BTOB is known for being reeeeeeeally loud (many groups said it's difficult to rehearse before shows because you can hear them warming up their voices through the hallways 😆😆). When they recorded this episode of killing voice, their voices were so loud that they overlapped with each other's microphones and Dingo had to edit it. So, many adlibs were cut out. That's why sometimes you can see them singing but you can barely hear them. I guess Dingo's mics aren't BTOB proof 😂😂

I can't with the person that kept saying that Peniel was the maknae and no one correct that 😅 hahahaha

Hyunsik and Minhyuk is the producer line in Btob. 🔥🔥🙌🏻💙💙

BtoB basically throw away their image with how crazy they are. their managers had given up on keeping btobs idol image

They are all crazy. If you want to see how they are react to BTOB are the quietest and reserved idols part 1 -6

Their vocals are unreal

Not only was this a great reaction, I really liked reading the chats in your live stream too! Such a lovely community!✨ Thank you for the reaction, looking forward to your future reactions of BTOB! 💙 The fact you picked up on BTOB saying "MELODY, it's all cause of you!" & "MELODY-SARANG... HAEEEE!" and asked if we were called Melody, that was lowkey impressive lol!

Btob is Vocal king in kpop industry 🙌🏻🙌🏻🔥🙏🏼💙

0:44 *From left to right* : MINHYUK, SUNGJAE (Maknae), EUNKWANG (Leader), HYUNSIK, CHANGSUB and PENIEL.

Love BTOB’s harmonies!! Discovered them during Kingdom!

I saw them at a festival.. I admit I wasn't there for them... but "I'll be your man" has never left my head since.. it was incredible

I saw someone in chat say BtoB is underrated. They are most definitely not underrated; BtoB is seen as a top tier group - highly respected for their skills. Their popularity on an international scale is definitely lower, but I wouldn’t say it’s a matter of their ~value, rather their music simply doesn’t have a wide reach. Unfortunate but true.

Never heard these guys - great harmonies👏👏. Thanks for broadening my musical world, Roscoe. It's been a fun journey!

Thank you for this reaction. If you want to know more about them, I would recommend checking out their guide, either from Ilhoon Squad (shorter guide) or Daemelro BTOB (longer guide). However, these are some information that I would like to share with you.The members from left to right are: - Lee Minhyuk/Huta (2nd eldest, 1 of most athletic idol, composed a lot of songs for BTOB but mostly on the B-side, also known as HUTA when he releases solo songs) - Yook Sungjae (youngest/maknae of the group, well-known as drama actor) - Seo Eunkwang (leader and eldest of the group, musical actor) - Im Hyunsik (4th eldest, known as father of BTOB's music because he composed a lot of title-songs for BTOB) - Lee Changsub (3rd eldest, intro-fairy (because he usually sings the intro of their songs with his airy and emotional voice), musical actor) - Peniel Shin Donggeun (5th eldest, born-raised in Chicago, had alopecia so he usually keeps his hair short, active in podcasts with other American-Korean artists) - Ex-member: Jung Ilhoon (6th eldest, main rapper of the group, were also active as composer) These boys were trained to be a band group, acapella group, and acrobatic group. They can dance, play instruments, and will always sing live. Their songs are also really hard to cover because their songs have multiple layers of harmonies and powerful adlibs. All the rappers write their own lyrics for their parts in their songs since the early days until now. In Killing Voice, the song titles are the ones above, and the album titles are the ones below together with the year it was released. These are the songs in this Killing Voice if you are interested in checking out any of them: 1) 그리워하다 (Missing you), 2017 - composed by Hyunsik 2) 봄날의 기억 (Remember That), 2016 3) 두 번째 고백 (2nd Confession), 2013 4) 너 없인 안된다 (Only One For Me), 2018- composed by Hyunsik 5) 아름답고도 아프구나 (Beautiful Pain), 2018-composed by Hyunsik 6) 언젠가 (Someday), 2017- composed by Hyunsik 7) 괜찮아요 (It's Okay), 2015 8) 기도 (Pray/I'll Be Your Man), 2016- composed by Hyunsik 9) Higher, 2022 - composed by Minhyuk 10) Blue Moon, originally 2018 & cinema ver. 2021 - composed by Minhyuk 11) 노래 (The Song), 2022 - composed by Hyunsik 12) 우리 (Us/Be Together), 2022- composed by Hyunsik 13) 나의 바람 (Wind and Wish), 2023- composed by Hyunsik 14) Finale: 우리들의 콘서트 (Finale: Our Concert), 2017 Changsub is really weird and does things his way. He became really good friend with Key from Shinee during their millitary service and he said that Key is the one who kept him from making troubles while Key said that he kept having 2nd-hand embarrassment because of things that Changsub did. They also said they are a really good team because Key is really good at planning, and Changsub is really good at executing the plan. 😂😂😂 From what I observed, the most put together one is Minhyuk. He keep things neat and he does the nagging to the other members when they were living together (he eventually gives up trying to make the other members as neat 😂). Being one of the eldest in the group with Eunkwang, he is like the mother while Eunkwang is like the father of the group. In S.Korea, they are really well-known as Healing-idol (they are famous for their soothing ballads) and Beagle-dol (they are really chaotic, playful, funny, loud, weird and laid-back). You can see how they are in a compilation series 'Reserved and Quiet Idols, BTOB' or any of their shows or the shows that they joined (Born to BTOB, BTOB Three Meals, Kingdom, Beatcom, others..) Some additional info on their vocal training: - Eunkwang and Changsub trained at the same vocal training center since they were in their high school years. - Changsub and Hyunsik are alumni of Practical Music Major in Howon University(one of the most prestigious university for the Practical Music major in Korea), and they were the only 2 male students accepted for early admission for their batch with the other 3 being girls (early admission have 5:3000 ratio of acceptance at that time) Again, thank you for this reaction. 🥰🥰

