I prefer TJ's edit on this one. That said, there is a time and a place for both and I think the audience appreciates the raw feel of TJ's style as we've grown with it, and can also get down with Anthony's for the rollers and such. Anthony has brought a sense of polish to the channel, no doubt. And a healthy mix of both is the best answer.

I agree with Calvin's assessment. I liked Toine's intro better, but the montage of the car with no VO was an energy drag, and the reactions lost their punch after the reveal.

TJ's edit hits different but Anthony's is just full on art and you know this is what he does for a living.

I don’t watch because I’m a brain dead toddler who needs constant entertainment. I watch because I enjoy the cars, the details, the fucking around and videos that treat the viewer like an adult.

I miss the old og jt edits 😭 low key

Old school all day. The new fast paced, overly edited, camera spin to start the scene is so annoying and everyone does it. Wanna feel like it’s a casual hang out

I like when we get a mix of both of your editing styles. I love them both

the new way is ok but the music plays a huge part meaning it needs to be some good music. no elevator cornhub music. old school way is fine too as long as its not over kill. like when sabrina said "just hurry up and open the garage" lol

Calvin nailed it with his description including his breakdown of the pause. Twan, you’re getting good feedback even though you are very talented. I say give Calvin a shot at editing cause he’s got a good sense of what an audience is looking for.

Alternate video title: "We're letting twan go..."

TJ's Edit: Tj's is able to show the viewer what he really cares about, you can feel the enthusiasm, you can feel how much he cares for this project car. hes excited. NO one is going to be able to share that perspective better than no other, then Tj. shows story better. OG edit Anthony Edit: Its a showcase. A Trailor. keep your attention. everything professional. youtube. we watch to feel connection. the video is beautifully done. but its a reel.

If Tj's had the car slo-mo sequence it would be indisputably better. Tj's was very thorough and I understood what he was trying to say but Anthony's was very easy to watch

Calvin’s insights were hella impressive. Wasn’t used to him breaking silence this much.

As a filmmaker, Calvin explanation and breakdown was great!

I LOVE this video. I like seeing both styles on the channel. Mixing videos in different editing styles keeps them all feeling fresh and entertaining, not boring

One is the BOSS and knows how the channel will react...The other wants the cannel to react well, but his boss to react well to. NOTHING bad at all about either, but one is worried about his job at the end of the day. BOTH GREAT!

i think the edits are not the problem, it’s the pace, personally i don’t want fast paced content especially on creators I want to watch longer per episode.❤

Dont get me wrong, Toan's editing and film making is amazing. I liked both, just depends on what they're going after. However, it's clear how easily toan gets upset when being given constructive criticism. Relax, no need to defend yourself. Listen and learn by listening and keep on improving. Great job both of you

I prefer TJs, but I think there is a really good middle ground between the two

Poor Toine..😂 buddy is not going to sleep well on this 😂 i like the og vlog style but hands down toine has some skils!

You guys should keep doing these. Very intrigued on the inner workings when editing. Would live for this ti become a regular occurrence watching the raw feedback.

Very interesting video to watch. Love that there are different perspectives that can appreciate each other’s approach to video making!

I think the discussion and back n forth you two have is vital to how the final product looks. All of us long time viewers are hungry for that raw, less polished nostalgic teej, but also love the high quality new edit that toine serves us. Personally, the combination is epic.

Me personally I like the b roll at the end of the videos. It gave a tj edit style throughout the video and a more professional style towards the end from Anthony

I think to be very clear, TJ’s editing has always felt like we were there with him and excited with him. Anthony’s style makes me feel like a viewer watching a presentation. I love both but TJ’s is the reason I love this channel

i think calvin said it perfectly. I love the pace TJ's video had but me being a cinematographer as well, i would like to see some more " storytelling " or b roll clips and stuff within the faster pace stuff. Either way i like them both and they both work for me, always good to come to that middle ground you guys talked about.

Old school TJ always. Makes you feel like you're there with him

A mix of both is what these videos need!!

Calvin said it best. Teejs brought back nostalgia and I like how he went over the reactions quicker. The perfect video would be first half teegs 2nd half twans. His came out more professional tbh. I enjoyed how he showed the car as he introduced it. Idk I don’t edit but the overall video was amazing. Thanks for showing this. Goes to show how much work is put into smaller things and how you’re open to seeing different POV to improve the channel.

