i feel like 2009 is the golden age of 2nd generation kpop.

Sulli used to dance so hard and smile so much! I miss this side of her

Sulli is so energetic and smiles a lot in this performance

저때 진짜 다들 어렸음 설리- 16살 (중3) 크리스탈- 16살 (중3) 루나- 17살 (고1) 엠버- 18살 (고2) 빅토리아- 23살 진짜.. 너무 좋았어 다들🥺🤭

에프엑스 보러왔는데 소녀시대 유리 너무 이뻐서 깜짝 놀라고감....

this world has destroyed sulli's smile . . .

F(X), I like you when you are this energetic..

I think the crowd was full of Amber biases because they were going CRAZY when she had a solo.

난 이렇게 떨리는 가슴을 믿어 아직 모르는 세상을 내게 열어줘요 이 부분은 아직도 들으면 설레네 ㅜㅜㅜ

데뷔초 에펙은 그 나이대에 맞는 노래와 의상이라 너무 좋다

no shades to the new groups or 3rd gen kpop artist, but this was the real deal. When Music shows were worth staying up late for. Now songs are sooo basic.

I swear someone in SM who's responsible for the artists' wardrobe is a huge Detroit Red Wings fan! Luna is wearing a RW sweater here and in SHINee's Juliette MV, Minho was wearing a RW top too. I love when my two favourite things in the world (hockey and kpop) come together :D

샤이니 에프엑스 데뷔 초 무대만 보면 뭉클 ㅠㅠ 그때의 풋풋함이 너무 보기 좋고 그때가 그리워서 헬로우 베이비랑 코알라 매일 리얼리티 챙겨본다 ㅎ

그립다 이때가

에프엑스는 그당시에도 노래가 참 세련되다고 생각했었는데 지금 들어도 세련됨ㅋㅋ

so sad I'm not yet a kpop fan during this time. i miss ot5 really. btw, f(x) got me into kpop esp. sulli.

이때로돌아가고싶다 ㅠ

the only kpop girl group i ever stan.. and probably the first group that i noticed their tingling accessories sounds in their singing.. yeah watching this on new year..

f(x): live before music shows forced artists to be

설리 크리스탈. 걸그룹 그 자체네. 걸그룹 하기 위해 태어난 사람인듯

최진리 양갈래 했다하면 레전드짤 수백만장 나왔었는데ㅜ

Now that Sulli is gone, KZfaq has been recommending me F(x)’s old performances....

Those day when sulli smiled while performing 😍😍😔😭

holy crap talk about amber excitement when you couldnt even hear krystal, but the crowd scream AMBER!!

다들 진짜 어렸다 설리랑 크리스탈 중3이야....

I’m binge watching their lachata, chu, and nu abo stages and im very impressed on how they sing it so well with that bouncy choreographies. I mean they’re mostly using everything of their body from upper to lower and they sing like they’re not moving at all. I know some may have backtrack but you can actually hear them sing like, they got good stamina. I guess it’s the training and all but holy wow. They’re great.

와 저시절 mc 부터…. 노래 소개랑.. 다 뭉클해…..

Such a strong solid unique girl group back then. I never find that kind of group these days Never-ending love for f(x)!

마음아파.... 이때 두잇두잇츄하고 다녔는ㄷ

The first video I saw of them was Rum Pum Pum Pum, and I couldn't believe that they were supposed to be the female version of Shinee. But, now that I look at older performances and their choreography, I can definitely see it. I wish they got choreography like this now; they're definitely talented enough to handle it.

아 설리 너무 밝게 웃는모습에 괜히 가슴이 먹먹해지네..;;

I remember in an interview f(x) said they make all their own jewelry for their performances like they get together and make necklaces and bracelets and its their good luck charms they were soooo cute back then

when Luna and Victoria get more screen time then krystal lol

데뷔초 루나의 교포바이브 진짜 좋음..

look how happy and smiley they are! ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

저 때 정수정 최진리 둘은 중딩? 너무 귀엽다. 설리 보니 눈물이 뚝뚝...

무대 그립다 노래 넘 중독성 있음 한동안 이것만 들었는데….

