I've heard some Jews that are anti-Zionist mention something about God saying that they were meant to live in exile and would actually be punished if they tried to take the land back before he said it was time? Is there something that Dr. Shabir knows about this basically expanding further on this topic? Thank you for your videos!

I am neither a Jew or a Muslim, but it seems to me that it is doubtful that God would promise a swath of land to a 'chosen people' but on the condition that, firstly, the chosen people wipe out seven nations who are now occupying those lands. So one of my problems is this, that if indeed God 'commanded' this, then what kind of God is this? I have many other problems with any written records in our history. Then of course, oral records are on a totally different level.

The promise was made to Abrahan. In the time of Abraham the Jews did not exist. If God says that he has given the land to the descendants of Abraham, then the question is which descendants of Abraham? We know that Abraham had children like Ishmael and Isaac...Is the promise made to all the descendants of Abraham or only the descendants of Ishmael or only Isaac? So you can interpret the verses in different, ofcourse if these verses are reliable.

With condition you must be righteous 🙏

When one considers that to top half of said promised land fell to king David in 1000 BC while the bottom half was lost and 75 years later on the death of King Solomon, they lost the lot, and all were taken in mass as hostages to Babylon. If it was a gift from God, they wasted it, and now no genetic or DNA trace can link the European Jews to said land.

Promised land was owned by other people, meaning Promised land is also called Promised to squat or grab land or territory.

Thanks Dr Shabir for the insight. I always enjoy listening to every topic and how you do justice to them. May Allah bless both of you.

The Old Testament's time span of composition is approximately 1100 years (12th century BCE to 2nd century BCE), The New Testament approximately 60 years (50 AD to 110 AD). The Quran, approximately 23 years (610 AD to 632 AD). I think these facts alone says enough which is the truer word of God. I.e, would the Almighty really need 1100 years to convey his message to man? And then how much of what is documented over those 1100 years can truly be attributable to God's words versus what man has decided should be included?

It would be interesting to talk about what Quran says about the promised land.

The pragmatic and moraly ,based on the 3 religions scriptures, and the human moral itself , the jews has a claim to an at least a part of the land to live and exercise their religion, building the temple with harmony together with the muslims , will bring everlasting peace to the world , and all of it's conflicts

MashaALLAH💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥

Seek Peace ✌️ Victory to Peace insha'Allah

الارض ل اللہ کریم may Allah bless you and us all the real Huda guidance to the straight path Amen

Their interpretation of being promised revolves around ownership. In truth it can mean many other things like but not limited to becoming a leader. I am pretty sure they are not acting as such today.

The land promised to Abraham's descendants was arbic mecca as he built a alter a place if worship near the well in the TORAH kaaba in the Qur'an 😢😢🎉🎉❤

If it is Qur'an, then it can be taken literally.There is no practicality in it.

GOD BLESS ISRAEL AND GODS CHOSEN PEOPLE ISRAEL......NOBODY ABANONED THE LAND THE JEWS WERE ALWAYS BULLIED BY MISHCHIEVIOUS PEOPLE.....NOW GOD HAS MADE THEM VERY POWERFUL .....

✝ Bible says we must believe in ONE God ( Mark 12 : 29 - 31) ➜ Do the christians follow what they claim to believe in ❓❌ 🕉 ( Chandogya Upanishad 6 : 2 : 1 says we must believe in ONE God ➜ Do the hindus follow what they claim to believe in ❓❌ ☪ Quran says we must believe in ONE God ( Surah Ikhlas. 112 :1 - 4 ) ➜ Do the muslims follow what they claim to believe in ❓✔

The Israelis in that period of time were all black peoples. The people living there today are of European descent and other other peoples. Israel is is very cruel, demeaning state after more land and all proceeds from gas pockets found via satellite off the coast of Gaza. The US has already secured permits for drilling, Britain involved as well as Israel. It is very sad for all Arabic nations as to what goes on in Israel, and I feel it is fear as Israel is after land in Egypt and Jordan. My heart and prayers goes out to the Palestinian people daily, I have eye bags now from tears. Thank you for the good work you both do, I watch you on my TV.

As a human

The real borders of the Promised Land . The river of JORDAN and its two sides into Sinai region . What we want to know is crossing the red sea from the desert of Egypt to a part the Saud Arabia .

No mention that Oct 7 is the reason Gaza people are suffering now, and how about they return the hostages?

Say it straight, The land belongs to the jews ✡️ It's a promise land by God ❤😊

The Holy Bible Say Do Not Kill

Brother i have blackmagic people on me , can you please help me

If you read Quran very carefully Israel is name found more than any other name.

