My #1 biggest hate for any mascara is flaking. If it flakes even a little, I won't wear it.

Thank you for this! I appreciate your thoughtful and thorough reviews.

Hi, Taylor!! Great video!! I'm definitely going to try the Milani and the Elf mascaras!! I have very watery eyes, so I haven't had any luck with tubing mascaras. Have a wonderful weekend!! ❤️

Your hair looks amazing!

I have been looking for the loreal age perfect mascara since your drugstore tubing mascara video-- finally found at walgreens!!! That was a treat considering I was there was a flu shot.. stay warm Taylor, our Georgia heat just took a hard turn!!!

Perfect! Thank you

Great video, thank you!!!

I really appreciate your informative, calm, delivery. You are pleasure to listen to, while always providing well thought out informative content. Thank you.

Omg I’m gonna go and try all 3 now!!! My go to was always the Covergirl super sizer waterproof mascara, but I can hardly find it now! The brush was so unique and perfect for my Asian eyes, so I always save the wand after I’m done lol! Btw I just noticed you changed your name from Drugstore Maven to your real name! 😢 I’m gonna miss it! I’ve been with you since your blog back in the day.

Hi. Just thought I'd follow up. I found the Age Perfect mascara online at Walmart. You are right! I think it's the best I've ever tried. I live in a snowy state. I just finished a long walk. Watery eyes and all, no smearing! Thanks for the recommendation. So glad I bought 3 tubes.

I’m seriously impressed by the results you got from the antigravity mascara! Now I need to try!

Love the Milani antigravity. Glad I took your recommendation. I curl my lashes, wiggle the brush at the roots to maintain lift and build a thicker base, then I sweep it through the rest of the lashes. Looks much better than bare lashes. Its not holy grail for me (i think mist mascaras at any price are average or worse), but its pretty nice. Ty!❤

Did a stock up of the bite before it’s gone forever, but def gonna try the milani!

You are so pretty and I really enjoy your channel. Keep posting.

My go-to drugstore mascara is the Honest Beauty lengthening one. I did just order the Tower 28 mascara to try (and looks like a lot of other people have too!) I have super sensitive eyes so I can only use clean mascaras.

The Milani side looks amazing! I've held off on purchasing that one, but this changed my mind! I have long straight lashes so I think it would help out a lot. I love the Lash Paradise from L'Oreal. Best drugstore mascara I've found! Thanks for the video.

Love the anti-gravity one! I used Loreal Volumnious for years and tried this one because of you and it's my new go-to 🙂

That Loreal tubing mascara is so good. I made sure to get the correct one. I got it because of your recommendation. I also just received the milani. I haven't tried that one yet. I ALSO ordered those short individual lashes, I will try them tomorrow.

Thank you for this video! I’ve been trying to find a good mascara that isn’t going to transfer or flake. I’m okay with the length of my lashes but I want volume and it not to go anywhere until I take it off.

what blush/bronzer and eyeshadow are you wearing? you look beautiful!

I’m always looking for waterproof mascara recommendations. My lashes are stick straight and after curling them , regular mascara takes the curl out. I haven’t tried the Elf one, so I’m going to get it!

I use the L.A.Colors Biggie Mascara & it's amazing for a $4.99 mascara. I highly recommend it. It gives my lashes alot of length & volume. It's also a tubing mascara.🙂

All I can say is you have spent so much time and money testing mascaras for all of us. Thank you for all the work you put in!! I'm an Essence Lash Princess user, simple and easy to remove. My mature eyelashes are short and sparse, so I just curl them and hit them once with mascara. I wear glasses, so fortunately my eyes are covered!!🏵🎃

This is great. I love the milani anti-gravity mascara. I still love loreal lash paradise and voluminous. I also love the elf big mood mascara. I have to try the waterproof I guess. I got the age perfect one just haven't tried it yet. Be well woman.

Awe…I’m in Augusta!❤

I love layering different mascara to get the benefits of each. I wonder if you can use a tubing mascara and then put something else on top.

I wish the Tower 28 mascara came in a waterproof version. Also, the Beauty Pie waterproof mascara is amazing but difficult to remove.

I’ve tried the Big Mood mascara both regular and waterproof unfortunately they didn’t work for my lashes. I haven’t tried the other two mentioned . The Milani one looks right up my ally. I agree makeup is such a personal thing to each individual. Thanks for a great video!

The Milani Anti-Gravity is everything! Totally would pay more. One of the few that doesn’t smudge on my lower lashes or browbone, but yet delivers on the impact I look for. It’s a staple for me.

