Either the husband was looking at a blue sky with a telescope, or the gardener was trimming a bush at night

The husband casually looking at the sun through the telescope 🗿

Gardener casually cutting bushes and trimming the hedges at night time 🗿

I love how the husband is looking at a blue sky with his telescope 😂

The husband and gardener were working together, 5 people in the house, but they both say they were outside.

The gardener was trimming hedges off of a family tree

“5 people inside the house during the murder” - husband and gardener outside

Cristian answer: You can’t overindulge on Sundays

that husband casually looking at the stars WHILE THERE ARE USUALLY NON ON DINNER TIME.

Grandma just had a heart attack after church

The hour of the crime should be roughly around 6:30pm given they were preparing for dinner. It's too early to look at the stars, and too late to be gardening. If both the gardener and the husband were outside, then they can confirm each other's alibi, so they both lied. The maid and the chef have proof if the table was indeed set and the dinner cooked, then they did their job and were too busy. However the butler in the basement is mostly alone, and can easily bring a bottle up later (or even before if it's premeditated murder) and pretend he did what he said at the time he said. It would help to know where the body was found, but the butler is the fishiest in my opinion. I think husband and gardener were just having an affair in the garden and gave the most random stupid excuses on the spot to protect their secret lol

The help all killed her under the husband’s orders. They were getting tight on money and could barely keep any of the help on except who was there the night of the murder. The husband told them all he’d raise their pay if they did this for him, so the cook poisoned the food, the maid left a tainted glass for the wife in case the poison didn’t kill her, whatever was on the glass would, the butler added something to the wine while in the cellar and the gardener was merely the one outside with the husband to let him know the job was complete and dinner was ready. As for those wondering why the husband didn’t die, he didn’t eat the food or drink the wine. The maid set out a normal glass for water on the table for the husband who claimed to have had a large lunch. The husband also wasn’t looking at the stars before dinner, rather setting it up for after dinner when he knew his wife would be in bed alone and leave him off of the suspect list since the gardener could confirm he was nowhere near the wife when she passed.

The husband was looking up at his wife in heaven

It was a planned murder by the 4 house helpers (Maid, Gardener, Chef & Butler) for making them work on a Sunday.

The husband just lookin at stars before there out

Butler for sure

It was the owner of Chick-fil-A. That is why they are closed on Sundays.

Gardeners don’t typically have a work shift on Sundays. It’s the gardener.

Looking at the stars in the evening is crazy 😂

butler trimming bushes at night

It was the husband and the gardener. They both claimed they were outside but he said everyone was in the house when the murder happened

It's the gardener. They don't cut in the evening unless there's a set time for him to come, and that wasn't listed. And the full video for this describes how it is

It's the chef who made the food out of the grandma, or the Butler who uses blood as the wine.

Clipping the bushes trimming the hedges sounds like a metaphor

The gardener trimming bushes in the evening 💀💀💀 and which freaking star was the husband looking in the evening 💀💀💀

They should ask the gardener and the husband one at a time if they saw each other in the garden

Def the hubby “staring at the stars” on a Sunday afternoon

They're all in on it together.

Bruh that husband bouta be blind lookin at a very bright star 💀

Ahh the gardener casually clipping and trimming the bushes on a sunday evening

“Five people IN THE HOUSE” gardener

Was looking at the stars in the middle of the day

It was either the gardener or the husband. It was either too dark out to trim the hedges or too light out to see the stars.

The husband and the garderner. Since it was evening it was too late to go outside and cut the leaves but too early to look a stars. Not to mention the gardener also had sharp tools which could have helped with the murder

The husband casually looking at a bird with a telescope

Every one else’s story suggest it was night time but the gardener was trimming the bushes?

There were 5 people in the house at the time of murder, but the husband said he was outside looking at the stars. The gardener never said he was outside since he could be trimming inside plants. The husband killed her because he lied about being outside during the time of murder.

Damn, the gardener really be trimming at night.

The chef making dinner-

Star searching at evening lol

As an astrophotographer evening is just about the worst time to look at the stars

It’s def the husband. The evening is too early to see stars. Edit: In the video it’s very light out so there’s no way you can see stars in broad daylight

Trimming bushes at night seems kind of odd. Especially on a Sunday

Bruh The butler is in the wrong room

“ Five people in the house at the time of the murder” but two of them lied about being inside. So the husband and garden is shady so far

The gardener probably tag teamed with the husband bro💀

He said that it was evening but the husband ,maid and buttler said that they were getting ready for dinner

Evening? Is it dark enough to look at the stars?