나도 나중에 슈가맨 같은 프로그램을 보면서 fx같은 어릴때 추억의 그룹을 완전체로 볼 수 있지 않을까 생각했었다 하지만 설리가 없다는게 너무 아쉽다..

아 진짜 너무 귀엽다...옷도 좀 난잡..하긴해도 노출이 없어서 좋은것같아 근데 우리 엠버 머리좀 잘라주면안됐던걸까 엄청 복실복실해보여..

F(x) is just a perfect group. From dance/choreography, visual, vocals, stage presence and concept.

They're like the girl versions of SHINee. XD

Amber looked like a little emo girl I love it lol

와 다 귀엽고 너무 예뻐...

I reallyyyy love f(x), and whenever I watch their old perfs I just can't help but notice that they were waaaaay energetic before. It kinda hurts me when I miss their energy

that scream when amber sing...

When you watch old performances like this, it becomes impossible to deny that Krystal and Sulli seemed to have lost their fire and energy nowadays. :/

I hope their next comeback will be as lively and energetic as this with the same level or even better choreo.

샤이니 FX 노래는 탈한국이었음....10년 지나서 들어도 개조아

에프엑스 데뷔초에는 남초였구나ㅋㅋ 남자애들 목소리 뭐옄ㅋㅋㅋ 완전 극여초인줄 알았는데 소녀시대 내리사랑인가

매일 수백번~ 상상하며 ~ 🫶

Watching this now in 2014, so much feels. They've evolved from cute young girls to such chic ladies. f(x) is the best!

I'd completely forgotten how smiley and energetic f(x) used to be live. But I don't blame them at all. I bet their lives are so tough with all the training, fans and media and everything in between.

when amber came up singing her part then the unnie fans started screaming i was like SAME MAN

풋풋해.......ㅠㅠ 다들 저때로 돌아가고싶을까

설리귀여븐거봐..

Yeah Fans crazh over Amber (x) as members team .. Thump!!!!!!!!!

지금 보니까 진짜 애기다....

OMG Sulli looks so happy😢❤️❤️ lover her❤️

SULLI omggg. so adorable.

Who else can hear their jewelry moving in the background? lol loved it! Fx fighting!!!

Krystal. You have been a huge part of my life for as long as I can remember. I first got introduced to FX by my sister who was an extreme fan of FX long before me. After she introduced me to you, I became absolutely mesmerized by each of the members and their unique styles. Since my first introduction some years ago, I have been a long-time supporter and fan of FX. I have stayed with you over the years and watched you and your group grow up. I will say, at first sight, I fell in love with your striking facial features and ability to capture your audience with your facial expressions. Over the years, I have become acquainted with your charming and strong vocals and effortless dance moves that give all of your performances character and life every time you hit the stage. I have watched you not only grow as a performer with FX, but as a strong artist individually as well. I know you have gone through a lot that has led to your evolution both personally and musically. That you have been able to survive everything that life has thrown at you and make optimistic meaning out of it makes you one of the biggest inspirations to your fans, members, and family. I know you have worked so hard to get where you are now and you continue to work hard every day. Throughout this time of growth you have been such a support for your members and that is one of the aspects about you that I have come to appreciate and strive to learn from. You all as a group have gone through a lot; and I have seen you build each other back up and be there for one another in a way that no one else could. You are such a generous and caring person and I have recognized that as a trait that you have always shared with others. I love how carefree and relaxed you can be, but at the same time, you are humorous and fun. You have been such a joy to watch and get to know over these years and I am so thankful that you came into my life. I know how highly your fans speak of you and I also want to thank you for the loving relationship you have with your fans. You have shown them so much gratitude and shared so much information with them even when you might have preferred to keep some things to yourself. In turn, I know that they are so proud of you and that they feel so confident in the trust that they have in you. I feel a special sense of gratitude towards you for everything that you have done in your long journey of becoming and being an idol. Of course, your journey is nowhere near over and you still have a lot to experience, but you have already done so much in your time that I feel honored to be able to come before you today to thank you for it all. You are so beautiful inside and out and have overcome more than a lot of people can say they have. Thank you for making me laugh, providing me with beautiful music and entertainment, and most of all, teaching the world how to persevere when obstacles come in their way. You will always be recognized as a legendary artist who has created a great story with four incredible artists by her side, but also as an individual as well. I feel so lucky to have someone so hard-working and strong as you to have grown up with and looked to for inspiration. I hope that you feel the worth and see the beauty in everything that you have accomplished this far; and that you are able to see the potential you still have. I want to personally thank your family as well for undoubtedly being a huge part of your success and motivation in an often demanding profession. Krystal, I hope that this birthday surrounds you with and returns all of the passion and selflessness that you have given to the world during your time as a musician, and even before then. I hope that you see all of the hearts and lives that you’ve touched with your story and feel all of the love that exists for you all around the world. On behalf of your friends, fans, members, and your loving family, I wish for you to have the most entertaining and perfect birthday that you can have! Thank you for all of the hard work and sacrifice that you put in daily to make us happy and enjoy beautiful music! I pray that you and your loved ones stay safe, and find happiness in your future. We are so proud of you and we adore you!!! Happy birthday!