What i love the most in BTOB their amazing harmony, melodic rap/singRap , and songs that never get old no matter how many times you've heard it. Thank you for diving into them looking forward for more BTOB content from you🙏😊

Love this show really highlights their voices and harmonies. Poor Sis.

Thanks for your reaction to BTOB! I love Eunkwang's ad-libs in concert, and their live performances are so wonderful that I feel something is missing from the CD soundtrack

Lol Changsub was invited to Key from Shinee's house to celebrate his puppy's bday party and he was so shy and cute. Key did provide sum liquid courage and he kept chugging them. Then Key left to cook lunch for him and their other guest Taeyeon from Girls' Generation's and he was like don't leave me alone here! If u wanna watch look up, "Shinee's Key, Throws Chaotic Birthday Party For His Dogs With Girls' Generation's Taeyeon And BTOB's Changsub In "Home Alone"

Peniel is awesome! I watch him talk on the Get Real podcast with BM from KARD and Ashley Choi - you can check them out on the DIVE STUDIOS channe on YT. They talk mostly in English, as all of them are grew up in the States. Thank you Roscoe for reacting to BtoB! (I'm a STAY, but stan BTOB because of Peniel... and Kingdom performances with Stray Kids)

Thank you so much for reacting to BTOB's Killing Voice..they are truly the vocal/harmony kings. I believe the actual performance they did here was so good and full of adlibs but their voices were so powerful and overlapping in each other's mics that Dingo staff had to edit it coz they said it sounded like a choir of many people. Dingo admitted to cutting out some sounds and even apologized for it..but BTOB live vocals are really top tier. Fun facts: Minhyuk and Hyunsik are the songwriter/composer/producers of the group (and for other artists too). Eunkwang & Changsub are both musical actors. Hyunsik & Sungjae were enlisted during Kingdom. Hyunsik was the one who wrote/produced/sang La Mar..you reacted to the mv. Sungjae is the maknae. Sungjae & Minhyuk are both actors. Changsub became more organized lately now that he has his own house & has his own talent training center, too. He's sometimes shy & silent..but most of the times he is crazy & funny and SO LOUD..he is the group's living meme. Now, Eunkwang is really the best when it comes to vocals..he already had his 5th win on Immortal Songs and people already know he's a legend when it comes to singing. He's the main vocals..the oldest & the leader & the target of all the teasing & bullying of maknae line. Also so funny especially when he's doing English time..even serious, he can't help but be funny like his life is a sitcom. These guys have been together years even before they debuted in 2012 and they treat each other like real brothers. They have genuine love & respect for each other and truly love their fans. They are one hell of a group and their music is worth listening to. Hope you could check out their THRILLER mv, IT'S OKAY dance version, WOW dance version, ONLY ONE FOR ME mv, BEAUTIFUL PAIN mv, REMEMBER THAT mv and THE SONG. They have a lot more..but I hope you could start with those. Hoping for more BTOB reactions..thank you.

