For Days

We can never figure out who suggested or composed that part. Roger or david !!!!?

@@KIAvASH_K David.

@@KIAvASH_K as it is in a different tuning from standard and aren’t traditional chords, it’s definitely not Roger

@@KIAvASH_K david has gone on record saying hes particularly proud of the chord progression in dogs, he definitely wrote it.

alb639 For the Animals tour they had Snowy White on guitar to help out Gilmour and it was great. They played every song on the album. My favorite concert ever

They had similar overdubs for the last two tracks of dsotm (or maybe just brain damage i dont recall) but they removed them because they thought it was too busy

hard to disagree on the song rating. I like parts of there 3rd guitar but not most. There are places where it fits in nicely (imo)

There are many incredible live versions of Dogs... Yes, it's one of their finest...

Mine either!

thats what I thought, but couldnt think it was true

Right on, I didn't realize it until I read your comment.

Yeah, agree. Basically RW had all these albums figured out in his head, to very last bloody inch. Masterful craftsmanship; a fantastic producer. To have someone like him beside you is a guarantee of albums (and millions). Lucky Nick and Rick. Cheers

@@octopus672003 The demos for "The Wall" beg to differ. Pink Floyd at their best was very much a collaborative effort, and Roger's raw demos were rather abrasive and unlistenable (or at least unmarketable). That being said, they were very much still gems, albeit in need of refinement and polish from Dave and even Rick.

Roger made up the singing melody and phrasing, but it davids voice sounds cooler doing it. Roger is a genius a vocal phrasing, he didn't make it for david, he just made it and handed it off to him, because this one sounds better with David. Rogers vocal phrasing talent is among the very best in rock history. This is not an easy to song to come up with a singing melody over. And Rogers vocal melody phrazing over Dogs is about the best i've ever heard. Although i do wonder about the middle seection "have a good drown as you go down" I wonder if Roger came up with that singing melody or David. It was prob Roger..... But i've never heard him sing it. Its really cool, I often wonder how did such cool phrazing come out of Roget...... He had a channel to real inspiration back then, like no one else...

When I listen That part that you 'described, the photo looks too beauty for me, and members are more special than it already . great music experience and you make That this experience grows.

I like the final version of this part much better. Makes more of a statement

The moog thing is actually in there after he says “ground down in the end” it was just covered up in the mix. You have to listen very carefully to hear it.

Me too

This song has gone through many iterations in terms of who sings which verse. 1974 Gilmour Waters Gilmour Waters 1976 Waters Gilmour Waters Waters 1977 Gilmour Gilmour Waters Waters 1977 live Gilmour Gilmour Gilmour Waters Currently when Waters preforms this song he has someone else sing the first verse but he sings the last 3 verses including the last 2 by himself

You're mouth is as big as waters gob!

is not gilmour is waters

in the spirit of 'Hey You', I agree.

Isn't that 3rd guitar layer fucking incredible? Gilmour is such a stud. I hope his new album is better than On An Island. I miss his raw, gritty guitar sound.

alb639 I agree right, I thought I didn't appreciate it but really it wasn't that good.

in 1977

iam so glad roger write this song

David sang the first part before Roger came in after the long middle section of the song. But I do agree I am also glad that he sang the first part of the song.

True, but it is Roger's lyrics. :)

Yes youre right lol

But David sings better ;)

Santii Herre yes but the original 2de verse sing by roger is also cool, the lyrics changes the point of view, so it's interesting to change the vocal :)

Alex Selman You are just totally wrong, Dave wrote a lot of lyrics for his songs in pre-Dark Side era, i.e. Fat old sun

yes, the first solo is exactly the same

3:02 as well. He didn't even try to hold out "Night."

according to David, this was probably the hardest song to sing the band has ever written. He didn't like singing it. So much that he has never bothered playing it in his post Floyd career. He preferred playing songs from the Wall (an Album he absolutely hated) over this song. Which is a shame, kinda wanted to see a Wright - Gilmour version of Dogs.

XD

Travis Azzopardi dogs still is best name after near 40yrs man

+Travis Azzopardi no it was "Raving and Drooling"

+milan alexich no raving and drooling became sheep Travis is right this was originally you gotta be crazy , the first line gives it away :)

I stand corrected

You've got to be crazy, you've got to be mean! You've got to keep your shoes and your car clean!

David could not not have don't vocals on sheep. Roger is perfect for that song. Same on Pigs. I love Rogers crazy voice.

Robert Wells Roger sings the second half of Dogs on the album and it sounds great. He also sings the rest of the album. I get annoyed when people say Gilmour is "the" lead vocalist when Waters sang more than Gilmour or anyone else in the band.

but in the dark side of the moon and wish tou were here, David Gilmour sings the major of songs...... in my opinion the songs that are more melodic were sung by gilmour because dave voice is more perfect and woderful.(welcome to the machine)......although the Roger voice can express anger and sadness (Hey you)............

