I cackled at that

😉

Shame an episode about music and the Beatles had hardly any Beatles or Beatles music in it though

@@tomspyro5795 no Cilla Black tracks either

@@tomspyro5795 That's because the rights for the Beatles songs are too expensive. Hence the plot of Maestro stealing music.

Valid point but this particular song makes me feel that the Maestro was right to steal the music in the first place.

@@TheGrayRoast Actually so awful. The "Disney"ification of Doctor Who. Becoming American (not that American is bad, should be authentic and not pandering) and losing it's identity. Used to be a family show, that kids and adults could all watch. The tone now is so childish and dumbed down. It's like from BBC to Cbeebies

No way! That’s so cool!! Thanks for pointing it out:D

The goat makes an appearance

Oh my gosh, he's playing the piano.

@@AuroraButterflyx - Which leads me to think: if they could have sourced a dancing goat, they would have added a literal dancing goat.

@@441MsVanillaRose Ahaha I wish :)

Facts

The real twist in one of his scripts is when there's none.

😂

Especially The Last Airbender.

It sure is 😮

Where

@@debbiegeu72 the melody of "always a twist at the end"

@@debbiegeu72 the melody of this song is an appregio, the same as the toymaker's laugh

THEY PALPATINES THEME'D US!!!

She wasn’t in space babies,star beast or the giggle I think?

@@originalmp9704 she's one of the crew that left video logs in Space Babies. Don't think she's in Star Beast or The Giggle

Plus the Doctor explicitly mentioned and explained Susan (Foreman) this episode!

as I said before, 1st comment : The twist : they didn'T do a Beatles Mersey Beat video musical! It was the twist of doing a Twist Rock & Roll musical with a sock hop jive side of dance !!! N the ginger kid is still there . H. Arbinger

​@@througtonsheirs_doctorwhol5914 nah

I’m so suprised no one else was not pointing out the scream so I’m glad you did oml

The line "there's always a twist at the end" seems to follow the Toymaker's arpeggio giggle too.

I didn't noticed the goblin's scream, but you're right

My view of it was When the toymaker was banished the state of play lingerie for what seems to be hours letting the tardis be doubled So this was akin to that but this time a state of music lingering so the doctor decided to have some fun with it Also explains the cross walk piano

Completely agree, but Maestro used they/them pronouns

Huh. I didn't really think of it like that, I was more thinking that the entire episode was about how music and dancing are important to humans so ending with a musical number seems appropriate (albeit silly but Doctor Who has always been a little silly).

I'll take a musical number over talking babies and a snot monster any day of the week.

She? The maestro was clearly a male

Your not love it

i still have it in my head two days later lol

@@darkacadpresenceinblood THERES ALWAYS A TWIST AT THE END

​@damienrevell7544 many people seem to not like this song. While not the best and maybe went a tiny bit long, I still find it a catchy and enjoyable song.

ITS CRAP

@brookse746 I am aware of that. I am just saying that it is nice to see a show take a break from being darker and edgier to just have fun and be goofy.

Losing doctor who to woke freaks. Is that so nice to see? Great work turned to a netflix adaptation

@@brookse746I mean we did get him playing the guitar on a tank.

@@iamsoup1210ah yes doctor who totally just now started being woke. There totally aren’t several episodes written by an actual card carrying communist in classic, one of which addresses colonialism where the indigenous people and colonizers come to an agreement only for the UN to bomb them anyways. And the nazi dalek allegory. And the brexit episode. And the anti war episode decrying how higher powers shove unrelated soldiers together for entertainment with no care of their lives. Totally the most woke this show has ever been is having black main character.

​@@eldritchcupcakes3195Go off dude.

Peter obviously on the guitar

Plus Christopher Eccleston's Head Bopping from 'The End of the World.' David Tennant's drunk dancing from 'The Girl in the Fireplace' and Matt Smith's Wedding dancing.

@@ieuanbriers Matt also sings. He was in a musical.............of American Psycho!

@@VelociraptourMatt also dances, Morbius

@@ieuanbriers And McCoy on the spoons!

I actually could now capaldi on the other hand 😂😂

10 would have also been amazing to watch. 😆

@@emilydesrosiers9034the drunk giraffe will always be the doctor who dance lol

@@funkoobsessed4729 That's what i looked like in the zumba class i took. 😄

@@emilydesrosiers9034 that’ll be my wedding dance routine whenever that’ll be because I can’t dance lol

Holy shit! You’re right!!!

Something tells me the toymaker will return.

Im the opposite- I feel like RTD ruined this show

@@myvividmemories It's been ruined again?

@@hi-viz if you’ve watched the devils chord or space babies then you know what I mean

@@myvividmemoriesumm no he didn’t

@@myvividmemoriesdoctor who is being ruined to people every other episode though. I feel like if people actually just stopped watching when it wasn’t for them anymore, there’d be less idle complaining happening all the time.

