The reason I watch your channel, Pete, is because I feel like I'm in the room while friends are having a conversation about the music I like. Simple as that. We could all be hanging out a bar having a few beers having these discussions and it's just fun. Whether your opinion matters more than anyone else's isn't really at issue for me. I disagree with your opinions sometimes, but you always make it a point to state that these opinions are your opinions and that anyone else's opinion on the matter is just as valid as yours. You don't come off in any way that somehow you think your opinion matters more than anyone else's. It's just a welcoming place to come and hear discussion of interesting topics. Plain and simple.

Since the partial lockdowns during Covid, my music choices have been more about finding 1) old bands i never heard of 2) old bands that i had heard of but not had any new material from and 3) bands which may have similar sounds to bands i love that i never really paid attention too. This and other channels i subscribe too have a mixture of the 3 points above. This channel in particular has introduced me to so many artists i never heard of. Pete and his guests love for new music from legacy bands has also helped me to take a chance on listening to newer music. That being said, you cannot love every thing out there. listen, make your decision and enjoy what you can.

Your opinions mean A LOT for me guys! You both are like a light house for me. A kinda of trustly, sincere, honest reference for us, music lovers. Keep the amazing work gentlemen Pardo and Popoff.

This GREAT episode bleeds into why I watch both Pete and Martin, although for different causes. I watch Pete, because I discovered a couple of years ago, that he goes in depth, and really researches and does good rankings and stuff of obscure-ish bands. I was into bands like the Michael Schenker Group and Gary More and Legs Diamond and Budgie-bands that no body in my physical environment has ever heard of. I'd come to love these bands (and others) immensely, and when I saw Pete had this depth of passion for music, going for even deeper bands like Bang and Aunt Mary and Triumvirate, I began to identify with that, cuz I put a lot of research into music and enjoy rarities like that. So now, Pete's opinion matters to me, he's worth listening to, because he's said so much that can make me trust his opinion. I by nature do not like stoner rock or doom metal, but when Pete talks about modern-day stoner or doom bands that play in the style of like late 60s psych bands, that makes me wanna check them out. I check them out, because Pete has said so many things to make this suspect suggestion now credible to some degree. Martin, on the other hand, I disagree with FREQUENTLY. BUT, he's still worth listening to, to me. He's accomplished, and he always explains himself to the fullest. He explains how he comes to his conclusions, rather than merely stating that X album is his least favorite by that band, he says why. I might disagree with him a ton of things like that, but I know his reasoning abilities are sound, and for me, that makes him worth listening to. Huge respect to both men.

“Writing about music is like dancing about architecture.” - Frank Zappa

What's important to me is that the people I watch and tune into, whether SOT or The Contrarians entertain me and you two and much of both channels mentioned above entertain me. I would rather be entertained by people who I don't necessarily agree with but find engaging than listen to someone I mostly agree with but doesn't have the engaging personality. You two are always enjoyable to listen to even when I don't necessarily agree. I think most sensible healthy thinking people will listen to an opinion, but however much they might respect that view (and respect is important) they will make up their own mind. Your opinions do matter to me, but ultimately I will still make up my own mind. It's all about people who I find entertaining that I will return to watch.

After years of only listening to stuff I knew, I’ve sent the past couple of years discovering so much new music. This is 100% down to you.

Interesting topic gentlemen. Opinions can be valuable if they're unbiased and informed and you guys do both. Thanks for the shout out Martin and nice mug!

After years of watching various reviewers, this channel is the only one I go to at this point for music opinions. I’ve gotten into so many bands and albums based on the recommendations of you guys. I also appreciate the care that goes into discussing and recognizing the full catalogs of the bands you talk about, especially those that have a long history and continue to release new music

Well you succeeded in coming up with a fresh topic this week guys great show👍👍👍👍👍

I never really thought of you guys as critics so much as musicologists, and the genres you cover are what drew me to the channel. Keep it up!!!