Love seeing this me and my buddies literally had this type of sit down about their band content Las Calakas it was just such a content builder 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

This was pretty dope to actually watch. Inside look at creative minds and process that goes on BTS. Personally, I think one can appreciate the dynamics you guys share. Based off of this you guys have a solid team. I wouldn’t change that.

Seeing this was great because it gives us a glimpse of how they think when it comes to putting these videos together. In a way we got to see how much of their time and effort goes behind the channel when putting out the content.

Def preferred TJ's by a lot. Surprised that Anthony was quick to jump in and saying it wasnt like Freddy's or Mat's style videos but its definitely leaning towards Mat style than TJ style

TJ felt more personal like you're there..

Calvin said it best. TJs is very “Casey Neistat” esk and that will always be a home run.

I love the pacing of Anthony’s, just flowed a lot better

For some reason when I saw the reveal on the main channel I instantly thought this brings TJ edit vibes although I wasn't sure and that was sick! But we love Tuan's edit/work as well!

I'm gonna have to vote for Cal's edit!

I'm a fan and also work in the production industry. The kid is talented, has an eye for what is popular, and looks current. Always support that energy TJ, because he's doing his job and keeping you current ad the company grows beyond our years. The end of it all is somehow, to work professionally as a Creative, you need the boss's approval and brand awareness. Push boundaries always when possible but never ignore the history of a Brand.

TJs edit just hits different, OG style of editing 👌🏻

Loved the layout of Tj's but like twons style. Looked back at the video released and really enjoyed how you combined and added some things.

I preferred TJs edit as it gave nostalgia og vibes. But Anthony you are a wizard in the edits and you’re doing an incredible job !

The start with all the homies seeing the car and their reactions was my favorite part of the revile, and how it flowed in TJ's editing felt more personal for some reason. I enjoyed the beauty shots, but the more personal walk around again felt better. I guess I liked TJ's better but would have liked the beauty shots as part of the vlog.

Bottom line for most of us I think tjs just hit home. The feeling of where it started kinda. Anthony's is dope as usual but it's more on a professional level. Both great. Fun video idea. 10/10.

This is so cool to see !!!

tjs edit is wholesome & twan was hypebeast mode

Ooo a dandelion! Must be the last one of the sheason 😂

TJ's vlog style with - then a fast pace cut of the "history behind getting the Evo" - then Twan's style of suspense to black out - TJ style facetime calls- then Twan's B-roll is what I think Calvin was trying to say

TJs edit is more personal instead of the new age cookie cutter that everyone else is doing

I liked tj’s because it reminded me of why i started watching the channel. The og way is what made the channel great. Quite honestly and no shade to twan. The new way has made the videos less appealing.

This was really cool. Also got to see a side of Calvin I’ve never seen. Very analytical and intellectual.

Tjs feels more personal like an actual vlog!

Got into it with Forsberg about this before lol. This situation is entirely different though because we've been watching TJ for YEARS and He made an established style for himself. As an editor coming in, you have to take their style and elevate. Forsberg wasn't consistent and didn't have an established style yet, so it was freedom. Ultimately, He clearly wasn't feeling it and is more of a TJ. I do think Anthony's pace is a little slow on this specific one. If you keep TJ's cadence with Anthony's style then it's a perfect blend. I will say I agree with Anthony is that editors will notice the huggggge bump in quality. Calvin nailed it on the head with his feedback. This video was tight! Good idea. This was helpful as a creative and could be for anyone coming in to edit a creator's channel.

I had the pleasure of meeting Twan at a golf tourney earlier this year. We spent most of the time chatting about his cinematography and the work he has done on the channel. Give me those Acosta visuals all day every day!

I think they should edit different videos, because to watch the same video consecutively it impacts your judgement. If you watch Anthony's clip first, maybe the reaction would have differ. Think the second time around it became redundant. But both edits were top notch!👌👌 Great work guys!

I’ve been thoroughly enjoying Anthony’s edits EXCEPT for music choice. I agree with Calvin that the music sets the tone, and would love to have some of TJs music influence back in the videos. As a passive watcher I’m just trynna see TJ build these cars though. Great edits from both.

