Does Rotten Tomatoes Hate DC Or Are We Just Crazy? | Fandemonium

  Рет қаралды 4,666

HitFix

HitFix

Күн бұрын

Miri Jedeikin and guest, Drew McWeeny discuss the fan backlash to the low Rotten Tomato rating for 'Suicide Squad' and how to use our strong passion for good.

Пікірлер: 30
@beyondxxl
@beyondxxl 7 жыл бұрын
going to see it tomorrow, cant wait. i dont care about the reviews just so hyped to see two dc movies in the same year.
@Paredwar29
@Paredwar29 7 жыл бұрын
So much for y'all tackling the subject in the title
@rhetro777
@rhetro777 7 жыл бұрын
lol the title topic was a joke
@WebSpyder777
@WebSpyder777 7 жыл бұрын
Rotten Tomatoes doesn't have a feeling one way or another. They are just aggregating professional critic reviews.
@intellix
@intellix 7 жыл бұрын
It's criminal how few views you guys get. You should advertise more. Get on movie fights and plug the channel, plug it on Collider or the Shmoes. Now the channel appears to actually have some vision instead of just being Roth doing Skype calls I don't want to see the channel die off again.
@Ranblv
@Ranblv 7 жыл бұрын
I agree about the spirit of things but I do think many critics are tired and frustrated by the surge of comicbook movies and they tear them to shreds on things that will barely get a remark on a "regular movie". Suicide squad has issues but it also has tons of fun and many redeeming qualities in the cast performances.
@rio_nakayama
@rio_nakayama 7 жыл бұрын
I think it's not the many bad reviews perse, but the way some or in this case most of the critics write the reviews, they wrote some of the most nonsense reason why the movie (not particulary only about suicide squad) is bad. Compared to DC's counterpart the critics just straight up destroyed it with no good reason. Hey I love good critics, but some are just rediculous. That's just my opinion. Great video guys.
@kerryholland4822
@kerryholland4822 7 жыл бұрын
I totally agree but also I think people are at the moment ready to hate on DC, expecting them to fail so are pulling out shit, or already made up their minds before seeing it.
@RudieObias
@RudieObias 7 жыл бұрын
ISHTAR is a great film!! It was completely and unfairly bashed during the late 80s.
@stewartwood66
@stewartwood66 7 жыл бұрын
While I totally agree as a fan it shouldn't matter to you what anyone else's reviews on a film ar whether they pan or celebrate it and in general I think its the case with most movie goers will see the movie and base the own opinions on the film. The problem with the likes of rotten tomatos is that it pretty much pans everything DC do and raves about everything Disney/Marvel does (now not saying I dislike Marvels movies in general some are very entertaining deadpool, the first couple of captain Americas the first iron man etc) Now you can look at that in many ways corruption being the obvious front runner here, or maybe the reviewers don't like more serious movies and think that superhero movies should in general be family friendly or comedy movies like the CA civil war ((I mean how can you have a war and not have any super hero casualties from it War Machine even walking at the end come on really...)) its hard to say. But the main problem is that yes everyone will form their own opinions on the film which is the way it should be, but for some reason film makers take the critics more seriously then the fans of the films/shows in a lot of cases and there in lies the problem meaning people who like/love films may never get sequels because critics pan what the audience in general think are good films....
@bigblues5251
@bigblues5251 7 жыл бұрын
Fact: Superhero (blockbuster type) movies can only be as good as the villain is bad. Vader, Hannibal, Joker, Loki, all were captivating, charismatic and made the heroes interesting. The complexity, intensity, pace, depth and I would argue ANY real artistic potential a these movies have, runs parallel with the villains performance and story. You can change the villain (making him more evil or dark) to improve the story but, ultimately the hero people come to see needs to be there to keep the story authentic. Fact: Fox and WB do not get this and in they are arrogantly pretending to be victims of the fans they are ignoring. Emo Superman and 5'6" Apocalypse only exist because a arrogant directors and corporate assholes do "what's good enough" to keep a demographic. Stop blaming the fans for not liking you product. Stop acting like your a victim when YOU KEEP GETTING WRONG and Marvel keeps getting it right. Stop pretending ZACK SNYDER is a visionary and his movies are misunderstood. JUST stop doing this shit. Stop pretending people will keep paying for this crap. That is just ignorant.