Very controversial. First, if the one who have a deed can claim the land, who gave them the deed? The israelites got the land from God. Secondly, why we can’t force Hamas to the peace deal? Is it because they want the land by themselves otherwise they ready to die instead of having two states solution?

Well the children of Israel forsook the land with graven images and the worship of Statues. Now the children of Esau want the land for themselves. Ezekiel 36:24-26 says For I will take you from among the nations, and gather you out of all the countries, and will bring you into your own land. And I will sprinkle clean water upon you, and ye shall be clean: from all your filthiness, and from all your idols, will I cleanse you. It just says your own land, not the land. Only a small remnant was able to return to the land before Christ's advent.

Hating. Does not help me or make me happy

The modern-day tafsir on Surah al-Isra 17:4-8 after the creation of Israel is a plagiarism on clear Tanakh prophecy. "in the last years you will come into the land that is restored from the sword, whose inhabitants have been gathered from many peoples to the mountains of Israel which had been a continual waste; but its people were brought out from the peoples, and they are living securely, all of them... On that day when My people Israel are living securely, will you not know it?" - Ezekiel 38 But those who attack Israel with Gog and Magog will go directly to hell without judgment.

Gene studies show that the Palestinians descend from Jews who converted to Christianity and Islam later. They are the descendants of the Israelites just as much as the Mezrahi/middle eastern Jews. The Palestinians are not genetically Arabs or recent Arab migrants. They are the indigenous and continuous inhabitants of the land, they just never left the land, unlike the diaspora Jews who went to other parts of the middle east and Europe thousands of years ago. The Israelites only dominated the other tribes for 200 years according to the archaelogical evidence anyway.

God in New Covenant in New Testament has given the land and field to a new nation. God has announced it through His Messiah Prophet Jesus Christ. Please see New Testament Matthew 21.41 to 46 verses Besides due to violation of law of God He has divorced Jews. Reference Bible Jeremiah chap 3 verse 8.

3:67 Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian; but a upright Muslim [submitting to Allah alone] he was not of the polytheists.

I’m not mad. Or upset. If. I could. Call it good. Now. And. never wake up. Again. Not worry about. Future

God said he would bless both descendants of Abraham (Ishmael and Isaac) in Genesis 12. Ishmael is a great multitude of Arabic people. God has blessed his seed with billions of people. Isaac, from whom the Jews descend from, are a tiny group of people in contrast. Had they obeyed God from the beginning they would have filled that original territory that God promised to Isaac and Jacob. They should have been equal in numbers to their Arab brothers today. However, they kept falling away to from God and followed false idols and other gods. But since Jesus came through the Jewish side of the lineage, Satan has made it his goal over the centuries to try and eliminate the Jews. Satan doesn't want Jesus returning to the earth, so if he can wipe out his lineage, he will have accomplished that. So unfortunately the Jews have had to learn the hard way but they still delivered the Messiah, even though they have rejected Him. SO we will just have to wait until Christ returns for Israel to reclaim the territory promised in Genesis 12.

So someone who follows texts that lifts from OT and NT is going to tell those that follow either or both they are wrong or doing it incorrectly? Doesn't anyone see a problem with that? Really sad to see this happen but then again, those who submit are told Jesus was not crucified. That their god has two right hands and is vastly different than what is of the Jewish and Christian Lord. So, this is all a sham.

Then the question comes to the mind of a decent man: Why did Allah (C.C.) reveal Quran?

Dr. Shabir is disappointed and seems to have a problem with how God handled the Israelites in ancient times concerning the promised land, particularly due to the involvement of violence. Interestingly, he refrains from providing the necessary context despite his usual tendency to contextualize, rationalize, and mitigate violent situation in problematic hadiths and Quranic verses in Islam.. this is the inconsistency with our muslim friends we have to deal with.

So,when the Quran says that Bani Israel should wage war (jihad) against the people of Canaan,should we read that literally? Funny how he steers away from the texts in the Quran where Allah commands the Israelites to take the land from the inhabitants.

As Salaam Alaakum. There were no Europeans in boundage in Egypt. Thats Prophetical 400yrs

there are no difficulties taking it literally hence when the messiah comes it becomes literal

Love your shows. They are so silly. God promised the land to israel, and israel returned to thier home land against all odds. That is a very strong case for God existence (too bad muslims dont use it, afterall, jews christian and muslim agree about this)

tHE PROMISED LAND WAS GIVEN TO ABRAHAM OR TO JACOB ( ISRAEL) ????????

The land was promised to the descendants of Abraham. The descendants are from Ishmael and Isaac. Ishmael Arabs and Isaac Jews should be sharing the land.

