Exploring The Site That Re-Writes Human History
Рет қаралды 809,398
Ай бұрынMystery Boxes are now LIVE! Save up to 45% OFF on Seek Discomfort for a limited time at seekdiscomfort.com/mystery
Or if you are in Europe use link: eu.seekdiscomfort.com/mystery
Special thanks to all the lovely humans that enabled this story for us in Turkey:
Sam Dural
Mehmet Celen(Guide)
Ozgur Colak
Savak’s Grandson Tarik (make sure to visit him if you ever visit Gobekli: gobeklitepe... )
Special thanks to Graham Hancock.. if you’re curious about his work then please check out his books and show on Netflix titled “Ancient Apocalypse”.
Thanks to Jesse Michels for connecting us with Graham. Check Jesse’s interview with him here: • Graham Hancock: Aliens...
Graham’s interview shot by: Oliver Mitchell & Aga Nawój
🙏🏼 Thank you for making these videos possible through your support of Seek Discomfort
⚡️ SEEK DISCOMFORT: seek-discomfort.com/yes-theory
✈ Book an Adventure: travel.yestheory.com/
JOIN OUR COMMUNITY
⁺ Seek Discomfort: / seekdiscomfort
📸 Instagram - / yestheory
🐦 Twitter - / yestheory
🎬 Facebook- / yestheory
☮️ If you want to join the Yes Fam Facebook group which is 100,000+ of our most engaged and badass community members, you can apply here:
/ yesfam
🎥 HOW WE MAKE OUR VIDEOS
🎵 Where we find our music:
1- Epidemic Sound. Amazing royalty free music for KZfaq. Free 30 day trial here: share.epidemicsound.com/wFFbr
2- Musicbed. Amazing label-quality cinematic music. 30-day free trial here:
share.mscbd.fm/YesTheory
3- Artlist. 2 Months Free High Quality Music: artlist.io/artlist-70446/?art...
4- Soundstripe: Get 15% off by using the code YESTHEORY at the link soundstripe.com?fpr=yestheory
🎞 Our b-roll and stock footage:
2 Months Free Stock Footage Videos: artgrid.io/artgrid-114820/?ar...
For an amazing b-roll and footage library, checkout: www.storyblocks.com/YesTheory
📈 Our Most Popular KZfaq Videos
🎬 Traveling to the least visited country in the world: • Traveling to the Least...
🎬 Becoming Superhuman with Iceman Wim Hof: • BECOMING SUPERHUMAN WI...
🎬 We Helicopter Bungee Jumped with Will Smith: • WE HELICOPTER BUNGEE J...
🎙 The Yes Theory Podcast: spoti.fi/3sFdq6v
GET IN TOUCH
🌍 Our website - www.yestheory.com
🌍 Advertise With Us - partnerships@yestheory.com
Who are we?
We believe that life’s greatest moments and deepest connections exist outside of your comfort zone.
Ask us a Question:
Tweet us @yestheory e
@YesTheory Ай бұрын
Hello friends, jumping in here! We are very aware Graham loves to speculate. And that he’s not formally or academically credentialed. Please remember, anyone in 1990 saying human history was likely older than the “academic consensus” starting point of the agrarian revolution at the time would have been heavily criticized before the discovery of Gobekli Tepe itself. Given that, and the remarkable carbon dating and fact pattern of the site, one might say it’s ours and Graham’s duty to speculate? While speculation is often wrong, if it’s followed up by real archeological work, it can be very productive and push human knowledge forward. And often that speculation and work is done by uncredentialed outsiders. For a historical example, just look up the speculations of heavily ostracized German businessman Heinrich Schliemann (spoiler: his findings helped lead to the discovery of Troy! We don’t agree with Graham on everything. And conflating speculation and fact is harmful. We made sure that the distinction is VERY clear in our video. The clear facts around Gobekli Tepe are remarkable on their own and that’s what the video focuses on often reminding the viewer not to superimpose their own biases as to the actual function of the site. Please chime in with any substantive disagreements you have about any of the material here - we’re always open to learning more! But we definitely set a boundary around hateful and uninformed comments 🙏🏻😅 We hope the video sparked your curiosity about the always evolving human story. ⚡️❤️ with love!
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
please pin your comment!
@JesseMichels Ай бұрын
Amen 🙏🏻❤️. Ad hominem attacks and credentialism are only resorted to when first principles reasoning falls short. The video clearly distinguishes between Gobekli Tepe’s remarkable existence - and any more lofty thoughts on why / how it exists and who built it… questions any HUMAN BEING (archeologist, journalist, or otherwise) should naturally ask given its miraculous presence. Thank you YesTheory for seeking some intellectual discomfort!!
@camwilliams566 Ай бұрын
thank you for acknowledging this but with a platform such as yours was there not better options other than the extremely controversial non-archeologist when discussing profound archeological discoveries like this? obviously theres alot more that goes into this but it just seems like he was the first to agree to doing it because you had a huge following.
@miraculous4104 Ай бұрын
@@camwilliams566 why does it matter?
@reddimus11 Ай бұрын
If you wanted to cover Gobekli Tepe that badly, why not reach out to someone who actually knows and understands the archeological site?
