She was a white-haired Scotsman before the fall, 30 min ago she was in the battlefield of Twice Upon A Time.

She's not mentioning the last time she was Peter but before

I see what you did there. 😂

Nice try at explaining the big plot hole

Ade2Bee It’s not a plot hole. She WAS a white haired Scotsman thirty minutes ago. She was also one sixty minutes ago and five minutes ago.

Yes, whatever one's thoughts about the series as a whole (and mine are generally positive) that is probably the best description of how regeneration *feels* that I've heard from any Doctor all the way back to Troughton.

This is probably the worst and lazily written explanation of regeneration I've ever heard.

@@soloskirmisherrts5043 Yes dear, whatever makes you feel better.

Michael McGrath And that is probably your second worst lazily written comment. (We all know what #1 is.)

Joe Astbury Definitely explains regeneration for those coming into the program for the first time.

I think that’s what they should call the TARDIS’ desktop theme: “Sheffield Steel.” A bit nicer than “Coral” & “Leopard Skin,” but not quite up there with “Roundels.”

I go there often. Still can't tell where Ryan was riding his bike in the opening.

@@chrissonofpear1384 Looks like the hills over Stocksbridge / Deepcar area. So northern edge of Sheffield, not really in the city.

@@James-gc5if Actually, I read a fair amount of these scenes were actually filmed up a hill outside of Cardiff (some of the last to be shot by the BBC in that region, when they were moving production...?)

@@chrissonofpear1384 AFAIK, they still shoot in Wales. The hotel in the spider episode for instance was Celtic Manor in Newport. It's certainly still made by BBC Wales, as it was they who announced a delay to production due to the virus. Although a lot of the modern day exterior scenes are clearly Sheffield.

I didn’t know anything about series 14 apart from Jodie being the new Doctor, so I was pretty surprised to just see Bradley Walsh casually being in Doctor Who

@@phantomforever309 do you mean series 11

@@obiwankenobi687 I did, sorry, was tired

EnderClan well the doctor is logical when it comes to saving people. But when it comes to times when they aren’t in danger YET graham is the logical one. He would be the one to stay away from danger where as the doctor would be the one heading to the danger. But like I said at the same time the doctor knows how to solve situations logically (most of the time) but graham doesn’t. So it’s a bit of a 50/50

EnderClan I’m talking about logical as in what people would do in real life like run when you see an alien instead of going to it. Not logical as in not doing what someone in real life would do and try and stop the alien

@@vb8428 okay fuck off. nobody gives a shit about how bitter you are over jodie. your opinion surprises nobody troll

@Raul Victor agreed, she's amazing

@@vb8428 You clearly haven't seen her other work if you think she can only make startled faces.

@@bluepolarbear Of course I've some of the work. Still doesn't make her Doctor. #NotMyDoctor

@@vb8428 We aren't talking about that right now. You said all she could do was make startled faces, which clearly isn't true, and you should know that if you saw her other roles like you say you do. Plus, she hits many emotional beats in future episodes. If you aren't convinced, fine, but stop being so rude about it.

It is also a nod to the locale, Sheffield, which is famous for steel and its production of cutlery.

You're doing it, mate!

lol, that song

AlexGlushkov The chase is not on!

We'll keep on trying till it's done!

So triggered that it wasn’t the official catchphrase of the seried 😂

Shitty KZfaq Account Literally.

Shades of "Logopolis"... whew, my first regeneration story, and oh boy did I cry over that one!

Flat on her back? 😂

You guys are clearly forgetting that the doctor has survived higher falls

Also if she fell out of the sky into a train I doubt a small fall from that would then kill her

The Night King, me !

Me! I am guessing there'll be some classic episodes (I hope Marco Polo doesn't turn her off from classicWho) and a few Torchwood as well (maybe even K-9).

Winter is here.

Daniel RCSP9 I should have lead with that damn

William Gionet oh god I hope not K9

Bless :( Have a subscriber :)

hope you’re okay xxx

@@venieceramsey575 much better thanks! Just never work in retail over Christmas, especially if you're a woman selling technology to angry men...

Tomorrow will be better.

Sending internet hugs your way

That's a really bad thing, means the Doctor is terrible

Brits love Bradley Walsh (Graham). Funny guy, full time quiz show host (see the British version of The Chase. Americans will know The Beast from the same show) and part-time actor. Lovely guy.

Victor K. How is that a bad thing

Victor K. And no it doesn’t make the Doctor terrible.