With due respect to Dr Ally and Dr. Ally indeed is an giant and expert in his field but on this matter, we should allow Ahmed Deedat to answer this question, check out his clip "The Children Of Israel Chosen By God For What??"

It's just say in the bible not in real documents papers

What forcast in theQuran,

Bless you Dr. Shabir Ally, The Bible (Gen. 12:3) does NOT say 'he who blesses Israel will be blessed.' "It does not say anything about Israel, but that all families will be blessed through Abraham, that is, through his seed Jesus Christ! In the book of Galatians Paul makes it clear that now the Seed of Abraham is Christ. That is why he said that Abraham was looking for a temple not made by the hands of human beings of men. This is why Jesus Christ said that that's at the temple was going to be destroyed when he proclaimed judgment upon old Covenant Israel of his generation of the first century . Jesus Christ said but I will raise it up he never said that a third Temple was going to be made by human beings and that's what Paul is trying to say Christians I'm going to tell you one thing you better stop accepting all this that's coming out where people are taking just verses of the Bible and not giving you the Whole story When you keep reading the rest of different chapters in Genesis you see how all these nations and they went to war against each other you know this person has been taken out of context by Christian Zionist

Jesus true successor the praised one Muhammad [on whom be peace] was born 500 years after Jerusalem destruction, the final prophet was born in 570, the same year as the failed attempt of the christians to raze the Kaba to the ground in Mecca, the Quran mentions that event in sura 105, named AlFil, the Elephant

We don't take Bible literally regarding God promised land to Abraham but Muslims take Quran literally about Sharia law 😅

why cannot the Jews be given some land from the USA or Canada where there is a lot of land lying waste? why take some place from the already occupied with over population, in Palastine?

When I lived in Israel I saw all signs in Hebrew, Arabic & English and met Israeli Arabs who spoke fluent Hebrew and got along with their Jewish neighbours. When I lived in Turkey signs in Kurdish were banned, people got arrested for singing Kurdish and until recently speaking it was even illegal. Kurds are even being bombed right now by multiple countries.

THE FACT IS THAT AFTER THE JEWS REJECTED JESUS. THE PROMISE WAS WITHDRAWN AS JESUS SAID;. 1. (Matthew 21:43) Therefore say I unto you, The kingdom of God shall be taken from you, and given to a nation bringing forth the fruits thereof. 2. And because they stubbornly rejected and claimed to have crucified Jesus, therefore they were punished. In 70.CE. Jerusalem completely destroyed. temple destroyed, and Jews expelled never to return again by Titus... 3. The Quran says to the Jews., that the only way of Salvation for them now is to accept the last and final Prophet Muhamnad.. (Thw Quran 7:157).

It would not piss me off so bad if I had not be. Mislead.

you comportably forget to tell how this war started

Qur'an hafs / qur'an warsh / qur'an al duri / qur'an qalun / qur'an hisham / qur'an ,,, etc qs 5 :; 21 qs 7 :; 161 israel submit and obey hamas can lie in 3 things , even oaths ,, can be redeemed ,,, if hamas are not kept 😮

Muslims should research Jacob's trouble. (jacob=Israel) fulfilling the last missing week of 70 weeks of Daniel. (1 week/7days=7 years) All this will take place and the world will try to destroy Israel. Jesus will return save the remnant and establish the 1000 year kingdom on this earth ruling from Jerusalem

GENESSIS 25 READ ALL GENESIS.

The Ashkenazis are the ones having the most power in Israel, compared to sephardis, mizrahims and Ethiopians. Ashkenazis:- 1. They look Europeans 2. They came from Europe 3. Their DNA is European, not Semitic. 4. They act and behave Europeans - colonialists, thieves, racists, supremacists 5. Ashkenazis aren't indigenous to the Middle East but originate from Europe, mainly Eastern Europe. They're most probably the descendants of the Khazars of Northern Caucasus that converted to Judaism in the late 8th century. 6. The strange thing is "indigenous" Askenazis don't get support from indigenous peoples of the world. 7. They are supported by Europeans and European colonizers in the USA, Canada, Australia, NZ, then-whites of South Africa 8. They also support their fellow European colonizers in (7) above 9. Palestine is for Palestinian Muslims, Jews, Christians, the indigenous people of the land plus whoever that want to live side by side peacefully with one another regardless of skin colour, race, ethnicity, religion.

There land is Europe... the holly roman empire!

Quran is famous due to describing holy bible .if no bible nobody no Quran

Seems like this scholar can't really interpret the Bible. You can't fool God, what he speaks through his prophet has not be changed. Even though he has scattered them all over the world he will bring them back to the holy land.