Popoff and Pardo are at it again to talk about whether all their talk really means anything. Fascinating topic for these two and particularly appreciated Martin's views as a published author of so many books. Excellent various points here but will try to comment on the one regarding personalities. Pete, you may be underestimating how much your personality as the 'visual and emotional head' of the SoT impacts your viewers. My entry to SoT was looking for a place that would bring new or unheard music to my attention that might be worth a listen. What caught my attention early was your straightforward approach but willingness to make the channel and outlet of optimism and positive enthusiasm and hold that standard fast over the almost three years this viewer has been watching. Even when a panelist may rant, it's done with such a positive spin of enthusiasm - even if that enthusiasm is a negative review or comment - that is a pleasure to watch. Do I agree with your views or all the panelists? Not at all. But you and all the co-captains have entertained me and brought lots of new or unheard music up for listening. Some is not my cup of tea, others are right up my alley. But the viewing of SoT is always a positive experience. Thanks for that. And special thanks to you and Martin for this discussion today. Great show.

To me you two seem like genuine music fans that I trust your opinions. You are the type of guys I'd like to drink a few beers with n talk music. Please keep up the good work n I will keep watching. Much love health n happiness to you both n your families

You both expand my musical universe! Because of your passion... the songs have been dissected and quantified. You have authors, critics, and most importantly music fans. It all gives the content merit. I thank you both for the insights. Ive purchased many "old" albums I never knew about.. but only discovered on this show!

I agree with Martin most of the times.Even though there are times when I strongly disagree (like Down to Earth is better than Rainbow Rising or Perfect Stranger is the greatest Deep Purple album to name a few),I always respect his enormous knowledge and insights about music.Pete and Martin are literally Music encyclopedia!

Shows like this have cleaned my ears out and extended my musical horizons. It's all about progressing in life. What all you guys do is vital for serious music lovers. You are greatly appreciated. PLEASE KEEP GOIN.....Thanks..

The combination of knowledge and enthusiasm focused on a topic we love creates a compelling listen. That's why IMHO the Funhouse is the best show on SoT, though I watch them all.

What I find is that I listen to these shows on SOT, and I find panelists who my tastes seem to lineup with. Then, based on discussions I definitely seek out bands I don’t know or albums I may have missed. Lots of great new discoveries thanks to SOT.

I love this channel both for you making me discover new bands and genres, and of course for the passion of the panel members, and their discussions which is the key. Ultimately I will have my own opinion about the bands while trying to be fair and not judging to quickly.

One word: Yes I thinks it’s good to hear different perspectives in so many places. I read so many opinions on all social media platforms (IG, Facebook, Twitter, and YT). Even on this channel it’s always interesting to see what other think about certain bands, albums, and/or songs. I also learn new things as well.

Both of your opinions mean enough to me to have bought a few of Martin's books and intend to read more, watch countless hours of SOT videos. I actually use the channel as a tool or guide through some of these discographies. I often pause when a song is mentioned, listen to it on Spotify and resume the video. So after being turned on to tons of good music I would not have found otherwise, credibility is built. Keep doing what you do. Your warmth, passion and personalities come through and are appreciated.

Love the show. I have been introduced to more bands because of watching the content on the channel. Even when I don't necessarily like or "get" what a band does, I check it out. Your opinions and different members of various panels that have pointed out favorite albums, live shows or participated in creating music themselves are providing a very valuable service for anyone that enjoys the style of music being discussed.

To answer your question...Let's say that since I started following this channel my CD collection expanded exponentially with artists I have never thought of checking out or not even knowing of their existence!

Week in and week out, you guys do "nail it", time wise and at not being repetitive. It has to be a challenge, we all appreciate your efforts and look forward to hearing your opinions! Thanks!!

You two (and all the other 'team' at #Seaoftranquility) have been a LIFESAVER during the last few years I discovered your content during Covid19 in the UK. And it was you lovely peeps who managed to reignite my passion for music, records, heritage, musical culture and to reconnect with bands I'd fallen out with or stopped.lsiteitng to. You gave me comfort. Solace. Laughs. Intrigue. Amazing anecdotes and views and insights too. Keep on keeping on!

My wife and I love watching the Hudson Valley Squares. We love the various personalities and the hilarious antics. They remind me of the metalheads and rock music geeks that I hung out with in my teens and early twenties. Its like going back to our old neighborhood which no longer exists for many of us.

Since I've started listening to your channel I've found we have similar musical tastes and I enjoy the opinions of everyone. You have turned me onto new bands, old bands I knew but haven't listened too in a while and bands I thought I'd never give a second thought to and find them outstanding. Luis is a hoot.

