"they are wasting a lot of money on semiconductors...". what a great analysis by this brilliant guy. 😂

Thank you for your concern for China.

德国真的是一个很有意思的国家，自己经济一塌糊涂，还那么关心中国，真的谢谢😂😂天天针对新疆穆斯林那么关心，连上帝都感动，对巴勒斯坦穆斯林，只字不提，挺有意思的。干得漂亮

It's interesting to see how a country would start bashing other nations when it's not going well for them internally. Trying to avert public focus perhaps?

DW shall take more focus on German GDP recession.

Wasting money on war is really better then spend on semiconductor development. 5*

This China expert doesn't seem know much about the Chinese economy. Wasting money on education? Clamp down on gig economy is bad for graduates? DW should get my brother-in-law to predict the Chinese and world economy, at least he own an auditing firm.

Once upon a time, Germany was exporting more to China and importing less. Germany was probably the only country having a trade surplus with China. And now...

A country that was still under strict lockdown last year this time. 300 million+ people locked and couldn't go anywhere but keep burning savings. Surely No damages are made, people forget quickly, and confident in the future that this won't happen again.

Where are the news from ukraine

It's time to take care of Germany instead of worrying about China!

Thank you Germany for always worry about China's economy, however it is now to Worry about yourself.

I don't get it: why do Germans Companies moved or plan to move to China, like BASF and Linde....?

They are doing fine and they are growing, its just that they are not growing as they grew last year, they are still growing more than US and EU economy.

Western analysists are usually speculative.Chinese leadership is among the brighest minds in the world.The fear by western companies is how to sustain their market share in China.

What you should be concerned about is how Germany can break free from American control!

It won't go 10% a year, but it's still going 5% a year, which developed countries don't even come close.

DW News Very interesting to hear “a drowning man teaching others how to swim “😢

Germany admin need distraction till polling improve. But with N$tream bxmb , U$A has been very $uccessful in de$indu$trialize$ EU .

Why DW doesnt report on whether Germany can get on a new economic growing path 😂

Meanwhile Germany and the EU economies are tanking

amazon of china, uber of china, chinese expert cannot even properly name such big chinese corporation.

China's next goal is to localize machines and their components for manufacturing mobile phones, cars, yachts, airplanes, and semiconductors

Irony that the US is willing to bail out big failing companies in the last financial crisis and China is letting property companies fail. So who is capitalist and who is socialist?

Sept PMI：Germany, 46.4; China, 50.2; Global, 48.7. 😂

So a report on China is talking about China, but not to China.

For those who invest/want to invest in emerging markets: just remember that economy performance does not translate into stock makret performance.

Thanks for the insight 👍

Not discussed: domestic consumption. China’s domestic rate is about 35%. This is about 20 percentage points lower than comparable economies. It’s low because the CCP has used a policy of underpaying manufacturing workers, and giving them a lot of state subsidies, in order to make their manufacturing sector the most competitive in the world. This has allowed a large trade surplus, which was used for infrastructure development. So, because demand has dropped significantly for Chinese exports, it’s near impossible to raise wages of workers, which would be the easiest way to increase domestic consumption. Because the CCP is so heavily dependent upon a large trade surplus - for many reasons - it appears that the Chinese economy is in a doom loop of lower exports, a smaller trade surplus, and more unemployment. The only way is through the Chinese dependence upon the trade surplus.

The EU is failing hard, only accelerated by Brexit, it's GDP is now smaller than China, DW as a EU mouthpiece will find any negative spin on China

5.3% Growth, enough said

Maybe tech will keep afloat

question is when or how soon

Putting aside that China is not a democracy but her leaderships team is selected based on Meritocracy. These chinese leaders tend to be educated in the fields of sciences and engineering. They will then be selected to govern backwater or impoverished villages and given a target to achieved. From there these leaders will be pruned or promoted to higher rank based on what they have achieved. So these folks are selected based on competency and pragmatism......unfortunately they are in general(mostly) not good in the arts of rhetorical skills unlike their western counterparts.

Kate with the best questions as always. Also looking incredible, as always.

Germany should better expect China's economic growth, cuz that will be the only good news for the shrinking German economy.

If you are going to put a report out on china, be a little more professional and put a reporter who can actually google how to PRONOUNCE the names somewhat correctly like the interviewee

The size of an economy ultimately depends on the purchasing needs of most consumers in that economy. With their work ability, that is, how smart they are. As long as there is demand, there will be a market. As long as there is a market, there will be enterprises and jobs, so growth. The slow growth in developed country is because most consumers have basically met their material needs. Without further demand, there will be no economic growth, and you cannot make robots have demand. Half of China's population is far from meeting the material needs, when it comes to smartphones, televisions, cars, and tourism. So China will continue to grow until the majority of people's consumption needs are met. Those problems are all minor ones. Will eventually overcome over time.

