This song is so hauntingly beautiful.

"We make harder than it has to be" -- so true. RIP Glenn Frey. This was a classic fav of mine. Thank you, God rest your soul in peace now.

2024 ans still listening to this. Absolute perfection.

Anyone 2024??

Who's still listening right now

The Eagles are such a big inspiration to me.

Jan,2024. Still listening❤

I've been learning guitar for two years now and have been practicing this song. I love this song so I'm very happy. I'll do my best.

As a 17 year old I love the 80's music. far far better. Still digging

"Eagles"-----I can't tell you why. This has to be the very best of The Eagles.

One of the biggest underrated hits ever! Love The Eagles! This song will live forever!

They don't make them like this anymore..The Eagles such monumental talent..LOVE THIS TUNE TOO MUCH

I'm 60..still listening to the Eagles since my teenage, high school years of the 70s..😁😁.. a masterpiece of the Eagles.. relaxing song with soul and meaningful lyrics..

Rest in peace Glen Frey....thanks for the music. 1/18/2016

Any other Gen Z boys loving this shit? Dad showed it to me a few years ago and I always come back, wish more people my age were willing to appreciate classic rock like this, supertramp, queen, dire straits, ELO etc. such amazing music was made than, hip hop is my #1 love but classic rock will always be a second and hold a special place in my heart.

One of the most beautiful song of I Can't Tell You Why.. EAGLES ♥️🧡💛🖤💜💙💚❤️❤️💚💙💜🖤💛🧡♥️

Rock the Heavens Glenn Frey! R.I.P.

a medical doctor in his early 50s here. so much stress at work with covid 19. the only thing that is relaxing me is escapism into the rock classics of 70s and 80s. peace.

I’m listening to this song right now

That' s me listening to this wonderful song in 2024 ...It reminds me my first love...I remember he likes Eagles...Where are you now? Haven't seen you in latest years...I hope you're alright... Certain kinds of love do never end...❤

If you’re listening to this you have great taste in music!

One of the best guitar work ever ...

It's an amazing voice. I hear it since last 40 years. Beautiful composed and outstanding performance. Eagles bass player Timothy B Schmit sang lead and was the primary songwriter on this track.

Timeless classic from 1979. Everything is just damn perfect and brilliant!😊

This is music you listen to when alone in the darkness on a cold night and thinking about what to do with your life

this song is a heartbreaker.....just read the bad news that Glen Frey has passed......God rest his soul.....very sad.....

Its June 28th 2024 Eastern Timezone and I am listening to this great classic! :)

This just popped into my head and just slung me back into my childhood days. A time when music deserved the right to be called music. 2023 and this still holds it's power and beauty.

Ironically my favorite Eagles song features one of the rare tracks Timothy B Schmit was given lead vocals on. His voice is terrific here. Love Don's drumbeat with the organ/synthesizer playing opposite that awesome guitar solo to fade out. It sounds even more delicious with your headphones

Beautiful voice, massive guitar solo , smooth keyboard,relaxing beat ..

Definitely my favorite Eagles song! Between the silky smooth voice of Mr. Schmit and the equally smooth outro.......perfection!

Everything about this song so is perfect. The lyrics, the music, Timothy's voice, oh, and that guitar solo at the end. My word 🤤

I was listening to this beautiful song while driving my car to a very beautiful place with rain pouring heavily.

I just watched two interviews with Glenn Frey; what a humble, noble man. I somehow expected Glenn to be arrogant because of all the amazing talent, but I was so wrong about him. His music is timeless and listening to this song brings back so many memories for me. He was the best of the Eagles in my opinion. RIP: Loved One.

I was born in 1965. I grew up with this . Favourite years of music are seventies, eighties and nineties. So yes i Listen . ❤

One of their best song's ever and I can't tell you why 💙❤️

Had the pleasure of listening to Timothy Bruce Schmit sing this live in Dublin last night. Pure bliss!

I am spending the day listening to Eagles songs. A day well spent.

Look at us baby, up all night Tearing our love apart Aren't we the same two people Who lived through years in the dark? Aha Every time I try to walk away Something makes me turn around and stay And I can't tell you why When we get crazy, it just ain't right (Try to keep your head, little girl) Girl, I get lonely too You don't have to worry, just hold on tight (Don't get caught in your little world) Cause I love you Nothing's wrong as far as I can see We make it harder than it has to be And I can't tell you why No baby, I can't tell you why I can't tell you why Every time I try to walk away Something makes me turn around and stay And I can't tell you why No, no baby, I can't tell you why I can't tell you why I can't tell you why, no

THE best Eagles song ❤

One of the most beautiful songs, I have ever heard in my entire life!

Such beautiful song, and the lead guitarist, all I can say is Wow

Whenever I listen to this song, I think of the old atmosphere that I used to be fascinated with in each song that has been carefully crafted until it resonates with the world and is a song that is in the memory of each and every new generation who listens to it.

Sin duda la mejor canción de Eagles, es una obra maestra, dopamina al 100%.

THIS SONG NEVER GETS OLD !! THANK YOU EAGLES

Good music will always be good music. Imagine a young man in a couple of centuries rediscovering this song and listening to it for the first time, feeling the same we felt

so sweet ..... so naive ....... another true masterpiece by Eagles !

Who's listening now?

people who came across this song are lucky because its a masterpiece.

Hermoso recuerdo de Oro, The Eagles ☺️☺️👍👍

una de las mejores canciones de este grupo, mi favorita, tenia 18 años cuando formo parte de mi colección, siempre la escucho, me trae buenos recuerdos, y sigo con mi compañera de todas la vida. la he bailado muchas veces con mi amada esposa.