The opinions of you guys really matters to me personally. You two, and other various contributors to this channel and the Contrarions, have helped me to really rediscover my love of music. My only music buddy of mine drifted apart from me over the last few years so I felt my love for music also drifting because I didn't have anyone to share it with. Being able to listen to you both espouse so wonderfully about the things I like really helped me feel like someone was connecting with me about it all again. You've not only drawn me back in to what I love but helped me discover new things too: the prime example being Styx. They weren't a band I ever gave a thought about but hearing Pete speak in so many videos about how great they are got me to give them chance...and I haven't regretted it as I love so much about them now. There's other artists that you have helped me discover or give another chance to, look at in a different light, and I feel all the better for it. Last night I went to my first gig in nearly 6 years thinking I'd never go to one again and I seen Saxon, a band I never would've in my younger years, again all inspired by channels like this. Everything is so informative too that I've learnt more about things I thought I already knew or had never even considered. Keep up the good work and know that you guys are doing wonders for so many of us out there across the world (Glasgow here).

I appreciate listening to people that love music of all genres as I do, and you and your team do a great service. It's not so much your "opinions", it's just the discussion! Keep it up! You all rock!

You guys are the best at what you do. I trust that both of you wouldn't talk about a subject that you weren't knowledgeable about. I've watched alot of other hosts on You Tube but no one is as good as Pete and no one has better panel members than Pete has.

Thank you, gentlemen, for such an honest presentation of your opinions. I am one of those who is not too much into prog or metal, and I am much more of a classic rock/ Deadhead,. Despite this I still learn so much from you, and every now and again, I am led towards new listening. This happened yesterday when Pete told us about Blues Pills. I would be hard pressed to find a better source of learning, as well as being so well entertained by your input. Please do not take your critics too seriously as you undoubtedly have far more admirers.

I've written Amazon reviews of albums I own for over twenty years now. A good chunk of them got deleted for whatever reason, oh well. I would say, since I've been reading Martin's stuff for about as long as I've been writing that there is no doubt that he has certainly inspired me to write about the bands I love. I love Pete's channel and have been a faithful watcher all the damn time on KZfaq for over two years now. I love the shows they do together on Friday's, what a great start to the weekend. I do value your opinions guys and even when I disagree, and it's not often, I can appreciate where you are coming from - love your stuff guys and keep it coming

Very interesting discussion. I listen a lot to your channel, even though I am not a listener to many of the bands you discuss (Black Sabbath being one example). I simply find your discussions and passion for the music intensely stimulating. Thanks to your channel I have become a huge Rush fan, a band I ne ver listened to before. Also thanks to you, Pete, I bought Martin’s “Bowie@75” book, and am thoroughly enjoying your idiosyncratic and engaging writing style and perceptions, Martin, and am going to further investigate your writings. My formative musical years were the sixties (yes, am that old!;-), and the Beatles were my band throughout my school years, followed by Bowie in the seventies. I listened to so much different music over the years, but your channel has now awoken in me a curiosity about numerous bands and genres (metal!) that I had not listened to before to any great extent, and this is the power that reviewers who are passionate about their work can have. Many thanks indeed to you both!

What a great and intelligent conversation. Thanks guys.

Pete n Martin, Your opinions matter because the way you present and facilitate the subject or topics. The depth of knowledge is quite deep. I really picked up on KZfaq channels such as The Contrarians which has helped educate me about bands, obscure albums, forgotten albums etc. which inspired me to go back and look at those albums or bands. Martin I first learned about you through the Banger TV series metal evolution, then on Lock Horns, then the year in review shows on Banger. I thoroughly enjoyed those shows and your opinions. Pete I started watching Sea of Tranquility a few years back at the beginning of the pandemic. It was such an awesome experience. Your knowledge and opinions are quite informative, educational and the various shows are awesome. To the two of you I really enjoy this show on Fridays. Makes my week. That being said I may not always agree with your opinions however I do respect it highly. Between the two of you, you turned me on to new music and bands I never heard of or, had not listened to in many years so this is a great service. I love Rick Beato because he is a fan, can play music, is a producer, musician, a professor and very knowledgeable and engaging. It's been an awesome education. Don't get me started on guitar channels like Guitar Hack, Steve from Boston, Phil McKnight, Glenn Fricker, Rhett Shull, Robert Baker, Tim Pierce, Music is Win etc, etc . Then again I geek out on guitars and gear since I am a guitar player myself. So does your opinion matter? Yes it does. Do I agree with it all 100% of the time? Nope but, I'm in line with most of it and learning constantly so, thank you. So I enjoy the content consistently.

