Editorial With Sujit Nair | IAS Puja Khedkar Case: The Rot In Our Bureaucracy | UPSC

No video

Editorial With Sujit Nair | IAS Puja Khedkar Case: The Rot In Our Bureaucracy | UPSC | Maharashtra

Рет қаралды 42,503

Күн бұрын

In this episode of ‘Editorial’, Mr. Sujit Nair speaks on the pertaining issues in the Indian administrative and civil services in India and highlights the infamous ‘Puja Khedkar Case’. Mr. Nair says how people like Puja Khedkar circumvent the administrative examinations and enter in civil services. Suggesting various reforms, Mr. Nair says that there should be lateral appointments in the civil services where subject experts can enter the administrative services at any age and handle the related department. Another reform suggested by Mr. Nair is the intermediate examinations in the administrative services. This means that like a medal-winning Olympian, where he/she has to again qualify for the next Olympic, a civil servant should also have some examination after they clear their civil services examinations.
#PujaKhedkar #IAS #IndianAdministrativeServices #UnionPublicServiceCommission #UPSC #CivilServices #Pune #CivilServiceReforms #Bureaucracy #IndianPoliceService #Politicians #IPS
#HWNews
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
Support independent journalism by subscribing to HW News English Premium Newsletter: hwnews.in/subs...
To Join KZfaq Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscrib...
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/c...
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotio...
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/

Пікірлер: 227

@tusharpotdar5762 Ай бұрын

People who having natural ability to Bullying there subordinate or lower class people, became top rank IAS

@nevillepinto5847 Ай бұрын

Absolutely spot on. Thank you Sujit

@ramakantvadje9216 Ай бұрын

Nice Video 💐👍🙏

@gratiangovias8398 Ай бұрын

Election Commission of India is another point of reference,

@jonron3805 Ай бұрын

Yeh agreed that why Cangress succeeded in rigging it to win the recent assembly elections ..... right??????

@sidindian1982 Ай бұрын

That's the reason want to leave india🇮🇳 😟😟😟😟😟

@sreekumarpillai9957 Ай бұрын

This is one of the best of your editorials

@Naresh00009 Ай бұрын

She got her ethics lesson from her father who made more than 100 crs being Director of MPCB ( Govt Service ). The whole system stinks.

@irenedsouza8017 Ай бұрын

We definitely need reforms immediatel

@viswanathankabeerdas Ай бұрын

My question is why this is happenings in NORTH INDIA which are likely to affect brilliant students all over India

@rogersri Ай бұрын

very well said Sujith - IAS officers are suppose to monitor Revenue and Expenses - but look at all PSU losses year after year in-spite of CAG reports - why do they even have CAG if no one is responsible to act on their findings - for last 70+ years - totally agree every govt dept must have KPI and lateral outside experts to fearlessly and boldly analyse and improve

@bunduuk Ай бұрын

This system is exactly followed in the UK, as you mentioned. They improved the system, while giving us the system, yet we are still stuck to this outdated method. They got to know about the system's caveats and flaws and took steps to address them. We should do the same instead of being complacent.

@wobblebluez333 Ай бұрын

You're absolutely right. Enhanced oversight of bureaucratic processes is crucial. Shifting towards contract-based appointments could foster a culture of accountability and performance-driven results. This transformative change, initiated from the highest levels, has the potential to streamline governance and improve efficiency across the board.

@mariapetma Ай бұрын

Very interesting editorial Mr Sudhir Nair thanks a lot.

@paulm.k.8740 Ай бұрын

Sujit Nair

@rigeshyogi Ай бұрын

No developed country gives their public servants the kind of perks that IAS officers get in India. Public servants, even their at high levels, use public transportation and live in their own or rented houses in those countries. No special treatment anywhere. India has a multitude of modern day sultans who are beyond laws and indeed live like sultans. That kind of entitlement for both politicians and public servants should stop.

@juiceeer3320 Ай бұрын

Keyword developed country. India is not a developed country.

@bipinvivek5334 Ай бұрын

Sir the India's Bureaucracy has ensured that your choice should be a private school for your children , our natural healthcare choice is private hospitals, our choice for child good education is good coaching which is the biggest start-up india.

