That's what I am also thinking

Blkul ...jistrha hurrem sultan ka cgehra bdla gya tha

It is Turkey after all and not Pakistan. A person can have a million reasons to leave their contract. Employment Contract is very strict in Turkey.

Its so normal for turk dramas caz their own public always watched the things when they famous in other countries big example is feriha etc 🙄 they killed her with no rZn

It's true Actors can be replaced however the Director says that the show is based on History not 100% history. Their is a significant difference between the 2

@fatima atif it is dear

Par real me history me halima sultan ertugrul ke bhi baad mari thi

@@rumesham8080 ertugrul ki history ki bahut kam details hai. Jyada tar part frictional hai. Yeh bhi clear nahi ki halima sach mein ertugrul ki wife thi ya nahi

Yea😜

@fatima atif 😂

Why you getting upset bro. Sure she is an actress and has individual rights. But a true professional actor/actress must also show loyalty to an ongoing major project from which she benefitted immensely. She had an obligation to act in an honorable and responsible. As has been reported because of Esra Bilgic's selfish irresponsible behaviour the real story of Halima Sultan had to be altered. Shame on Esra Bilgic. I wish another of the many capable Turkish actresses had been given the vital role of Halima Sultan. And then we would have seen the real role of Halima Sultan as per true history in both Dirillis Ertugral and supporting her son Osman Gazi as happened in history.

@Bilal khan bro you are confused. Mehmet Bozdag the man behind the Dirillis Ertugral drama had to change the script because of Esra Bilgic's decision to leave because she was offered another role while still in Season 4. In true history Halima Sultan is alive during her son Osman's rule. Not only Esra Bilgic but also others he had problems with. I believe now he makes them sign contracts so they can't leave. Hope that is clear now.

I couldn't agree with you more

hahahahaha...ye hmara almiya hai bro.... puri duniya inko actrors km or asli shkiyat zyada smj rahin... wo kya krty kya nai is se hmko koi concern ni hona haiye is dramy se humko jo lena hai wo message hai jeehad ka hthyar uthant ka datt jaany ka... tabhi Alim e kuffar ko taklef pari hui.... ye bat puru dyniya ko smjany k liye apko or mjy hi niklna prna LOL.....

I honestly agree with you. Esra Bilgic had every right to make her own decision to leave the show, I just wish they had replaced the actor rather then killing her off..

yeasss shii kha

Yes

Yes and ilbilge hatun suit Halime Role

No, no actress in my opinion could be better then halime

Yes

exactly!!!!

LOL 😂 how could she have been replaced?

U r absolutely rite it's depand upon director and it's his responsibilities to take right decision to show right history. He should have replaced person to another person. Instead of character..

Halima what have you done we miss you in ertugrul

@@AzamKhan-ht7wx it had been done before on other dramas...

Exactly

Soooo true my frnd . The actress got fame & won awards for her role as Halime Sultan . No person will leave it for another drama . I do not buy that but yes if the script was written in a way which wanted her dead then tht is wht has happened . She did justice to this show & character . We need to stop spreading these rumors . Story was written in this way & we need to appreciate that

@@maharafaqat9033 yes u are right. itd not real drama . it's fiction most of the characters are fiction . but they complete justice to their roled specially halima sultan .

They are lying 🤥 is not true

R Riaz i know

Yes season 5 is boring without halime and I don't like that ilbilge hatun !!😠😠😠i hate her becz she takes place of our halime!!!😠 I wish she will return back in kurlus Osman!!!💖💕

@@uroosakiran7366 yh ... Watching season 5 without her was too boring .... But engin altan's lov made me to watch it ..... I watched the half episode of osman but it has no flavour without ertugrul. ..

@@r_ia12 yes😭😭😰😓😒😪

@@uroosakiran7366 😢

Excatly& further more,it was her choice!!! She& the Producer Mr Mehmet Bozdag mst have come to some comparise! The real fact that Esra stood against Priyanka Chopra fr spreading hate speech against Kashmir,mde me love💞 her more thn her role as Halime Sultan,as Esra out rightly stood up fr her (RELIGION)ISLAM & that makes her a Great mascot of Islam!!! I Salute her for being a proud Muslim& standing in Solidarity with kashmir & her Muslim brothers & sisters& that's m0st important, rather than defaming her!!! Drillis Ertugrul is jst a drama based on Turkish history,wer some parts of the storyline was mde up fr entertainment!! With much Respect for Mr Mehmet Bozdag's Script writing& Producing such a informative inspirational Series..EVYALLAH MR. BOZDAG! As Muslims we should conceal one another's faults ,rather than disgracing your brother or sister in Islam!!! May Allah SWT.grnt us all nerq hidayt aameen thumaa aameen Ya Rabbaallaameen

Compromise*

Why did she commit to the role if she was unable to stay with the full five seasons? Whilst I admire Esra Bilgic's great acting it is disappointing to see her unprofessional, selfish and irresponsible behaviour.

