Opinion on Minecraft's downfall? 🤔 kzfaq.info/get/bejne/er-Hf5N_0bfRlqs.html (Leave a comment on that video)

This is one of the scariest parts of a non-horror game in my opinion

They must have done this on purpose. It's impressive how they made the sounds fit together even when these discs were released separately Edit: The arguments going down in the replies are something else.

*The GM after waiting literal YEARS for his players to solve the puzzle* "C'mon, guys, it's not that hard. Three discs, three jukeboxes. 5, 11, 13. What could you possibly do with those discs. Could the names maybe possibly mean something?"

2:05 - flint and steal? and the guy sounds like hes panicking, trying to open a portal or something else...

MatPat will go crazy after this.

Fun fact: 5, 11, and 13 are all prime numbers, so I predict the next disk will be 7.

2:53 what if the sound here could be that portal frame at the ancient city lighting up Note: this is just a random theory

With all the updates and info we have now, I'm convinced this is an ancient builder going through the entire story of minecraft, the wars, different mobs that were made accidentally, the builders creating portals to escape(being the nether, end portal, and then ancient city, which we dont have yet), and the us the player is the actual big bad of the whole thing. we are running away from the bad now, not the ancient builders or mobs.

Worth mentioning that discs 11 and 13 were made years before 5 and any of the sculk stuff.

If this was planned all along then this might just be one of the best things ive seen done in a videogame

I really wish they added a mob that'd mimic noises to lure in people, playing disc music, playing noises of specific friendly mobs, (Sheep, Pigs, Cows, Villagers,) And being some sort of skulk based entity, but it'd have a jukebox/disc-player merged with its body, or a gramophone, sounded kind of cool.

does anybody notice that at 1:15 there is a sound of a flint and steel click then sounds that resemble a nether portal? this might mean that the player might've been running away from some nether mob(s), like piglins

0:58 Want a break from the ads?

Theory: What if all three discs were about the Warden? I would assume that when you play disc 11 right after disc 5, its as if the player was running from the Warden to escape to the surface because he's one of the only survivors after such a tragic attack. And possibly in Disc 13, I could say that the survivor dodges the sonic ray and jumped into a river below the hill.

1:40 I hear someone whisper “thanks sweetie”

We need an animation of this now.

I first discovered this with my cousin. We thought it was a hidden piece of lore because it matched up. My cousin was really into minecraft lore after I told him the game has a lore, and he became hooked.

I think instead of having a cohesive plan they probably just thought "what if we make the other disks fit together" after making the first one.

I have a theory on what's happening in these discs after listening to them closely. It sounds like an experienced adventurer in a cave moving to probably the new biome in the cave, he cycles through a book to see if there's any records of such a place so he tries to light a torch with flint and steel. Most likely the reason why he was using it so long was because the light was dimmed and flickering. That's when The Warden probably comes into view from the light and the chase ensues. The player manages to barley escape and makes it back to his house. The next set of sounds could probably be a nightmare sequence of what happened and that unidentified creature actually catching him. This leads to the player eventually going back to face The Warden with the slow steps and when he does something strange happens instead...

i thought that disc 11, 13 and 5 just had random names, but seeing how their sounds all blend in together to tell a story means that mojang must've had this idea years ago and just didn't wanna tell the community to spoil the suprise

Turn on subtitles for the best viewing experience... 🕯

0:30 player is walking along - possibly mining 0:34 cave sound 0:38 player messes around with some flint and steel 0:40 the warden draws nearer 0:50 player hides from the monster 1:01 player uses a small song player of some sort to calm themsleves, unaware of the consequences 1:09 player tries lighting flint and steel 1:16 player forgets what they are doing and starts running 1:28 the player blocks themsleves off from the mobs - this is apparent due to the bubbling lava and the sound of metal on stone (likely the player dropping their tools) 1:46 player starts mining again 1:53 player attempts to use the song player again 1:58 *guess who’s back, back again?* it’s the warden 2:10 player starts walking 2:14 player starts walking on sculk 2:23 player successfully lights the portal in the middle 2:42 player walks towards portal 2:47 player sets off sculk shrieker 2:50 a wither is killed but the sound is slowed - it could be a wither or it could be used as a sound effect for something else 3:10 silence 3:15 record crack there is a story in the replies ⬇️

honestly this makes perfect sense that they’d set it up like this compared to playing all three starting at once, since that actually gives u time to put them in consecutively without having to rig something

I remember back in the old days getting scared of the cave sounds, but this is a whole new level

IDK if this is just me, but it sounded like the discs canceled eachother out and only one was playing

not sure if it’s just me, but I thought it sounded a bit like someone running from the warden

“Ermm… guys? You’re gonna want to hear this.”