@laxmandeshpande7204 Ай бұрын

An impressive analysis dear Sujit sir. This is an eye opener for UPSC & the DOPT too. Thanks for this elaborative analysis....!💐💐💐💐

@VIKASH_55972 Ай бұрын

Om birla daughter's result also need to be checked and investigated

@Satyameva1952 Ай бұрын

Your idea of having a doctor to run the health department is fantastic. Likewise, an educationist to run education, an IT professional to run IT. That will make India great again.

@cosmicray3395 Ай бұрын

You mean experts who also have good organisational skills.

@gdaruna7200 Ай бұрын

Absolutely correct.some are not even capable of writing notes remarks ,parawise remarks in court cases 😢

@gdaruna7200 Ай бұрын

They harass sincere and intelligent officers

@user-lw3no3ok5k Ай бұрын

Excellent presentation, the whole system of selection is corrupt with favourisum

@mohamedAli-oe1fi Ай бұрын

Good editorial which has brought to lime light the luccuna in the systems. Any system should have an objective and several expectation under the objective in line with overall government policy. Every expectations shall have a process/programs in place to ensure the expectations are holistically achieved. I am not sure every position holders are provided with job descriptions and an orientation has to be provided prior to take up positions. If this done accountability can be fixed. All these procedures if available are not put in practice with no check and balance. Hence a complete revamp of the system is mandated.

@levirengma1398 Ай бұрын

Sir, your editorial is something every Indian should listen. The rot in bureaucracy is the system.The politicians are also to be blamed for the rot in the system.The problem is that ones a person gets into an IAS he or she thinks that they are equal to God or only next to God.They think they know everything on this earth,he or she becomes expert in every field.Also the problem is an IAS and political boss becomes partners in corruption looting nation as much as they can.Ofcourse there are honest and good officer's among IAS but as usual in India if you are honest you will be always targetted by politicians and posted in insignificant post as punishment posting, so even some of those good officer's succumbed to the rot system. God bless our country.

@SARajanGenesis Ай бұрын

Wow Sir ... what an excellent editorial... Superb thought every bit ... Best is they need to keep upgrading lateral entry is need of the hour what if someone the Best CA in india becomes FM as lateral entrant .. we can become superpower in Short term atleast we will eradicate powerty in this great nation. May God help us

@Apparently.Me. Ай бұрын

Sir, she used Visually disabled quota. Which means she could have used a scribe to write her preliminary exam. The scribe could have been an expert in the subject.

@sreekumarkochuparampil5144 Ай бұрын

Nobody can touch them, but great conscientious people are there, so that we common people survive.

@anilnarang4243 Ай бұрын

Great editorial. BUT we reap what we sow. If we are corrupt, we are corrupt in all walks of life. Examination or assessment for promotion or lateral entry or any other rules/law would fall flat. A common man can only think to get some relief from courts and courts do not get time to list cases and when they do, they say the justice is NOW TIME BARRED. The courts lists or decides cases 5,10,20 years after they are filed . GOD BLESS US.

@meltherecafe2394 Ай бұрын

The biggest sin is to be an honest hard-working general category student in India.

@miliindsose Ай бұрын

We must thank this khedekar girl for showing what the ias really is on the inside Most people had doubts. Some were sure that this merit thing is all a sham Now we all know Not a single institution in this country is worth any faith or integrity House of cards. Hope the nation gets its act together soon

@fernandofaleiro3429 Ай бұрын

You are absolutely right, Sujith. I hope the top authorities and honest government decision maker makes note of this.

@Sinned75613 Ай бұрын

Undeserving position being taken starts right at the top, best examples are PM, Jay Shah & many more.😂😂😂

@jalajabhaskar6490 Ай бұрын

Good point 😂😂

@vidyadharnprabhu Ай бұрын

Rahul Gandhi too 😂😂

@pawankhurana1345 Ай бұрын

Definitely, the right topic at the right time. Bharat needs specialists in the form of consultants like we had Nandan Nilekani in Aadhar card. USA, UK and many other consultants from different walks of life and from different sectors of the economy and make Lateral entry in the administration of the country even at the age of 40 , 45 or in special cases even at the age of 50 or 55 years since by then they have great experience and degrees.