Chinas growth was 3% for 2022 and has an expected growth of 5.2% for 2023. Great work China 👍

Western world should focus their economy health

Yes

How’s Europe doing?

China has slowdown in economy but surrounded with energy rich countries will be able to survive. Europe lost Russia as a cheap source of commodities, oil, gas.

No. Not while Xi’s in charge.

Nowdays there are more economic experts in comment section than in video that's why I only read comments to measure the seriousness of topics just it should be bot free environment

Germany worried about China??😂

😅😅😅 is this the best guy you have got to analyze what is going on in China? All I m hearing is Xi, Xi , Xi as if Xi control everything without experts opinion. As usual we expect this from this guy if you have followed him.

China is good in Trade & Construction . When the US is waging wars around the world & created a lot of Destruction , economic growth path of China will not be too bad , so long as the US & China are not going to war directly .

Is 5.5% growth not good for you? Germany is in recession and becoming miserable.

Andrew Collier bringing the sass

I answer your internet question: No.

Property bubble cannot be attributed to the current leadership? It’s been there for more than 10 years, no?

Do you think the Chinese government will bail out the developers and investors (some of whom are foreigners) on its real property sector?

New paths require at their very base new thinking. Without question the largest hurdle the ccp faces so ironically is it's very own dogma for which allows no wiggle room for an admission of failure. Now that may not seem like much until you disect it and come to the understanding that a new path, in other words, a new logic of thinking, a new idea must at its very beginnings come from a recognition that if a new path is required, the old path was incorrect which brings us back to, the party is always correct and for all intent and purpose.. a standoff. Simple logics do carry at times significant worth but, if they are so etched to stone as to be static and not dynamic then, that tool is no longer relevant and that said simple logic so too is inversely effective as to become an impediment rather than a policy that could be built upon had it been more fluid. I give you the Soviet Unions very own five year plan, carved in stone as a static playbook irreversable by decree in a dynamic environment and ultimately one of the most weighted reasons for their failure. So, yes, barring an enlightened despot among them brave enough to change course, China is screwed....by themselves.

What's next for China ? Growth rates higher than those seen in Europe and USA ofcourse. What else do you expect? 😂 Every now and then the growth rate would drop down to 4+pc so you could stress up on their behalf because that's what ya'll like to do. 😊

getting rid of youth unemployment figures doesn't help and too many people have invested in housing in China tbh i don't think anything will change in 2024

In 2023, which country perform (in dgp volume, not gdp growth) better than China?

The world would have been a much better place, if everybody could and can mind its own damn business, instead of sticking its nose into other's business.

DW should focus on getting speakers to talk on Germany, why bother on China, not your business. The Chinese will overcome their own problems, I do not accept these DW so called experts who knows what from reading other analysts but not on the ground, living in, China.

I think u should ask..what next to German? It's German is more concern about china then German itself?

You cant bring a 5000- year civilization just like that. Think harder.

What does he know, REALLy, what does she know, what do we/ i know, unless we were in there in the meeting......????

Lets hope not! 😂😂😂

China cannot have high growth unless the world has high growth which demands its exports. Germany should understand this as its car exports fall when world goes into recession.

As a Chinese, I like Germany.

Global meth variable is xin real tho...number crunch?! pay diplomat here

Don't underestimate the right of these little emperors who had been spoil rotten growing up by 2 parents + 4 grandparents. They have grown up and found them not just unwilling, but also unable to work. The market isn't going to spoon feed them. These little emperors have to earn their salaries.

Strange similarities in rhetorics about behemoths. US has antitrust laws, or used to have, that breaks down monopolies that spawns many smaller innovative companies. Are there serious difference in what China do and antitrust? What China needs is to restore confidence in spending post COVID and encourage small and medium businesses. Are those millions of youths doing social streaming counted as employment? For instance.

By talking down about others, hopefully, German will have higher grounds. Worry about your own problems !

U can’t keep feeding drugs to druggies and hope for the best, some difficult decisions ought to be made and pain needs to be felt in order to grow

Worry more about the west & other countries . Worry less about China . Lee W Chiang is like all other standing committee member who are all properly promoted to help build China . They are all possessing enormous support & love

Economic investigator Frank G Melbourne Australia is still watching this very informative content cheers Frank as subscriber 😊

another growth path instead of just growing a merely 5% each year?

61 trillion dollars! are you talking about the US or China? Why use dollars which is foreign in China. This is bad, how US guys always compare other countries with their fallen and sleeping economy.