I laugh sooo hard when u said changsub is the quiet one...wait till u watch funny btob moments😂😂😂

I’ve got eargasm when I finally heard them live last concert here in the Philippines. They gave me a total of good vibes for my entire 2024. I am forever Melody. My expectations exceeded 1000%. Such a gem I wouldn’t trade.

So glad you reacted to them, their voices are just heavenly

I totally love BTOB and found them thangs to Kingdom. The harmony is just amazing and they are way to underrated.. sadly.. Edit: Eunkwang once said, he wanted to make music and sing, because he wanted to reach people and help them. Heal them.

I’ve lost track of how many times I’ve seen this killing voice episode and how many times I’ve watched people react to it. At some point, I just wanted to listen to the full songs and found a playlist with all their ballads

it makes me happy to see more people get to discover BTOB and they start to wonder how come they never knew BTOB before. coz thats how i felt back then Dec2016. I regret not knowing them earlier. but later on i realized ive crossed paths with BTOB way back then. ive played the OST of Cinderella and the four knights a thousand times not knowing it was BTOB who sang it. Also, i liked sungjae in Goblin but i never paid attention to actors/idols before. BTOB just celebrated their 12th anniversary but they are still growing stronger in their careers and more doors are opening for them. I am proud to see them striving despite the odds that come their way.

I haven't been on KZfaq in a few days, but I have never clicked so fast, Roscoe. So happy you enjoyed BTOB! To see their true nature, I suggest "BTOB are reserved and quiet idols" videos on KZfaq. Funny and you get to know them better.

omg yes!!! I can't believe today's finally the say you see BTOB's Killing Voice!!! I love them so much. I've seen there killing voice multiple times now and it doesn't get old. There vocals are just outstanding! Loved watching your reaction and am excited to see you react to BTOB even more in the future. 💜

Thank you so much for reacting to btob!!! ❤

Now you know the real kings of killing voices 😊

I discovered BTOB when I watched Solar's vlog with Changsub. I love BTOB as much with MAMAMOO. I am addicted recently on harmonies. Thank you for reacting to BTOB! 💙

I don't know if you know this already but a member of the group Big Mama trained 2 of the members of BTOB in singing! Big Mama have their own Killing Voice if you haven't watched it already! They're known as professor-dols because all of them are vocal teachers at various universities in South Korea. One of them is a Dean at a university. They debuted in 2003, and have made some of the most amazing harmonies I've ever heard. I hope you watch it if you haven't already!

OMG!!!! You reacted to BTOB! Now u’re officially one if my fave youtuber! Stray kids and btob on your channel, im done! Btob unfortunately not really known worldwide, but in South Korea, they are very popular and highly respected. When you talk about vocal, you can never forget Btob. Not to forget, Ilhoon (the member that unfortunately needed to leave the group), is still until today one of the best rapper in South Korea.

Thanks for appreciating our Beats. I really enjoyed your and your chat's comments. Sungjae is the only one not in his 30's and the only one in the vocal line without serious vocal training before becoming a Cube trainee. His voice has come into its own now and I think you'll enjoy his cover of Benson Boone's "Beautiful Things." You've seen them on Kingdom so now you may like reacting to the 2012 "Wow" MV to see where they came from. I would love to see your reaction to the Kingdom Mayfly vocal unit's cover of IU's "Love Poem." As a director, you may be interested in some of their song production videos. "Wind and Wish" Recording Day: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/ns1mlN1-ypPFg3U.htmlsi=DCKt0Dgw4ZwfLPTd

These guys are simply incredible, each of them is unique in their own way. But when they are all together, it is something absolutely incredible a hundredfold. God, their voices can “turn off” your brain and mentally take you somewhere very, very far away!

