That giant step from proficiency to artistry is a Big One indeed!

These young folks are lucky to have Renee listening and coaching them. Wish I could have great Renee as my voice coach. Renee is smart teacher and beautiful Soprano.

Ms. Fleming is naturally astude at giving Singers a "Teachers" recommendation whether future Professionals, Chorus, or Choir Singers. She Understands the Importance of relating Technicality & Musicality. So necessary as a Musician or Singer. That makes the difference between just Playing or Singing the Notes versus The Joy! Absolute Wonderful experience hearing her Master Class. D'ette K.Matthews

Wonderful singers!!!! I love Renee Fleming in coaching she is Amazing.

that last bit with the q & a was so open and honest from Renee, with all the wonderful tips she gave based on her experience, she's so humble, lovely and generous in sharing all that!

👍👍👍👍👍👍🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

Amanda particularly sounded so much better after so little working time!

The last girl has such a beautiful voice!!!

The second singer is a quick learner! Beautiful voice!!!

Does anyone know the video Ms.Fleming mentioned around 50:55 on youtube? cause I can't find it anywhere.

I've watched several of Ms. Fleming's Masterclasses where she has come off as being cold and uncompassionate when in fact, she's being objective and real. These videos aren't just for the particular student but present and future students who'll never have the honor of ever seeing Rene Fleming. Frankly, not necessarily in this instance, but having watched A LOT of these Masterclass videos I question what kind of education some of these supposed awesome music schools are giving. Seems like they're blowing smoke up their students to sustain enrollment. It's must be bad when I'm grimacing listening to a performance.

First one could use more expression and dynamic . Great job tho

I love how the accompanist is introduced and they say *we* will be performing… I hope that becomes the norm. That first girl took zero direction at all. What a waste.

If this is vocal pedagogue we are f-Ed.

The voice is white and edgy. Chest breathing is evident. The directions she is given are a disconnected ramble of nonsense, abstract words that cannot be connected to any actions that have anything to do with vibrating vocal cords. A serious lack of understanding of vocal physiology is evident with this mish mash of vague directions. It all will end up in nothing and certainly will not,improve this singers voice.