@no_alias_for_me 29 күн бұрын
As soon as Mustafa mentioned the dinosaur bone he knew he said too much and left instantly. What a legend haha
@jimijaimz 27 күн бұрын
Dinosaurs 😂
@Corteum 27 күн бұрын
Our ancestors rode those majestic beasts! 😁
@WeMissYouSnail 27 күн бұрын
@@CorteumLook up the Acambaro artifacts. 33,000 ceramic figurines resembling dinosaurs were discovered in Mexico. How could the ancients possibly have known what dinosaurs looked like unless they were present on earth at the same time as humans
@Corteum 27 күн бұрын
@@WeMissYouSnail The puranas says we been here billion of years. many times. see the michael cremo.
@cowboyhank456 26 күн бұрын
@@WeMissYouSnail Those aren't exactly accurate depictions. It's simply not possible for dinosaurs to have been alive at any point during that time. The simpler explanation is that some guy just happened to imagine some things that happened to look like dinosaurs. Humans have been drawing silly monsters for ages. It only takes one guy to dig up some dinosaur bones somewhere for the idea to spread that there once lived giant creatures, and once people's imaginations start running wild, well...
@hooverity 29 күн бұрын
I say it all the time, humans exactly as we know them today have reportedly been around for about 400,000 years. I promise with all my heart, we were not just staring at a cave wall for 390,000 years before we realized a rock can go on top of another rock
@williamanderson9024 28 күн бұрын
I don't remember where I heard this, but it speaks on human development. Similar thought exercise to your statement. Our current rate of technological development, roughly 11,000 years, is repeated nearly 40 times in 400,000 years. What's to say they were using backhoes and massive excavators to build gobeklitepe only to have everything wiped out and reset by any number of cataclysmic event- asteroid, volcano, or weapons of mass destruction. Obviously this is just speculation, but it's an interesting thought practice.
@hooverity 28 күн бұрын
@@williamanderson9024 exactlyy. The cement we make only lasts like 50 years, metal is a couple hundred. We wouldn't even know if they were using power drills 😂
@CharlesLechmere_the_Ripper 27 күн бұрын
Well not 'Exactly as we know em', at least theres yet to be any proof of that. Oldest known 'modern Human' fossil is around 300.000 y/o. And sure they would sit in a cave for thousands of generations, why wouldnt they? Do you see any other apes building skyscrapers, vehicles or just a plain and simple fire? Those furry friends have been around for pretty much the same time and they are still living in the forest dont they? I do believe there is A LOT more to our history, but there is no hard evidence (yet).
@bigblueshoe777 27 күн бұрын
We excavate and date microbial fossils that are older than that. The mere fact that we don't find human ones that old destroys this theory.
@lucaskruiniger9738 27 күн бұрын
It’s not just ‘a stone on top of another rock’. This takes years to build, maybe decades. How can a group of people achieve this without farming or domesticated animals?
@AngryBerb Ай бұрын
Graham Hancock is the Joe Rogan of archeology.
@cern.a 18 күн бұрын
Don't disrespect Graham like that.
@bigdongussarita 16 күн бұрын
@@cern.ayou can stand behind graham but not Joe? 😂
@lalamoop870 Ай бұрын
as someone in the field of archaeology, the name graham hancock always seems to cause a stir lol. a site like this is certainly interesting, because it doesn't necessarily show the earliest form of a culture. carvings like these, the shape of the stones, all of it came from time and practice, not just overnight. i wish i knew more about this particular site, but it is most likely not the earliest form of organization, but that has yet to be discovered! site note: would LOVE to hear more from the archaeologists working on the site and how they came up with their theories about the site. very interesting!
@SpaceFlye Ай бұрын
I like Graham because he challenges the pre-established narratives we've come up with over time. It's all subject to change once more information comes forward about our past. Not to say his theories are spot on, but it's not to see alternative theories about where we came from and how advanced our ancestors were.
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, nobody would deny it was evidence of a civilization. academics are going out of their way to not call this civilization because the people who created it were white, and there is without a doubt a strong anti-white bias in Marxist academia.
@marshallschurtz Ай бұрын
This is how I feel. Also an archaeologist here and agree. They didn’t need to take that angle and talking to archaeologists who work on the site would have great perspectives
@XingAoShen Ай бұрын
@@SpaceFlyeHe actively disregards facts that would debunk his theories…
@cecefisher1590 Ай бұрын
It is actually the oldest extant building. I work in Malta as an archaeologist. We have similar structures en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_extant_buildings
@PK-lh2om Ай бұрын
Graham Hancock? oh this is gonna be some juicy archeology drama then lmao
@JeffinBville Ай бұрын
I"m sure whoever built this place was taught by survivors of Atlantis. At least, that's what Mr. Hancock would say. It lays a dark cloud over this episode of YES theory.
@PaulDidIt Ай бұрын
@@JeffinBville I've un subscribed. If they're buying into this idiots woeful lies, what next.
@JeffinBville Ай бұрын
@@PaulDidIt I'm not going to do that. It's no secret Yes Theory tugs the heartstrings like a teen movie made for girls and they do it on purpose. But that's how you get 9 million subs. With that said, there's still good content here and it's worth watching. But when you have that many subs there's no need for click bait.
@sirashley2355 Ай бұрын
"...but my dad, who was an archeologist..."
@bradys9383 Ай бұрын
@@PaulDidItyou sound very close minded. Have you listened to the other side?
@nuffsaid6229 Ай бұрын
FYI when it comes to the "invention of the wheel", ofc we have had wheel far longer, it's just the oldest proof of a wheel wich is described as the "invention of the wheel"
@DanielGT_93 Ай бұрын
Came here to say this. I've watched a lot of documentaries on this place, and some believe agriculture was born here. Its not a fack, it is an ideia. The same with the wheel
@irissupercoolsy Ай бұрын
Then you have the display of the people from back then using wheels to carry a big piece of stone 😂😂
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
why believe in something without proof? that's called religion.