Opinions help, and I value hearing other music lovers opinions. In the end critics put a credible spin on music in a way the potential appreciator will understand. It makes sense if you are into the genre. Also, Production matters for sure - sonics are vital. Song writing and musicality really matters, and so does musicianship. The opinion of the listener matters more than the experts, but how the music affects you is on the listener. Knowledge helps, but what you want to hear again is a true sign you like it.

I find both of your opinions interesting and valuable because of your backgrounds in writing/commenting about music and because you both share many of my interests in music, especially Pete (I also grew up in NY and my main interests in music tend to be 80s rock and metal). I find Pete’s album rankings especially interesting because if there is a band that I’m not as familiar with, because of our similar tastes, I find his rankings a good place to start.

I enjoy watching these episodes I like hearing different opinions about songs or albums or bands. I could talk about music for hours. And sometimes u guys talk about some things that I might not pay attention to before or hear before

Pete and Martin should be on the committee for who gets in the rock and roll hall of fame

That is an interesting topic since it is true that as far as I am concerned, I watch the different shows on SOT because I share the same taste in music with most of the people on the panel (especially in the Prog Seat). I love the fact that although I have been listening to music, getting albums for almost 40 years, I still learn about so many bands. It is also really refreshing to hear about different perspectives on albums I love or hate. It is not only about someone being knowledgeable on music but the whole concept of finding out that there are many people like me who enjoy music on such a deep level.

Watch your channel every day! Love to see likeminded people like me talking and bonding over my favourite thing… MUSIC❤️🤘🏼🎶

Great topic. I actually enjoy when guests have contrasting viewpoints or preferences (especially with genres like prog where there are so many different styles). This is especially true with the band Chicago, who I know Martin isn’t a fan of, but he still respects their work and will discuss and offer insights. Thanks again Pete & SOT team.

I like when you share your opinions. I may not always agree on some bands, I like that I can see the beauty in bands and albums, people might not see... and vice versa.

You guys are fun. And your love of music is contagious

I listen to you Pete because we're the same age, the foundation of my musical tastes and my collection is: hard rock/heavy metal/progressive rock/jazz and jazz fusion. You don't dominate the panels like similar hosts on other channels out there. Your knowledge far outstrips mine in these genres and I'm always looking for new music. As for Martin, for a man who's written so many books on hard rock and metal bands he sure has an appreciation for other genres like punk. Enough said.

The Friday shows are my absolute favorite on SoT. You two are a great team! To answer the question in the title - yes! In this last three years since I'm watching SoT I learned a lot about bands I didn't care much about before and you also brought me to a lot of new bands - thanks! Meanwhile your opinions are some kind of a radar for me, they help me in decision making what to listen to.

One thing is clear: Both of you know a lot about music. Much more than me, certainly. Good enough to watch you two. 'Nuff said.

It's just big fun to listen to you guys waxing poetic about all things rock and metal. Feels like "There are human beings out there (across the water) who are just as deep in this stuff (maybe even deeper) as me", which feels pretty good. I used to have those vivid conversations about guitar-driven music with friends of mine, but lots of my buddies completely lost interest in music (to be frank, twenty years ago, I purchased about seven new albums per month... these days? Maybe one or two.), so at least you guys keep the fire burning. Do your opinions matter to me? Sometimes they do(several books by Mister Popoff in my shelf are printed proof), sometimes they don't (never got into Tull, Purple or X, no matter how much you guys praise 'em). But that's not the point - the point is: I look forward to listen to you guys (and Butch, and Lynn, and Ryan, and the mighty Chris Alo, to name just a few) 4,000 miles away from Toronto and the Hudson Valley ALL THE DAMN TIME.