Per mujy lagta hai.... Esra ne contra contract thek se parha nahi...ya phr drama sign krty waqt socha ni... K iss dramay ko banany me kitny saal lagy gy.... But any i salute to bamsi turgut & also abdur rehman ghazi.... Q k sab se ziyada dhekaye jany waly character yahi hai... Start se ly k abi tak.... 1st Bamsi or 2nd abdur rehman & 3rd turgut jo k agay aye ga kurulus osman me.... ❤

Exactly

Noooooooooo esra is the best role for halime noone else can replace her

Ur right

Yes they could have used the actress of illbilege hatun they look similar

@@eissaalhammadi9493 yes

The women playing Ertugruls second wife roll is perfect for older age version of Halime

utubebeena According to history, Halime was quite old when osman was born to ertugrul. Osman’s mother is unknown, but Halime died after ertugrul.

@@mahnoorqureshi3281 more the reason to replace Esra with another matured actress...! Anyways what is done is done

Yup

Yes☑️☑️☑️☑️☑️

So true

Not 2 seasons he stayed 3 seasons. That make me so angry 😡. If the director can keep a villain for 3 seasons why couldn't he keep the important role of Halime?

Why you getting upset bro. Why you bringing all the mehram/non mehram arguement here? The lady is giving the report on why the script had to be changed. You don't understand basic english? A true professional actor/actress must also show loyalty to an ongoing major project from which she benefitted immensely. She had an obligation to act in an honorable and responsible. As has been reported because of Esra Bilgic's selfish irresponsible behaviour the real story of Halima Sultan had to be altered. Shame on Esra Bilgic. I wish another of the many capable Turkish actresses had been given the vital role of Halima Sultan. And then we would have seen the real role of Halima Sultan as per true history in both Dirillis Ertugral and supporting her son Osman Gazi as happened in history.

Right they should have replaced her instead of he married another person.

@@anisatutunis830 LOL.😂 how would they *replaced her"? Do you even know what you are saying? 😂🤣😂

@@AzamKhan-ht7wx instead of killing her and in history Halime did not died before her husband. And if she wants to leave the show because of personal reasons; don't change the storyline creat something that will suit the story by replacing her with someone whose almost looks like her.

Finally someone who sees the reality of this case. Don't they realise women or even men who are in this profession are not just because they played a role of Some greats in history are somehow going to be on some form self induced state of WILAYAH. They are actors that is their profession. She was a model before acting why are we getting this self absorbed obsession with actors personal lives it's Pathetic but it shows a great deal of what delusions Bollywood has espoused and hypnotised people. The acting profession unfortunately is such that your Imaan in most cases is jeopardised irregardless of which country you are in. Acting is a western concept originating from the Ancient Greeks where the pre-requisites for its profession were set. Do you honestly think a religious practicing woman would consider becoming an actress??? It's self contradictory. I can safely state that majority of Actors and Actresses are not that faith focused. The ones who do end up going go down that path end up giving up their professions because of what it entails.

By not telling the truth in the first place to the director she has caused him stress and has now changed both ertugrul and Osman series.

@@kama3422 what makes you think these are all facts

How can you compare ertugrul to Harry potter. Are u tapped? Also every point in this vid is valid. Because of Esra bilgic's greed for popularity and success she left while also lying to Mehmet BOZDAG. Can u deny that???

​@@yazin_2046 this isn't about comparing the the series..and how can you believe everything the narrator has in the vid..were you a part of the Diliris Ertugrul Team that you know every single detail??

@@s.nnoorr Fair point. I give you that one, but why would you leave acting for spending time with your husband. Why did she divorce straight after her " perfect fame and popularity opportunity" failed.

@@yazin_2046 These are things only she knows. I wouldn't dwell on trivial matters. Be grateful for what we got accept it and move on.