@DanielGT_93 Ай бұрын
@@AustinKoleCarlisle I work with science. At least i dont believe they had wheel, but its not like they could not. See? it's just another theory, and it makes sense, since they wore advanced enought to make this place, they could have wheels. Let time tell, that site is huge! and they just started learning it
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
@@DanielGT_93 i agree we need to keep an open mind about all of this. clearly the existence of GT upsets a lot of people in the field because they're realizing what they've been taught is based on assumptions and lies.
@HanOle12 Ай бұрын
A suggestion for another place you should visit: You should really visit Bosnia during the Sarajevo film festival in August. It's so amazing and inspiring seeing a country with such big scars suddenly being filled up with young people from all over the world. The whole diaspora comes back and just parties for some week straight, and they're the nicest people despite all the hardship they've been through. The streets are filled with free concerts and raves, and there's just happiness and joy everywhere. Really reccommend!
@FerIgrac 27 күн бұрын
And while you are in Bosnia, visit Pyramids in the Visoko
@lemonlicious6095 20 күн бұрын
@@FerIgrac Pyramid-shaped hills* The "pyramids" are an intentional tourist trap and are kind of like a local legend, similar to Bigfoot. There's nothing in or under them. If you need further evidence of that, the guy who originally called them pyramids admits this very thing.
@udoheinz7845 23 күн бұрын
"And some things that should not have been forgotten were lost. History became legend. Legend became myth. And for two and a half thousand years, the Ring passed out of all knowledge."
@sodabru1764 Ай бұрын
Milo should have a run at this one! "Miniminuteman swoops in!"
@lor3nz42s2 Ай бұрын
hell yeah!
@xliquidflames Ай бұрын
I love his channel and he showed how wrong Graham is.
@rogerelzenga4465 Ай бұрын
@@xliquidflames Yes because KZfaqrs never scammed their audience for money :P
@sodabru1764 Ай бұрын
@@rogerelzenga4465 It wasn't as easy until the snowflake woke mob infiltrated many social platforms and basically made the Dislike button a distant memory, which bothers me almost everyday. When YT murdered the Dislike button, fair and true criticism on this platform died along with it.
@BooksRebound Ай бұрын
For real!
@MoshMob Ай бұрын
"Nothing is set in Stone" oh the irony...
@gildaramirez9948 Ай бұрын
My thoughts exactly. 😂
@doriftochicago Ай бұрын
This is exactly what I said
@bdydrpd8825 Ай бұрын
21:09 begs to differ
@MoshMob Ай бұрын
@@bdydrpd8825 youre funny.
@bitterellaselectricgroove8544 Ай бұрын
My very thought when he said that!
@hollowtahh6860 Ай бұрын
Bro I'm getting chills sitting behind my computer screen, imagine how these guys feel standing there.
@rickycatta5152 Ай бұрын
Graham Hancock is not an Archaeologist. He has a degree in sociology. This doesn't mean his opinion should be rejected at face value (although as an Archaeology student myself it pains me to hear the absolutely wild opinions he throws around without a shred of scientific evidence), but having his opinions put at the same level of credibility of those who studied for years and decades in the field is disrespectful at best. Especially because none of these internationally recognized archaeologists and scientists were given the opportunity to share their theories and actual evidence. I really think you should do a follow up video in wich you give these people and theories the space they need and deserve.
@IanSizzler Ай бұрын
That's the problem. Archeologists stick so strictly to the facts that there is no room for theorizing. Generalists are important for developing theories which can then be tested by specialized scientists.
@rickycatta5152 Ай бұрын
@IanSizzler this is correct, but the problem with G.H. specifically is that he presents these speculations as facts and then whines about "mainstream academia" when the scientific research is actually done and it disproves them again and again, portraying himself as a victim
@akarminius Ай бұрын
Have you put in as much physical ground work as him? Lol this reply is just silly. How many of your textbooks have lied to you? Science is only true until proven otherwise.
@caesurios949 Ай бұрын
@@IanSizzler I think you misunderstand how scientific research works. A lot of research, especially in history, archeology and anthropology may be done using circumstantial, incomplete or otherwise lacking evidence. Because we certainly did not find everything there is to see, any type of avant-garde research can be spotty, incomplete or otherwise lacking. The difference between Hancock and actual researchers is that researchers can admit where their research falls short, needs expanding or further field research to be substantiated. You can put up a theory for an ancient civilization and present evidence for it that may not be enough, but could be just a step that other researchers or you yourself can take to yet another step. Hancock does not take steps, he leaps forward and falls ass first into spikes.
@Jessicahurst1 Ай бұрын
Some archaeologists have been blacklisted for their discoveries that counteract mainstream narratives. A paper isn’t a substitute for decades of research. Failing to consider the points he raises is missing the point of any kind of scientific curiosity.
@spencerz4503 Ай бұрын
For these historic archaeology videos can you put your sources in the description? It’d be nice to know where this information is coming from.
@SuperMo15 Ай бұрын
Sources for what? No one knows for sure what happened 10000 years ago, everyone is offering their best guesses
@spencerz4503 Ай бұрын
@@SuperMo15 well who came up with these theories? What is the theory grounded in, what supports and argues for or against the theories? Or for the intro which gives us some background information. Where does that come from? Huge difference in the validity of information from a journalist and professional archaeologist.