Can’t wait for the game theorist to solve this one

The discs were probably supposed to hint about an enderman attacking the survivor on a dungeon where the end portal is, but then the new update changed it to the warden.

Don't worry guys he was just going threw the 5 stages of terraforming. 😁

Matpat spending 10 years listening to every millisecond of this but then realizing by that time the game will be long dead.

These three already creepy disc's just became altogether terrifying

They might’ve been planning the warden, or at least it was supposed to be another mob, for years! Such a creative Minecrafty way to make a kind of audio storyline and split the audio file into three then name them based on when you should play them, gotta love Mojang

1:10 sounds like someone reloading a gun

Minecraft: "WE have a dark secret" Everyone: "Being lazy is not a secret!"

I love the them all combined, as if like mojang is telling a message, and i think there gonna make more secrets/lore in minecraft

My theory: we will eventually have a full set of numbered disks and will have to play them all together like this. This will give us the full story of what is going on

This is the kind of stuff to look for in older games. I love that content like this is still popping up years later

People should animate this, it would take a lot of creative liberties but thats what makes ir so neat!

Gongratulations, you have officially done these 4 amazing things! -more Minecraft lore -fuel for matpat -finding out something that mojang hid -and getting appreciation in the Minecraft community! You could find ALOT more lore if you want to. How did you find this out anyways? But anyways, have a cookie, sub and like! Edit: why did you like on this comment? Like, im just stating an opinion, but. I guess thank you? PS: why tf are you talking about matpat manipulating children? PSS: i do not want to be a person, who constantly decides to add something to his yt comment but please, for the love of God would you just stop having a fight over is matpat manipulating someone, and if UJustGotGamed is insane, just stop please. UJustGotGamed has an opinion, and I respect that. And the reason why people can comment on a comment, is to comment ABOUT the comment, that commented a video. (Sorry for saying comment so much lmao)

Minecraft is now an official horror game.

1:59 Starting From Here Until The End Of The Video , It Really Started To Sound Like He Opened A Portal And Went in... Probably The One in the ancient City...

real horror is not where you would expect to find it

i have conquered my fear of the discs and the coughing sounds relaxing now for some reason

“That is not a coincidence” jumpscared me harder than the noise at 2:48 upon hearing it for the first time

Amnesia vibes. Love that you can play multiple disks simultaneously instead of one overriding another. Waiting for the 18 disk that includes lurics.

Dude, 7 year old me playing Minecraft nearly shit myself when I heard these disks for the first time

"That's enough of KZfaq for tonight"💀

Theory: Date of Record: May 11, 2013 Title: "The Warden Prototype" Record tool: Jukebox

This is amazing! Glad they're expanding Minecraft music disc lore after all these years

sounds like a horror genre ad for Minecraft

It sounds like a group of people preparing to go to the ancient city after the sculk infested it after they made a portal but the panic try to run but instead go strait to a shrieker and set off

I love the addition to the story of Minecraft, but I kind of hope it’s never fully told. Ever since I was a twelve year old girl playing on her cousin’s computer cause she didn’t have her own, I liked that we had to ability to take all these pieces and use them and our own imagination to come up with our own story. Back when all we had were Discs 11 and 13, and there was no apparent connect to them, I always thought Disc 11 told the story of a man who was… clearly running from something, not sure what though. His coughing suggested illness, or an issue with his lungs, or maybe where he was there was just a lot of smoke or something. That clicking sound we hear I always thought was him lighting a pipe, so maybe that’s it. The flipping of paper was him journaling about something, maybe his travels or his discoveries or his secrets. I always thought that whatever it was he was journaling about was the reason he was running from something. Eventually that thing catches up with him, and he has to escape into the Nether, hence the warping music and why it suddenly cuts. Although now I’m thinking he might be escaping *from* the Nether. Back then I always wondering where Disc 12 was. And now we have this.

