I almost passed out at 10:06 seeing my work featured in YOUR video😭🛐 The advice you gave was so helpful since I struggle quite a lot with perspective and directing the viewer’s eye to certain parts of the piece and you showed EXACTLY how to do that🩷 Everyone’s work was so cool🌷✨

This is probably the most helpful art critique video I’ve found. It really helps to actually see adjustments

every time i'm like "this can't make a huge difference" and then she swaps between the two and it is STUNNING

Thank you so much for the critique! (Mine was at 8:11) I got so excited when I saw my art I never thought I would be picked!!!

The fact that the most used phrase in this video is “a little bit” is evident in the fact that most of these drawings don’t need a lot changes. It’s mostly just construction

I like that you actually explain how your changes help emphasize the artist’s work, and you don’t just say that the “anatomy is off” or the shading is “funky.” You go into depth of how the artist could emphasize their art better, and that really helps.

Please consider making this a series! Your paintovers are incredibly helpful to see, thank you!

Thanks so much,, Jackie,, for roasting & drawover my artwork! The silhouette’s so much better on your version! Man, what have I done 😩 Actually no longer a fan of eyebrows coming out front of hair either hahaha, but anime had consumed me since I was working at the studio using anime style (now not anymore).. Still need to learn a lot on anatomy, proportions, shapes, composition, everything. Really helps a lot on this

Oh I love this so much. Would love to see more if you ever do! My art professor always said “claiming it’s ‘just your style’ means you refuse to improve” and I live by that

This is a really great video and probably the most constructive art critique I've ever seen on KZfaq. The only thing is that in the revised version of the piece of the girls singing at 9:08 the girls seem a little aged up. The round faces of the original piece really sold that awkward preteen thing that I think the artist was going for. All of the critique that was left in the edit seemed like a big improvement though. It's crazy how much hair can add depth to a portrait like in the picture of the lady in a sweater and the lady in the white cloth in the wind.

I love learning dynamic poses from you, everything clicks and starts to make sense why there's something a bit off

She doesnt change the shape or design at all, genuine tips that helped me.

I like how when she mentions things that are more opinion based she admits it can still work, she just doesn’t like it. Like with the eyebrows she even admitted that you see it in anime all the time

i love how you don’t completely change the original artworks. you just give tips instead of implementing your own style to it and calling it fixed. i loved this video! i’m definitely going to try to implement the things you mentioned in my future artwork!❤

Wow I wasn’t expecting mine to be done (mine was 9:14) Thanks for the advise I’ll try revising it 💞

Your video was randomly recommended to me and I love it. I hope you create more of this. It’s really interesting and I’m glad you respect the artists’ style. You just fix the basic elements and not “fix” them by turning it into your style. Since I got fascinated by this concept I tried searching other artist who do this but I have to say you’re the best teacher. Keep it up! 😊

Love these style of videos! I’m at the point that I’d look at the art and think it looks perfect but then when I see the adjustments you make, it suddenly clicks for me too

Just started the video but I wanted to say I'm a big fan of your work and that you're an incredible artist! Excited to watch this :) ❤️

jackie you are nothing short of a wizard

I really appreciate ur stuff and how you just fix a few features and still maintain the original art style

7:20 this was a great video but it was kinda funny seeing her calling Mike a girl XD

I know nothing about drawing but these are so satisfying to watch and you're so gentle with your critique, it's almost like a art class, not a roast, I love this!💖 It reminds me of what my dad says "people who really know what they're doing don't have to tear others down, they teach instead"🤩

Ahh pls do more of these! This helps me figure out stuff that doesn't sit right with my drawing too, like when I draw eyes I didn't know it was supposed to be tucked in, thank uuu ❤️❤️❤️

Please make this a series, this is the most helpful art critique video i've come across

would love to see this become a series

I learn so much whenever you do these videos, thank youuu

Please do more of this!!!! This such a great way to learn

I like your videos, your generosity in sharing them, and your exceptional quality as an artist.

your critique are very helpful!! can't wait to see more content like this!

I'm literally blown away by the first example already

I love that you try to keep the person's og style while editing. Also less of drawing over and more of fixes to enhance the existing piece

We need more of this

I would love more videos like this! It really helps to be able to see mistakes i make as well being fixed and how to do better :)

I LOVE THIS! MORE PLZ. Thanks for all your hard work.

I like that even when she adds portions she keeps the style it was created in

I love this type of videos! It helps so much to learn

You're so inspiring, thanks!!!

This is so freaking good. Very helpful

I would love to see more of these! They are really interesting, i definitely haven't noticed somethings you did

these are so helpful please do more!

I loved whatching this! Would love for it to become a series

This is amazing! WOW! Thank you for sharing

I loved this so much!

This is actually super helpful! 😮 going to come back and watch it again

This was everything!!

You did a great job. Kinda shocking how much better some of those small adjustments make things

Finally, roast me video made by an actual PROFESSIONAL artist

So happy that you don’t work against the style you work with it which is unlike most do

Thank you for this, even though my art didnt get fixed, i never knew that eyes dont really make it to the side of the face.. i'll try to implement that into my art

GOD the blueycapsules jumscare caught me SO off guard

I don’t even do 2d but I need for more of these, love seeing the changes and improvements that can be done🤩

Do more of these asap !!!

