The 1,000 damage from him landing star power needs to be part of his base ability like what they did with Mr P, and Brock. Also it’s not about his super. Yes he needs to get in close and I think the trait will help in 3v3 but people know how to avoid Edgar most times now I think. He needs survivability. It’s why his second gadget is best. Don’t take away his life leach. It’s a unique mechanic. But he does need more health or damage in my opinion. So many new brawlers that can deal massive damage and have so much health Edgar is just leaving behind stats wise.

Really interesting rework but life leech was one of the the overpowered things about Edgar because of how he abused robo rumble against the big bot ; when the big bot attacks he uses shield gadget, when it sends misses, he uses super and heals. The evasion trait is interesting, enemies projectiles or attacks? Does poison clouds or any kind of damage count? Waiting for that rework!

Edgar is actually a worst epic brawler in this game like he's so toxic and it's not that easy to kill brawler with edgar. Finally edgar getting rework. I think brawl stars will release that concept! That's great idea!

Since December of last year, it seems that Edgar needs a remake, so I've been thinking about the remake plan of the Brawler like this. • HP increased from 2800(lv.1)/4200(lv.11) to 3200(lv.1)/4800(lv.11) • Lifesteal of normal attacks reduced from 35%→25% • Normal attack rate of fire increased from 0.2 sec→0.4 sec • Reload speed of normal attacks increased from 0.7 sec→0.8 sec • Normal attack range increased from 2 tiles to 2.67 tiles • Increases the bullet speed of normal attacks by 12.5%​​(3500→4000) • The speed at which special attacks are automatically recharged is reduced by 33%(30 sec→20 sec). • When using a special attack, it deals 800(lv.1)/1200(lv.11) damage in a range of 2.67 tiles and charges 12% of the special attack gauge on hit (partially passive of 'Hard Landing' star power) • Star Power 'Hard landing' changed to 'Vaultage' Effect: Increases the range, charge speed, and movement speed increase of Edgar's special attack by 12.5%. • Gadget 'Hardcore' HP and duration increased from 2000→2400/10s→20s • Gadget 'Let's Fly' changed to 'Resistance Scarf' Effect: Increases movement and attack speed by 25% for 4 seconds when used, and all interfering effects (knockback, attack power down, healing reduction, stun, slow movement) except for BiBi's normal hit knockback and Crow, Byron's normal hit dot damage, and Gale's special attack etc.) instead of ignoring most CCs), the self-heal function of the normal hit is reduced by 75%. (You can use gadgets while using special attacks.) While not changing too much from the existing Edgar concept like any other brawler (especially users who want a remake of Edgar, there is also a reaction that lifesteal should be maintained as a unique characteristic). I've done my own rework, of course all the other mechanics are awkward, but the Scarf lock gadget seems like a really good idea.

I feel like the life leech is needed, as it really is the difference when you don’t exactly make up all the distance with your super, and it can make you lose more easily against brawlers like surge and buzz.

Imagine edgar using evasion mechanism against 8-bit's 18 shots gadget😂😂😂😂

Idk how i feel about it, cause his coolest thing is the life leech and if it gets removed he’s not really that unique anymore

Edgar rework is needed, he's a high dps brawler but the fact he has to rely on his super puts him at a disadvantage so i think the evasion mechanic would be good and he'd be able to participate more in some modes because of it...thanks cryingman for a new video, can't wait for stu guide 🌸