I really do miss the old tj editing style so it put a huge smile on my face and it would be a resounding tj wins BUT taking away nostalgic feelings, I agree with Calvin because right in the middle would be PERFECT tj and Anthony are a great duo and could definitely feed off of eachother and this proved that exactly

Definitely need some more og TJ edits in the future if you got the time!!

While I do feel the nostalgia of TJs edit, I like the evolved feel of Anthony’s. I think the happy medium is true. The raw feel of tjs vision of the vlog style and pace but for sure Anthony’s editing + cinematics as well as music. I like the put together feel of Anthony’s style but on tjs placement of clips.

I liked TJs edits better overall, but as a photographer, I appreciate Anthony’s, shots of the car before going into tj talking about it, plus the talking over the sea of cars was nice as well

Anthony’s style is suite for longer format but for youtube, where attention span matters, Tj’s keeps you more engaged.

I enjoyed this banter. I like TJ’s but i respect the more cinematic version

Both versions were good. I like the pace of TJ’s but I gotta give Anthony props on his artistic talent. A mix of both is the perfect blend for me.

Tj’s video with the car montage of Twan would be the ultimate choice. Tj’s was great just didn’t get to see the car in its full spotlight where Twan really showed the car. I also liked Tj’s reactions a lot more they were very direct and you could still get the feeling rather than the long ones where you lose the pace.

Damn Cal hit the nail on the head with his analysis. TJ’s transition speed and jump cuts matched with Twans b-roll would be perfect

I liked the pace of TJ's edit especially the reactions and I have to agree the music was better choice. I liked the artistic shots of the car on Anthony's edit and I agree with Calvin that a merging of the two edits would be perfect. Tj's edit is more personal and I think that's what his viewers relate to the most. TJ is a genuine person that has a passion for what he does and that resonates with everyone. Anthony has an artistic flair and a vision of what his videos should look like. At the end of the day TJ is paying Anthony for a service and ultimately he has the final say on the end product. Anthony needs to understand this concept and defer to TJ's wishes. Having said that though it is TJ's responsibility as an employer and mentor to foster the creative side in Anthony. He clearly has a desire to create peices of art and we have seen these and they have been very well recieved. Anthony: Make the edits like TJ likes and understand the business model of youtube and also what the subscribers like to see. Have your input and make suggestions for improvement but respect TJ's decisions. TJ: Give Anthony special projects to feed his artistic side. Make mini movies. Let him expolore his creativity. He will grow as an idividual and as an editor and ultimately he will move on to bigger things but you will retain his service longer if he is happy. As the years go by he will look back with respect and remember what you did for him. That is your legacy.

Kinda funny you two are so young and yet there is still an old school vs new school thing goin on. Well done! Still need more r34 tho pleaseeeeeee

the new way sucks dont change it the vlog style is what gives you guys more of a unique charm that not a lot of channels have now days

I’ve been waiting for an evo build for like 8 years omg…. But I mean of course TJ edits his own videos better. I mean come on, that’s a level of incomparable passion that you just can’t compete with. Love the Ant videos though so far course

Love this BTS clip, learning a lot

I like this because it’s a healthy bouncing of ideas to make everything better. I like TJ’s style more but some of the transitions on Tuan’s I liked more. I lean toward TJ but maybe a much younger audience member would lean to Tuan’s music choices. Calvin is right about an in between. Take both strengths and make it one. Casey Neistat’s method clearly works and following Teej for so long, I remember watching Casey drop a vid and then TJ drop his similar styled vids. It works, it captivates. It feels “real.” I like the behind the scenes aspect because I love to see how things work so thanks for sharing

Very interesting, it seems so similar to making music.

Do it your way tj that’s what we all like and know from you

Twan won and its not even close! Goodjob tho TJ. Maybe Twan can cut his editing time down and still deliver a great looking product which seems to be what TJ is aiming for, save the heavy editing for the major collaborations. I get a reveal can be major, but previous video suggested that everyone already knew what car it was anyway, so the grand build up wasn't so necessary, but visually I loved it. Took the L like a champ, Twan, keep the fire edits coming bro! Only thing I liked about TJs was how he dated the recap of the trip to Japan. Having that context felt helpful, not totally necessary tho I still very much enjoyed Twan making it a voice over situation.

Tj’s is the way to go it’s the reason I have watched him from paintball to cars but I learned to just keep moving forward

I genuinely liked TJs more, the way it was set up was just perfect!