@Zak-qh5tb Ай бұрын

Any new system in India will start well but eventually even that new system will also be exploited due to the highly corrupt nature of our people to find loopholes in everything.

@kenlandon6130 Ай бұрын

In America civil servants are hired based on the qualifications for a specific role, not a general exam. Or entry through internships.

@pawankhurana1345 Ай бұрын

@@kenlandon6130 That is what I am saying, Nandan Nilekani was hired by Indian Government as he is an IKONIC figure in IT industry of India and I am sure he had not given any UPSC exam, similarly we should appoint IKONIC people like Nandan Nilekani, which is a privilege for Indian Government that he accepted to work for Indian Government, Rashtrapati Bhawan or PMP should thanks him, as for sure he did not come to join Government of India just only for money or LAL BATTI OR GOVERNMENT BUNGLOW OR SEWAKS. UPSC should appoint such IKONIC figures, and no need for exams also for such IKONIC personality, they are Board of Exam themselves, their name sells.

@kenlandon6130 Ай бұрын

@@pawankhurana1345 Yes this is the way. Hire people for what they can actually do and what they have done, not generalists except in a few rare cases like military or diplomatic service that have few equivalents outside the government.

@pawankhurana1345 Ай бұрын

@@kenlandon6130 Well Dear, fully agree with you. Are you a professional with more than 20 years experience

@nancydesouza145 Ай бұрын

Kudos to you, sir, for bringing to light the rot and corruption in the system. It is a great shame for our country that this sort of people is in power at various levels.

@gdaruna7200 Ай бұрын

Wonderful

@hillaryfonseca5542 Ай бұрын

Spot on...like the PM's education certificate controversy that went & still goes around.

@chandrakantgadade2616 Ай бұрын

Very nice episode

@sreekumarkochuparampil5144 Ай бұрын

Sir, We want more from you. 👌👍👏🎉🎉🎉🎉

@joshuakirubaraj9863 Ай бұрын

Who have made things very clear. Salute you sir.

@cheryldesouza3115 Ай бұрын

Excellent points

@gokulsethmaji2458 Ай бұрын

Remember a revolver wielding probationer of that service years ago who was helped by a Governor who reportedly requested the then Home Minister to intercede and rescue his career against the opinion of the then Academy Director.It was all in the newspapers those days.

@AlwynMenezes Ай бұрын

What about our parliament speaker daughter who became an IAS officer without giving an exam. Where is the check and balance.

@sandyj342 Ай бұрын

She wrote the exam but was in reserve list. But question is what was the process of caste, quotas, interview when they knew she was the speakers daughter.

@krishnamurtisharma4507 Ай бұрын

Appreciable suggestions, policy makers must review the advice given by Mr Surjeet Nair .

@RavindraSinha Ай бұрын

Inherent corrupt system breeds more corruption. Sabka vikas.

@remapai7085 Ай бұрын

Very well explained and should be considered all points by higher authorities

@pramodkul Ай бұрын

Under Faqueer's regime all key institutions have lost reputation. Look at ccbeei, eedee, rbeeii, ayias, ayips, itee, ceeagee, ceevcee, etc.

@jonron3805 Ай бұрын

Yes when EVM's rumor did not succed you will support this rumor

@ramakumarnambiar7010 Ай бұрын

@@jonron3805absolutely!! Just how they ‘turn the plate’ unashamedly…😅

@vidyadharnprabhu Ай бұрын

@@jonron3805😂😂😂

@joyroy6549 Ай бұрын

Thank you Manoj Soni for selecting Puja Khedkar. Farewell for uplifting the system of selection in UPSC. All the best for your future engagements. I hope you will become the Chief Minister of Gujarat and next Prime Minister of India.

@itsmepols Ай бұрын

A rot in the education system is a rot in any systems!

@jonron3805 Ай бұрын

If the education system was that rotten the country would not be amongst the top economies of the world

@suryamanoharm4782 Ай бұрын

We need total reforms as you said

@1k5hay Ай бұрын

UPSC 🙏

@LM-rk3nm Ай бұрын

Even the continuous upgradation , they will manipulate that also!