We talking about China. Let us call an expert from Europe to give assessment. Are there no Chinese Economist around? I need unbiased opinion. He said XI is dictator. When has Chinese president not been a dictator, unless I was in a coma.

A 18 trillion economy with GDP growth expected to be 5% in 2023 not good enough? How does it compare with the US and the rest of the developed world? Recent US 3rd Qtr GDP of 4.9% was cause for celebration but it resulted in gloom and boom instead from most of the analysts because they are skeptical of the GDP number. US GDP growth is mainly funded by debts and in spite of that, it is not even half that of China...

Many times i found myself thinking, what's happening here?? You are trying to figure out what's happening behind closed doors that will never come out at all. Why waste so much time doing this 🤦. And for a channel that can easily travel to China and actually see for yourself what's going on around the country and how it's people are reacting to current economic challenges. Which of course are there, only much better than most people in USA and Europe. That's what I so,it might change in future. But that was not the case right now.

China's economy is really bad, as it's GDP is expected to grow by 5% in 2023. Its exports to EU countries are not doing good either. FDIs from Europe into China are dropping as well.

Why doesn't Deutsche Welle criticize the United States? Is America your father?😅

Chinese bots in the comments. Enjoy the show 🍿

No, they cant. The current crisis is the result of both old mistakes (Mao destroyed the demographics of the nation and there's no correcting it now) and Xi's agressive deliberalization of both chinese society and economy. Since the first thing he did when he became leader was purging the very people who put him in power (the Xiaoping and Zemin factions), there is literally no one to stop him at this point. He's basically ruling alone, and his vision for the future of China is clearly about expension and world dominance, not cooperation with the West. And germany is supporting it all by making more and more deals with this psychopath, so thanks again Germany. Russian gas and now this, I cant help but feel there is a trend developing here.

Where did she pull that one out of five number on youth unemployment? They were close to 75% unemployment and that only counts cities. It got so bad that they stopped publishing the data.

Hmmmm...

Why are they interviewing this guy who is quite clearly uninformed? China has already quite clearly articulated what their long term, mid term and short term goals are and have put in place pretty clear policy guidance. They review this every year and keep tweaking the actual implementations as new challenges as well as opportunities present themselves.

Main difference of the Chinese economy and the West is that China knows its limitation and willing to learn from mistakes. I invest in China because it has one quality that the West (EU, UK, USA etc.) has not. It is the willingness and ability to recognize mistakes, admit them and immediately apply remedy.

We don’t know whether China can get on anew growth path or not. But we do know they are much better off than Germany. They have secured cheap Russian gas and oil, Belt and Road projects provides markets for their products. They are using the German model which Germany no longer has.

Can germany get on a new economic growth path?

western experts are funny, they know everything about china without going there to see , feel or hear..The experts in China are sitting together trying to find the right solutions.BTW good luck to the German economy, they need it.

No. That answers your thumbnail question. That country is on a STEEP slip down, and it’s going down hard and fast.

Now that American companies have withdrawn from China, it is extremely hard for China to get back into the manufacturing dominance of the world .

Not for a long time. A Positive image and trust are hard to gain, even harder to regain, and the Chinese society is not as simple as it once was, relying more on things that will now fall apart, plus the demographic challenges are only starting to kick in. Without some major event, geopolitical shift or technological breakthrough, Chinas suffering will only get worse for the next 1-2 decades.

Ask ccp

Do you know what language is spoken in outer space? Hint: Not English or Hindustani

DW should get a better China analyst than this Buffon, who has not been to China but airing his opinion. China’s economy is still growing and expected to grow 5.2% this year which is on a $18.5 trillion GDP. Where on earth any country has that growth this year. Yes it has challenges and it could have grown much faster had it not been for the slow down in European and US market . There is a problem in real estate if someone had invested in third tier cities, but first tier cities and second tier cities the property prices are resilient, you gave 10% discount, it will be snapped up in minutes. The local government has still huge restrictions on buying properties in first and second tier tier cities. If those restrictions are lifted people will buy. Stats to think about, there are 1 billion Chinese still living under USD 400/ month, imagine the potential here. Even if China is growing at 3% per year which is slow by China’s standards and if India is growing at 6% still the difference of growth in India and China is more than EU in the next 3 years. Let those numbers sink in before you bring such buffoons to talk in your show.

People are happy in China 😂😂😂😂

winnie the pooh only knows how eat and eat

China will ghet there no doubt. One of ther many reason ? Even VW (Volkswagen) is going to buy China EV's and going to rebadge/rebrand them for European market! That's how far the Chinese are in EV tech. that's just one industry.

Chinese power 💪👏 no1

It can, can Germany?

😂😂😂