That moment when you find out that your favorite band of all time covered one of your favorite tunes of all time and the video was directed by your favorite director of all time. And you didn't know it for like 20 years. Brain melt cry face.

I am sitting here with tears streaming down my face and then...wonder of wonders, there are people who have left comments that make me feel like I'm not the only living girl on the internet. Thank you.

Great cover version and the video has EBTG and Hal Hartley written all over it. They work well together. Can't get better than this really.

beautiful. They kept to the addictive harmonies of Simon & Garfunkels original, with just as much soul.

Is it just me or are Watt and Thorn the sweetest people on earth?

a true joy of a song

El dia que descubri esta canción.. algo cambio.

thank u so much ! I really love this video. the idea that singing with their mouth closed is wonderful.

LOVELY

you've got me trying to think of other decent covers now.. all i've got so far is thin lizzy - whiskey , i'm sure there are more .i love this tune and all ebtg stuff . prob my fav is the 25th of december track

I reckon this is the ONLY cover that is better than the original!

i am a sucker for critisizing cover versions, normally i will slag them off as a cheap way to get into the charts, being fucking bone idle to not bother writing your own tune, just copy someone else's. but in my opinion this is one of those rare occasions were the whole song is an honest homage to the people who wrote it, simon and garfunkle. well done everything but the girl. a really decent bunch of talented musicians.

They've done some good covers, They're my favourate group I have loved all their incarnations! from acoustic to clubby to chill out!

Class.

Thanks for posting one of my favourate songs and a great cover!

beautiful cover... and God Ben looks cute here :-)

EXCELLENT

precioso

This may sound dumb,but here goes.I used to have a copy of a Tracie Thorn solo album.I cannot remember the name of it for the life in me.I hope it isn't just called Tracie Thorn

soooo good, love it....

It took me 4 years but I agree with you 100% Fuck it ! Im going with 200%

probably because he is! haha

Was Ben Watt chewing gum?

@NeverSayNeverToAlway But it's not identical. The vocal arrangement is totally different.

@NeverSayNeverToAlway No you're actually wrong. Listen carefully, there are indeed differences.

Great use of sign language

Yeah, but that is probably only because of the video, which - admittedly - seems a bit too conceived. Suggestion: Close your eyes and just listen to the song.

A Car crash

Generally a very nice cover. They have nice voices, etc., but I thought the harmony drowned the melody in a couple of places, unfortunately in some of my favorite places. Not so emotionally compelling as the original S & G recording. Also, loses some of the impact of the original's fabulous bass part, although this one seems to be the same notes, at least most of the time.

I really hate this. And I love Simon and Garfunkel. It;'s the smartness of this I dislike