This is so cool, it's like the stories of all three disks are incomplete in till played together.

0:32: some one/Steve wondering in some sort of cave?or ancient city 0:40: walking 0:53: opening some sort of Device or new block? 1:01:Book page/blue print? 1:08: *gasps* and preparing some items 1:14: Running? towering some blocks? building something? 1:26:Ender man?new mob? 1:27: some lava sfx* 1:33:Cave sfx* 1:39: building something? 1:50:Portal??? 2:11: Wondering some sort of Place? 2:17:Pig?new mob? 2:26: Sword? Attack Clash? 2:29:New Boss??? 2:47:sulk sensor activation? 2:48: Warden?New boss (I hope so) 2:55:? Idk What I'm doing but these are just my theory Somtin New I guess?

It sounds like a dude is running from the warden, tries to block up towards the surface but gets knocked down, maybe hits the warden and it goes away. The man starts to light a torch and begins to run when the warden comes back, he then strikes it with his sword which is the sort of slicing sound and the warden screams and runs away. The man tries to block up again, but alerts a skulk sensor, which summons the warden and finishes the man off. This is just what it sounds like to me.

Hmm, a continuation of disc 11. Legendary.

Here's hoping it's actually herobrine. Lowkey imagine if it's been scripted since the start. Fuck the chilliad mystery, that shit would be huge.

I had my eyes closed (idk why) so i didnt see the video was boutta end and your voice scared the shit out of me 😂

its so crazy that disc 11 has been in the game for so long and they are still adding secrets to it, amazing when you think about it.

only OG's remember those 3AM youtubers that played disc 13 and 11 at the same time

“At 5 seconds you put this one in” bro started the timer at 5 seconds lmao

Next up, we need an "8" that lines up. Come on, C418. They line up so well.

1:21 sounds like they tried to escape using dirt blocks

2:30 kinda sounds like a portal in the background

GET THIS TO TOM ASAP for context, the game theory man

I distinctly remember MatPat already making a video about discs 11 and 13

I'm just going to come out and say it, these discs all have similar vibes and will probably sound like they go together regardless of how they're played together. I think this is just a coincidence.

Damn, so interesting ! Cannot wait until MatPat release some mind-blowing theories based on this !

Hear me out.. The first disc "13" no one knew what it was about before TU11 other than the only threatening being Herobrine, disc "11" a broken record about someone escaping the Enderman (or Herobrine again), and disc "5" the Warden the being responsible for the abandon mineshafts. In other words Mojang should make Herobrine an official boss worst than all

I honestly cant hear anything out of the ordinary, just three disks playing one over another

it sounds like a player getting chased by a group of mobs

Another clue to the Disc Mystery. I don't think it's about the Warden. Some sounds don't match. It's something more powerful, something unnatural. Something we've never seen before.

Man watching Matpat's latest theory it sort of does make sense. Disk 5 is the most heavy lore drop disk in my opinion as it clears stuff out even more. You can literally hear the wither dying towards the end after the warden was set off, likely due to the portal in the middle of the area opening which results in the warden spawning in and killing the wither, but obviously the warden doesn't side with the survivors, instead attacks them too which results in the disk cracking towards the end into shards. Long story short for those who haven't watched the theory: Basically Matpat believes these ancient builders of a tribe which worshipped one of the gods (referring to Minecraft legends) fled down into the caves due to the wither chasing them after a horrible experiment gone wrong (4 soul sand and 3 skulls which spawned him) they built a civilization in the deep dark and tried setting up the middle portal to escape to some unknown place but it never seemed to work (there is proof because underneath the portal is some Redstone they were probably experimenting with to open the portal). The wither finally caught up to them underground and the portal (for some unknown reason) opens which you can clearly hear in the disk which tragically also fails as an escape route as it results in the warden spawning in through the portal and blasting it's ray at the wither which kills it (we can also clearly hear a slowed down version of a wither cry). So when you look at it that way, it genuinely does make sense