@ghfdsgfhs8ughjnv Ай бұрын
@@SuperMo15but there are archeological artifacts and research papers that are written on these sites. There is a difference between a best guess and presenting a well researched paper with facts.
@tylerb4235 Ай бұрын
Everyone wants to be an armchair explorer
@-KJL Ай бұрын
@@spencerz4503 Graham does the same work as professional archaeologist, only difference is that he provides an alternative explanation
@emmanoiret1637 Ай бұрын
"Nothing is set in stone" while looking at the carvings actually set in stone hahah There will never be a Yes Theory video I dont click on because I just know each time it will leave me with something to think about long after. I must say however that I believe covering something of such importance should have probably been met with an archeologist talking about the site.
@Persistence_run_444 Ай бұрын
Um. They did. Thats who took them to the actual site. And people who are from the area showed them the place and the museum.
@JulianAKAWindy Ай бұрын
the editing of this video was just so on point. such an insane story.
@ellen4956 24 күн бұрын
Gobekli Tepe is NOT a temple. No one refers to it that way anymore since much more discovery has been made around it. People lived there. And it is not the oldest; it's part of a complex of similar structures.
@GengoSenmon 4 күн бұрын
But they are still unsure if people lived there permanently. Much of the evidence suggests the hunter-gatherers would live there seasonally or other short periods of time. There are no stockpiles of grains or other plant food at Gobekli, but there are at some other Tepes.
@nondescriptnorbert Ай бұрын
Where's Miniminuteman when you need him?
@oui2611 Ай бұрын
Graham is on a mission trying to uncover if what we know about human history is wrong. Miniminuteman is someone who tries to disprove people like graham and tell us the established history. You can read whats established in books. it can be fascinating to understand both perspectives but miniminuteman wouldn't challenge us to think beyond what's already been told.
@rok8031 Ай бұрын
@@oui2611 well that's not really true, minimiminuteman provides extra context to ancient apocalypse with Graham left out on purpose because it doesn't support his theory. I'm not saying what Graham is saying is 100% wrong and should be laughed away I'm saying he needs to find better proof of he wants to prove his hypothesis. Because ancient apocalypse is misleading and doesn't tell the full story.
@caesurios949 Ай бұрын
@@oui2611 you didnt watch minimminutemans videos or just misinterpret them to do make believe. he himself said, and i agree, that a lot of progress in anthropology and archaeology has been made by people who have no formal training in the field. the difference is, they use the available evidence to make sensible claims and graham hancock sees natural rock formations in the ocean and calls them roads to atlantis. graham may be correct, but the evidence and arguments he presents are riddled with strong biases or are easily disproven. extraordinary claims, extraordinary evidence.
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
@@rok8031 why would GH include irrelevant information in his own documentary?
@rok8031 Ай бұрын
@@AustinKoleCarlisle well it's not exactly irrelevant, if you say ground scans show a chamber, but you leave out that you are on a old volcano it implies that there is more yet to be discovered, while in actuality it's just a natural occurrence.
@casdenblanken8804 27 күн бұрын
They took him out of the thumbnail and title😂😭
@cowboyhank456 26 күн бұрын
What was it before?
@lemonlicious6095 26 күн бұрын
As they should have. To be honest, they should have not done a video with Graham at all. At best he is a quack conspiracy theorist and at worst he parrots claims rooted in eugenics, racism, and right-wing occultism and esotericism, whether he intends to or not. The best thing Graham could do for his career is to just shut up instead of digging himself deeper into a hole.
@Discover-Hidden 24 күн бұрын
Him??
@casdenblanken8804 23 күн бұрын
@@Discover-Hidden graham hancock
@casdenblanken8804 23 күн бұрын
@@cowboyhank456 graham hancock
@intothelabyrith 29 күн бұрын
Thank you guys so much!! Being from Turkey myself, this video is so well portrayed and educational, a great new perspective to bring. I didn’t even see much content on Karahantepe
@MotivatedGoall Ай бұрын
Just wow, I was so invested during the whole video. We need more!
@Aspenglade Ай бұрын
Incredible! Gobekli Tepe has been on my bucket list for several years now and I look forward to exploring it one day just as you've been able to do yourself. Looking forward to your amazing explorations to come!
@caraupton2791 28 күн бұрын
I just found your channel. And I am SO pleased. I can’t even tell you how happy I am for you to cover THIS topic! I have been obsessed with this discovery for years, and I’m so excited to watch y’all there. This has made me think so much about where we have come from. Maybe our history really IS more like the fictional planet Pern?! I can’t wait for the next part!
@brkncng Ай бұрын
I remember suggesting this place to you guys in a comment from a video from years back. Nice to see that you've explored it
@bjojohnson372 Ай бұрын
Your comment definitely made this whole video happen!! Thank you so much for your cultural contribution, idk where we’d be without you!!
@briees Ай бұрын
@@bjojohnson372you’re so silly
@davidefazzino225 Ай бұрын
I’ve been there last year. That place is truly amazing, the more you look the more minute details you can catch! I’ve also been to Karahan Tepe, it’s even more phenomenal! There you can see pillars still under the earth…not proud to say it but I actually stood carefully on one of them :) Truly magical!
@animalswin2105 Ай бұрын
So so so jealous. My dream is to visit these places. Did you go on your own or as part of a group ?
@davidefazzino225 26 күн бұрын
@@animalswin2105 I went with my family, we rented a car and saw a lot of places all around Turkey
@GengoSenmon 4 күн бұрын
@@davidefazzino225 The Turks ignorantly and selfishly built the nearby Attaturk Dam that flooded out several other similar sites to Gobekli and Karahan from this same time period (~10,000 BC) very close by 🤦♂Forever lost because of Turks, among other historical atrocities committed by them...