Mickey was her favorite; Nardole was her favorite.....

are you claiming that the reason its bombing iis because people did not ahve an opened mind ? . Actually people did watch it with an opened mind and the bombing has nothing to do with social issues . It has everything to do with the bad writing and bad acting . In fact people are still watching it with an opened mind but they get decieved every time by the plots and acting . Chinballs is the one who transformed the show into a political correctness show when the show was never about political correctness but only the doctor traveling thru time and space to save the day . Chinballs version of the doctor does not do that anymore , she is concentrated on politicly correcting people . I stopped watching it in half of the season last year casue it had becomed so borring beyond words and trust me it had nothing to do with Jodie playing the role of the doctor .And the three companion that she has are even worse actors than the ones with the Capaldi doctor . Its like if chinball went to the Mall and saw those three at a cofee table and offered them the role jodie's companions for 100 dollars an episode . Even the old series from the 60"s had better actors and writing

@@guytremblay1647 doctor who has always been political, there’s nothing more in this season than any before

@@elizeyt yes its true but butthey never concentrated on one specific politic or specific group of politics untill now .

@@guytremblay1647 when you learn to string together a coherent argument with correct spelling I will listen to you

@@elizeyt hey bud youtube is global so dont expect people to ably to your language all the time when its not their language so count yourself lucky that we at least try to talk to you guys . Go try to talk on chinese youtube for fun and let see if they wont give you the same comment that you just gave to me . Why do you people allways think that by obligation your language has to be the main course of action on anything even Aliens that would come on earth . Do you also think that you are so important that if they came here they would logicly try to land in your back yard cause it would be the logical thing to do cause by your standard your country would be the most intelligent one ? ?

Hey, there's a way around it... the Doctor tells her not to wander off, she doesn't wander off... And something weird still happens, which is helpful to the plotline. ^_^

perspective. I have always thought that this Reactor watches shows as a fan of shows, not someone who wishes to control the outcome, but someone who wishes to be entertained by what she watches. This Reactor is more of what the fan of a show should be. She loves Doctor Who and allows it to take her for a ride to see where it is going, some of us come here to be reminded of what it means to love this show because we tend to hold on too tightly at times and "Lenny" it

Nobody is refering to people who simply say they're not a big fan of it, but the people who call it the WORST or offer no actual reason for disliking it, or make a HUGE SCENE out of hating it now and wanting to stop watching. Like if you're gonna tell people you're disliking it, actually try and have a discussion about it instead of "WAH ITS SHITE CHIBNALL SHOULD DIE AND QUIT" like the actual trolls do. I've seen too many in the comment section already, Declann.

​@@DeclannShieldsFilms Not everyone who dislikes this series is a troll, you're definitely right about that. This series has also brought internet trolls out in force, though. Having a woman doctor and doing episodes like Rosa was always going to.

Firlow I'd happily have a discussion about how bad series 11 is. And people aren't trolling when they say Jodie and Chibnall should leave the show.

@@DeclannShieldsFilms If you actually read my comment, I too don't find this series to be my favorite season of Doctor Who ever. But I know that when a show changes hands, it should be different. I think it's still trying to settle into it's spot. It will probably get there, give it some time. And some people didn't like Capaldi (or Smith or Tennant or Eccleston) but that's ok. The ratings are what the BBC cares about. They are already millions above Capaldis best numbers & on par with the highest number the show has ever received. If you truly hate the show, why are you watching it the second it comes & then going online to bash it? Just stop watching it. It's really easy if you truly hated it. Go back to your bridge troll :3

@TheKarlOshaughnessyyour opinion, the reactor seems to enjoy it thus far.

I agree! Jodie's portrayal is very strong.

I agree on your take, but this those very characteristics of a Doctor who was the last survivor of his species, used beats and tones that fans have gotten used to, and may not want to watch a series without those beats. I've liked this first season of the 13th, but I do miss seeing the Doctor deal with the weight of the losses that come with living 2000+ years.

Yes, Graham's my favorite out of this batch of companions.

I appreciate this. And I agree. And it's weird for me.

Since he's the only good thing to come out of this series.

Michael McGrath for once we agree with something jk jk but seriously I was completely wrong about Jodie and series 11 it sucked and isn’t worthy of being called Doctor Who

Fan Of Fandoms true. If everyone was like Jess I’d confuse the world for heaven

that 80's girl Her hair should get longer and messier like Peter Capaldi's did, haha.

MyAbridged yeah I feel the same way too!!!

I know, right? Somehow, Jess never fails to give you a fresh perspective on each episode. 3 years in and it's still so refreshing to see! It's a great antidote to all the toxicity that's flying about at the moment.

Same I did like it on airing. Now I like it a lot more. Looking back it was a solid opener.

MyAbridged ditto, and I already liked it a lot. Seeing how other people react to and process Doctor Who episodes tends to help me solidify my own perspective a lot, even if I don’t agree with them. It’s nice to see how other people take an episode as they watch it.

I felt the same way! I think she had a much more open mind than some of us did when the first episode hit...

thank you for limiting your thoughts to this episode, you should be the one with more comments, unfortunately, the "the squeaky wheel" always gets the most attention

shouldn't it tell you something about how terrible it is right now when all their good ideas were used up in the first episode?