They must be rich as hell to have a Staff like that, I say the grandkid did it.

did the gardener just cut the bushes with a watering can 💀💀💀

I love how now you can see stars somehow at evening

Gardener. Who trims hedges in the evening?

bro who tf watches stars in the evening it's the husband for sure

Gardener be giving clean cuts to bushes at evening 🌆 💀💀💀💀

I think it was the gardener

The guy who was looking at the stars it was daytime

Husband looking at the stars when it's light out? I'm sure he's trust worthy

My guy looking at the sky hallucinating in the evening

She had a heart attack

Exactly either husband or gardener

The grandma was the real killer, she killed the husband and then dressed like him, put her clothes on him, and then acted like the husband 💀

sunday = no work no work =no hedge trimmer it also says he was in the house

Husband casually seeing the stars at telescope

The maid , butler, and chef because it’s not dinner time + the husband because there no star in the sky yet , i don’t think it is the gardener because it isn’t very suspicious ( im not very good at English so im not very sure what evening are specifically but i think around 14:00-18:00or19:00)

ITS THE BUTLER. The husband and the gardener were both in the garden, so they can “vouch” for each other, same with the chef and the maid. And if the dining and kitchen are in separate rooms, the chef/maid would have heard or seen the other person working, if they weren’t working, then there you go. That leaves the butler, that is alone, and could also have poisoned the wine

"5 ppl were in the house at the time of her murder" Gardener and Husband are outside 💀💀💀💀

Why am I thinking the butler with that door jammed open like that

Ain no way he is watching the stars in the evenings

Every person's alibi makes sense since it's related to night time except the gardener. Edit: everyone is saying evening which could be in daylight. I said night because the lights were on in the house if that makes sense

Bro the butler who has wine in the cellar

It was Professor Plumb, in the living room, with a chainsaw.

its the husband like who tf looks for stars in the evening

Dinner/evening means it's dark outside, so the gardener trimming the bushes in the dark is the most suspicious

Ya this is common sense its husband stars at 5 💀

Butler did it. Its always the butler.

The husband's trying to blind himself 💀

Guys it’s literally the husband 💀 It happened during the evening and he was “looking up at the stars.” Also if you say some evenings are that dark, even if it was it still wouldn’t work. The gardener was trimming bushes which would’ve needed the lights on, which would’ve flushed out the view of the stars.

The husband looking at a blue sky but the gardener is working Sunday evening

the husband was looking at the stars in the middle of the day

It’s the gardener, who tf trims trees in the garden on a SUNDAY EVENING

The fact that the gardener was outside working on the bushes and all three of the others were working on dinner means it probably was not dark enough out to look at stars through the telescope meaning the husband is most likely the killer.

The husband was just looking at birds lol

In the evening it’s not dark enough to star gaze yet the evening being 4-8ish but then it depends on where you live if it’s the uk and summer it’s not dark until about 9:30 but if it’s winter in the uk it can get dark as soon as 6:30 so it all depends on what season it was the time and the country. The most likely suspects are either the husband or the gardener

"your honor, my client is not a psychopath for killing those people, he just has a detail oriented mind"

bro i thought the chef was cooking the old woman for dinner 💀

It was the husband.in the beginning of the riddle they say she was killed on an evening like about noon or so. The husband could not have been looking at the stars because it was day time. The sun would be to bright making it nearly impossible to see the stars. Hope that helps some people😊

There’s no stars at day, so it is the husband

Never let them know your next move: She just had a heart attack

damn the husband really likes his wife so much he calls her his star

You can't see stars at evening.

The gardener would not be working in the garden in the evening.

Proof the camera man never dies Thanks for all the likes btw

Poor Mrs. Smith and the Gardener, they lived in a house with 4 murderers.

Colonel Mustard in the Library with the Candlestick

Her husband trying to see stars during evening

The husband was either looking at a telescope in the bright ass day or the gardener has night vision

the husband was watching his wife go up into heaven too make sure she doesnt turn into a ghost

The husband becus its not stars on the day

Well, it says it happened during the evening, indicating from 6:00 PM to bedtime. Assuming she is from the US, the average dinnertime for elderly citizens is around 6:30 PM to 7:30 PM, so let's take 7:00 PM. Since the garden is being maintained, it means it's either spring or summer. In spring, the average sunset time is 7:30 PM, and in summer, the average is 8:30 PM, so let's take 8:00 PM for the sun to set. Now, the chef was preparing the food and the maid was setting up the table, meaning the food was almost ready. Given that six people live in the house and assuming they all share the table, the maid would start preparing the table 10 to 15 minutes before the food is ready to serve. That means Mrs. Smith was killed around 6:45 to 6:50 PM. Around this time, there is enough sunlight for the gardener to do his job, and not enough darkness for the husband to see/watch the stars. Henceforth, the husband is the killer. In my opinion, of course.

Both the gardener and the husband were in the garden so you could ask them if they saw each other. If they didn’t, someone’s lying and it was one of them