@isterbro222 Ай бұрын
Milo Rossi would’ve been the perfect collab for this video
@isterbro222 26 күн бұрын
Yoooo this is firee
@annievalentine3164 Ай бұрын
Now we have to wait until next week!! I can’t wait to see the experience you guys have in the underground dwelling!
@Cutiepatutie888 Ай бұрын
3:34 that dog was chilling love your videos ❤
@YurikRoss Ай бұрын
Not sure if relying on someone known for pushing pseudoscience theories is a good idea. Why not talk to actual archeologists instead?
@kiffenredding8043 Ай бұрын
Because they disregard the site completely
@YurikRoss Ай бұрын
@@kiffenredding8043 yeah from what i read its just a simple temple with no inscription anywhere or any pottery remnant and no evidence anyone lived there. No sign it was part of a civilization
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
@@YurikRoss it took civilization to create this site and all of the other Tas Tepelar sites. if this was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, you don't think it would be called civilization? get real.
@sannie8000 Ай бұрын
Real archeogist digged this site up, and what graham hancock says is already proven to be that old by real archeogist..
@belesir8847 Ай бұрын
@@kiffenredding8043 You only know about the site because archaeologists excavated and preserved it lol.
@Sbtn44 28 күн бұрын
This is amazing! Thanks a lot for your work!
@ShaolinMonk95 29 күн бұрын
This episode is amazing …..we need more stuff like this ❤❤❤❤❤
@ioan.panaite Ай бұрын
Wonderful, as always!
@wardarcade7452 Ай бұрын
While these sites in Turkey are incredible and somewhat blow out our previous conceptions of the origins of human cultures and civilization out the water, they may not even the earliest evidence of the above. One should consider the surprisingly sophisticated art in cave paintings from as early as 40,000 BC in sites on all six continents inhabited by humans - and keep in mind that cave paintings are the earliest known SURVIVING forms of art. However, how many countless other works of art were created earlier on less durable media have long since disintegrated without a trace? Regardless, it's quite amazing what you've gotten to see and thank you for sharing with us (and I look forward to your adventures in the ancient underground metropolis).
@spulwasser Ай бұрын
So after this video I did a bit of my own research: It is not uncommon for people to have settlements as hunter-gatherers before starting agriculture. In fact, the oldest findings for this date back around 20 000 years ago. However it was previously believed that people in the stone age lived in small, isolated groups. The special thing about Göbekli Tepe is, is that it is so big and technically challenging to construct, it is impossible to be done by only a small number of people. So this must have been a collective effort, a cooperation, maybe a civilization - challenging the idea of isolated tribes. It's the earliest known proof for such a collectiveness.
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
@@spulwasser if GT was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, archeologists would have no problem calling this "evidence of civilization".
@spulwasser Ай бұрын
@@AustinKoleCarlisle do you think so?🤔 I would say sub-saharan Africa is more relevant for human speciation from maybe 6 mio - 200k years ago. Fertile crescent like Turkey on the other hand was always believed to be the center of sessile lifestyle, which is somewhat of a prerequisite for civilization
@joeymedina7115 Ай бұрын
It doesn’t take a massive collective and organization of people and skills to draw a painting on a cave wall. So I wouldn’t necessarily say the cave paintings are earlier examples of “civilization” but they’re still incredibly impressive and made by a sophisticated people not just “dumb cavemen.”
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
@@joeymedina7115 where else on earth are hundreds of 20+ ton stone monuments being constructed and carved by hunter/gatherers?
@reporeport 29 күн бұрын
WOW you guys did such a good job!!! damn, thank you guys!!
@DolphinTM Ай бұрын
You should make a VOD channel with no cuts and little edits? Even if it's 2-3 hours long I'd love to watch it
@mikimakotini3893 Ай бұрын
These cultural travel videos are my favorite type of content period. Amazing stuff!
Ай бұрын
Funny how they will call an ancient statue "indecent" for showing a phallus while at the same time selling thousands of phallus-themed souvenirs everywhere in the same country...
@droli7218 29 күн бұрын
Indiscent to the people of that era when it was found at first.. now it's indiscent anymore... I know where u going with such retrospective thinking.. grow up sire
28 күн бұрын
@@droli7218 Wtf are you accusing me of? 🤣 Wtf are you even saying at this point??? Do you have a fever or something? Phallic motifs have been popular in that region for centuries, maybe even millennia, hence why it was so weird to describe them as "indecent". The acceptance of the phallus as a common symbol for fertility is nothing recent as you imply. Maybe open Google next time before you leave an uneducated reply like this. 🤡
@GengoSenmon 4 күн бұрын
The Turks ignorantly and selfishly built the nearby Attaturk Dam that flooded out several other similar sites to Gobekli and Karahan from this same time period (~10,000 BC) very close by Forever lost because of Turks, among other historical atrocities committed by them...
@RichsLife Ай бұрын
I made the video background again 😅 Another great video legends! This has been one of my favorite topics for some time! This was phenomenal coverage.
@drumstick74 Ай бұрын
Awesome _cliffhanger_ episode! Can't wait for the next one!
@DanielleGlick Ай бұрын
Been a fan of Yes Theory for years and am interested in Graham Hancock's general ideas, but was sad to see this video was missing the perspective of a real archeologist with current facts and theories about this site. This site is such an important one and scientists' understanding of it changes constantly, such that several things your local tour guide said are not currently true. This channel has such a huge audience reach, I'm sad this video wasn't better planned or fact checked before publishing.