What if the Warden is actually simply built with bone, but powered by complex redstone? Maybe it was taken over by the skulk which was created by dead bodies? This could be a reference to the old caves (when mushrooms spawned in the smaller and more frustrating caves). Mushrooms irl convert waste (ex.: manure and dead bodies) into fertilizer for themselves. When the ancient builders found out about the ability of the mushrooms, they harvested and stripped the caves of their mushrooms, explaining how the caves generated in newer versions barely (maybe even no mushrooms I haven't played in a while) have mushrooms. They experimented on dead bodies with the mushrooms they harvested, but all they created was mush, the mush known as skulk. The intrigued scientists continued their experiments, but other scientists took the opportunity to use the excess bodies to create a machine monster made of bone, the Warden. Suddenly the experiment of skulk, dubbed the Mush Experiment went terribly wrong and infested the entire city. Several blocks were fine, but some of the blocks were consumed by the skulk. Soon, the skulk had gained the power to create it's own physical forms, the skulk catalysts, skulk shriekers, skulk veins, and skulk sensors. It had also gotten sentience, as the mushrooms had "sentience" of some kind (it's a living thing irl so yeah). It also discovered that some bony robot called The Warden existed, and so, the skulk spread to farther caves to add up to its power. Several months later, it grew far too strong for the Warden, and the skulk took over the Warden. The end theory children. Sweet Grubhub dreams.

that’s actually a really dope and creative secret im not gonna lie

wait are they different or does it just sound creepy all together

Subtitle: * minecraft lore intensifies * Deaf people: *interesting*

*”If you don’t play this at my funeral, i’m not coming.”*

Poor guy, manage to flee an Enderman just to end up facing the Warden

its cool to think that they're all supposed to be linked, but at the same time 11 & 13 were never made with the warden in mind so

You've had such a golden opportunity to RickRoll the audience and you've lost the chance! I was so desperately expecting to hear "📯 never gonna give you up" I'm honestly sad that this wasn't the RickRoll 😂

So it’s like 11:12 and I am chilling outside a McDonald’s but just came to the realization that towards the end of the discs being played together it sounds like there was a wither and the scull together in one spot' thus leading to a realization that the sculk is ever growing and that the wither is ever decaying, two halves of a whole possibly?

it sounds like all the MC bosses combined, like the moist sounds and heartbeats are the warden, as well as the amethysts. The crackling and winding up sounds could be the wither, 1:50 could be the sound of the wither spawning, starting, or a portal to the end. and 2:27 has soul sand sounds. Then again at 2:46 this is clearly the warden making clicks.

How much time in advance was this planned, I wonder? Amazing how new things are always being discovered, even years after release

This is terrifying,im not sleeping anymore,thanks

i love that CC says "minecraft lore intensifies" through the whole thing

theory: minecraft had the idea about the warden for many updates, the discs playing together is from the sculk dimension and in 1.19 it came over into our world. The footsteps are animals, mobs and even players running.

also i like the part where like the music begins and right after then the book pages turn it legit sounds like he hid in the library or something like that

We're getting Matpat out of retirement with this one

I love how captions says “Minecraft lore intensifies” 😂😂

This is awsome. great job RedBeret. but i feel like 1 disc is missing...maybe in another update?

Raw power at the peak Not a single weakness In the masterful design yet holding strong Planned, perfectly precise Shall it suffice to say *It's all being made up as it goes along?*

The real question is who recorded all this, and how did they split it into three disks? It's almost like it was set up by someone who knew this was going to happen.

Retrogamingnow is going to go crazy after this one

Unlikely, a developer said that the Warden was inspired by Disc 11, so seems unlikely that they were planned to be connected from the start. Also, what “coincidence” are you taking about at the end? I don’t anything that sets this apart from playing them at the same time.

Here comes the lore

It’s lore that some guy found two years ago that he shared with Matpat

credit goes to Weenie HutJr because i believe he’s the first person who found to do that strategy