Obviously you're going to find mostly positive comments if you look up the scene online. People who hated this moment aren't going to be choosing to watch it again on KZfaq.

@@HOTD108_no there are people who watch video to crap on it. Which even on this video there are people saying it dead etc. which is far from it

​@@HOTD108_they are and only to shit on it. the haters are always the most vocal online just less so on a clip of what they hate

While I think your opinion is valid, I personally thought this episode was a new low for the show. At first I was optimistic about the start of this new era, but the only positive I found is to keep my expectations that this show could possibly redeem itself in check. To each their own, though.

@@jakeculley9173 Thank you for being respectful, totally understand why this wouldn’t be for everyone. It is rather pantomime.

Knowing that It seems like it'll be followed by taking itself seriously

Yeah mostly dark Doctor Who is kind of missing the point. It's why I fell off Doctor Who at Series 10

@@pikachucetthesecond4296well you can also be campy and dark look at the toy maker spice up your life it’s a good example of that balence

@@superplushtiman7ti075 shshshshshshhhhh *goofy grape*

you're not all there are you

Yes! Absolutely, in fact the implication could be that's why the Abbey Road sessions were so iconic. Because they were the recorded distillation of all that musical exuberance.

I felt the same way about this. With music having been gone for awhile the sudden return of it I think would cause the world to break out into a musical. The power of music was so important in this episode and I could see the return of music leading to this fun chaos.

Ikr that's what I heard and I was like omg that's Janice's screech!😂

That’s a coincidence

​@@dazzag371there are no coincidences in Doctor Who

​@@jimmy_the_squid9456 Literally are, it's what the entire series 14 is anout

I was thinking that, there's also a similar sound in the trailer but I don't know if I'm reading too much into it

Smith and Coleman would have been ridiculous! 😆

@@BlueManIan God, Eleven would be so AWKWARD. I don't think ANY other New Who Doctor would be able to do this!

I think the 2nd Doctor, Ben and Polly could’ve pulled it off. Maybe the 7th Doctor and Mel too.

​@@EditedAF987Ooh, Seven and Mel! I totally agree, that would totally work!

Bonnie would of being good to

It fits perfectly because of the theme of the episode oof

If you liked this, I would suggest Rocky Horror Picture Show.

If you enjoyed this, maybe you just haven’t found the right musical. Especially since you said you refuse to give *any* of them a chance. It’s a very diverse genre.

No it’s not

@@mmarshfairc3 the "always a twist at the end" sounds like the giggle

@@daraen673 It doesn’t I’m sorry. It’s not the giggle.

Like The Flash? Yes I suppose so.

​@@ThatCoalSoulthe 6th Doctor story Doctor Who and the Pirates was a musical and it was amazing too

Last 3 episodes out of 4 have had songs! Please make it stop! Yes I am old but still want some subtlety and drama....

​@johnmorris2414 The Giggle: Spice up Your Life(odd one out of the songs) Church on Ruby Road: Goblin Song Space Babies: no song The Devil's Chord: this

It has the same notes as the giggle, so that might be a part of it

Yeah, everyone is bashing it as a cheesy number (and it is) but that's what makes it uncanny. It comes out of nowhere and goes out in the same way. Like, what the fuck is going on?

The melodies are off. It’s actually quite uncomfortable to listen to.

@@tom_de_bomno it’s not

What?! 😮

I think it is because the actress has been nearly every episode of the new era

@@alistairrae9807 yeah since her introduction in wild blue yonder she only missed one episode which was the Giggle

Yes it does 😉

No it doesn’t that’s why everyone isn’t watching this crap anymore this isn’t doctor who

@@Sixsilon People have been saying this since the 1960s lmao. The show goes through eras. Maybe this era isn't for you and that's fine but it absolutely is doctor who. I hated the Chibnall era. Plenty of people hated the Moffatt era. Guess what? Still doctor who

Now that you mention it, I can't unhear it. That's such a cool detail

Not to mention Harbinger was aslo in this musical number

YES! You're the first person I've seen comment this. I'm not musically trained, so wouldn't know the notes, but the main chorus is definitely the Giggle laugh. ha ha ha HA ha ha haaa

Ah, I'm so sorry to be a party pooper, but those notes aren't right - so it isn't the same sequence as the Giggle. Although I agree it's similar, so may still be a subtle reference! Real sequence goes: There's always a twist B - E - G# x2 There's always a twist at the end B - E - G# - F# - E Or, transposed to C major: G - C - E G - C - E G - C - E - D - C

@@steffanalun8055 ☺️ I concede to your musical knowledge. Either way, it’s a brilliant song 😁

No, you're a Doctor Who fanatic. The kind who doesn't care for consistency and will go nuts over everything that's put out regardless of quality or if it works with pre-established lore/character because it's part of that thing you like.

The one who waits?

All the celestial do that. Maybe the Doctor ...

I'd like it if it went unexplained: so in the next season the fourth wall goes back up and no-one acknowledges it, just for fun.