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
real archeologists are a joke. Flint Dibble couldn't even admit that a rock looked manmade.
@sannie8000 Ай бұрын
What exactly was said by the tourguide that was not true, please explain
@DanielleGlick Ай бұрын
@@sannie8000 there’s an archaeologist that commented below to explain some points. I’m not an archaeologist myself, but I watch enough of them talk about this site in particular to know this video was not all current info.
@SpaceFlye Ай бұрын
@@AustinKoleCarlisle The Graham and Flint Dibble debate was interesting to say the least lol
@Southpaw128 Ай бұрын
@@AustinKoleCarlisle real archeologists are why this site is known in the first place and graham hancock shows respect to the hard work done by archeologists many times. He has problems with prevailing narratives pushing aside new ideas and group think. But we need archaeologists. With better technology, funding, and cross disciplinary work with scientists from other fields, we can uncover more without relying on old methods.
@geraldrhied.villaceran806 Ай бұрын
This is the type of content that I would watch on my TV 3 AM in the morning.
@user-hi6ki5ck8r Ай бұрын
Fascinating!I believe some answeres will not be found.Though in time and place this could be biggest time evolution in human history!Thanks for venturing and sharing.
@KrisMartinezMusic 28 күн бұрын
I HAVENT EVEN WATCHED YET BUT WHAT A COLLAB OMG TWO OF MY FAVORITE PEOPLE/CHANNELS
@ThmSphone 29 күн бұрын
I had a good laugh, it's like calling your uncle that never finished middle school to talk about an archaeological site
@arborn6115 28 күн бұрын
His sources? Trust me bro
@Jouhatsu-oi5qg 27 күн бұрын
The fact that we get free travel videos on KZfaq by Yes Theory is truly a gift. 👏👏👏
@ahleahhook9791 26 күн бұрын
I went to Cappadocia a few months ago to see the underground city. It's amazing and we took communion in the church there can't wait for you to share the story.
@maverick3069 12 күн бұрын
This was such a brilliant video!
@jacksongetthedogg7066 27 күн бұрын
Holy crap. We just found your channel last night. This was our second video of yours. Think we’ve finally found our new favourite channel. Epic work guys.
@n1xtun Ай бұрын
Watched the whole video. Great to see that there isn't a single archeologist in the video, just great. Maybe because they are "just interested in gold" ?
@MoonBoomChannel Ай бұрын
I'm an archaeology student, so to see a pseudoscientist instead of a real archaeologist in a video about Gobekli Tepe is interesting to say the least.
@n1xtun Ай бұрын
@@MoonBoomChannel Yeah, just love when the best argument is "I think" and "In my opinion"
@kiffenredding8043 Ай бұрын
Hey it’s because real archaeologists don’t give a fuck about this place because they don’t want to be proven wrong
@davidm1591 Ай бұрын
People cant have different thoughts? Wild
@Rhartman22 Ай бұрын
@@davidm1591 Not without actual scientific evidence
@tommeyer8288 29 күн бұрын
Absolutely unreal! I never knew anything about this site. Thank you!
@lissyricardo9385 Ай бұрын
been waiting for this video 🙌🏻
@ExcitedSloth_ Ай бұрын
I just finished Mats book for my journey between Sweden and Ireland. Loved it. Thanks Mat and Derin, and rest of YesTheory. Been following you since mid Project30
@andrewo5296 Ай бұрын
Miniminuteman!, help! 🤘
@IanSizzler Ай бұрын
Theres nothing to refute.
@DopeSauceBenevolence Ай бұрын
@@IanSizzlerThey’re giving him airtime.
@theroamingcolt Ай бұрын
This is such a wild mashup I didn't expect but am SO HERE FOR: human creation stories & Yes Theory 🙏
@madigoes 26 күн бұрын
i have been WAITING FOR A video about this!!!! SO HYPED!!! :)
@CaptainAMAZINGGG 21 күн бұрын
Yes same but now I NEED MORE!! haha
@madigoes 21 күн бұрын
@@CaptainAMAZINGGG exactly !!!!!
@louiseburns3640 Ай бұрын
It’s so nice to see Ammar back in videos regularly again I also can’t not acknowledge Thomas’s mystery box ad - **chef’s kiss**
@PatrickSteegman Ай бұрын
First human sculptures; penises 😂😂😂😂😂
@TheLastFullMeasure76 Ай бұрын
This literally left me speechless. Amar, you and Thomas have such a unique way of telling a story that it captures my mind, takes my breath away and keeps me wanting more and more. Thank you Staffan for always putting a smile on my face.
@animus3721 Ай бұрын
was not expecting this but i cannot say I'm disappointed. Great video!
@MichaelJamesNoggin 25 күн бұрын
So amazing! Thank you for going and sharing!
@dweamy1 Ай бұрын
If you follow/watch Matthew LaCroix he is about to go to a site that's apparently either same age or older. Also in this area there are many other sites that have not been excavated or explored, there are stones sticking out of the mountains all over (tops of the T shaped pillars.)
@passerby2562 29 күн бұрын
Where?
@evandercaldwell9993 Ай бұрын
Wow, so interesting!! Can't wait for the next video!!!! 😍🙌 Thank You guys for going to these sites!! I'm giddy to see this underground site!! 85 meters deep, that's absolutely mindblowing!!