(there are 2 edits, so tldr is up till the 1st edit) I like the Edgar rework idea. How about: Super Bar, instead of Super button? So that a player can jump based on the ammount of charge Max Charge = Max distance. A star power like the double jump concept... I think works best with this. So, the star power would reduce the ammount of charge consumed by 50% to reach max distance. Meaning you get to use two full Jumps at Max Bar. But you don't need full super to use it. Instead you hold it and calculate distance based on super charge. Edit 2: May be a handful. Big Big Edit. Ive been thinking about my comment. So, i Gave it a thought. There could be one or two things in place... But i will Elaborate. So were trying to keep it within the games current rules and controller. With that in mind. The Scarf thing i mentioned. Could work similarly to that of Janet. If you hold the Shoot button for like 2 ~ 3 seconds, it will become a Long shot that consumes 2 Ammo and does damage equivalent for 1 of Edgars ammo. (utility over damage) And for some Gadget or star power make it a Grapple that allows edgar to either pull enemies or Get himself closer to enemies (maybe for edgars consideration, he gains ONE ammo back immediatelly if he connects) Considering edgar gets good reload speed. This wouldnt be too harsh on him. By the time hes punch flurrying, he has 2 ammo again. And only hurts if he pulls like... A shelly. Could also be used as a star power/gadget to have like a Buzz anchor to pull himself towards them. As for the Super Bar, given that they want to do the DODGE thing. (Graze. For touhou fans, anyone else?) So. That being Edgars new Super charge method along with Doing damage. I believe the JUMP bar would be better. However. It troubles me on how to balance it, cause in itself movement is INSANELY STRONG... but on the damage side. If he can only K. O. low-Mid to squishy brawlers.... Then he would remain pretty low. So i thought. Maybe Jumping while he holds certain ammount of super Gives him a few extra Amps for 2 to 4 seconds. Like 1/4 gives him a 1500 shield/or/ 40% damage reduction. 2/4 increased Speed by 8% on top of shield. Full bar to do the Additional 1000 Damage on area. And that threshold would change with the Idea of the star power that reduces the ammount of super bar Needed (so that he has 2 Full Jumps) Considering Healing to be gone... Well i dunno. They could keep the healing since reworking the star powers would mean that theres no Extra Healing. Incorporating at least the extra damage as a PERK to A Full super as sugested. And scraping Only the EXTRA healing. That leaves with the grapple thing being a Gadget. (and i preffer it to be a gadget to be honest. But, beggars cant be choosers) Shield Gadget is fine if you ask me. But maybe a SECOND gadget idea could be the Opossite of Pippers. Given that Piper gets a Tracking Shot. Edgar could get a Deviation Barrier. Reduces Damage by 10% and adds some Deviation to directed Shots for 5 seconds, that Add to edgars Bullet Gracing for Super charge to try andalter some shots similar to Colts/rico/piper.... But wouldnt matter on area effects, throws... So thats why maybe Added resistance of 10% sounds Decent. If you read this edit and liked the idea. THANKS. Im actually happy that people thinks its a decent idea. Maybe unbalanced, most certainly, but i think it would be fun.

Evasion is epic, but I dislike the idea of removing his life leech, it's what he is. However I would love supercell if they decided to make his unload time longer, so he doesn't destroy a low hp brawler with no problems.

I think his hard landing star power should be his main power 1 super. I think they should remove hard landing and replace it like he heals 300 health per secound after his super for 5 secs

Awe man, boss fights gonna be impossible without life leech🥺

My suggestions: 1. New trait: Berserk -Edgar can charge his super over time like usual, but the lower his HP, the faster the charge rate 2. New trait: Meditation -Edgar heals 10% of his health every 10 seconds 3. Gadget Rework: Absorb -For the next 7.5 seconds when Edgar takes damage, it will charge his super by 15% 4. Gadget Rework: Power Jump -The next super used will gain 20% more range, and if any enemy is near Edgar when he lands, they will be slowed down for 4.5 seconds 5. Star Power Rework: First Blood -Edgar gets his super fully charged at the start of the game 6. Attack Rework -Edgar's attack is slightly decreased, but he will have three punches instead of two (Total damage will be slightly increased)

Your are my favorite brawl stars content creator, your videos are amazing. Keep up the good work.

I know its an old video but I wanna share my opinion: edgar is my favourite brawler, yes im aware about the fact that he's the worst brawler and im really sad about that because he has so much potential, im also a little mad with supercell for nerfing him so much, if he wasn't nerfed that much he could've still been playable. I hope he will get reworked soon so I can use him after a very long time

Edgar only works in SD and on maps where there are bushes, but in open fields it is lousy.

Edgar is good at boss events

i think that another rework idea added to these could be: - the star power for the jump becomes permanent. (so the idea of ​​star power in the video would be added instead) - With the evasion thing, the jump gadget would no longer be necessary, so that other gadget from the video could be added. - It would be interesting if it had a bar, which, when charged with time or number of attacks, causes an effect on the next attack. The effects I can think of is that the next hit with the charged bar can destroy a square of wall, bush or fence; and the other effect could be that, like Fang, he has his own version of a "longer" distance attack, it could be the shock wave of his punches or his scarf, in both cases it could double the range he already has or add 50% to it, So it remains as a short-medium attack range brawler. These last effects could be an addition to the other stellar that increases the percentage of healing when attacking.

hit insane 16 while u can guys, cuz after his life steal gone, no one can replace him in boss fight

edgar rework idea can be like him getting his gadget shield while he uses his super and the gadget should be change to be something more fun...