The one that is really organized and quiet is Minhyuk though 😅. Changsub is more like a free soul jeje, but he is quiet with people he doesn't know. Actually in Korea Changsub is one of the most famous idols right now he is among BTS members in popularity for his youtube program and his appearances on variety programs. That has start making his solo songs more famous too, and soon he will have a solo comeback, for his current popularity in Korea maybe he could even win a music show i dont know or chart really well in music apps.

Minhyuk writes almost all of their songs💙 Changsub is musicals artist, Hyunsik also writes amazing songs, Eunkwang leader (9:54 as he glanced at Peniel 😂) Sungjae - actor and the youngest member). I'm happy to be Melody 💙

BTOB are where I go when I need a good ballad or 80. Their vocals and harmonies are unmatched. You were watching kingdom..make sure you watch their stages! They are next level vocals! Stray Kids covered I’ll Be Your Man. Han sings. It’s my absolute favorite kingdom stage!

Their live performances, concerts are great

don't worry about subtitles. I like the sounds, the vocals are stellar. I dislike love songs so not knowing what they are saying lets me enjoy the songs. such gorgeous vocals.

I've lost count of how many times I've watched their killing voice tbh

저도 은광님 좋아합니다.비투비노래들어주셔서 감사해요.방탄도 사랑합니다.😊

Thank you for appreciation of BtoB, they are the best in their crafts really amazing! 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙 Waves from Filo-Melody's❤🫰🏻

glad you enjoyed this one!! hope you check out more of BTOB!! ♥

Sad i missed this live but i am so glad you reacted to it. My favorite Killing Voice ep

Thankyou for reacting to my one and only favorite kpop group.💙

Thank you for react my favorite killing voice

The Kingdom Mayfly vocal unit needs to be at the top of your list. Eunkwang is spectacular, and Ateez’s Jongho and Stray Kids’ Puppy are absolutely perfect. The song is a cover of IU’s Love Poem, and it is beautiful.

you're such a respectful, fun person to watch. it's my first time watching you but i really liked this.

You also have to read the translation of their songs. Because it’s full of meaning, deep. Also, they always end their concerts with the last song that was sang 😢 it’s one of my favorite songs ever ❤❤❤

BTOB The Vocal Kings The Healing Idols The Beagledol This group has a diverse discography. They're very versatile, they can sing any genre. Rappers can sing and Vocals can rap. The rappers wrote their own lyrics. 2 members are on Musicals and one has his own Music Academy. 2members passed on one prestigous university with a cutthroat of 3000:5. 3 members are songwriters and producers. Hyunsik is considered Father of BTOB's music. If you dig deeper, you'll discover how talented each member is. Hope to watch more BTOB reactions

I’ve only just brushed the surface with your videos so I’m like way behind, but BTOB is my favorite group so of course I had to watch this first. I hope you react to more of their stuff because they are such an amazing and talented group.

Roscoe you should react to some reserved and quiet idols: BTOB!!!! That compilation will show you the real BTOB hahah

Omg YES. CHANGSUB IS THE MOST QUIET BTOB MEMBER. HAHAHAHAHAAH

@Roscoe I saw someone mention in the chat but wasn't sure you saw it. Eunkwang's mother is an Opera Singer and he performed with her on Immortal Songs, you can watch that here: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/brOErNR_q63PdKM.html&ab_channel=KBSWORLDTV

Thank you for taking time trying to remember their names❤

Thanks for your reaction, please love them more❤

Eunkwang's mother is a very talented singer, too. He was raised to be comfortable and happy on stage, and he definitely got her talent and love for music. They performed together on Immortal Songs kzfaq.info/get/bejne/brOErNR_q63PdKM.html

BtoB I used to listen to them all the time since debute, but I thought they disbanded so I stopped but glad they r still killing it as always.

