I agree I wasn't his biggest fan at first now hes my favorite Doctor!!!!!

@@nickloschen2717 same bro!

That's insane!

@@nickloschen2717same! His first season was okay, but Series 9 is where he really hit his stride, and this speech is where he became my Doctor.

@@Jim_The_Fishmine too

remember this was the man who spent 1000 years on Trenzalore, fighting to save Christmas village

Damn... I love your explanation it's so true(after 2 years but it's still true 😅)

Eleven, the wolf in the sheep's clothing.

except (for new who at least) the "real" doctor was Ten. even when he wanted to hide his true self, every single one of his emotions were written on his face. That's what he became after Rose healed Nine, he was at his happiest in s2, and then, after losing more and more, regenerated into Eleven with a carefree and childlike attitude to try and forget all the loss he experienced. Eleven then spends 800 years protecting Christmas Town, committing to a place despite previously not being able to stay at one place for a day, immersing himself into a community, and being his kindest self for the people, because in the end of the day that's what he strives to be and who he is. And then all of it is thrown out of the window when Twelve comes in in s8. Suddenly he's not compassionate anymore, needs guidance to find kindness within him, he's calculated and cold hearted, letting people around him die, when 9, 10 and 11 would cherish and mourn every soul they'd come across and lose. No, Eleven didn't hide Twelve. Twelve is 800 years older than Eleven was for 99% of his run. If anything it's a transition, but that is poorly written, bc Eleven getting tired and suddenly growing cold in his years spent on Trenzalore makes no sense to me. Twelve is better in s9 and thankfully s10 exists, where he's still grumpy but only seemingly cold, when in reality he's truly compassionate. His s8 characterization is a disaster though, and doesn't tie in with Eleven

Hell yeah! can't wait to see that!

At least he won't have to watch episode 12 then...

lol agreed

mashallah alhumidllah inshallah better

Everyone talks about the how long is eternity, but the best part is "why can't I just lose?" part

The episode? The entire show is that speech.

This is how you use Capaldi. If only all of the episodes could have been written this well.

Meh, If only every episode was as good as that speech. Still 100x then the writing with the next doctor...

Cemented Capaldi as my favorite Doctor, nobody can ever take that place in my mind now. I can only WISH the rest of the world could think the way he thinks.

That's so well put.

He’s such a good doctor, his acting is always top notch and he nails the doctor monologues completely. His emotional moments are really good too

And also "Laugh hard, run fast, be kind. Doctor, I let you go."

One of my favourite moments from Capaldi is that face the raven quote. Sends chills down my spine

Why not just phone them up, tell them whats going to happen, and fuck up ALL the reactions ? Dick.

@@celt67 They don't read the comments, chill the fuck out...

Gave me shivers just reading it

I agree. He's a doctor that I tend to appreciate more as time goes bye. Jason Inman tweet about his arc from "I am a good man", to "I have a duty of care" and then" and then "I do what I do because it's right! Because it's decent! And above all, it's kind! " (if I remember the tweet correctly)

Peter Capaldi is one of the best doctors. Many trolls and haters targetted his average era for not being the most consistent. It was more consistent than other eras like Hartnell, Peter Davison, Sylvester Mccoy, Collin Baker but trolls don't target them, trolls target the most recent. Now the Capaldi era is over trolls will leave it in peace and treat it with more respect.

@@chriszone50 And now the trolls are targetting the Whittaker era, and after they will target the next era, and the next, and the next, and the next until the end of the show.

@@Kephy_ Tbh Jodie was let down massively by inconsistent writing, Chibnall wasn’t a good choice for showrunner

@@dylanburton4955 Not true

Lewis It’s the only reason.

Yeah..... the Doctor driving.

Scott Porter His monologue

......and bad Clara.....Goddamn.....

Eyebrows

They know she died. But the never ending question is - which Osgood have died? Do we have two Zygons or original Osgood and Zygon. And it's actually one of those instances when it doesn't make you mad that it never was answered. And really it doesn't matter.

But if one died in Death in Heaven and then another one died as part of an interrogation from the zygons...who is the Osgood that's left?

I dont see a Zygon going down withoit a fight the way Osgood did. I'd say the human one is dead

@@sarahhiggins1515 when did one die in an interrogation by the Zygons? Episode and scene, please.

@@sarahhiggins1515 Osgood

Bird

How many seconds....

If I didnt know better...

@KayKo ooooooh...do it again!

Peter Capaldi is my favourite doctor, it is good to see Peter Capaldi getting the love he deserves because many trolls and haters targeted his average era for not being consistent despite his era reaching some of the highest peaks(top 5 stories) and his average era being better than Hartnell, Peter Davison, Sylvester Mccoy, Collin Baker etc because trolls and haters tend to attack the most recent eras. Now Capaldi's era is over, the trolls will leave his era in peace and people will treat it with more respect.

Who'd have thought it? Well, the guy's a seasoned theatre actor with decades of experience with a variety of material playing a war weary Doctor, tired of losing people. A skilled actor can do a lot with a little.

Oh, hey. Wasn't expecting to see you here

Liam Catterson The Doctor Falls speech felt more natural with better quality.

@@chriszone50 No. The speech is great giving rules that 13 ignored anyway. This speech is the Doctor, and vastly superior.

@@shauntempley9757 No, the speech in The Doctor Falls is better, and it wasn't directed to the 13th doctor until Twice Upon a TIme. The speech in the doctor falls felt less shouty and more natural.