I think that the first star power should be part of the brawler, and that they also make an improvement in their health

As someone who plays Edgar, I find it really difficult to kill most brawlers as they have a way to defend themselves from Edgar. I really hope they add this because it would make Edgar different and much better

Also a buff idea is a starpower that if Edgar uses super he will be immune to stun slow and knockback for 3 seconds

ideas edgar keeps all his current abilities (i wount find him any more fun to play if they were removed) evasion will be a unique gear for edgar (in brawl talk they said some brawlers will have a unique gear) hard landing will be built in fisticuffs will increase his total lifeleech to 50% total healing without fisticuffs should be buffed to 40% hard landing should be reworked from dealing damage on landing with super to (For 4 seconds after using his Super, Edgar can jump back to his original position) so that people wont only use fisticuffs. hardcore now also gives a 2 second immunity from knockbacks, stuns and slows hp at power 1 should be buffed to 3100 main attack range should be increased by 1 tile super range should be increased by 1.5 tiles main attack damage at power 1 should be increased to 570 time taken to charge super decreased to 20 seconds idk if this will be broken or not :/

i think that the dodge ability would be enough. i dont like removing the heal or changing his super. also, the 2 super idea is good

4:48 edgar in the nutshell

Just do not take away the life leech trait because it helps him heal when he is on low hp

Imo edgar is not bad in showdown just like cryingman said but we don't have competitive showdown and we probably won't , due to this we only have competitive 3v3 and literally ever other brawler is at least viable in some maps but not edgar since his mechanics essentially make him for of a solo type of gameplay

I feel like they just need to rework him entirely. Maybe have a mechanic where his scarf stretches out even longer so he has more range. But maybe don’t make it too often. Similar to fangs flying show. They probably just need to rebuild him from the ground up and do something more severe to him than what was done to penny

I think the rework idea was cool but one thing I don't agree is that the heals he get from basic attack is going to removed. Because imo what makes edgar fun to play is the heals he get from his attack 😄

My rework for him: -Heal per hit: from 35% to 30% 2nd Star Power Bonus: 25% to 100+ (no longer a percentage, and wouldn't be boosted by force cubes either) 1st Star Power will be passive, dealing up to 900 damage at Level 11 1st star power: It will be called "Good launch", with it, when aiming your super, a yellow bar will begin to charge for 3 seconds, when it fills, you will deal up to 100% extra damage with the super. If the bar isnt filled, the extra damage will be less -Your 1st gadget will charge you +350% for 8 seconds (was +525% for 4 seconds) -His shield will start to lose health on taking damage, rather than instantly -His HP from 2800 to 2900

That music at the end was so cool and fitting

Great video, I have a simpler idea of ​​rework. Rework on the first accessory, instead of reloading the super, the accessory now gives a dash forward, a little smaller than Mortis' super dash. It also buffs health to 4500 at level 11, increases the duration of the speed after super to 3.5 seconds and decreases the amount of hits needed to charge the super from 12 to 9 hits. For me this would increase the skillcap needed to use Edgar, since you would get the super rarity and would need to play well to cycle it. And the dash accessory would give Edgar ways to deal with brawlers who manage to push him away. He would still have very effective caunters like the Surge, Shelly, Gale and Stu. But it would no longer be impossible to apply in 3x3. And it would also drop considerably in combat because of the removal of the first gadget.

Edgar needs more love❤ Make a video how to be good at Edgar before rework please

A year has passed, but we are still waiting for the Edgar guide. Crying man make a guide please 🙏

To me, only giving a full Charger super from the start, and 2 jumps per super

7:37 to 8:14 felt like an action movie scene

*Timestamps, Tips, Comments, Music, and Highlights* *Timestamps:* 0:05 - Intro 0:20 - Edgar Rework idea by _u/Koolcatdk_ 1:19 - Showdown | _Skull Creek_ 3:33 - Showdown | _Skull Creek_ 5:00 - Brawl Ball | _Backyard Bowl_ 6:26 - Knockout | _X Marks the Spot_ *Tips:* _no tips_ :) *Summary of Comments:* Rework Idea: - Edgar will gain super by dodging shots - Life leech removed - Base HP buff - Super charge rate buff - Can stack 2 supers Edgar: - Good in passive modes like Showdown - Can't play passive in 3v3 - Used by no one in top power league - Thoughts on rework idea: - Evasion trait seems cool - Supercell are focussed on gear rework - 2 supers will be too broken - Gadget and super ideas are cool (3:39 4:31) *Music:* 0:05 - LAKEY INSPIRED - Chill Day 1:18 - Snake City - LA Made U Crazy 4:14 - Cushy - Life I Live 6:47 - FormantX - Dark Utopia *Highlights:* 7:10 - Nice! Won a 2v3

4:04 cryingman said f 😆

Imagine he can go in the walls I mean he's in a wall like a real parkour thing and can go dash after that that would be pretty broken mostly if can't hit wall except trowers

In my opinion, Supercell could do the same thing as Fang's attack. If Edgar doesn't hit any brawler his punch will fly and deal less damage, so he could be useful at long range and charge the ult without having to stand still!