Im 19 yrs old but im a millenial fan i like eagles a lot because my father introduce me to eagles and now im a fanboy sorry for my english im a filipino

And this is 1980 ? Unbelievable... it's timeless!

This song also never gets old❤love this song so much 💟

Chillin in Punta Cana, surrounded by the ocean waves, and pools on a beautiful breezy night, listening to this amazing song. Life is good.

This song is SO well done, hard to describe, you gotta feel it.

I discovered this 3 years ago. If you don’t feel this in every fiber of your body then I feel sorry for you. What a masterpiece. Thanks to everyone involved.

Привет, друзья! Впервые услышал ИГЛЗ с их Отелем Калифорния школьником, но как-то не проняло, пластинка 79-го расставило всё на свои места-супер!! Нрвится всё! Мало, блин, выпустили! И сейчас, мне 60 лет, когда обновляю свою технику и колонки в первую очередь ставлю ИГЛЗ-как звучит!

I first heard this song from my father. My father was a legend 🦅🦅

Look at us baby, up all night Tearing our love apart Aren't we the same two people Who lived through years in the dark? Every time I try to walk away Something makes me turn around and stay And I can't tell you why When we get crazy, it just ain't right (Try to keep your head, little girl) Girl, I get lonely too You don't have to worry, just hold on tight (Don't get caught in your little world) Cause I love you Nothing's wrong as far as I can see We make it harder than it has to be And I can't tell you why No baby, I can't tell you why I can't tell you why 🎸🎸🎸 Every time I try to walk away Something makes me turn around and stay And I can't tell you why No, no baby, I can't tell you why I can't tell you why I can't tell you why, no

Still listening & love this song even if i don't know what is love anymore...🖤🖤

I am an old soldier of the Foreign Legion (France) and I love this song and all these American singers ! God save America ! 👊

Desde mi juventud,es un himno a escuchar con el corazón, tengo 59 años y es como si tuviera mi juventud otra vez

This is my favourite track by the Eagles. I love everything about it. A timeless classic.🇬🇧

09Feb2022. Who's still enjoying this song?

Purely lovable song of Timothy B. Smith, I love this song since it was released from the Eagles.🌻🌻🌻♥️

Tracks like this probably ensure that like today, they will always outsell any other group in US history - truly sublime writing and recording.

Like an echo of the past, my mind slips back to a moment. That rogue of a boy, with big feet and refer smoke in too long hair. Holding the girl so close, savoring her warmth and the scent of her perfume. The lights flicker in her eyes, her lips covered in cherry lip gloss. She smiles, the music fades all too soon and...

The Eagles 🦅. I Can’t Tell You Why. What a fantastic band they were. I still listen to all their songs. Great memories from a long time ago. Perhaps, we’ll pass that way again sometime soon. Here’s hoping so. We need something to believe in now more than ever. There’s nothing like great music from the past and re-living that time once again. Total pleasure ….. Mmm 😋

The guitar play by Don Felder is just awesome! I listen to this and pretend I am he! I am 66 years old...And a female!😅

Still listening to great Eagles music ❤❤❤

Good music doesn’t have an expiration date. This will live on forever!

I strongly believe that as a kid growing up in this era with songs like this was a blessing

Simply...a classic tune...love it...timeless

This song connected me and the Missus to 40 yrs now and still love her soooooo much.

Eagles- I cant tell you Why is one of my favourite tracks from a long time ago but still holds great memories for me. Theres just something about this tune which makes me want to hear it again. Sometimes legends never go away.

Perfect, They just don't make quality music like this anymore

Never tired of this magical song. 😊❤👏

Probably the best song they did.

So beautifull still..this jewel will never age.

I was 17 when this was released so I’ve been listening to this for 40 years. Never gets old. One of my favourite all time songs❤️

Voz increíble del Sr. Timothy Schmit

I really like this song 🎵

C'è una sensualità in questo brano che può portarti dove vuole... Mitici e senza tempo ❤️🎶

you know a song is timeless when you see people commenting “who’s still listening to this in 20XX”

Yes, 2024....wonderful song❤

A banda Eagles é fabulosa, essa música beira a perfeição, melhor que Hotel Califórnia, solo magnífico!

my favorite by The Eagles RIP Glenn

Once in a lifetime track, words can't begin to describe it.

That riff at the end of the song.... timeless!!!

Old is gold Just want to listen while driving Now a days such songs composition lyrics poetry new bands don't know.

Thanks to my father. I have a good taste in music.

Saw the eagles in concert at Wembley stadium london england in june 1976 !! The line up that day was elton John the beach boys the eagles joe walsh band one magical day of music !!! The Eagles more than held their own that day great band great concert !!! Keep rockin folks keep safe keep strong love and peace y all !!!

Great tune by one of the greatest bands of all time SO TALENT

Yes, I'm still listening this song

Just amazing how every member of this band is a recording artist in thier own right. All time favorites.

My favorite song of all the music in the world ever made still listening to it every day and never gets old for me 2020 December

Perfect falsetto of its kind. Reminds me of my dear friends who passed away living in peace ... this song feels like heaven with them. ✌️❤️🙏😎

This song says it all .. nothing more to add

Wow Love Love Love this classic song... anyone in lockdown may 2020 still Lovin this classic song.... please please stay safe ppl.... Love From The U.K. ♥️♥️🇬🇧🇬🇧