설리야.. ㅠㅠ

Still proud watching this in 2015! f(x)

Aww. Still my ultimate fave f(x) song! How I wish they could go back to their debut concept, everything just seem so better back then, and as an f(x) stan from the very beginning, I can't help but miss the old days.

Rewatching past performances of f(x) makes me miss Sulli more. 😢

애기다 애기

omg ! Sulli danced it with all her heart .

luna looks like a princess with all that hair ! XD

Sulli is so adorable!

Amber Liu. Since your birthday is around the corner, I found it to be the perfect time to prepare for the celebration. The first time I ever saw you, it was through my older sister who was, and still is, absolutely obsessed with FX. I have been a K-Pop fan for about a decade now, but at the time, at least 5 years ago, I wasn’t acquainted with many groups. I saw the absolute glow in my sister’s eyes as she showed me endless FX music videos and talked about each member with such love and inspiration woven into each of her words. Since then, I have been a huge supporter and fan of FX, and I have grown alongside you during your most difficult and triumphant times. I know that you have been through a lot, and even saying that doesn’t even come to close to what you must have been feeling for the past several years. I know you have been in the business and making music for a very long time now, and I know you have experienced extreme tragedy as well as glorifying victories. I have never seen someone respond to any obstacles in the mature and hopeful manner that you have. That, as I’ve gotten to know more about you over the years, might be what I appreciated the most about you. I am so aware why so many people, including my sister who introduced me to you, are so inspired by you and desperate to follow in your footsteps. Amidst all of the pain you have felt, sacrifice you have made, and challenges you have faced, you continue to make barrier-breaking music and share your voice with the world through that music. Your response to the problems in the world is so wholesome, genuine and confident; and you have taught many around the world how to effectively recover from any pain they may have felt. It can be understood that you have gone through what many have not, and yet you have not given up on living out your dreams and encouraging others to follow in your footsteps. What has always stood out to me is that you have always been confident, and done what has been best for you, rather than listen to others. You always came off as so comfortable in your own skin, and that makes you such an iconic performer and musician. Your powerful and bold rapping, combined with your soulful, smooth, and energetic voice makes you an incredibly compassionate performer who is so connected to her audience and music on stage. You are an unbelievably beautiful dancer and have such a demanding stage presence that has been such a privilege for me to watch over these years. I know that your fans love you in a way that’s stronger than anybody else ever could. You have given them a reason not to give up trying when the worst happens to them, and there is no higher form of inspiration than that. I am proud to be one of these fans, and I know my sister is as well. Similarly, your members love you and have such an unbreakable bond with you that I have seen firsthand without even knowing any of you personally. I know that you have all relied on each other in such a way that most people can’t say they know or understood, and I can’t even speak on how unique your relationship is with one another. I can’t even thank you enough for coming into my life and showing me confidence, strength, and reliance on my passion, friends, and family in the darkest times in my life. You are an inspiration like no other, and I know all of the fans, and even those outside of them can recognize as such a once-in-a-lifetime authentic musician. On behalf of your friends, fans, members, and most importantly, your loving and adoring family, I wish you the most blessed birthday ever Amber. I hope nothing but love surrounds you and those close to you always and forever. Please stay safe, and I pray that you continue to live your life in such bliss as you do now and have always tried to. I absolutely love you so, so much, and happy early birthday! I hope you have as much fun as you possibly can!