What I expect the most from guys like you (and the reason why I watch SoT or Contarians) is because I LOVE finding out about bands/ artists I know nothing or little about. Yes it's great to hear that Paranoid is a great album, but I'd rather find out about more obscure (to me) bands or genres. I love watching the new releases on Wednesday and get tips on what I'll go get at the record store the next week-end. And I've "discovered" many many many great artists just watching your shows. Thank you for that! Cheers.

It's a good question. I don't agree with everything that Pete and Martin have to say but I'm interested nonetheless, because they clearly have an insight and interest in the subject matter they discuss. Anyone should be able to express their opinion on a platform like KZfaq, anyway. No point questioning the authority or validity of a point of view you don't like on a platform like this, and the number of views and subscriptions these videos receive is more validation than most of us will ever have in any case.

I started to watch this channel at the start of the pandemic and it helped get me through some tough times. It also has introduced me to some cool bands. I like being part of a community of people who are passionate about music. That doesn’t mean that I love every band that is discussed on this channel but I still like to hear people talk about bands that they like. Some of the panelists are a little more well informed than others but that’s ok because you still get a good cross-section of tastes. I do wish that the show would broaden out more into other genres like pop. But otherwise I think the variety of topics and guests keeps things interesting. Well done!

I became a regular viewer as I liked your personalities. The topics, you choose, also your experience of several years reviewing and listening to music and films. Also I am from the UK, and am largely ignorant of American bands which I haven't been exposed to. For example an album called The Captain And Me by the Doobie Brothers. This gives me albums to listen to that I might not ever have come across ,but for your blogs. I would say your opinion matters at least to me. Keep on Keeping on.

What an fascinating conversation on this episode! It has opened up my eyes to things about other people and maybe they Do hear things differently, and what you guys have to go through. I Respect both of you Alot! You are BOTH Rock Stars in my opinion! 🙂Keep up the great work! I Love what you 2 do. Not as easy as it looks for sure!

Guys your maturity, and I mean that in the best sense, is priceless. No body is wrong. Nothing feels toxic. Keep doing what you do....so many channels (some more and some less popular) I used to like alot I realised after some time, are run or partly run by people who don't realise they have not mastered the above enough to be reliable or responsible to wider community. And that point is not age related but is personality related. Alot of people who love music are very sensitive people and that's sometimes ignored by more commercial channels. Here, everytime I pop in, I feel welcome....and I don't have to feel reactionary.....there's not an unhealthy price....physical or emotional.... attached to it either which feels right when talking about music. There seem to be no unwritten rules that are frowned upon if broken...or if you don't fit in. Everyone seems upfront and has lovely way of discussing things....and really like you say Pete about critics....there's only so far you can go before opinions become harmfully subjective because they impact a wider community and create unhealthy bias.....the other way.... Where you feel helped by people to appreciate, is the end game for me. And no ...I don't always agree. But I listen, feel I can pop in, and wether I know much about the topic or not, quickly feel welcomed in...part of your community....👍👍👍 Thanks Pete and Co👏👏👏 Ps I do write reviews sometimes but they usually are short and only on music I'd recommend in some way. Writing a review I think comes with a responsibility. Just don't promote it if you don't like it....because someone out there probably will. Oh and heres my review of Opeths performance at Hammersmith on Friday night.... I went in thinking they might be the best band in the world..... I left knowing they are the best band in the world.....for me.😁

Your collective opinions matter;because - there's a passion, a history, a work ethic in making videos & writing books that correlate with "fans" experiences & acquired tastes. Everybody's got an opinion & the final 👍 or 👎 is very personal.... it's still healthy to hear another perspective(makes a person think & consider different nuisances to the "sonics" that's out there.... past or present. + Just really enjoy youz guyz interactions(Pete, Martin, Chris, Butch especially).

Great episode. Love you guys. This is really the only show on SOT I look forward to every Friday.

Does it matter that I think you matter? I can’t tell you how much music I’ve discovered from watching this channel, so there’s value right there. I don’t always agree, but you guys teach. Besides all that, it’s fun. It’s fun to talk about stuff you love and you guys lead the conversation.

I guess its your enthusiasm and knowledge that counts. The mix of personalities and their interests is what makes the shows interesting.. I was a metal head back in the early 80s but moved away about 86 but I still love listening to your shows..they bring that period alive again to me..I want to thank you all for that..