@yearfire9
@yearfire9 7 жыл бұрын
Emo superman he was good in man of steel
@abonny
@abonny 7 жыл бұрын
2:15 That's the problem right there. NO ONE uses RT like that. Everyone just looks at the score and looks at it as a measurement of how good or bad a movie is. RT is deeply flawed and completely misdirecting. And people won't tune it out. They don't want to READ. They look at the number and that's it. A petition to take it down is nonsense. But it is quite obvious that it HURTS the movie industry in many ways. I can't stand the site and it's mechanics. There is no middle ground - only good or bad. It's a black and white mentality. You can't create a percentage score out of it. It's VERY misleading. Most critics won't admit it because they are part of that system of verified critics.
@rio_nakayama
@rio_nakayama 7 жыл бұрын
Well said. Agree!
@CavemanJesus4Life
@CavemanJesus4Life 7 жыл бұрын
I find it funny that Drew McWeeny says ignore the rotten tomatoes ratings for films, yet this is the fucker that started the BvS hate bandwagon. Once again Love you Miri
@yearfire9
@yearfire9 7 жыл бұрын
I mean critics hate DC cause marvel bought them. Note dark knight came out before iron man 1. But in the end man of steel great movie critics hates it cause of its destruction, avengers, ultron and winter soldier has a lot of destruction also critics love it. Bvs had similar story line to civil war one movie critics hated it and the other critics said best movie ever even thought the pacing was worse. Then suicide squad a lot of action, good characters, decent story and good humor. It's kinda like GoTG group of outlaws who do goods. One was loved and appraised but didn't do a good job on the origins of each. The other did a good job and had origins for each of their character like dead shot and Harley
@Bacbi
@Bacbi 7 жыл бұрын
dude I loved the movie but there is no way people are getting paid to give ss a bad review. I have 4 critics that I follow regularly and we all agree. Then I watched kinda funny who for the most part are about games but they do big movies too, and ultimate dc fanboy greg miller didn't not like it at all. So clearly this is kinda like man of steel where you either love it or hate it
@Tierkuyok
@Tierkuyok 7 жыл бұрын
No one likes age of Ultron everyone hates it and winter solider was good because it had actual characters that the audience can sympathise with. Man of Steel had potential but they hired Zack Snyder a visual director. The Dark Knight Trilogy was so amazing because they it had a director that know what they are doing. I hate when people like you say " Everyone hates DC and you are wrong" if you like the movie you like the movie if you don't like it you don't like it. Enjoy what you love and don't make up bullshit theories up. Love, TK MAX
@yearfire9
@yearfire9 7 жыл бұрын
+TK·MAX are you kidding me last time I checked age of ultron got an 80% on rotten tomatoes.
@Tierkuyok
@Tierkuyok 7 жыл бұрын
+yearfire9 Zack Snyder really isn't a comic book fan. If he is he does not read the comics he just looks at the pictures and says hey that's cool.
@Bacbi
@Bacbi 7 жыл бұрын
TK·MAX well it is cetainly clear he has a very spesific version of batman in mind. Is he a goef johns or kevin smith level comic reader? probably not but I dont think why that is why bvs fell short. I actually loved man of steel, it was nice seeing superman being used fully for once. And he idea that bvs was made just as a response to the destruction is riddicilous.One thing though that snyder actually did better then nolan is batman himself. I love the nolan triology but its not batman, batman in my mind is abke to both believable be out and fight regular crime while in the next moment should be able to stand along side the justice league and be their most valuable member. Bale is if batman was "real" he wouldnt last 2 seconds against superman.