Well David´s voice is certainly easier to listen to and likeable, but Rogers pained out breaks often fit the intention of the piece better, PF used the contrast artfully,

"rogers voice has no vocal ability" He sounds great some of the time. The Wall all sung by Dave and Rick would be interesting, wouldn't it. And worse.

I hate to not know this terms...

@@baitman2368 A chord progression is just a sequence of chords.

+jorkanmx yeah it sounds pretty terrible :b ! Only certain passages of certain songs are meant for Waters to sing on, obviously this were Gilmours type of song to sing :) ! And these guys realized that, and switched back and forth between Waters and Gilmour perfectly!

go-Ta

exactly what i've been trying to explain to all the Waters haters for years.. There are songs that fits him, that wouldn't fit Gilmour!

Roger's vocal sounds like a guide vocal, btw as it was an ongoing studio recording, both Waters and Gilmour vocals sound like just guide vocals .. but you can hear many instrumental parts that have been kept till the final version. The first guitar solo is the one that appears on the album. unless David was able to meticulously replicate his own solos to such perfection.. nice to hear this w.i.p. recording. thanks for posting!

@@vgfxworks I wouldn't be surprised if he can replicate them identically.

I think EMI called them "reference mixes" -- early mixes you listen to to decide what you want to change or add. Not a demo.

+Maggie Anaya Maggie. Animals is my favorite Pink Floyd album. I prefer David singing the first part and Roger can sing the second part. But it is the "dragged down by the stone" on the released version that always gives me goosebumps! "Stone, stone, stone on tape delay works!

Yes, shivers up my spine every time!

And the Vocoded dog barks.

And the master out, whistling for their Dog. Under the forest of steam and pollution pumped out of Battersea Station, back in the day.

Which songs?

Great sound for The Wall, .

@@kevanbodsworth9868 You're right!

Maybe he was completely pissed.

I believe it's because animals is so underrated

I feel you. This would've been the only box I'd be willing to spend 100€ on. To me it's their best stuff and the most interesting stage of the band aswell. Just the right mixture of waters/gilmour imo. Gilmours musicianship can get boring quite soon. Waters is the epic songwriter and gilmour the melody maker - together with wright of course - I would have also loved more information about the recording, how the ideas evolved, what wright and mason felt like during these days, and of course i want that 77' Boston Bootleg as an official Live release. I would take any Live Concert of that time as an official release. How come Pink Floyd just has Delicate Sound of Thunder and Pulse as official Live recordings? Isn't that a shame?

Gilmour can do pretty, or angry, but Waters says how he feels.

That’s true, but the band members (particularly David and Roger) actually produced a lot of the music, that why their records usually say “produced by Pink Floyd” instead of the name of a producer. That’s not to say they didn’t have other producers or engineers working on the albums though.

Me too Syd!! I think my 3 grand trip to Newport this past summer to see Roger Waters & my planned trip to Chicago this spring are proving my PF obsession is getting costly! Lol. Will Luv them 4-ever!

DIEJENIGENWELCHEN Yes, good ear there

Definitely Farfisa, good ears

Yeah, you can hear that effect on Division Bell and Broken China too.

This is just a guide vocal

No way

Eu prefiro essa guitarra demo que a original

But my god, how insightful that we can hear rog sing the first part.... Mad

U can mix it

@@baitman2368 I'm not that good at it (:

Tal cual

I prefer Roger's voice.

Dave did a much better job

xunit94 Dave did a better job on Dogs than a lot of songs. Most of the time he sings like he's bored as fuck.

Devin Ellis Time? Comfortably Numb? Welcome to the Machine? Did he sound bored to you?

Dave's smooth vocals and Roger's manic highs together in song are what made Pink Floyd great. The two of them sharing vocals on Dogs is why it's one of my favorite Floyd songs.

Yes, I agree..I was there that night. First half of the Show....Shine On......You Gotta Be Crazy......Raving and Drooling.....Second Half of the Show....Dark Side of the Moon..Complete with Circular Screen and Animation......Brilliant Concert....

"Who told Roger that he could sing?" About a hundred million record buyers. Who's Daniel Bernard?

This guy is fucking moron

Its called putting all your anguish and pain into a work

Viva Waters*

Devin Ellis Juanka Trevi Viva both of them, as well as any other member and the whole Pink Floyd!

Viva Wright y Mason

Sin Waters, Gilmour, Wright y Mason simplemente hubieran sido un buen grupo, uno de tantos.

No se olviden de Barret El loco diamante

Nope, still mainly minor pentatonic with some notes from the minor scale

"Pink Floyd for no letting Roger" Sigh.

Yes, once something is rare, it can always be called rare.