You help me discover new music and find new insights and appreciation of “old” music. You educate me on my favourite pastime. Your opinions matter to me. PS. My fave programme has to be the UK Connection, Steven & Simon are not only knowledgeable but amusing and entertaining characters.

i’ve bought several cds after listening to both of y’all over the past two years

Your opinions matter as much as anyone else. I have listened to a bunch of stuff Pete and Martin have talked about that I wasn't aware about since they come from similar tastes and respect the recommendations. Always appreciate the videos. You guys are knowledgeable music fans that can talk about music without coming off as know it alls whose opinion matters way more than mine

I got into a lot of bands thanks to this channel and though I don't agree with everyone's opinions on 'Sea of Tranquility,' I love the discussions because everyone on the panel are music lovers like us! I don't comment on every single video because I'm not knowledgable on every single band that is mentioned on the show and that is ok. I'll comment on the videos that I have some knowledge on, and I'll just sit back and watch the videos where I don't have much knowledge on. Simple as that!

Your opinions are a music learning experience, really enjoy the bands I never heard of that are mentioned, elaborated topics etc.this is the best show

For sure you know what you’r talking about. Agree or not, but you have tons of knowledge and the most important, lots of passion.

I surely listen to Pete's and Martin's recommendations, Because of that I discovered a lot of good music I had not known before

Simply put I watch you guys cause I enjoy it, I've learned about alot of good bands from you! And I respect your opinions!

Cheers Pete and Martin, I tuned in three years looking to see what new music I haven’t heard and what older music I may have missed. I love Progressive Rock, Fusion and Hard Rock/ Metal and if someone who shares that sensibility tells me check out this newer band that I haven’t heard called Haken for example, Well Pete I will and I did. Now a band I wouldn’t have otherwise heard of I end up buying their entire discography and seeing them live. To me That’s the power and value of opinion and why it matters. On the other hand that’s why I never respected or listened much to Rolling Stone critics who constantly hammered bands I loved. SOT also has a good level of entertainment as well even if I don’t always agree with everyone. The foundation has been established and certainly value watching. Rock On!

Great discussion- your guys' opinions definitely matter. Just this year you've turned me on to so great bands like Marbin, Candlemass, the Clash, Voivod just to name a few. Keep these discussions coming gentlemen!

Hello guys, I'm from Serbia and I started watching SoT during the pandemic. I was first drawn to the themes, and now I watch most of the shows regularly. I like that you love and respect music, it's natural that we don't like everything the same, but on the other hand I got to know a lot of good music that I hadn't listened to before. That's why, keep on hard and strong, and without looking back, you're doing a great job!

When you guys mentioned about hearing things differently, it too depends on what you went through in your personal life. Because of what you went through a song or album will hit you differently than someone who didn't go through that.

Great question. Your opinions matter because you have credibility and history. Almost an existential question seen more broadly!

You both are the real deal. You really know the bands and topics!!!! Back in the 70's I knew all the members of the bands that I liked and even Leber and Krebs who were the guys that handled Aerosmith. Cannot do that now, I have waaaay too many CDs. This channel is Awesome and I have written before, have learned sooo much from this channel and am a fan of more prog and developing more knowledge of some of those bands. Keep it up!!!!

Your opinion matters and your excellent knowledge of the music matters…. Keep it going!

Another terrific, insightful and entertaining discussion. Keep up the great work!

Great show and topic. I can boil it down to this....I like you guys and have watched every show you two have done together. I trust your opinions and even when I don't like bands you guys talk about I still find it interesting. Your opinions matter to me.

I respect both of your opinions on music and movies, even if I don't always agree with them. You guys definitely know your stuff. You are educated and informed on the music you cover. I've made countless discoveries based on your recommendations. You also welcome the knowledge and opinions of others on the panel shows. Some of my favorites are when everyone DOES NOT agree on everything, which is kinda the whole point of having panels.