저희 집 말티즈랑 놀때 이 노래틀고 방정 맞게 따라불러주면 엄청 좋아해요 신나서 배까고 발버둥치고 개뛰어다니면서 웃네요 ㅋㅋ

이때로 돌아가고싶다

I really hope fx can deliver a performance as energetic and committed as this one for their next comeback!

watching in 2023 im a 2nd gen kpop fan and i miss f(x) so sad what happened to sulli (RIP). i miss the 2nd gen kpop groups. 😢

설리야..사랑해

저시절 감성 춤 너무좋다

이때가 제일 좋은 때였는데...

설리 ㅠㅠ

설리😊

Their videos will never get old for me to watch, just wish i can see them live. Who knows, maybe one day, meanwhile - GO F(x)!!!!

sulii I love her

I can't believe it's so long ago! After all these years, still the most innovative group in Kpop! RIP Sulli 😭

i miss this f(x) i hope sm will give them a powerful dance routine just like this for their next comeback

Oh my God SULLI!

루나는 어케 메인보컬인데 또 메인댄서여.. 다시봐도 17살에 능력캐

Sulli was so young here.. bright & fresh😢❤❤

2009년 에셈 진짜 잘 나갔구나🤭 Gee, 쏘리쏘리, 링딩동, fx 데뷔...

Amber Liu. The first time I ever saw you, it was through my older sister who was, and still is, absolutely obsessed with FX. I have been a K-Pop fan for about a decade now, but at this time, at least 5 years ago, I wasn’t acquainted with many groups. I saw the absolute glow in my sister’s eyes as she showed me endless FX music videos and talked about each member with such love and inspiration woven into each of her words. Since then, I have been a huge supporter and fan of FX, and I have grown alongside you during your most difficult and triumphant times. I know that you have been through a lot, and even saying that doesn’t even come to close to what you must have been feeling for the past several years. I know you have been in the business and making music for a very long time now, and I know you have experienced extreme tragedy as well as glorifying victories. I have never seen someone respond to any obstacles in the mature and hopeful manner that you have. That, as I’ve gotten to know more about you over the years, might be what I appreciated the most about you. I am so aware why so many people, including my sister who introduced me to you, are so inspired by you and desperate to follow in your footsteps. Amidst all of the pain you have felt, sacrifice you have made, and challenges you have faced, you continue to make barrier-breaking music and share your voice with the world through that music. Your response to the problems in the world is so wholesome, genuine and confident; and you have taught many around the world how to effectively recover from any pain they may have felt. It can be understood that you have gone through what many have not, and yet you have not given up on living out your dreams and encouraging others to follow in your footsteps. What has always stood out to me is that you have always been confident, and done what has been best for you, rather than listen to others. You always came off as so comfortable in your own skin, and that makes you such an iconic performer and musician. Your powerful and bold rapping, combined with your soulful, smooth, and energetic voice makes you an incredibly compassionate performer who is so connected to her audience and music on stage. You are an unbelievably beautiful dancer and have such a demanding stage presence that has been such a privilege for me to watch over these years. I know that your fans love you in a way that’s stronger than anybody else ever could. You have given them a reason not to give up trying when the worst happens to them, and there is no higher form of inspiration than that. I am proud to be one of these fans, and I know my sister is as well. Similarly, your members love you and have such an unbreakable bond with you that I have seen firsthand without even knowing any of you personally. I know that you have all relied on each other in such a way that most people can’t say they know or understood, and I can’t even speak on how unique your relationship is with one another. I can’t even thank you enough for coming into my life and showing me confidence, strength, and reliance on my passion, friends, and family in the darkest times in my life. You are an inspiration like no other, and I know all of the fans, and even those outside of them can recognize as such a once-in-a-lifetime authentic musician. On behalf of your friends, fans, members, and most importantly, your loving and adoring family, I wish you the most blessed birthday ever Amber. I hope nothing but love surrounds you and those close to you always and forever. Please stay safe, and I pray that you continue to live your life in such bliss as you do now and have always tried to. I absolutely love you so, so much, and Happy Birthday! I hope you have as much fun as you possibly can! We adore you so much and never give up on your once-in-a-lifetime artistry. Be safe, and praying for the happiness and health of you and your loved ones always.