New rework make him can't easily kill big bot mode enemy more 😢

this is my favorite brawler and i really want his rework but i don't like the idea of ​​him losing his healing passive

Que bien ver un vídeo sobre Edgar, sería bueno ya una mejora y su actualización para que haga frente al resto de rivales.

but edgar will no longer good at robot boss fight after his healing removed😿

If edgar loses his lifesteal, he might be quite weak, but with the evasion, he might be really good. Overall he’s a super fun brawler, my favourite too.

I think two super means I he jumps on Shelly (or anyone else) he can jump backwards safety afterwards

What's the name of the first song you used in the video

Cryingman: No one uses Edgar in top power league OJ: Are you sure about that?

I think this rework is really good but I think it should be a new brawler Idea not a rework but Edgar need a rework but not this one

A new trait: adrenaline. This brawler gains acceleration by being close to the opponent. Also, when using super, opponents in the landing zone receive a 25% damage reduction for 3 seconds

Just give evasion a small cooldown so dodging a barrage of bullets wouldn't charge him up too much, also edgar can't be too cocky since he's a glass canon and after rank 20 everyone starts to aim properly

Cambiar la star power de daño al aterrizar por una que al usar la super te de una carga que se consume para evitar un efecto de restricción contra el usuario

La idea del esquivar está buenísima algo nuevo y le daría sentido el tener caderas

먼저 피흡은 에드거의 가장 특이한 특징이자 제가 에드거를 좋아하는 이유인데 그걸 없애면 에드거는 데미지가 쎈 엘프리모가 되는거네요. 패치가 더 시급한 브롤러는 체스터가 아닐까 싶네요

I have a rank 25 edgar and i play him but he doesn't require much skill i hope they make this a real rework he needs it!

According to me Edgar' health at max level 4200 > 4900 Edgar's first gadget should be reworked Now instead of charging super, it will give edgar a small jump like of surge super and for making him balanced The amount of healing will be reduced from each attack will be reduced by 10 or 15 percent

Creo que hablo por todos al decir esto... Que bueno que lo reworken

i thought of something better you get two star powers one gives him health steal but not evasion and the other applies the new update but removes health on attack

Amazing soundtrack in finale game :)

Meu Deus mano kkkk na última partida eu fiquei impressionado!!! É incrível como você consegue ser bom com todos os personagens!! E realmente o Edgar podia ganhar um "rework' kkkkk

I am Edgar main ,questions?

Honestly just buff his súper charge rate to be faster get a little hp buff and change his hard landing star power to the one in the videos he doesn’t need to be too op

It's been funny to playing with him, I think I'll miss his mechanics.

Edgar can be a unique brawl if he gets two type of modes that he stays the same as he is now in showdown but there are different trait and mechanic while you play him in 3v3 (probably buffed so he isn't useless in 3v3 also) I know this is very complex but maybe we can see this in future 👀

I have a huge idea about Edgar's mechanics. 1. his first star power need to be built in for him. 2. His health points going from 2800 HP up to 3000 HP 3. Super is charging in 20 seconds instead of 30 seconds. 4. His damage is going up from 810 to 900 per hit and the same about his life leech it's going up to and at 315 health recovery (staying 35%) 5. He's second star power should be removed. And now... First star power called "Hard landing": when Edgar is jumping to an enemy he's stunning him for one second. 2nd new star power called "Warm scarf" When Edgar is landing, he's getting a shield of 30% to 3 seconds First new gadget called "Long fingers": Edgar's attack range is getting from 2 tiles to 4 tiles for 5 seconds. 2nd new gadget called "wanna mess?" Edgar is dashing to the closest enemy to him and deals 700 damage. And that's my rework idea for Edgar. Hope you'll see it Cryingman (huge fan)

i think they should increase range of engage

I like that he's gonna be reworked but life leach is good and should not be changed, maybe a small range/damage buff would be great,plus they would better look to fix the trophy road bug(I didn't get anything after the update) then to fix brawlers bc the update broke the game😟😠

Isn't it harder for edgar to attack tanky brawlers without lifesteal ?