Ty for the demos. I've tried both Loreal Age perfect Mascaras, and I like both, but they are too tame for what I want. The Maybelline Sky High original in blackest black is better. It builds really quickly. It's not my beloved discontinued Bite Beauty mascara (for which I haven't found a replacement) But its nice and dramatic without being ott.

Totally agree re Anti Gravity. It has replaced all my high end mascaras.

Try the LA Colors Biggie Lash tubing mascara! I found it at Dollar General for $4.25.

Try the Revlon that's so fierce eyeshadow palette in that's a dub wow wow wow is all I can say

I really like the anti gravity mascara and I have been asked if I’m wearing false eyelashes when I wear this mascara.

Can you share what you are wearing on your lips? Looks really pretty.

Glad you mentioned you were in Georgia bc climate, I believe, has a lot to do with the wear of the mascara.

Great video! I’m def going to try the milani. I love Blinc tubing mascara at least yrs ago! What color is on your nails?

Great video! I'm always looking for mascaras that don't smudge or flake and last all day. I would love to see a best cheap mascaras under $8. Recently I tried one that Jen Phelps recommended the LA Colors biggie lash in the purple tube that's a tubing mascara. It's great and I paid 4.35 for it at Dollar general. It's a tubing mascara but it doesn't remove in the tubes but it removes in a smearing way which is different but fine with me. It's a dry formula that lasts all day and holds curl.

hey! do you think the age perfect mascara would stay put at a concert where I'll be sweating and potentially also crying a bit? lol. looking for a bottom lash mascara that can withstand tears and heat!

Best tubing mascara - Ulta Lash Flash!! Try it if you haven’t.

I didn’t know about Tubing mascara. However, I can’t help but wonder if it’s harder on your lashes. I won’t even wear fake lashes because I don’t want to damage my regular lashes. I like the Milani mascara because it has castor oil in it, which I’ve read is good for hair.

This mascara is my 1st step, then I coat with another mascara.

Have you used essence waterproof mascara?

I love those earrings! Link please?

I really like Flower Beauty mascaras. Big Mood didn't work very well for me. I just didn't like how my lashes looked and the wand was too big for no reason lol. I need to try the Milani. I loved their Highly Rated mascara so I'll probably like this one as well.

Hi beautiful what are your favorite high end mascara? Thank you

I bought my first tubing mascara (the Loreal age perfect) & have some questions! When I apply it, my lashes stick together. How do I seperate them? A spoolie didn't seem to work like it usually would with a regular mascara. How can I do more than one coat when the lashes are already sticking? At the end of the day, how do you remove the mascara? How do I clean up the smudges that always end up on my top lid?

Before watching your video I was going to buy the Tower 28 mascara. Have you ever tried it and if so would you pick the Milani over it?

Could you please recommend some that don't flake?I've tried lash paradise, high sky, cover girl in orange tube, essence one that everyone praises about... all flaked on me after few hrs.😐. I also do like the bit more of a dramatic look /fluttery vs natural.

❤❤❤

What do you use to take waterproof mascara off? I have a few things and they don’t work well.

I kept wondering why your left eyelashes looked so much longer and more volumized and then when you said you had 2 different mascaras on, I was like ohhhhhh!! 😂😂

I’ve been loving the Anti Gravity mascara too! My other favorites are the Maybelline Curl and Bounce and Covergirl Clean Fresh (their waterproof one is good too)

My BF told me the other day..He didn’t like me wearing such long lashes…I said I’m not even wearing fake lashes….I was wearing the Milani Anti-gravity…I only wear two coats 😮😮😮

So the milani anti-gravity is better than Essence lash princess even for as cheap as it is?? I need to know lol.

I have SUPER oily skin. Most mascaras will smudge and flake on me. The waterproof L'Oreal Age Perfect mascara, along with pretty much all the other L'Oreal mascaras are BAD about smudging on me. Maybelline mascaras are the same. I haven't tried Milani. But I've tried most brands. The only brand I have good luck with is CoverGirl. Exhibitionist, Lash Blast Volume, and Lash Blast Clean are fantastic. They will wear for several hours before I notice the first signs of smudging. I don't wear waterproof mascara. I've found that my oily skin acts as a waterproof makeup remover. Does anyone else avoid waterproof mascara like the plague? 😆

Btw I thought you were actually wearing individual false lashes on your left side. Guess what mascara I'm buying 😘

I was wondering what a tubing mascara is!?

i thought the loreal one was discontinued

I thought I hated Big Mood. I don't. I *hate* the wand .

Nothing comes between me and my Lash Princess False Lash Effect. Super lengthening, volumizing and it is super black.

The L’Oréal Age Perfect tubing mascara is not discontinued. I’ve seen ads promoting it, and see it in store not only at Walmart but CVS.