@@pjgs4933 see, i don't even remember what Heaven sent and Family of Blood WERE!!! and demons of the Punjab is just way too similar a reminder to last years christmas special. u know? like, way too recent

2000diamondman why are you talking about episodes she hasn’t seen yet and why are you watching reactions to a series you don’t like

@@obiwankenobi687 why are you watching reactions to a series you DO like if you've already seen it? to get your opinion validated, should be fairly obvious

2000diamondman Not really, Ive been here since day 1 to watch someone’s journey not to sit there clacking my fingers together like Mr. Burns in the hope someone’s going to hate the series

I didn't really think Moffat's episodes were too complicated, as in they were fine to follow along, I didn't really like his style of series writing. I didn't hate it or anything. I have different 'issues' with RTD. He had increasing stakes each season, and at some point you run out. He went from humanity, to humanity twice and potentially the universe, to the universe and all of time. It was escalating so much. :P I preferred the stakes smaller, more personal, like S2 of Torchwood. While still had high stakes, the focus was mostly on the personal. I would agree that this season could stand some more complicated things, but at the same time I don't mind as much, since to focus is now so clearly on the personal, which I love, and which RTD did use sometimes, and Moffat almost ignored sometimes. (which is what made it hard for me to get in to Moffat as a writer, I really needed some grounding in relationships, and while they were there sometimes, they were fringe mostly) Anyway, I'm enjoying this series a lot so far. :) And I'm curious to see where they're taking this. :)

It shouldn't matter that the Doctor is a woman, but Jodie Whittaker and the writers made that pretty much ALL that mattered. That plus the obvious disdain for males in general, and white males in particular, is why so many people complain about this season. I mean, I'd have to rewatch the season again to be sure, and I don't want to do that in the slightest, but I'm fairly certain Graham was the only white male all season who was even remotely portrayed in a good light.

@@JakkFrost1 Jodie was badly written and her stories didn't always make sense. Who knows, maybe they'll do better in the 12th series.

And why would you think that, even now, lots of people are negative about this series and episode? Do you imagine it’s because they are evil, nasty people? Or is it simply because they are who fans that just don’t like it?

And she's been working hard to get some Yorkshire-isms into the scripts (it was her idea to have Thirteen's first words be "Oh brilliant.")

C B 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼 How does it feel having Yorkshire be the center of creature/alien activity, rather than London or Cardiff? 😁

@@firefly24601 I'm really enjoying it, it makes a nice change and we have some fantastic locations for filming as well (though a lot's still filmed in Cardiff I believe haha). They shoot Happy Valley, Last Tango in Halifax and Ackley Bridge near us too!

I was born in Hartnell's era and I am a woman from Yorkshire, just like Jodie Whittaker, but I'm like "so what?"

@@gaynor1721 That's fine Gaynor, we're all allowed to feel excited about different things :)

he's the only one u can click to lol shame I cant say the same for the other wooden actors

Graham is great, the best definitely. I like Ryan and Yaz though, I think she's gonna enjoy them all though because she's a fan of Tardis Teams.

@@FirlowXD yes a racist white man... u never see an episode with a racist black man. im just tired of it because its everywhere now in so much media we have. only time I can remember where a black character says anything fked up was a couple seasons ago with peter, when a timelord regenerates from a white male to black female and says some shit about having so much ego.... now if that was female to a male and he said that no doubt everyone would lose their shit over it but its ok when its towards a male,, again im just tired of watching my fav shows/films and being knocked on the head with either political messages or straight up racism from cast writers directors then being told im a toxic fan just for calling these ppl out for their crap lol and btw before anyone says dr who has always been political, yh it has been but not to the point it is now.

@@ozzie1397 it's almost like racism in western society stemmed from white people so... Like why is it a shock, and why is the idea of seeing a white person being racist pissing you off so much when that's still such a prevelant issue in the world?

Hear hear! Graham is awesome!

Or, you know, TARDIS? It was an intentional joke, dude.

People who miss obvious jokes and then think they're the smart ones noticing "errors" are silly

Chibnall is a dull bastard who ruined Torchwood for me. It'll just get worse

Victor K. Chibnall made the best episode of torchwood and also made the worst. I still say hes a competent writer

@@Jake-pr7js I've never found him competent enough. Only thing of his I liked is DW minisodes and Blowfish scene. Everything else from dialogue to ideas is just awful.

Victor K. Adrift is one of the best episodes of torchwood and it was made by chris

It's been since 1969/1970 for me. I really love the show overall.

I 100% agree with this sentiment!!!!

Lol. Don't have such high expectations

Why not?? lol already heard amazing things about tomorrows and Chibnall is at his best when writing non-filler episodes like beginning and ending episodes.

Wow karl, you're a troll AND you're shite at bait! :D

@TheKarlOshaughnessy what someone who doesn't think it's ok to say someone hasn't written anything good in their life and basically shit on their life work solely because YOU don't like it? Right on

Me too. Been looking forward to Dr Who December. When the notification came up, my first thought (well, second, after "Yes!") was "My God, it's December already!" Totally took me by surprise! :-)

That's regeneration for you