I cant speak for everyone here but I don't blame Esra Bilgic. Whatever her personal life is its not my business BUT al I am saying is that they should have replaced the actor instead of changing the history.

Agreed!!

And the mother of Great *OSMAN KHAN GAZI*

Real halima is strong

typical liberal spotted. It is her channel and she has full right to say her opinion. So you dont judge her

Ohhhh dude,,,what she said is not a secret,, you can verify this yourself

What if she left the series? She is free to execute her will. Lekin chote muhalle me beth kr tabsre krna aur hmara zaati haq h na? And now some dumb people will explain me that I am a "liberal" since, I'm being logical. Wow.

A true professional actor/actress will behave with loyalty, integrity and show respect to the major role they have been assigned. Especially if they have been given the honour of playing such an important historical figure as Halima Sultan. Esra Bilgic has behaved in an unprofessional, selfish and irresponsible manner. Because of her Mehmet Bozdag had to change the script and deviate from true history. Shame on Esra Bilgic. The lady making this video has every right to make all aware of that.

Make a video. Aware people. Sath me judgements pass krne ki kya zrort hai? Koi contract to tha nhi us ka. Un ne apne lye jo behtr smjha kr lia. Jese dusre projects hain wese hi yh bhi h. Dusre actors ne b quit kia. Unhe q kuch nhi bola ja rha? Haleema ki mout ko plot twist bta kr us pr back lash dala ja rha h as if she was the major attraction of show. Phr yeh b nhi btaya k us k jane se kya twist aya h? Us ne Sahi kia kya ghlt ye us ka mamla h. Yahan beth kr use kehna jese bht smjhdari ka kam h.

Bilkuul theek ha Dua ha kh in acters ka dil bhi hadayet pajay

Agreed..

Yes

I agreed... hm Pakistani awam byshak is py bht comment kr rahy hain...lakim jab koi actor itna jan dar act kr raha hai... ahadees Allah ka rikz us ki taleemat islam Aurat ka muqam izzat.. sharm o haya... etc.. jab wo log us mn itna deep kirdar kr rahh thy.. tu mary zehan mn yahi khyal ata hai k kiya un ki zindgi mn zara c b changing nahi ai is drama ko krny k bad... Allah bhtr janny wala hai... but jis trha ka nazar ata hai sab..phr waqy e hi darma us trha sy dil ko ni lgta.. jasy pahly lga tha

@@zarishayan6596 Turkish secular party & it's people r responsible for these behayayi..

That's what I'm trying to tell but people aren't ready to digest it.

The lady who played Mahidevran in Magnificent Century is one that comes to mind....

Yes u r right haleem ko replace karna tha marna nhi tha so sad😢

You are right 🙂but, the reasoning this women gave were not true at all. Halima ko koi bhi drama offer ni hua ta iss kai doran🙄🙄. They killed her just bcoz it is an inspired drama not the exact same

Agree bhai, replace kr du marna zrori nhi... Mehmet Bozdag is going to replace this series from historical to fantasy series...

I am amazed a lot of people here are defending Esra Bilgic the actress who played the crucial role of Halima Sultan. True professional actors/actresses behave in a ethical and loyal manner especially if they have been given a major key role. Unfortunately because of Esra Bilgic's unprofessional, selfish and irresponsible behaviour Mehmet Bozdag had to change the script. Instead of Halima Sultan's role going on full five seasons of Dirillis Ertugral and then onto Kurulus Osman, as in true history, Bozdag was forced to change the script to end Halima Sultan's role. All because of Esra Bilgic's unbelievably irresponsible behaviour. Shame on Esra Bilgic.

@@AzamKhan-ht7wx great

Right

Right ,people get used to it after a few episodes they shouldn't change history

lol

True

Bhai kisiko itna kaha pta th ye itna maqbool hga k earth k dusre hisse pr bethe hmlog b tabsera kr pynge.. k dirlis.. phir kurulus.. aor aage jane kya Allah ko pta h

@@mohdfuzelansari5115 😂😂😂

Uh dude esra should have stayed she basically messed the program up

no what on earth are you saying?at least she told us what really happened i'd like to see you try making it

She's lying

She is not lying. You can check halime's death date on google. She died in 1281 same year in which ertugrul died.

You should check the facts before calling someone a liar.

Bilkul

No, it's not.

@@RoshniLight ok

Facts