@@chriszone50 Then the speech in The Doctor Falls is actually not as good, since it is about the Doctor questioning the need to be cruel if he has to stand alone in that situation. It leads to him committing suicide afterwards because of how that speech was responded to as much as the fact that he had to relive fighting a desperate, no good outcome battle. As well as the fact that the Doctor knew that Cybership in The Doctor Falls is the exact same one he encounters in Tomb Of The Cybermen when he was the Second Doctor. I do not approve of that suicidal end at all, by the way. This speech is shouty, because he is drawing on personal knowledge of what happened in the Time War. This speech is many times greater because of what he is talking about, as much as it is what every Doctor would say as passionately.

I agree - "I know that face" is a beautiful line, perfectly delivered.

The Doctor`s face when he says "Got ya" is very Dr. Brown-ish...

I don't get that line.

And the WhoMobile. Never forget the WhoMobile!

@@GedUK Bessie WAS the who mobile

@@julieeverett7442 No, not at all. The WhoMobile was a weird wing shaped thing the 3rd Doctor drove in Invasion of the Dinosaurs. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/p5meorNzqtqzcp8.html

@@GedUK oh you mean that funny looking silver thing, not yellow roadster. Cool!

julie everett Yeah that's the one!

I'm glad they've taken to 12 and Clara as well - the guys clearly have excellent taste! Capaldi and Coleman are my favourite Doctor/Companion combo in Nu Who, very closely followed by Tennant and Tate.

Which was a lie in and of itself, since the Doctor forgot his age and started back at 1.

ArlanKels when did he do that?

@@GreenBoxStudio1 During the original Doctor Who(I think). I'm not sure which season or which doctor. I'd say check the who wiki for specifics.

By my calculations he's almost 4000

@@spacepenguins8939 those are canon?

"I forgive you", literally the Doctor forgiving himself for his - what he sees as - mistake in the War. This is one of the Doctor's most defining moments, plain and simple.

Capaldi has the greatest voice. When he speaks, people listen, when he is angry, people cower, and when he pleads, people cry

That doesn't actually say much, since the Zygon inherited Osgood's health problem too.

^This. I love that when I get frustrated with the guys not getting it quite right, I can come down here and someone has already put my thoughts into text.

I agree that the situation was probably different each time. I think it's also the first time that the Doctor found the right words to change Bonnie's mind while being sure of it because this time around she had Clara's face.

The most logical explanation to me is that the Doctor just failed to convince Bonnie 14 times before, resulting in her pressing a button and realising they did nothing. Each time that happened he wiped their minds so he could try his speech again until he could persuade Bonnie.

I always forget if Hell Bent or Heaven Sent is the first part or the second part... Both work poetically xD

HEVEN SENT DA BEST

An appalling episode

@@justsomerandomguyonline1144 Oh shit it's you! I haven't seen you in forever. How's it going buddy

@@justsomerandomguyonline1144 oh wow I literally just thought about how you always were in their doctor who reactions and that I haven't seen you since some of the season 6 or 7 videos I think, wow

I wouldn't be able to not cry!

The actress who plays Osgood said all she did was cry while Capaldi did his thing

Read somewhere that they only did one take -- it was so obviously perfect that they didn't need to re-take.

yeah he DID do it one take, and got a standing ovation for it!

@@elliotkouame3849 When they're on the plane, Osgood claims that those were the "old rules" and that Zygons have now figured out how to keep looking like someone after they die. And that's probably true since otherwise Bonnie/Zygilla's threat to kill Clara would be less effective.

@@theadamabrams never thought of that.

@@elliotkouame3849 The Big Finish UNIT audios finally confirmed which one died.

Guys, didn’t they just both become half and half? An implication of the Hybrid was intended.

@@elliotkouame3849 The UNIT component of The Eighth of March - Part 4, Narcissus.

The thing that happened 15 times was trying to convince Bonnie. 14 times before the Doctor failed in presuading her so she pushed the button only to realise they did nothing, only for the Doctor to wipe their minds and try the speech again but differently. The 15th time was the first time the Doctor succeeded in persuading Bonnie.

@@giglefreakz I honestly don't think I've ever heard that interpretation before. I certainly don't see any reason why that couldn't be the case, but I also don't see any evidence particularly in support of it over the more conventional interpretation. Personally I think your interpretation is a bit more realistic, but at the same time that line was meant to be a joke, so honestly I find the more ridiculous explanation more fitting.

lucas dolding it’s purposely unclear whether the “15 times” was referring to the speech or the the revolutions .

@@buckguy720 I like the idea that he has been teaching the Zygons one revolution at a time. He has done it 15 times. Heaven Sent kind of confirmed it.

The best is coming soon 😁

Alex James No, Heaven Sent, World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls, Mummy on the Orient Express, Flatline, Listen and Twice Upon a Time was better than this and many more like Oxygen etc.

@@chriszone50 this episode has one of capaldi's best scenes though

@@stevencrighton6890 I disagree, his speech in The Doctor Falls was better. It felt more natural and less forced.

@@stevencrighton6890 One of, but not his best, his kindness speech is better, it was in one of his good episodes, with his series 10 persona, not his doctor disco persona, and he was in his suit, not his hoodie and sunglasses when he did his kindness speech.

To be honest, it is one of the defining moments of the entire show, and considering how many great speeches there have been, that's quite an accomplishment.