F(x) made me believe that hard choreos wasn't an excuse not to be stable in singing parts. Gosh they are so strong.

People should give Krystal's credit for who she is and for what she can do. They should stop saying that shes only famous because of Jessica. Let her be free from her sister's shadow. True... she gained fans because of that but that's not enough reason for her fans to stay as her fans for 5 years. Give her credit for her own talent. Krystal is one of the most talented artist. You cant deny that. She can sing, dance, play instruments. By sing and dance .. I really mean sing and dance not those artists who can't even hit the right note or steps but call themselves a singer or a dancer. Watch her, try to get to know the real her. Don't just be like she's a jung. PS: I've been a sone first before being their fan and no... I'm not their fan because of snsd... I just stumbled upon their video (hot summer) and saw how talented they are.

Luna. You are, of course, a musician ahead of her time, and I want to start with your voice. Though it can be very delicate and soft when you hear it, it holds so much power and meaning. You have this ability to adapt to the instruments and sounds around you, and your voice responds remarkably to the music.Your voice is so smooth and stable; and have such great control of it. I also feel that you are en extremely emotion-filled singer, and you let how you emote navigate the wonders of each song. Your voice is so versatile, and it always comes as a surprise when you try a new trick or approach to how you project your voice. There are so elements that are wrapped up and captured in your voice alone, and there is so much that you release when you sing. You were born with a gift and you were meant to share your pleasing voice with your fans. It heals and speaks for us when we need a voice. All the same, you are an absolutely astonishing dancer. You have such incredible stamina and boundless motivation to execute each choreography fully and with all that you can give. It is impossible not to watch you when you dance because you just exude confidence and dominance. You hit every little movement, every little gesture, and still infuse your own personal expression in with each one. You are really presenting yourself to us in your own skin, and sharing one of the most vibrant sides of you when you dance. Your expertise and professionalism that you have when you dance is unmatchable, and you come alive. You own the stage and you let your body become one with the music. You are so mesmerizing to watch, and as flawlessly as you move your body, we become lost in your movement. Your facial expressions are just as crucial to you putting on an unforgettable show, and you always let them direct the rest of your body. Overall, you are are one of the most influential artists that I know. You (and the rest of your members) are the first to create the unique music, choreographies, and performances that you have; and I know that you are the only one who was meant to share them with the world. You have become a part of some of the most iconic music our generation has seen, and I know you’ve helped unlock other musicians to follow your example. Thank you for doing what has never been done in music and for making your own path. As much as I love your musicality, I love your personality all the same. I love how kind you are and how thoughtful you are of others’ feelings. I believe you are so fun-loving and high-spirited. Your generally cheery mood and brightness is so contagious and lights up no matter where you are! Most importantly, I know you are a great friend and there’s likely nobody that knows this better than your members. I know you have been with them for so long now and you have lived through what you might not have even thought possible. Both on and off the stage, you brought so much stability to your members and your team when it was called for. Every single time, you have been able to ignite the fire in your members and bring them back to their reality once more. I know that they have always looked up to you as well. You have always been incredibly hard-working, and I know this has help to bolster your members ability to give their all to whatever they were working on. They have relied on you for multiple reasons, many of which we have not even been exposed to. Over the years, we could see them steadily growing into the independent and determined young women they were destined to be, and I know that a lot of that is because of the faith that you’ve always placed in them. From the beginning, I truly think that you were able to see a spark in all of them and found a way to bring everyone together. Your members have always known who they are, but I don’t think they would have been able to find their identity without you by their side. I know that they can take any road they want; they will always have the time they spent with you at the heart of their greatest memories. You’ve helped raise them and set them up to make their own choices in life. Thank you for changing their lives, and helping them become who they were meant to be. I want to personally thank your family and parents for raising you and helping you to become the sensational young woman that you are today. I know that they mean a lot to you, and likely could be the reason you were able to chase after music in the first place. I’m sure you already know this, but I just want to say that I hope when life tries to drag