@lacoovs 28 күн бұрын
love your guys videos, keep up the good work!
@journeythroughindia Ай бұрын
Excited for the upcoming episode, and that guide is Goood.. 🤝🏽👏🏼
@katherinef5123 Ай бұрын
Waiting for the Milo Rossi response video
@newtrimene8927 Ай бұрын
Be disappointed if he doesn't do one
@E-Lykos Ай бұрын
I mean, the poor guy should have to listen to more of the drivel Graham comes up with but if Milo has the time/will to go at it again I'd love to see it.
@IanSizzler Ай бұрын
Theres literally nothing to refute wtf...
@henryofskalitz5212 Ай бұрын
@@IanSizzler Yes there is, he has actually already done an episode on this site, where he already previously refuted, WITH EVIDENCE the claims Hancock is still making.
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
has he ever shown proof of his degree or credentials?
@x.d.hazard Ай бұрын
I seriously want you guys to consider going to India and explore the ancient culture there. There are very old structures there, you would be shocked.
@DailyShit. Ай бұрын
But only if you find some conspiracy believer for the video to seem cool and interesting.
@DopeSauceBenevolence Ай бұрын
I mean here in the USA we learn from grade five (9 years old) what the Indus Valley was, and the Vedic texts, and the story of Buddha, and we read Siddartha in grade eight. Except kids tend to hate school and learning here, so they probably don’t remember learning it. But it’s not really shocking. We know it’s there.
@user-bj5wu1ug6x Ай бұрын
@@DopeSauceBenevolence do you know there is Bhimbetka rock shelters which is 12000 year old
@jonathang7842 Ай бұрын
@@DopeSauceBenevolence You must of had a really great school to be taught all that and be able to remember. I just read Siddartha not long ago and I'm 21. Great book though, would've been neat to learn all that in fifth grade. In fifth grade I feel like I had a very limited understanding of world history/culture
@neunzehnvierundachtzig 23 күн бұрын
True, There are some temples which are considered to be around 10,000 years old and Temples carved out of mountains, which is an engineering Marvel for even now. The thing that it was done during the supposedly "stone age" where humans ran around with spears. History is all bunch of lies agreed upon. We have so much evidence to ancient Humans, we just ignore it cause it contradicts the western christian viewpoint.
@Duke373 20 күн бұрын
Thank you guys! Your video’s are the best on KZfaq. Thank you for what you do.
@maxdorfler3818 Ай бұрын
So awesome, hat you guys picked up this topic! We humans are much more than meets the eye ❤
@c1llacy8n Ай бұрын
no please dont tell me yall let this crackpot conspiracy theorist take you around this place 😭😭😭
@Tentorkel Ай бұрын
did you read any of his books? there is no conspiracy (and certainly no culprits nor victims), just a story about a hypothetical alternate history with the same outcome. most people that like him and his way of thinking are looking for more that what the world has to offer. that's all. stop throwing shit at people. fcking internet-heroes.
@tommeofficial Ай бұрын
You mean like Zahi Hawass
@braedynhoward3644 Ай бұрын
what is his conspiracy?
@YurikRoss Ай бұрын
@@braedynhoward3644 Conspiracy was the wrong word to use. Hes more a pseudoscience peddler pushing theories about civilization that most likely never existed
@c1llacy8n Ай бұрын
@@YurikRoss yeah ur right i guess he generally just fits into that bucket of people for me and his insinuation that the academic community is trying to "silence" his "truth-telling" is definetely indicitave of that kind of thought
@Daisemiin 27 күн бұрын
Half of this video is about the people filming it rather than the actual site. I did learn some things but overall do not enjoy watching people geek out about what they are seeing. I want to see what they see. Learn about something. I understand how exciting it was for you all, but keep in mind your audience. I personally enjoy Graham a lot and watched this because of his name, and to say he is featured when he is barely in this is misleading and did not sit well. Not a bad video, but not one I would recommend to others either.
@CaptainAMAZINGGG 21 күн бұрын
Then you go see it yourself.
@jackmm8 Ай бұрын
I love this!! One of the best videos I've seen in a while. The idea of an unanswered question, a change from the "norm" or a leap from the known into the potentially unknown embodies the idea of Yes Theory. Its not necessarily a yes this is all correct but, yes I am willing to listen, to think independently, to understand and imagine one was and say yes lets explore something undefined.
@YesTheory Ай бұрын
Thanks for such a thoughtful comment Jack. Sending love ❤️⚡️
@DylanArmstrong07 22 күн бұрын
@jackmm8 Very well said
@joedirt5720 Ай бұрын
*Flint Dibbler enters the chat* 👀👀👀 "Whatcha doin"😂
@poljenol6868 27 күн бұрын
Historians and archeologists should be grateful to Hancock for popularizing this and other sites. Public awareness is the best protection against grave robbing private collectors.
@NotfromDateline 29 күн бұрын
Its clearly an advanced civilisation for the time.
@Skippitydoobup Ай бұрын
Cant wait for part two!
@therealjuanpedro192 Ай бұрын
Thank you for shining a light on this, it is fascinating to know there's been unknown civilization/s before the Sumerians.
@adambartlett6277 Ай бұрын
Fantastic video. I absolutely loved this
@jewel2022now Ай бұрын
This is so cool, you get to really open up the mind to wonder even more. 💕💕💕
@DopeSauceBenevolence Ай бұрын
Wonder is good, but remember to use logic and think critically. Remember that the people who came up with the idea of a globe spanning ancient civilization were white supremacists.