There are two opinions that are important to me, the first is are the opinions informed and entertaining, in the case of ITPS, thats initially why I watch it, there a couple of member that talk about bands I’ll try but not in any expectation that I’ll like them because I know their tastes are different to mine. Yet I’ll still watch because they are informed interesting and put across in an entertaining way. The other opinions come from watching lots of shows and knowing the individuals involved, the viewers learn which contributors are in tune with their own tastes and trust when they recommend an artist or band that it is one worth investigating. again using the ITPS A-Z so many bands I haven’t heard of that it’s impossible to try them all, yet I know from the detailed informative descriptions , and which panelists are in tune with my tastes which bands I’m most likely to to enjoy. So yes opinions matter and help discover new things to listen to and enjoy , or sometimes not 😊

I have purchased Martin Popoff's FAQ books on Judas Priest and Black Sabbath. Absolutely fabulous, entertaining, informative, detailed, and credible reads!!! Loved reading the work Martin put into creating these testimonials. Grateful for what it took to create! Forgive me... I despise PUNK music.. but I fully appreciate Martins insight none the less. Open minds appreciate alike.

100% what Martin said about music curation. It can be invaluable. I am forever in Rhino's debt for all their compilations and curation of blues music. It made it SO much easier to ingest and appreciate the genre. Also I remember in particular how awesome the Police Message In A Box box set was, all the photos, bios, quotes and liner notes and the fact you basically had the band's whole discography to enjoy ... hey there's another topic for you guys to cover - all-time favorite box sets!

I find your opinions fascinating and frequently very informative, even if I don't always agree with you. I think it can be both fun and challenging. Sometimes hearing you guys can change my opinions about things I didn't care for before. I've also been turned on to different things by you fellas. It's a great thing!

I am both a drummer 1990-present and a guitarist 2016-present still learning. I know gear and can use my knowledge as I listen to music. I am always listening to new music to me all the time.

Very interesting discussion, gentlemen. As someone who has been appearing on The Contrarians and elsewhere, in recent months, this gives me some food for thought. I'm specifically thinking about my own presentation when taking part in these panel discussions, as well as what role each of us plays on a given panel. We just did a BOC - The Symbol Remains panel for The Contrarians, a few days ago. I had notes for every song, but ended up ignoring my notes and found that everything flowed better. Yes, Pete, sometimes less is more. 👍

It is up to an individual whether they take on board an 'opinion' or not. As we know everybody will have an opinion and to them it matters. You guys and your friends and colleagues, in combination, hold a huge repository of knowledge about certain genres and bands. I love hearing you all talk about 'stuff'. Experience comes from knowledge and knowledge is transferable and my knowledge has grown from listening to you all. So thank you and keep up the great work, whatever your opinions are! Always interested to hear your weather forecasts, living in the UK, where we are accused of talking about the weather all the time, it makes be laugh.

I think the conversation is what we come for. You need an opinion to participate.

Well...I certainly value this channel and everyone's input. Helps me with some of the music I like. And sometimes I'll discover a band that I've never heard of...and this is coming from someone with a fairly big music collection. Always something new to listen to, be it classics, old or new.

I watched your show on heart and you explained your opinion on the song dog and butterfly and it hit me like a twin brother you explained the song the way I feel it Pete and emoted it and it touched it’s the human connection and i respected it like when I was 12 and heard Stevie at 12 singing edge of seventeen it got me on a different level 35 yeas later it’s still with me it’s respect and human conation and trust 👍🏼🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿👍🏼👍🏼

One more point and it may be the most important one. You guys are honest. You aren't just trying to please everybody or tell them what you think they want to hear. I may not always agree, but you're being honest and genuine with your opinions and that's more important to me.

Inspired by Pete to do my own show I don’t consider myself a music critic because I am very opinionated about vocalists. My show is based on 1965 to 1975. trying to find my own niche the fact that I was going to concerts in around the music world back then. where a lot of people weren’t even born or were old enough to appreciate music at that time. also I own a psychedelic Light Show company and I’m really into the early psychedelic blues rock of that era.

Hi Pete, I've been watching Sea of Tranquility for a couple of years now and this is the first time I am contributing a comment as this subject is interesting. I've found listening to you guys interesting because to me it is like talking to my friend who is also a music fan and we can talk about music for hours. Of course I don't agree with some opinions made but that is also what makes things interesting. I fell in love with your segment called 'Curse of the Collector' as I am a collector. So that topic speaks volumes to me. I'm no musician but I like to think I listen to the musicians musician. I also love 'In the Prog Seat' and you introduced me to Martin Popoff of which now I own a few of his books. Anyway, keep it up, I will keep watching as long as you keep releasing the videos.