Definitely recommending a deep dive in btob because they are literally the most underrated K-pop group

amazing reaction as i literally enjoy every second of it! hearing you pouring out your thoughts was fun! if you need some recommendation on where to check for next BTOB's video, perhaps you might wanna start with: 1. BTOB - Be Together Album listening 2. Helpful guide to BTOB enjoy. have a great day and looking forward to your next BTOB reaction!!

Thank youuu for reacting to btob🥹 they’re talented and hillarious🤍

Thank you for listening to BTOB💙💙💙

this should have subs cause the things they are saying are so funny, btob is one of the funniest groups to ever exist !!

you should watch their funny moment or their guide to know video, cause they are too funny🤣🤣

BTOB Is an amazing group. Their songs are so beautiful. They were great with Ilhoon...but things happened and... They grew up since that day. BTOB is really really a talented vocal group. I love their music (i enjoy especially the Japanese onces but that's because I love Japanese...the Korean ones are as good as the Japaneses ones). I love and support them from Switzerland.

Its not wrong to say Btob is the MOST vocally talented boy group currently active today. Everyone of them has vocals. Peniel's name always throws everyone off haha, you have to be a very religious person to recognize his name. Its from the Bible, it means Face of God. Peniel is also one of the 4 angels that directly serve God alongside Michael, Gabriel and Raphael in Enoch. He was the Angel of Penance. Peniel is also the place Jacob wrestled an angel in the book of Genesis.

Best male vocal line in Kpop. FACTS

there was another member who unfortunately left the group - Ilhoon 💙 super fun and positive rapper. all Melody hope that he will return to the group🥹🤞

waiting for another BTOB's reaction video😊

My boys🥹🥹💙💙💙 The talented, unhinged kings of kpop lmao

Sungjae is the best known person from this group. He has been in some of the best kdramas produced. Those people in your chat really doesn't have a clue if that's all they said about Sungjae. In fact Sungjae could probably carry this group alone on his name alone. That's how BIG he is.

Please react to eunkwang's "rock star" Changsub's "gone"

changsub also close to mamamoo solar and have done musicals together and did song singing exchange on her utube channel

I love BTOB❤

Actually, even Minhyuk admits that Hyunsik is "the body of BTOB". The guys talk about how he's so muscular and never even exercises. They mention his neck, "bowling ball shoulders", huge chest, abs and legs. And Eunkwang says Hyunsik has the best butt. Which I agree with.

Idk if Roscoe does videos like this, but I really need him to react to BTOB: Reserved & Quiet Idols series on YT.

I was waiting for this video my whole life thank you so much for doing this!! ❤❤❤

You must check TVXQ's too pure talent

waiting for more BTOB videos

Has Roscoe reacted to Huta's "Boom" MV? It's....tasty.

"Changsub has his shit together bcs he sings like that" little did you know he's the messiest sloppiest clumsiest 😂😂😂 P/s: Hyunsik used to vlog w members, his vlog was called Sik's Sense 😂 it's the funniest thing ever

Finaly!!!!!! Sooo good

I hope that you do a rection to infinite killing voice to😭 they are amazing

They grew up so handsomely 😢

Finally ! 😊

I wish you can check on TVXQ killing voice too

I feel the same and I like them 💙

Btotb are known to be the vocal king in kpop for years, here the staff had to low their mic cause their voice were too loud (some other good groupe known for their vocals "Beast/ Highlight - SHINee - & few others from 2nd gen) to be fair 2nd gen have really some if not the best vocals in kpop

Long time group

비투비 노래를 잘하는 가수네요

BTOB los mejores

Sadly the kpop industry is now filled with talentless idols especially the late 4th & 5th generation 😢

Check out Big Mama's Killing voice 😍

Scifishewolf if you see this, I love you fellow SHCJ 🧡

Has Roscoe reacted to Stray Kids version of BTOB's I'll be Your Man and BTOB's version of SKZ's Backdoor?

EXO -EXO слушейте их вакал не пажелейте потомушта ани карали вакала kpop ❤❤❤❤❤❤

Exo killing voice ❤

Kiiiiings ❤❤❤❤

💜💜