Why you don"t want to give up your sin to jesus who die for your sin no one is good.

Dr... Does the flying donkey literally fly from Mecca to Jerusalem....

Allah’s creation of mankind are all the same and he doesn’t distinguish between us.Only to spread amongst the land.Allah is the most knowing and we will be judged accordingly

HOW MANY PEOPLE IN THIS WORLD BELIEVE IN THE TORAH ??????????????????????

This is the fundamental difference between the Bible and the Quran. The Quran provides no history, and people invented hadith stories to fill in context centuries later. Even if the Old Testament were compiled after the exile, we know from archeology and history that there was a real kingsom of Israel pre exile, with a real Temple in Jerusalem. Then there were real returning exiles who built a second Temple. Then there was a real nation under Roman rule that Jesus Christ was born into. So the Jewish claim is based on historical facts, and not just some metaphysical religious claim like Muhammad flying to Jerusalem on a buraq.

Is Mars promised by God for them as well?

This is jesus time not land i call on all muslims to come to jesus now and give up your sin before you die.

Why highlight bible, when Quran 5:21 and onwards is crystal clear and more relevant. Allah gifted the entire land in HERITAGE to the Jewish people (Bani Israel). Ancient and modern contexts don't apply to Quran, as it is believed to be for all times. Any muslim opposing is in dire t conflict with Allah Swt. Accept the harsh reality, swallow the bitter pill and wait for the judgement day with Sabr.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Wow, what a hypocrite. When it comes to the Quran we need to consider it literally while for other text you can't.

Dr. shabir should light a long cigar and with strong drink in hand and rather have a good time because after this life he is gona burn in hell for eternity. Why is he wasting his only life? In allah shaitan eblise!

The promised land was not a Political but rather a spiritual promise.. Deuteronomy ( 9: 1-6) J's are arrogant and disobedient to the God command but less evil compared to the inhabitants of Cannan. Spiritual precondition was to be implemented as prerequisite 1) listen to the Scriptures Exodus 19: 5-6. 2) change the Stony hearts into fleshy ones (Ezekiel 11:19-20 & Isaiah 1:16-17). But they didn't fulfill it and became a sinful nation ( Jeremiah 16:12 & Isaiah 1: 4,6 and 15). They became a reproach and a horror for surrounding nations ( Ezekiel 5:17-18) and God published them with death caused by famine and killed with swords. The rest scattered throughout as a diaspora until now ( Ezekiel 5:12-15). Political z'ism was formed by radical movement in 1887 by Theodor and wrong interpretation and understanding of the scriptures. God is always just. A thief never becomes an owner of possession. This thief will be punished by a great nation in the near future ( Jeremiah 5:15 and Deuteronomy 28:49-53 & 68). God's promises will never fail. We believe in Him and put our trust in Him only.

Look up Nabi Asli , learn why it's forbidden to speak about this So called prophet you might have a different point of view, and that they're at least 26 VERSION of the CORAN

Dr Ally make it sound like only Jews from abroad wanted to establish the state of Israel when in fact majority of the remaining/resident Jews (not all) were favorable in establishing such state. While after the Ottoman administration there were more Muslims in modern-day Israel than there were Jews nobody really had legal claim of modern-day Israel as a state. The historically entitled Jews, while the minority, just beat the Muslims into establishing a legal state covering less populated non-Jew regions (ie not Gaza, not West Bank). I said historically entitled because what used to be Kingdom of Israel and Kingdom of Judea was illegally renamed to Palestine by foreign occupier Romans. Even Jesus, whom both Christians and Muslims recognize, addressed the Jews collectively as Israel.

Jesus Christ existed woth moses as Qur'an says in many verses wrong timeline CREATED by the roman catholic church ❤😂😂😂

🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💪💪💪

The Bibel is the Greatest book in the whole universe "In the pages of the Bible, the ink of eternity inscribes the stories of resilience, the poetry of hope, and the wisdom of ages, inviting every seeker to find solace in its sacred embrace." There is no other book greater than the Bibel.

For such a smart guy there's so much dishonesty here I could write an essay in response. Hey Shabir! how many Jews live in Arab and Muslim lands today? "Out there, in the world, all the walls were covered with graffiti: Yids, go back to Palestine, so we came back to Palestine, and now the worldatlarge shouts at us: Yids, get out of Palestine.” Amos oz When we talk politics with Arabs in Israel, they say, 'My grandfather used to live in Tel Aviv, and now it's owned by Jewish people -- we want to come back,'" he says. "I respond, 'My parents came from Iran and Tunisia, but nobody is going to give our property back to us. It's all been confiscated . . . We have this little sandbox we call Israel. We give our hearts and lives to make it a proud country. Every one serves in the Israeli Defense Force in order for Israel to survive. You have half of the globe.'" Rapper Subliminal

Arabs started a war at 1948, lost and therfore displaced. You know, sometimes you pay for your mistakes. Arabs started a war on october 7th, god willing the good guys will win again, and tough on the arabs.

