soon.
@VoLvOX.
@VoLvOX. 25 күн бұрын
Absolutely true, I was also thinking about that.
@VinodBandari-ps5yd
@VinodBandari-ps5yd Ай бұрын
black hole ought not call any pro indi alliance members but a neutral to inculcate true picture of india 😊
@mohitkumarrai5536
@mohitkumarrai5536 24 күн бұрын
Don't worry BJP will rise again soon
@rkpotukuchi1
@rkpotukuchi1 Ай бұрын
First of all, thank you for drawing the India map correct on the board. And it's a joke to discuss at Pakistan and be concerned of India's secular state. Can there be a sincere effort, debate, dialog in Pakistan about the miniscule minorities that are left over there?
@sreenathc
@sreenathc 19 күн бұрын
When Pakistan is an Islamic country, why would they be asking India to be secular??? Strange!
@bharatphoenix
@bharatphoenix Ай бұрын
Learn from Pakistan and learn how not to become like Pakistan!! What made India survive as one and thrive ? And why we should improve on it ? - not that we let indias worst impulses take it down the route of Pakistan. Modi’s campaign was disgusting and so was his entire political history Wish Pakistan changes for the better and India resets its path to what made it better in the first place. Hate has no place - universal human rights and dignity of life should be the goal
@ramendradwivedi4530
@ramendradwivedi4530 Ай бұрын
Bhai India phle bhi secular tha abhi bhi hai constitution padh le thoda aur kabhi India Aakr ghum le
@dollartreeshark6786
@dollartreeshark6786 Ай бұрын
We will bring UCC to ensure secualrism
@shailendrapatil6217
@shailendrapatil6217 Ай бұрын
Sharad pawar is big figure in maharashtra
@maheshpant518
@maheshpant518 Ай бұрын
Indeed, the audience though thin appears diligent.
@subhashkatkar6364
@subhashkatkar6364 24 күн бұрын
Pakistan should demonstrate equal treatment for shiya, Suni, Ahmedi, Devbandi fist befor teaching India to become Secular.
@harshnaik6989
@harshnaik6989 Ай бұрын
Thank you for bringing Dr. Vivek Monteiro!
@shreyashpande4796
@shreyashpande4796 Ай бұрын
are par tumhare country me tum secularism kab laoge
@VinodBandari-ps5yd
@VinodBandari-ps5yd Ай бұрын
bharat mey jaichand millions mey hai aur aab bharat ko tutney sey koi nahi bacha sakta 😢
@ramachandraraolakkaraju8970
@ramachandraraolakkaraju8970 Ай бұрын
For a better Bharat, secularism is the path ... progress for all on scientific understanding...citu&com.Dr.vivek monterio thanks &our greetings...
@Shantanu85
@Shantanu85 Ай бұрын
Thank you for drawing the correct map of India!
@aditya93784
@aditya93784 21 күн бұрын
India is a very tolerant country. You Islamic fundamentalists don't have the right to talk about how secular India is 😡
@nomanbasheer3536
@nomanbasheer3536 Ай бұрын
I m surprised at ignorant Indians who have no idea about the formation of Pakistan which got its independence purely on religious grounds while NEhru and Gandhi totally maintained the claim that there was no divide between the Muslims and the Hindus thus preaching a secuar India. If BJP is successful in enforcing its Hindutva ideology, it will naturally justify the creation of Pakistan
@KrishnkantSingh-qk8tk
@KrishnkantSingh-qk8tk Ай бұрын
We have no issues if hindutva in india justifies creation of Pakistan. Don't get fooled by this communist idiot. Most hindus support hindutva and even those hindus who oppose it publicly are not fond of Muslims at all. In short indian society is today extremely hinduised. I am a hindutva supporter and elections really don't determine the advancement of hindutva I india.
@distilledpoison7563
@distilledpoison7563 Ай бұрын
Why does he look and talks like mohan bhagwat 😭
@helloneet321
@helloneet321 21 күн бұрын
Irony in its peak 😂😂😂😂
@Sk-cr2bl
@Sk-cr2bl Ай бұрын
True picture of India ....... But we need akhand Bharat......🙏🙏👍👍👍🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@SushilKumar-sm1dh
@SushilKumar-sm1dh Ай бұрын
Sive sena ;congress,,comnsit vaha Kiya mel he
@parvindersingh9781
@parvindersingh9781 Ай бұрын
sir app apne desh ki bat kre views na chase kre .......... hmare nam pe .....
@QasimAli-tc2pj
@QasimAli-tc2pj Ай бұрын
Why indians here are upset about the topic of the discussion anyway it's just scholars sharing knowledge and guest speaker is also indian
@atheist2982
@atheist2982 Ай бұрын
From india❤
@salimalvi5178
@salimalvi5178 Ай бұрын
He says Namaskar which was Salam etc which was originally Shalom. You decide which represents native Bharat and which is imposed on natives.
@devrajjhingta2310
@devrajjhingta2310 Ай бұрын
Why don’t you pakistani make your country secular
Pakistan at 77: A Time for Course Correction
2:05:18
The Black Hole
Рет қаралды 18 М.
Bertrand Russell - Philosopher and Activist | Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy
1:40:27
Schoolboy - Часть 2
00:12
⚡️КАН АНДРЕЙ⚡️
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН
Harley Quinn lost the Joker forever!!!#Harley Quinn #joker
00:19
Harley Quinn with the Joker
Рет қаралды 23 МЛН
Harley Quinn's plan for revenge!!!#Harley Quinn #joker
00:49
Harley Quinn with the Joker
Рет қаралды 27 МЛН
I'm Excited To see If Kelly Can Meet This Challenge!
00:16
Mini Katana
Рет қаралды 33 МЛН
Exploring India's Past: From Al-Beruni to Marco Polo and Ibn-Battuta
1:48:19
India’s Cricket With Ayaz Memon | Caught Behind
1:08:26
Caught Behind
Рет қаралды 100 М.
Why Pakistan Should NEVER Go To Nuclear War? Ft. Dr. Engr. M. Afzal Khan | EP190
53:59
Why Abdus Salam Isn't Celebrated As Pakistan's Hero Ft. Pervez Hoodbhoy EP158
49:39
How Does It Work Podcast
Рет қаралды 80 М.
A Roadmap to Fiscal Sustainability
1:06:09
Tabadlab
Рет қаралды 20 М.
Schoolboy - Часть 2
00:12
⚡️КАН АНДРЕЙ⚡️
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН