they look younger without make up

почему у Роки такие огромные глаза с черными кругами?!

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

We have the same opinion. First they ship MooBin with the pretty boy to rise him up to the sky. Then pair MoonBin up to promote the youngest. They were never opportunity for Rocky & MoonBin to pair up. It hurt so bad these 2 besties can’t duet in this life time. Our baby Bin were too good so he been used. I send all my love to Binnie, no more stand, or idolize. He is, was & will be the last and the only. Love you forever baby Bin.

​@@ThaoLe-js8hb I'm a 54 year old woman and I didn't know anything about Kpop world before Binnie passed away. When the bad news reached me, I just wanted to know the cause of his death. And here I am captured by Binnie's personality. But what especially holds me here is what the agency and some others (the 2) had done to him. It affects me so much that it revolts me, I really feel very bad for Binnie who only deserved happiness. Honestly, the aroha whose Binnie was their bias should open their eyes to the facts that the agency and the group was only hurting Binnie by overexploiting him without recognition, betraying him and plotting to trick him into re-signing the contract. They didn't deserve Binnie at all, sorry for MJ and Jin jin who have nothing to do with this tragedy. Binnie wanted to leave the agency and Astro. Rocky left the place is a fact. Binnie was sick and needed a break is a fact. The agency not only didn't give him a break but didn't even care about Binnie's health conditions and left him alone is a fact . Binnie died of it all is the fact. I wish so much justice and honors to be returned to Binnie.

@@thachvyana3660 Binnie stand did try, but the agency use legal action against due to the overboard content. MB mom also ask Aroha to stop comments about him. In 2023 MB seem to forgive the youngest brother, only cut off the pretty boy. If our super star MB wasn’t physically unwell he would have recovered from the heart break. MB need good break & medical acid,but MB schedule was pack. MB was prepared for an oversea schedule so his body must have gave up. MB bucket list for 2023 was healthy & composed a song. Unfortunately there won’t be any justice served. Many of us hope MJ not to sign contract so Aroha & Astro will forever belong to our beloved MB. Many feel sympathy & empathy toward pretty boy & betrayal youngest brother. That make us sick. Thanks to whom share pain, understanding & prayer for our beloved MoonBin.

Moonbin is a pure heart angel who would like to promote Astro and help other teammates to be successful as well. Arohas love Binnie for his warm and loving personality. 💕 The hard-working Angel Binnie has gone back to heaven, who worked to die for his responsibilities. Take a good rest now, arohas won't forget you, thank you for all the beautiful youth time you devoted to Arohas. ❤

Karma is a b!#$h,it knows no religion or status. I have never liked the pretty boy and the other youngest clown. Fantagio on the other hand is purely a corrupted and evil managed company,that used Binnie to stay afloat. Rest well Binnie for you are now free.❤❤❤

아우~~끝까지 봤더니 라키 진짜 착하다~~ ㅎㅎ 빈이형한테 맞추느냐고 고생혔네~

At times I feel MJ was loyal to Bin as well. You are right though Bin was made to teach and raise Sanha. Bin had expressed he's desire to subunit with Rocky but Fantagio had another agenda. As well, I believe Rocky's height had an impact. Sad...✌️

Está empresa nunca los dejo ser a MOONBIN ROCKY ya tenian sus preferidos ,solo pido q les llegue el karma a todos los q lo usarin a MOONBIN 😢😢😢

Yes, that's right. Thank you for watching 😄

It was. But they still look like babies without makeup.

October 2016?

​@@deanbutler1467im not sure, but I have a screenshot of me watching this live on November 2017, so sometimes before that ^^;

если я правильно поняла спойлер, о новом видео, где будет Сан Ха, то речь о походе Бина, Роки и СанХа в парк аттракционов. Я видела такую съемку с датой лето 2015. Но я не уверена.

Nice cute bin, rocky.

Yes and Binnie said they already had dinner...meaning they are already full. And drinks came late. But both Bin and Rocky played it so well just to promote and support Astro group and Eunwoo. At this stage, they really will do anything for their group Astro to be known. Love them but at the same time, pity them.

Hhhhhhh❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

As I wrote it above. Until 2023, Binnie had repeated in all interviews that the duet he would want to do was with Rocky because they danced together, they are friends since long time and they have the same tastes. On another side, when Rocky was asked who he would choose... Rocky's answer was "Moonbin". They were the bests of Astro but Rocky was underrated and neglected, Binnie was used and overexploited in order to favor some others members without receiving any regconition. At the end they did not take care of his health and made him die 🥺😢💔💔💔💔💔💔 Now Astro band is just a shell without soul. Oh please, what was Rocky's mistake ?

라키가 연애를 확실히 한건지 뭔지도 몰겠는데, 그리고 연애하면 왜??? 25살도 안되어서아직 애기들인데~ 너무 가혹해~ 그 긴 연습생 시절 보내고 이제 뽀작 올라온 새싹들한테~ 한숨나온다..ㅠㅠ

Prečo vyhodila agentura Rockyho? 😮

@@user-yr8cz8rv1j 연애는 할 수 있다 생각해요 그래서 지금도 라키 응원하지만 맏형 군대가기전 마지막 앨범을 여친과 작사작곡하고 곡에 여친 목소리 넣는건 진쩌 선넘었다 생각해요 콘서트 뮤지컬마다 부르고..물론 저도 여친분 좋아해요 라키의 행동이 약간 아쉬울뿐..

​​@@thachvyana3660You know, I agree with what you wrote here. Binnie was "promoted" to Sanha's nanny in the subunit, and a duet between him and Rocky would be something explosive, the two singing and dancing together, as we saw in To be Continued. If that wasn't enough, the company itself sabotages the group by transforming Eunwoo into the male version of Susy from Miss A, but thankfully he's not a damn dazzled peacock, he really regretted that his other obligations as an actor took up time that he didn't could dedicate it to ASTRO. And, of course, Binnie's solo album lacked with the lyrics he wrote, and as I regret this fact especially after hearing it in Let's Go Ride and Desire, it would be a kpop masterpiece, for sure. Injustices leave such a bitter taste in life... 😢