I genuinely just LOVE tj hunts style. That’s not to diss Anthony in his craft because he’s simply better than tj, but we didn’t really start watching tj because he was better. We started watching tj because he was so relatable and when you click on his video it was like your buddy showing you some raw footage of him and his buddy modding something they had no idea how to do (you may ask yourselves if we know what we’re doing) it’s just because tj was and is different style wise and I really think his edit is simple and chill so basically just try a little less to focal in on the editing and be involved in the videos more too because you’re an awesome personality

I think Calvin is right. A mix of both would be the ideal style. TJ's needed that b roll footage of the car for sure. Working towards symmetry is the goal since us humans find beauty in it.

Both of your videos was fucking good ya still killing it

My boy twan can throw down on edit! But after reading comments, I agree with alot of the perspective here. Twan is an artist and has the ability to captivate, where as Tj has a style that has worked for years. Don't move away from that forever because it works, but definitely use Twans work for big reveals or videos that need to showcase not only the cars but also his work. Twan and Tj both have their own style, yes, and together they can build one hell of a video, but it goes off the saying if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

Love gettin personal with TJ :), new school edit was a bit fast paced for me but would of made a epic start to a crowded content video.

TJ's was nostalgic and I felt like I was getting more content but Twan's was visually more appealing and flowed more like a show than a vlog. TJ run clips. Twan should do the main channel.

Old school all day bro. It's one of the main reason I watch your channel to be honest. The new way seems a little less personal to me as a viewer.

Real OG’s will love both 🫡. I do like twons more just because of the cinematic feeling when introducing the car 😮‍💨

Well now I need a Doug Demuro intro for you. Get him out there because you all are right down the street from each other!

TJ Hunt Clips Great Video I definitely agree that with Calvin because TJ style of editing is definitely more enjoyable because it has a slower pace and more banter and I'm glad you guys chose TJs edit for the video

To be honest, both were meant to be melded... TJ has the energy, Twan has the beauty rolls etc... it’s no competion, just good content 🤘😎

I’m gonna watch the content either way 😂😂

Okay idk if is works at all but blend of both would be perfect. I think teeg editing the beginning and end to give us the OG personal feel that we love, but twan edit the middle portion to spice it up when needed to keep us engaged. But yeah a blend would be perfect

I'm a bigger fan of the vlog style. It gives me something to look forward to in future episodes. You can add a cinematic look to a vlog like LZ and Dut doo

TJ’s editing was more catching and straight to the point. Per cut, watching it was very exciting. Music choice was bonus, facetime call wasn’t too long.

Tj's edit flows way smoother, but twons edit would keep ppl who have short attention spans still hooked with the clean colors and the B roll shots. All in all, both edits were good to me and there will always be an audience for both types of editing styles

I prefer TJs clip but I really liked twans when it did the money shot of the car upon reveal. The music aspect is more OG videos which brings a nostalgic feel to the videos. Either way we are here for you and your content. The flow of the videos, unless heavily modified into something we are not used to, will not make that much a difference in my interest in the channel. Keep the OG music ! It brings me back everytime to Calvin's garage and the basics!!!

Above all, I actually appreciate Calvin's critique.

Not sure if anyone else said this but Anthony’s was more visually appealing and cinematic, but for a KZfaq video tj’s was more captivating. I do agree a mix of both would be perfect.

I defenitely prefer TJ’s one, for me the biggest thing is the music, i just love this style and it bring back a lot of memories, that being said I think Anthony can take it to the next level with all his knowledge and his « race to perfection » with all the color grading things. (Sorry if it don’t sound right, im french)

I think Anthony’s style suits the epic brand new car builds or final product reveal, rollers. Tjs style for most content.

Add the B role in the second one to the first one and it’s just about right.

Agree with Calvin on a couple of things. First TJ was better. Second in between those two is the better one. The music though, I agree with Tj he’s trying too hard but in between the two videos is the good choice, literally 50/50 twan needs to actually listen though, this guy was just agreeing to disagree on everything😂 This video is the kind of videos we need for this channel. Just days in the office, vlogy vibes 👌

Tj’s edit Nostalgic 🔥 however Twan had a clean edit as well maybe less of black screen reduce the length on the pause. But hell yea this video was cool both side of the story!