I think its because she has great looks and personality but she lacks some skill, and people think there are other trainees that deserve a spot in top 9 while Esther is n. 1 for being "famous", so that's why

@@caramelatte5477she is nt Dat famous as u think, all she did was supporting roles and low budge lead dramas and only few was recognised for her talent, I rejected and criticised many tyms bcoz of her personality till date, she went through a lot b4 coming to this show so stop it

Caramel Liris lol many of the girls on this show are much more famous then Esther, she gained popularity during the show which is normal since it’s a survival show. But people like the snh girls have very big fanbases in China and they have participated in shows with groups like UNINE and r1se and people like minghao and Cheng xiao and kyulkyung. So them using popularity as an excuse to hate isnt good enough they can just say they hate her and leave or just shut up. Popularity doesn’t justify someone they all work hard to get to where they are like every idol and trainee.

@@user-jl4dl2bb4e yeah some are famous in weibo some already debuted as an idol

Caramel Liris ppl always thinks she’s famous but tbh so many ppl are known in China but compared to other countries Esther isn’t known at all. Esther has great talent she just don’t show it on the show

Indian?

@@kulsumzehra4710 yeah

S they look like Bengalis soooo cute😍🤩

Well she's already rich so...

@@michellemerin But being rich doesn't define a person.. 😊

If i'm rich like her, I wouldn't wanna worry about the competition because i have the money and fame already. But for the other trainees, do you think they can be like her when she already have everything?

@@michellemerin Well, not all rich people think the same way that you do. 😊 Regardless of the status, not everyone is good in making friends and in making people to like you. 😊 There are even some rich celebrities that I don't like. At the end of the day, it's not the wealth that matters, it's the choice.

@@michellemerin I know this is very subjective but I also believe that money and fame is not EVERYTHING! 😊

Same too

Uhm, no...

This is why she needs to be in the top 9 in my opinion, she would be a support girl for the team, in my opinion

Sophia Prem honey stay a fan then ✨💓🥵⭐️

Agree

their mindset be like rich = brat

my dog name is kai! Lol I saw u everywhere Guess u also are fan of Esther

@@cookie-rp2co hahaha hi! actually i'm a K Lu stan but i'd like to just randomly comment in ywy2 related video 🤣

@@cookie-rp2co me? You saw me everywhere?

yelsha grace no I’m talking to kai

where?

download Chinese iqiyi to vote

Agree🤣🤣

She will obviously get a stomachache if she keeps on eating cookies when moving excessively as they practice lol xD

Stomachache(gastric) and crawling down here is not shooting on the same day.

Let's not make assumptions, xin liu is a kind person, I don't think she will let her starve if she's in pain.

Shes on a diet too

@@Ljwolf07 no she has a gastric, and about biscuit it just her way to wake them up

Shipper? 😂

Gosh she's kind we get it but we need an all rounder and limitless center we dont settle for less . a CENTER is not a position for everybody its a responsibility

zumabie bit I know this position is really important but this is just my opinion then when the results come out no matter what happened I can received all because I know her talent then I just wish for someone I admire.

Where did u see those videos when esther had stomach ache..aya our queen esther trying so hard..i felt pity for her

@@romalsawmi1262 When she have stomachache and when she acted like caterpillars/eating biscuit is both on 2 difference days. Why I know? Bcoz she wores different shoes. I know you are concern for her health but than please watch again the videos before making any assumption guess. Since she is lacking behind of coz she have to work harder for the collaboration. Eating biscuit(junk food) and trained later? If Lisa is around Esther will get a good scolding for fooling around too much. And if she really on diet by eating biscuit(junk food) than it wont make her any slimmer.

@@huiechin9120 lol

@@huiechin9120 thank you for explaining..🤗🤗

Huie Chin she was sick for quite some time. The weather in guangzhou can hit over 30 degree Celsius but she wore really thick jacket on some days. She may not be the most talented but she’s trying her best and I don’t see why people are not appreciating people who tries their very best.

It's related to the Chinese childhood stage perform classic makeup.

@@zachjarsle4606 What does it symbolize exactly?

Gustavo Villar No, I think it do has some relationship with Hinduism since it comes from the forehead decoration culture in Buddhism which derives from ancient Hinduism. But it is a culture introduced to China a thousand years ago, and nowadays it is mainly a purely aesthetic action instead of delivering religious meaning.

Yes

Too much dieting and not eating right causing stomachache(gastric) is the issue here.

胃疼跟做毛毛虫并不再同一天。

No.. it's not on the same day. She not wearing the same shoes when she stomachache.

@@huiechin9120 i don't know why people just only see the shoes and then jump to the decision that she didn't have stomachache that day. Trainees can change shoes and their outfit during the training time. I have evidence to make sure that's on the same day. The outfit of LiuXin and K Lu were the same, Aria changed to a purple one. At the time, everyone stopped her from eating the biscuit, Snow Long didn't there, and she was the only member in the team knew that Esther had a stomachache. I didn't blame everyone bc they stopped Esther from eating, I'm just so disappointed and annoyed at the fact that the Iqiyi staffs had did some evil edit on my baobei in order to make her being someone awful in others' eyes. Iqiyi did post the video on weibo and then deleted it. I feel like they're trying to get my baobei down and that makes a fan like me so mad. I am an Vietnamese and in my country, there are a lot of evidence that we took from weibo and others sources to make sure that my baobei did have stomachache the same day...

@@tunglinhnghiem7674 So trainees coincidentally are so free to change shoe & clothes anytime? You even know there is something call editing? So obviously its wont be everything happening on the same day. They takes few days to practice not possible everything on a single day. So I hope you all are not exaggerated. Not everything on weibo is true, sometime its just does not make any logic with their posting there.

Toxic fandom. Cnets knows their attitude the reaaon the girl group of their idol never been successful in China.

胃疼的时候跟变毛毛虫不再同一天录制。

爱奇艺没有💔