you down in the future, you are able to lean on your family. As I always say, there is no situation that you could find yourself in that your family couldn’t pull you out of. When you think all hope is lost and you are alone, I know your will be healed again once you spend time with your family. They love you the most in this world, and their top priority will always be you. They are proud of you even when you feel that you’ve failed, so there is nothing you could do to disappointment them. You honor them every step you take. As your fans, we vow to be as courageous and empowering for others as they are. We keep them in our hearts as you do. Luna, you have showered your fans with only your greatest intentions and your truest self through all of this time you’ve been active and working. It feels like we are such a huge part of your life because of the way you allow us to become a part of it so readily. It feels as if we were figuring out who we were as you were uncovering more of yourself, so it felt less lonely with you staying close to us. You’ve always been somebody to turn to, and even though most us can’t see you in person, this hasn’t taken away from the fact that you have been the greatest comfort to all of us. Just having you around is enough to take our worries away, but you go above and beyond to ensure that our happiness is there to stay. Nothing has been enough to hold us back because you remind us of what we’re capable of. You are so hilarious and entertaining, so every day with you has felt like a party. When we’re with you, it feels like we’re a part of something and that we are with our family. You’ve taken a place in all of our hearts that I know is only reserved for you and nothing could ever change your position there. We’ve learned so much from you, and I know we will only continue to take after your headstrong approach to life. You’ve been the greatest person and idol to take with us through all of our endeavors, and you’ve given us the best memories we could have asked for; similarly to your members. Thank you for working so hard for us for so long when you never had to. Thank you for changing who we are and helping us see the love that exists within all of our lives. I know that you’ve been through a lot; even more than a person should ever have to go through. I know that we don’t even know the half of the work you put in just to debut; and that was just the beginning of what you would have to face. Nobody deserves to struggle through what you have, and it’s hard to even empathize when I know that some of it has been so extreme. Despite all of your struggles attempting to hold you from venturing on, I know that these instances made you who you are. I know that everything happens for a reason, and these rough times wouldn’t have come to you if you couldn’t have made it past them. We are truly so proud of you for holding your own when you are going through a troubling time. You are indescribably strong and you grow more so every time that you are met with such problems. As you go through these trying times, you find out more who you were meant to be; and you teach us how to do the same all the while. Thank you so much for turning our hard days into a reason to be happy and thankful for the world around us again. I know that you’ve really been through it in your life, and many people can’t even say they’ve had similar experiences, but I know that you’re ready for whatever happens next. I hope that all of your dreams come true and that you achieve all that you hope to today. I don’t know when the last time you got to relax was, but you deserve to live in paradise today especially! I hope you are able to look at your fans with great pride and recognition; and that we are able to lift you up higher than you've ever been today as you have always done for us. I hope that those around you also help you to feel as cherished and beloved as you really are. I hope that this day goes down in history as one of the greatest days you’ve had ever; and that from it you only gain memories that are worth looking back on. You deserve all of the success and blessings that have come to you, as well as those that are yet to come. Please have a fun day filled with smiles and laughter! Thank you so much for suffering through so much just to make FX and so many other projects possible. Thank you for suffering through any pain, fear, doubt, isolation, fatigue, trials, hardships, and so much just to bring us the slightest bit of content. I hope that you never feel the need to change who you are because we love you for exactly who you are, and how you present yourself to us. You are changing so many people just be being yourself, so I hope you continue to do so without hesitation. You are beautiful inside and out, and I hope you never forget that! You are perfect in our eyes, and we will support you forever through it all! I pray that you and your loved ones stay safe, and find happiness and worth in the future. Happy birthday Luna, and we adore you so much!

i miss Sulli very much. i hope she will happy

I miss you my sulli...RIP my little angel

my little Jinri with her beautiful smile... i miss you so much Jinri ahh

설리야 난 너의 팬이 아니였지만 살아있다면 우리랑 같은 서른살일텐데 뭐하러 일찍 간거야 더 놀다가 가지... 하늘에서도 맑고 깨끗하게 지내렴.... 영상 잘보고 간다 그럼 안녕 최진리...

에프엑스 진짜.. 열심히 살았다

맨처음 티파니 유리도 진짜 어리고 기엽고... 그시절인걸

Missing those smiles and energy. SM, Please let f(x) comeback. Big fan since their debut. 😭

victoria so beautiful!

설리보고싶다ㅜㅜ살아있음 30대...