Yes, your opinions matter. We listeners/viewers get validation from what you two guys think. In my case, Black Sabbath's Sabotage is one of my favorite albums and hearing that it's also one of Martin's favorites was reassuring. Besides that, this channel is very informative.

Yes, definitely your opinion matters. Especially when talking about unknown or forgotten bands and also for the knowledge of deep dive cuts.

reason i listen in is because not only do you guys know a lot about the popular bands but also talk about obscure bands that are really good. and even if i dont always 100% agree on some things said. i think you guys are respectful about having different opinions and can make jokes about them wish is funny. besides it would be pretty boring if we were all the same so its always interesting

Hey there Pete & Martin Interesting topic. I always look forward to Friday at the fun house. Though I don't always agree with your opinions, they're as valid as anyone's. Even though I don't know you both personally, when I watch you 2, it's like watching 2 of my friends talking about whatever in music. I'm 58, so i definitely relate to both of you. Thanks to Martin, I checked out The Stooges & I like them & thanks to you, I checked out some bands I normally wouldn't have so to answer your question, YES your opinions matter. Have a great weekend! Kenny from Edison NJ

Hello, The reason why I listen to your channel is that I can try out new things. I may not like them but I give them a chance. I do not have to agree with everything but I will at least try to listen to it. Not all types of music on your channel are for me. I used to work at a CD/record store and University music library back in the late 80's and early 90's. My job was to keep up on top 40 and Alternative. I never say that I am am an expert but I know lots. I was also an avid listener of American Top 40 as a kid. I also am an avid reader of music history reader and music documentary watcher. It is my hobby. As I used to tell my parents, my music hobby is better than me doing drug and drinking. I enjoy all the people on the channel because they help me broaden my knowledge plus many have become my friends on Facebook for example Armando, Pete, Charles, Martin, Chris and Etc.... People ask my opinion on different types of music and albums but I always say I am not an expert. I am just an avid fan of music and not all music types are for me. Your channel has just become a weekly part of my routine and thanks for all you guys do.

I’m very grateful to both your informed comments. You’ve made a huge difference in my musical enjoyment. Two years ago I’d not even heard of Porcupine Tree, then Martin rated ‘Fear of a Dark planet’ as one of his favourites. After checking out their music I saw their performance in Toronto sept 10th and their triumphant return to the stage. Mike’s love of Dream Theatre led me to check out that band who I also love. Thanks to you both guys, you literally Rock!

For me watching the channel is the same as sitting with friends talking music (and horror films) which is due to the way the channel format is. It's a relaxed informal chat with people giving their takes. As in life you'll agree with some opinions and not with others. I'm guilty of sometimes posting about something said (not often but occasionally) that got my hackles up but I do respect everyone is only giving their perspective. As to why does you and your guests opinions matter more than others it's as pointed out you know and love the bands films and topics raised as do I and the majority of the viewers id suspect and due to that.

Great topic. Kudos to you guys from coming up with new ideas every week. Everyone has an opinion, whether the subject be politics, sports, music, etc. I always felt if after listening to someone I could walk away and gather even a tid bit of useful information then mission accomplished. I'm a big believer in short and sweet. Make your point and move on. As soon as you drone on I start to lose interest, not unlike a 20 minute drum solo... ha ha! In other words, stating your opinion and storytelling go hand in hand. A couple of sports figures come to mind. Vin Scully could tell a story and keep you captivated. Dan Patrick can ask the most provocative question in the simplest of terms. Personally, having watched SOT for a few years now I can honestly say I've learned a ton about music from every aspect. That's why I keep coming back. You guys have a good weekend.

Well it helped me a lot during lockdown whether the opinions matter or not.

Always enjoyable content. You brought up a lot of valid arguments.

Wow, a SoT show that opens with REM... Pete is turning is his grave (just an expression... Wishing you best of health, Pete!) I truly think that if many REM haters took a deep dive, they would change their mind. One of my favorite bands ever -- and at the same time I like all the music typically discussed on SoT! Magic...