@adityasrkrishnan Ай бұрын

Excellent editorial with all relevant and well made points

@abhijit84 Ай бұрын

Well said sir...nice to hear someone saying it out loud...kudos sir

@chandrashekharkoti6525 Ай бұрын

A best analitical observation, T Q Sir Nairji.

@techsolutions2766 Ай бұрын

Don't describe IAS, IPS as if they are God or protector of us.They are simple government employee, responsible to the legislature and those legislature are elected by the people of India. Infact everyone including legislature and these bureaucrats are protected by our "Indian Army❤️".

@sanketjadhavar Ай бұрын

Indian army had zero power and influence in your day to day life. An IAS and IPS decide the course of your day to day lives. They control and guide the direction in which administration and security (internal) goes. They decide if its development or crime that will be in power. They are not like elected representatives, who if found to be useless can be made to sit at home after 5 years. Here , the appointments are permanent and so is their influence.

@martinjeaks Ай бұрын

Thought provoking. Good editorial.

@amitabuch 8 күн бұрын

Excellent topic👍

@vishwanathpujari716 Ай бұрын

Great 🎉 The points - periodic review & lateral induction, certainly is the need of the hour.

@MickeyFrank-nb9kp Ай бұрын

Good information sir❤

@zehniyat6410 Ай бұрын

Namaskar!

@ashokddani Ай бұрын

Thanks Sujit🎉🎉

@marylincutes Ай бұрын

Canada has a fantastic model where health minister should be a doctor, finance minister should have a strong background in finance with relevant qualifications and so on...

@tujams Ай бұрын

Sir, I completely agree with your view that India should possibly allow parallel recruitments into the Administrative Services, the bureaucracy is designed to never allow this. We can be taken on-board as domain experts on a committee, but not as a part of the state machinery. The reason is our IAS is still the British ICS in disguise and has a degree of elitists and entitlement attached to it. What one learns in the two years after qualifying for the IAS training is to develop the rhino skin to digest personal remarks, the tact to handle matters in a bureaucratic way and give all kinds of diplomatic solutions where every party involved feels like a winner. Anyone from outside has a lot to catch up and its not easy to survive. It is a world where one is judged not on their work, but position and pay scale.

@polytricks2935 Ай бұрын

We need a good, honorable and honest on PM chair Sir.

@rc2k22 Ай бұрын

The whole focus is around Puja Khedkar, no one is exposing those who gave her false certificates.

@yeskumar8757 Ай бұрын

Sir abhi aur lijiye NAME - NIKITA KHANDELWAL IAS RANK 2014 -857 Inki visual impaired 6 KA CERTIFICATE SE ENTRY HAI INKI AUR 857 RANK PAR INKI IAS CADRE BHI MIL GAYA . Inka certificate bhi check hona chaiye .

@ameenulhaq1367 Ай бұрын

Very good editorial ❤

@ushashivpuri4835 Ай бұрын

Thanks to our Govt...we are not living with truth and honesty for last 10 years.everybody has becum greedy and non responsible..becoz one knows there is no answerbility.😢😢😢😢😢😢

@varalakshmielango5208 Ай бұрын

Brilliant!

@kannanthillainayagam7697 Ай бұрын

IAS assurances listed by you are all expected results of IAS officers But reality is once you got the post then luxury life and power no ordinary person can question or stoo

@LalyHarvey Ай бұрын

Yes long ago

@baskerjohn3574 Ай бұрын

Enlightened of sab ko Vikas generation.

@Naresh00009 Ай бұрын

Tell me Sujit I am forced to do business ( 4 out of 5 fail) Whereas If I get govt job, I not only get to make crores, with no chances of failure alongwith POWER that comes with it. Businessmen are screwed by these same Govt Officers......