If you’re hoping for explanations, I’d recommend a different show 😂

I agree. If RTD did something well, it was the seasonal arcs that were tied together by a repeating theme, like those winks. I feel like we get an answer, but the twist might be, that those winks were never intended for us, the audience, but for something else we aren't yet aware of. The only thing I never liked about RTD's story arcs was, that they ended up being existential threatening or introduced humanity as a whole to alien life way too early, just for them to push a reset button at the end. I hope the reset button is a thing of the past by now. But I really liked his arcs. The existential threats especially could hardly escalate even more, and only threats that felt personal to the doctor would maybe have a larger impact. The other seasons since RTD's initial depature tried to deal with those. So I'm almost glad we got a bit of cosmic horror back by inviting beings beyond scientific reasoning or the Doctors knowledge into reality. I also really didn't enjoy the other unresolved arcs that happened since RTD's initial departure. Like why did the TARDIS blow up? Who knows? Who controlled the TARDIS? Who knows? We got fan-theories, but never any true answers. Or all that other stuff that led nowhere and was dropped and forgotten eventually. So I really enjoy the return of the little hints at the end (or somewhere in the middle) of the episodes, because I know it will be resolved eventually in a hopefully satisfying manner.

Certainly Neil Patrick Harris too. Maestro and Toymaker duo.

Will be released before the series 10 soundtrack

@@TomLord99at this point i think hes in on it and purposely not releasing it

not stupid at all. WTF are you saying? :P it's GENIUS.... It goes in the tradition of Mason Williams's "Classical Gas", Nancy Sinatra's "Sorry Bout That", Clothilde "Fallait Pas", Petula Clark "Sign of the times"...

no stop please, i just cant beleive it why does dr who allowed to be rly bad and people will stil love it? i support dr who please dont stop making it but could you make it good. the only reason i ask is because it is so bad.

this is exactly what i'm thinking. he's messing with this world or they're either trapped in a show, an alternate universe, or some sorta simulation that the toymaster / the pantheon is controlling. i know RTD said that he's adding more fantasy but the very loud and noticeable differences to the usual universe and its physics/reality based world is wayyyyyy too noticeable to not be setting up something massive. the way the doctor winks before singing is exactly what the toymaker does, right down to the sound effect and everything. - ruby made it somehow snow? - she immediately turned into another species and changed all of history just because she stepped on a butterfly? - they keep breaking the 4th wall and have done so in every episode this era - susan twist is playing a different character in every episode and 15 mentions susan plus the twist song within the same episode - 15 hit the tardis with a hammer and magically made a second one? makes absolutely no sense in the universe we know especially since there's a deleted scene where 10 gives the meta-crisis doctor a piece of the tardis which he says takes 1,000 years to grow (donna tells them how to speed it up but still it would be impossible in the usual world to just make another tardis instantaneously without some sort of explanation) SO many things are hinting at something and i'm surprised more fans aren't talking about it

@@zocialixomg you're so onto something

This would be a great explanation

@@tidalwavefilms2113it’s about Susan twist

Harbinger is still lurking too at 2:10

Maybe there has been a camp element in Doctor Who meaning that it has always been whimsical and ironic but that isn't the same as infusing the show with LBGTQ messaging. The rating are pretty poor for the first two episodes. If it carries on like this I doubt the show will continue for many more years.

I don't see how this is doctor who as it's core but cool that you feel this way

You mean LGBT messaging like the transgender trampoline and the pansexual secret agent from back in 2005?

@@duncanbrown8868 What was going on in 2005 is nothing like what is going on in 2024. Lady Cassandra if she was transexual it was never very clear and Captain Jack Harkness never lectured anyone about his sexuality as far as I can recall. We have had two characters lecture us about their pronouns since RTD has returned. It was certainly never alluded to that the Doctor was Gay in the Tennant and Eccleston era, the Doctor has always been asexual until the last two incarnations. We also live in a far more illiberal world today than 20 years ago people are becoming less willing to tolerate LBGTQ activism in their entertainment which is reflected in the declining ratings for Doctor Who.

Cassandra, a woman, says “back when I was a little boy” in her first ever appearance. She is 100% trans. Jack never “lectured” anyone but his sexuality was a massive part of his character. Bill was a lesbian, Clara was highly implied to be bisexual. LGBT characters are nothing new. The first doctor had a romance arc in one of his first ever serials. The eighth doctor has a romance arc in the movie. 10 was in love with Rose. 11 was lowkey a weird pervert at times. 12 had clear romantic tension with Missy. Them being non asexual is nothing new. No character has “lectured” anyone about their pronouns. One character said “maybe they use different pronouns” about an alien life form which is totally valid if a little cringe. The other just said they were a they, not a he. Which makes sense because they were an alien god from another universe. Why would they use he/she pronouns?

Me to so camp

​@@damienrevell7544 ? camp? no simplyu a good product in hommage of an era long gone.