Maybe the evasion mechanic could be like 1% for each 150- 100 damage you dodge?

now if theres edgars in the lobby u wont get ur head jumped on as much

imo the life leech part makes edgar fun to play so that shouldn't be removed instead remove the speed gained after using a super

Whell about his rework it's not bad Idk but to me Edgar means more than a brawler. I hope they don't change his shield gadget. I really like Edgar like he was and removing his healing was not the best idea in my opinion At least he's not going to change in his look :) Edgar the best for me and he will always be

Finally

This idea is better for a new brawler concept than for an edgar rework.

Supercell already planned the idea before KoolCat's post was made so it's not really his idea

Edgar with his current rework concept would be even more useless than he currently is, because he can no longer deal with almost any brawler in close range due to the removal of his life leech. He either needs to become a tank or let him still have his life leech

I think that Edgar should keep his healing, because it's the reason he's a unique brawler.

I think when it’s reworked, live leech shouldn’t be removed cuz unique for Edgar and defirienciate it from other brawlers

Congrats u made it to 1 million subs

You can use the first gadget in knockout for charging faster the super. But I don't understand why he is the worst brawler. The cincept ideas also look very good

Edgar es uno de mis brawler favoritos 🖤

Colt is never gonna be touched in competitive meta if this ever happens

For beginners under 500 trophies he's a great brawler cause it's fun and easy to play, but once you get above 500 trophies he becomes pretty much useless and frustrating to play with. Can't survive tanks with high damage at close range. Needs at least a buff in HP and maybe a star point that gives a consumable shield. Or may be a longer range of attack. Anything that lowers the damage taken at close range from high damage dealing tanks.

edgar rework idea: edgar will have 3 fighting posistions depending on his hp 1st position:normal edgar without life leach 2nd position (below 50% hp: range buffed, life leach enabled 3rd position (below 25%hp): range buff, more life leach, more speed, more damage

Esse final... 🤌🏻🔥♨️

I'm looking for the guy who comments with every video's summary of Cryingman! Where is he?

In fact a I have post in reddit where I share my ideas to rework Edgar But I'm not sure to add the link here 🤔

Me: Edgar is good CryingMan: It’s bad Me: yes it’s bad

I really want to see a sandy buff too. Just unlocked him and I'm losing against bots 🤣 Edit: Guys guys calm down... I not talking to rework him all over. I'm just asking if they can buff his damage even 5%. Just a small buff might do him good..

Cryingman, my thoughts of Edgar's rework is, he gets a nerf of healing while attacking, buffing his hp, build in his hard landing star power, movement speed buff for gadgets first gadget is fist slaps:his next attack will make him stun for one second and second is hardcore(new) Edgar's next super will give him a 50% of shield, star powers as per the 2 supers but 2nd star power will be invincible:while Edgar got attacked the next attack which he is facing will get 10% of health and immune to stun, slow downs, knock backs and poisen and the evasion ability is awesome

tirar a cura do edgar é acabar com a essência do personagem, n vejo necessidade nisso

Edgar Rework -Super : Revamp Old: Edgar jumped to designated area and gain attack speed New: Edgar jumped to designated area, enemies who is in the area will immobilize for 2s and will be slow for 0.5s -Model New: Stay the same but his scarf will be longer due to attack range buff -Attack Old: Edgar's bar shape attack and short range New: Edgar attack range will be longer as the scarf length longer than before and his attack will be in semi-circle shape( example : bibi's attack) -Attribute Old : Edgar's attack can heal if hit the enemies New : Every shot of enemies(his vision) will increase the duration to get his super, so he dont need to wait for so long to get his super or hit enemies just to get the super, just by watching enemies shot he can even get his super directly ( 1 ammo of his enemy = 2 hit to get his super) lol ma english bad, it just for 🤣

Edgar should born with a fully charged super as Sam, so he don’t have to wait for 30sec in the beginning of 3v3 match. This change may help him threaten the rival and recharge his second super by his first free super:)

Do you list the hardest brawler rn?

This thumbnail gadget would op against some of his counters

SO CLOSE TO 1 MIL WOOOOOOO Please guys this man deserves it, he puts so many effort in his videos

i rememeber the edgar apocalypse 😭

When you post the stu guide?

But when he got his super he counter so hard most of lo dos brawlers so thats why many people get easily rank 25 on him