@saroshbharucha Ай бұрын

Our bureaucracy is sliding from bad to worse

@hameedshahul6191 Ай бұрын

This is the proof! If you have money & the political connection, you can do anything and everything in India! Party comes and goes, but the rotten system remains intact 😢

@calmcurrent1998 Ай бұрын

I am an eighty two year old super senior citizen and I had an unfortunate occasion to meet a DC in Kapurthala to get some information on my complaint about my land grab case which was addressed by Punjab NRI minister and DC gave me assurance in his presence to solve the case.But myself and my wife both were abused by that DC who is much younger than my sons.We were shocked.Although British masters have left our country but our governments are still using the same slave mentality.

@vinodsmita2017 Ай бұрын

Thank you,it was quite exciting

@PurbhiK Ай бұрын

Even if upgradation tests are held, these people will find a way to rig them

@saraagsn7161 Ай бұрын

What about other IAS officers who joined illegally... Big scam in UPSC..

@sarahsheila38 Ай бұрын

Well said

@percysequeira284 Ай бұрын

Every system in India was designed to benefit the Ruler, the British earlier and the Politician today. How can an individual with a Mental problem be an IAS?

@joypmmatthew9298 Ай бұрын

Timely reforms and evaluation are in need for every systems

@MisraSuneeta Ай бұрын

Same goes for our politicians. How do we hold them responsible for disproportionate accumulation of assets and for inefficiency!

@darkhorse1907 Ай бұрын

great video this!!❤❤❤

@mariamyanlem640 Ай бұрын

I agree to all d points u mention

@user-cl5ym5mq7n 6 күн бұрын

Need of an hour to set regulation. To ensure country administration is under qualified- upgraded and under honest leadership. Politicians are just to pass the laws in parliament/Assembly-but actual it is these adminstrators who are sole responsible for country development.

@TruthinQuest890 Ай бұрын

Good one

@rajendranv2582 Ай бұрын

I am with your findings. There are still more issues 1) the present number of attempts allowed should be reduced to two. At GrA level what we should look for is intelligent well educated person of young age, not a hard worker. Getting through CSE on 4th or 5 th attempt indicates that he/she is a hard worker. Such people are goid for supervisory job only. So limit the number of attempts to two 2) reduce the maximum age to

@rajendranv2582 Ай бұрын

On NCL for OBC, for the wards of gov. servants, the 1993 DOPT order clarifies that their parents position in gov determine their NCL status. On income nothing is mentioned in their case.

@sonaliz3721 Ай бұрын

There should be checks and balance in politics

@albertbaryawal9522 Ай бұрын

Please analyse how many reservations IAS Person whose parents were IAS have used reservation certificates

@jayaramprabhu5595 17 күн бұрын

Puja khedekar is one example & there may be plenty of this type cases in the recent past. After formation of govt whether it's in a state or at the centre, cabinet ministers select those IAS officers who are ready to toe their line & sometimes act as conduits for wheeling & dealings. Our electrol system so strange that even those jailed can stand for election & recently two fugitives won the elections even though they are behind bars.Tax paying & law abiding citizens when apply for passport, policeman come to your door steps for verification & of course for some consideration.This is our India 😊.

@KUMAR-bq4xn Ай бұрын

IAS IPS is remnant of colonial British era. British dont follow it but we still follow it 😢😢

@avinashkarnick385 Ай бұрын

The civil services in India have been trapped inside a time-warp of the colonial past, they have turned anachronistic and have shut their eyes and ears to a new and changed environment over a 77 year period. Extremely drastic steps will be needed to change all this, for which our elected representatives too are unprepared. So how does the entire process come into motion. A puzzling question for the common citizens.

@user-oi6xf9be4y Ай бұрын

Super

@A4Aqua Ай бұрын

Why the lateral entry experiment failed in GoI? I would say no industry expert will be ready to serve in the post of IAS officer if the salary is that of an IAS officer.

@lvjayashree9718 Ай бұрын

Sir they (IAS) have a strong lobby. They will protect their own even if he or she does some extremely bad infraction or inhumane treatment of ppl...after all we are slaves...

@drsheiba5644 Ай бұрын

Well said how about disproportionate assets after a salaried job...feature applicable to those in Government services?

@SuriSri117 Ай бұрын

Don't know how many of you agree i suppose the govt should give first preference to social workers who are trained to do social services and taught about the social skills and techniques also about community services also trained for engaged people's