Love this need more 😍

amazing videooooo i LEArn alot from these even though the intention on my style is different

I'm not an artist, but watching your video I started to think I could be one. Very well explained and I love how you used the perspective lines to make the images more anatomical

This is gold

I love how she changes (whenever she’s sketching) her artstyle to fit her fans artstyle. She makes me feel comfortable with my art and I’m sure many others

I'm an artist too art as art.Someone's good some people like it.Some don't act probably pick your stuff apart too.Just as bad as you're gonna pick everybody else's apart

Thabks for the videos!! I find them very inspiring qnd helpful

Hi Jackie! Thank you for your awesome videos! Would you consider make one teaching how you create your turnaround, showing the thoroughly process?

A new channel for me. Great vibes!I'm not an artist but I love watching people drawing/ painting. Like your presentation and proficiency! Gonna check out more stuff on your channel )

You feel like old KZfaq. Thank you I love you for that

I love these vids they’re my fave

this is so h elpful omg

I love this!! If you want and can.. can you make another! 🥹☺️

Yeah, I usually make the bangs shorter bc I dont like the eyebrows, eyes get hidden and don't like it when over the bangs/hair.

the before and after are so jarring

oh hell ya new jackie vid

great job, good vid! more like this :)

4:49 bro turned an 8 year old into an 18 year old real quick 💀💀💀

I love this! I used to watch paintover palls from sinix and it's a lot more clear how small changes can make big differences.

I think it’s amazing that you explain very clearly what you’re changing and why and it’s really helpful. Though it sometimes feels like you’re not emphasizing the feeling of a face and character and sacrifice it to the anatomy instead of bringing the personality of a face back onto a new, anatomically correct shape. Ofc you don’t have to do it all the way because you’re just sketching over, but I felt sad you’ve forgotten about the character. For example: 1. Prominent chin and umm… bumpy? nose, I’d return it to the face. Sweater looks like it’s not a classical shape but something more interesting of a neckline but the author probably could not emphasize it enough for it to be understood. I’d make eyebrows a bit thicker to keep the feeling “they’re so dark and thick they are visible through the bangs” but ofc keep them under the bangs :) 2. I see the author tried to make this girl more of a shy, hunched girl and adding sass instead of more shyness seems bit off. Etc etc. But your skill is amazing 💐💥

Well done

Eyebrows overtop of the hair (eyes too, for that matter) IS ONE OF MY BIGGEST ART PET PEEVES. Thank you for this!!

its amazing to see how many talented people are at drawing. i love seeing other people draws, they are really amazing. i try to draw, but... it aint worked. im just not good at it, sadly, but i dont worry, my call is writing, not drawing, so im still some kind of artist xd still, love this kind of videos, people who draw and show their work is so brave, keep going!

This is so helpful. Thank you so much. Do you have recommendations for a drawing tablet i should get? I want to go into the animation industry for sure, so i was wondering what should I invest in? Im not working professionally yet as much as I would love the Cintiq 24. I appreciate any help! Love your art and content!

omg i'm in love with you

Love this series!!! Do moreeee

That was fun to watch I'm not a professional but I thought it would have shown more distortion and movement if you raised the left arm of the one with the rollers (the server). The left arm brings balance and shows that she's grounded than she's in a rush. That's my opinion, I can be wrong

the only thing I disagree with in the WHOLE video is your suggestion that you'd like to open up the pose in the work at 3:00. that is the only thing you suggested that I think would actively alter the intent of the artist by changing the character and the vibe of the piece completely.

The last one was sus for a few reasons but we can have cheesecake and critique the art haha, I enjoyed the redo

12:50 I really liked all of the improvements you made on the drawings before, but I don’t really like how you completely changed the character for this one. before she looked like a villain; she had a maniacal expression on her face, she looked unhappy, she looked evil; but now, she just looks like a magical girl? the improvements were fine, I just think you should’ve kept the original drawing and premise. I could be totally misinterpreting the character, but oh well

So at 10:05, I’m not an artist or anything but I feel like to bring focus to the moon I’d make the character look at it, as to kind of “lead with the eyes”.

I feel like 2 or 3 art pieces where better before , but the rest has been truly improved ❤

Your content might be beneficial to me, im currently teaching character design and animation, but for the most part its the digital technical skills component of it, most of my focus is on illustrator and adobe character animator. I like to teach industry standards i would be curious as to what softwares are used by disney / pixar

6:46 BLUEYCAPSULES REFERENEPCE

Original pic of rollerblade girl has 2 right legs

Oo! This is a fun video I’d love to be roasted by you one day, for the training!

i really need help with something i’m working on. a pose i’ve never drawn before and it’s not looking right but i don’t know why !!!

6:53 blueycapsules jumpscare

Wait! I've seen the drawing from minute 6:55 being fixed on another artist channel!

Extra Nice

There was only one that I feel you changed the look of the character a little too much. Overall this is cool how you just basically help fix proportions and body position while keeping their style

Hey I was wondering if you had to have an certain artstyle to be a animator/ character designer??

What do you use as an app for digital drawing. I’m new here and I have questions sorry if you have already explained this.

bc jumpscare holy moly

real

anyone thought the first one was allison from umbrella academy

"in this house we respect women"

Where did you go to art school?