@sleepyazathoth5238
@sleepyazathoth5238 7 жыл бұрын
This DC/Marvel slaves make us (the real fans), look awful. C'mon Hitfix, get rid of you own player and put all of your great content here!!
@ryiin
@ryiin 7 жыл бұрын
You over complicating it. They are like sports fans. Fan of a team. If the opposition is doing well they will begrudge it if they're percived to be underachieving . But unlike sports they is no league table where you can deal in fact and stats to back up your argument. So the champ is who rates better. The issues with that are the critics who have website and live there mum's who lItter rotten tomatoes . Or mainly people who arnt 25. Who grew up with marvel on the big screen. And have a big say on rotten tomatoes. So if your team is constantly getting a bad score for not being marvel (because it's not) which a lot of the reviews say. You can understand the lash out. Also more poor reviewing can also add heat to fire. You have reviewer friends who say (they may not be) "I had fun. But not enough to rate it fresh" wtf! That's either you are scared to say what you think. Which then makes the dc part of your audience question you. So it's not all the fans fault.
@rio_nakayama
@rio_nakayama 7 жыл бұрын
Agree. It's not the fan's fault entirely. I am a DC fan, but I like Marvel properties as well. But most critics (which plays great influence to common movie gower to wether see DC movie or not) just straight up saying that this is not "Marvel" enough. That pisses me off. Don't get me wrong, some critics put some good thoughts in why it isn't good etc, and though I love DC, I agree with most of the critics about the problem with the movie. It just seems that when it comes down to other movies (say Kingdom of Crystal skull) they just automatically love everything about it.
@swanpride
@swanpride 7 жыл бұрын
The movies get a bad score because they are simply not well-made movies. More than one third of SS is pure exposition (breaking the old rule of "show, don't tell), the story manages to be generic and needlessly convoluted at the same time and the editing manages to be even worse than the one of BvS...which is quite a feat. It plays like an overly long youtube video. Fact is that there are a lot of DC fans who don't like those movies either and want better. And no, I don't understand it when DC fans lash out, mostly because I really don't understand why it is so important for them that Warner Bros gets more money. If I were a DC fan (and for the record, I don't consider myself a Marvel fan, either), I would be p.... off with the way the studio ruins my favourite characters.
@rio_nakayama
@rio_nakayama 7 жыл бұрын
+swanpride Just saw suicide squad, wasn't good (at least for me).
@bloodybed9692
@bloodybed9692 7 жыл бұрын
rotten tomatos does not hate dc. we are not crazy. just got back from the movie a few hours ago... worst movie of the year
@bloodybed9692
@bloodybed9692 7 жыл бұрын
view my page for my... review... my kinda review..
So...I watched THE ACOLYTE - Episodes 1 & 2
10:03
Jeremy Jahns
Рет қаралды 200 М.
Omega Boy Past 3 #funny #viral #comedy
00:22
CRAZY GREAPA
Рет қаралды 35 МЛН
Would you like a delicious big mooncake? #shorts#Mooncake #China #Chinesefood
00:30
Which SPIDER-MAN Is in the VENOM UNIVERSE?
8:06
New Rockstars
Рет қаралды 24 М.
Mr. & Mrs. Smith - How to Break Screenwriting Rules
9:35
Baby Screenwriter
Рет қаралды 8 М.
This is what our Movie Critics think of 'Yoga Hosers'
5:04
Aunt May Slaps Captain America at Peter's Funeral
4:06
DanCo Comics
Рет қаралды 89
Badcomedian - Дивергент [удаленный обзор]
40:06
Евгений Небаженов/
Рет қаралды 2,8 МЛН
WHITE WOLF A First Look That Will Change Everything
8:57
Film Royalty
Рет қаралды 1,6 М.
Удачливая дочь сделала из отца миллионера 😳 #фильм #сериал
0:59
DixyFilms - Фильмы и сериалы
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
Форчан ищет Флаг (Финал) 🍀
0:46
i11ushenka
Рет қаралды 3 МЛН
Форчан ищет Флаг (Финал) 🍀
0:46
i11ushenka
Рет қаралды 3 МЛН
🍬 Testing the Viral Gummy Pack Opening Lifehack! 🤔 | Epic Fail Alert!
0:40