@TheJediBendu 16 күн бұрын
This video is criminally underrated
@taylorfedele6867 Ай бұрын
Ahhh this is the series I live for!
@robinchills Ай бұрын
SO good everytime lads!!
@lorenzstrauss4695 Ай бұрын
please open up about why thomas and ammar are not travelling together anymore - at least it's my feeling that they don't travel together because I barely see you together in videos. I also miss the "i do this with strangers" videos.
@bmarshy Ай бұрын
Dude, they’re not here to make content to serve your wants. They’re not puppets for your viewing pleasure. They’re telling insightful and meaningful stories, not just making videos for people to enjoy while sitting doing nothing. I’m not trying to be horrible, but try opening your mind a bit and see it from their perspective.
@7199Sammo Ай бұрын
they literally just did one in Georgia together
@evoknz Ай бұрын
@@bmarshy Damn you're stupid
@looptimelapse Ай бұрын
@@bmarshy pheeeew calm down budd. Take a hot shower, eat some soul food, stop fapping. You gonna be alright. By the way the dude asked a question, he didn't demand or impose anything.
@SpaceFlye Ай бұрын
the channel has evolved. I for one like their bigger projects. As to their personal relationships, don't care that much, not my business.
@aycaadil4381 Ай бұрын
I looveee my country and the history. I am glad people now seeing the value
@carolbassem1571 Ай бұрын
steffan's giggles warm my heart. i can feel his inner child's joy
@investigatelife8281 Ай бұрын
Cool vid thanks, the museum looks amazing...Graham Hancock though...hmmm
@MooshYT 28 күн бұрын
*_Flint Dibble is going to go NUTS when he sees this_* 🤔😂
@MissNisa-vh8vs Ай бұрын
I remember this site being shown in ‘Ancient Civilisations’ on Amazon Prime Video / Gaia. It’s great to hear another perspective of this and to see Yes Theory explore this site. Great to also get an insight and view of the museum and how this site was uncovered 🙌 Love & peace from the UK 🇬🇧✌️
@Fattyyyyx Ай бұрын
you guy's need to talk to Minuteman
@ajmisirli451 Ай бұрын
My home country ❤
@brooklooker8686 27 күн бұрын
The duo we didn’t know we needed- Yes Theory and Graham Hancock.
@ashman870 26 күн бұрын
I was there in March. Gobekli Tepe is incredible. I saw that statue in the museum so its good to hear the origin of it. When I went to Karahan Tepe there was a flock of sheep grazing in the same enclosure which is crazy considering its such an important discovery.
@DavidS5118 Ай бұрын
Been fascinated by GT for decades and watched many documentaries. Many thanks for taking this trip and sharing...
@jensrs Ай бұрын
Oh gosh. I'm a huge fan of Yes Theory but horrified that they gave this man another platform. Saw the thumbnail and my heart sank. -A career biologist
@xNorth931 Ай бұрын
You're Horrified over that??? how do you even survive in the real world ?
@yuikol14 Ай бұрын
@@xNorth931in English there are things called metaphors, similes, hyberboles. It's ok if English isn't your first language and you misunderstood the expression.
@xNorth931 Ай бұрын
@@yuikol14 She is Horrified. Leave the poor woman alone
@jensrs Ай бұрын
@@xNorth931 Actually by reacting strongly to things and having passions I’ve been able to succeed very well in the “real world” both financially and socially. Sorry if this is a weird concept to you, but having reactions to things isn’t a bad thing and might benefit you. Hope you find your passion someday.
@xNorth931 Ай бұрын
@@jensrs I'm with you girl, Im horrified by YES Theory featuring Graham Hancock on their channel, He is a terrible and harmful person.
@Renezmee 28 күн бұрын
I love this type of content, history is so fascinating!
@katarina6114 13 күн бұрын
Going there in august. It's awsome that you made a video about it before I go there!!
@thejuanderful Ай бұрын
I wish more museums would use replicas and return the stolen artifacts to the cultures they took them from. It's not that hard...
@mariusmustermann4915 Ай бұрын
Ur right, but then they cant Show IT in theirown museums
@Sandeee Ай бұрын
So you mean you want to empty out all British museums?
@IamShemsAldin Ай бұрын
@@Sandeeeyes
@Persistence_run_444 Ай бұрын
This museum is in the country where it’s from.
@johnbyrnes7912 Ай бұрын
Without the effort by the more civilised countries much of it would still be in the ground or lost and sold off to private collectors. Stop being so fake woke ! 😹
@Tobihobbit Ай бұрын
Why the hell would you have a pseudo archeologist on the show like that?
@sannie8000 Ай бұрын
Because he is not wrong about gobleke tepe
@AustinKoleCarlisle Ай бұрын
If Gobekli Tepe was found in Sub-Saharan Africa, nobody would deny it was evidence of a civilization.
@Andrelse Ай бұрын
@@sannie8000oh really gobekli teke was created by the atlanteans who were a global advanced civilization that rose and fell over 10000 years ago? Nah didn't think so. He's just wrong
@mariebischof2111 20 күн бұрын
amazing video!!
@gameplaykingz9545 Ай бұрын
GREAT VIDEO!!!
@jaysengomez51 Ай бұрын
I love the change in content yes theory has had
@loganpeters7543 Ай бұрын
He is so good at ad hominem and red herring "logic" that it almost doesn't come across as making no sense. His first few sentences in this video were beautiful. They were also filled with seeds of distrust and assumptions.
НОВОСТНИЧОК
Рет қаралды 3,4 МЛН