Hamas use their civilians as human shields, what do you expect would happen to them?

Thanks for sharing your funny jokes, Dr. Shabir. It’s absolutely hilarious. But Christians should rather tell their stories than you. It’s unfortunate that you are misinformed or brainwashed. What I can comment here is you are deviously wrong, bro.

The land promised to the Israelites is indicated in the bible and it's division's by tribes. Isn't it that the other portions of the promised land(promised to Abraham) were occupied by the Edomites, Ishmaelites, Midianites etc the other Descendants of Abraham The Land promised to Israel is a portion of the Land promised to Abraham.

The Bible is absolutely clear about the promised land. Read with an open mind Jeremiah 33. The covenant of God with Israel in inviolable. The judgement of God fell on the Cananites for their gross immoralities. ISRAEL is not free from the judgement of God.Quran also affirms that the land was given to Israel.

Stop, stop stop 🛑 Bible is men written book and you are wasting our time. Let's see what Allah SWT commands: In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious and Most Merciful وَالَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا بَعْضُهُمْ أَوْلِيَاءُ بَعْضٍ ۚ إِلَّا تَفْعَلُوهُ تَكُن فِتْنَةٌ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَفَسَادٌ كَبِيرٌ And those who disbelieve are allies of one another, (and) if you (Muslims of the whole world collectively) do not do so [i.e. become allies, as one united block under one Khalifah (a chief Muslim ruler for the whole Muslim world) to make victorious Allah's religion of Islamic Monotheism], there will be Fitnah (wars, battles, polytheism) and oppression on the earth, and a great mischief and corruption (appearance of polytheism). 8: 73 Why are we Muslims not talking about reestablishing the power and control Allah SWT give us from the beginning? The command is to unite under one Khalifah. The number one concern on the minds of the Muslims is the tragedy in Gazza. The destruction in Gazza is worse than that of Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined. The Zionist Israelis are the modern day Amelak as they were a tribe from nation of the Israelites and their brutality in Gazza and West Bank is the evidence. We have to listen to what Allah SWT is saying to us in the above verse and from the beginning. "And Remember when your Lord said to the Angels, I am going place Khalifah on earth".... 2: 30 You see the UN which is controlled by USA, is dead body in the muddy water as every resolution passed by majority, is vetoed by USA. Which means we have to create a balance of power in the world by creating United League of Muslim Nations. Which is to reestablish the Caliphate because we are children of Adam, peace be upon him . "United League of Muslim Nations" under one Khalifah will be a strictly defensive Force with a quick response to any threat to the Ummah of Islam. And it is easy to do it. It will be the Council of Muftis, from which they will choose the Khalifah. Under the Khalifah will be a seat for a Mufti from every country in world with 100,000 plus Muslim population as Islam is for entire World. From every municipality we will choose a representative till we have the Council of Muftis for that country with a Grand Mufti of that country to sit in the Council of Muftis under the Khalifah. All communication can be done remotely with everyone working from home. Most effective and real democratic way of governing where all decisions are made by the Council of Muftis but the Khalifah having the final say. Under the Khalifah, the "ULMN" will have its own army, navy and Air Force under one commander for defending the entire ummah. We already have the hardware from major Muslim countries. They just have to be relabeled "ULMN" when they out to defend any part of the Ummah like removing the Mediterranean Sea blockade by Israelis.The four letters "ULMN" will be enough to deter anyone from doing what is happening in Gazza today. But we have to be the Nation of Al Muttaqun for Allah SWT is saying now: "You are the Best of People ever raised up for Mankind, enjoying what is Good, forbidding what is evil and believing in Allah SWT" .... Quran 3: 110 Then how can we go wrong when the fear of "ULMN" will overwhelm the hearts of our enemies? That is what Islam is and we are Muslims to resolve every matter in a Peaceful manner, Insha Allah. Alhamdu Lillah. If no one is willing to act as the acting Khalifah, I will be the acting Khalifah till one is chosen and sincerely invite all Muslims to join me in this effort, for if we fail but we will never fail, we will still get one Hashanah for our intentions, Insha Allah Jazak Allah Khair Your brother Abu Saad Acting Khalifah (as Son of Adam, AS)

Whole of the video the speaker is confused what is he saying,why is he saying,should he tell these things or not,am I damaging my agenda??