I can not believe that TWO people in this video no longer exist. It literally hurts so much.

This was my favorite song on the album but even saying that is hard because all of pink tape was flawless and amazing. It's been a long time since I've been able to listen to an entire album on loop and never get tired of it. Pretty Girl and Step were also awesome tracks omg. Just the best Kpop album ever.

미행 너무 예쁘다 노래도 예쁘고 가사도 예쁘고 노래하는 함수도 너무 예쁘고.. 그립다

Two angels in the same space. We were lucky to have them. Shadow is one of my favorite fx songs.. They all sound so fantastic.

다들 음색이 전체적으로 예쁘고 서로 어울리네 .. 루나 안정적으로 잘 부르는듯 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 짱예 ㅠㅠ

생각해보면 에프엑스 멤버 전부 라이브 잘 했던 것 같다. 라이브 논란되는 아이돌들이랑 비교해보면 빼지않고 자기 몫을 잘한 것 같음. 오히려 저평가된 느낌. 다들 이쁘고 노래도 잘했음. 그립다

아 이때 민희진이 디렉팅 했구나 어쩐지 넘 세련되고 몽글몽글 하다❤

여기 이제 두명이나 없다는게 너무 가슴아프네요.. 대학생때 이거보고 진짜 너무 행복했는데..... 하... 이제돌아올 수 없는 과거지만 영상이 남아있어서 너무좋아요. 감사해요😭😭

The fact that they are actually harmonizing and aren’t relying on the backtrack for that? I’m in love. I can’t believe I got into this group just now and finding out two people in this video are no longer with us anymore.. I will continue to listen to their music. :(

I think Luna looks absolutely amazing in this hairstyle??? And her makeup omg

알고리즘 떠서 뭐에 홀린듯 들어왔다 ,, 눈에 밟히는 아름다운 사람들 둘이 영상에 생생하게 담겨있어서 눈물이 났고,,, 잊으려고 애써 노력했던 9년 전의 향수가 순식간에 그때 미행을 처음 들었던 때로 시간을 돌려놓는 듯해서 맘이 울컥한다 다들 행복하지?

종현 설리 ㅠ 저때는 행복했었던 거겠지? 만히 그립다

Victoria looks so gorgeous. I think this was her best hair era.

This song isn't even a song that you can really smile through. It's has that like nostalgic and dreamy feeling and I don't think it was intended to be happy. I think the real problem would be if they WERE smiling so brightly through this...

suli seems upset when she's singing, but she smiles when crystal is talking. Maybe she just focuses on it.

People really slept on their vocals, didn’t they? So did SM. Shadow is not even an easy song to sing live yet they’re harmonising and sounding amazingly. Also, watching this makes me so sad 😞. It’s so hard to even accept that two people on this video are no longer amongst us.

shadow is actually very hard to sing.

우와 이 곡 진짜 띵곡인데 저는 이 노래를 에뛰드 하우스 광고에서 처음 듣고 우와 노래 되게 신기하고 좋다.. 생각했는데 이게 수록곡이었을 줄이야!! 진짜 에프엑스만이 소화할 수 있는 노래고 핑크테잎은 진짜 명반입니다

This is my favourite song of the album. This album was amazing, in general. f(x) songs are amazing in general. It's quite surprising since I actually don't really like a lot of Girls' Generation songs, I love them but a lot of them sound the same, and the same with Red Velvet actually. f(x) songs are all really different, like this one gives off a creepy doll vibe to me, and Snapshot reminds me of puppets, and Pretty Girl has some R&B plus Luna *swoons* But the most SM sounding song on that album is probably Goodbye Summer with Kyungsoo orz

이 노래 좋더라구요 .매장에서 많이 나오던 곡인데 좋길래 찾아보니 이곡이었던..ㅎ

아... 하모니... 귀가 녹는다...

i love Amber's voice so much f(x)

Oh my god...this hurts. I miss them both so much. Such a beautiful song.

I really like this song, seriously

우와 루나 진짜 잘부른다

I like this song cz it's sound like creepy but makes me listen it on n on.. plus their voices so cute...

Dearest F(x), You are all so beautiful. Sulli - that dress is awesome on you. Victoria - love the dress and your beautiful long hair. Luna - your voice is really awesome! I really love this song - so cute. - Your fan Jeremy

Amber and Luna are allmost dancing their chairs off. Hahaha love them.

음색너무예쁘다

Luna is so pretty!

I Love Amber (My Princess Llama) and Luna (Princess of Smile ====> she always smile, indeed!!) Amber so georgeous here.... f(x) jjiang!!

설리 음색도 곱구나... 영원히 그리울거야

매일 몰래몰래 네 발걸음을 쫓아 항상 조심조심 네가 눈치 못 채게 말하지 않아도 시작된 둘의 데이트 둘만의 데이트 넌 어딜 가니 한 발 또 한 발 난 너를 따라가 아무 말도 없이 날 이끌어 한 발 또 한 발 날 알아챘을까 숨을 곳도 없는데 * 해가 뜨고 나면 발을 맞춰가며 또 함께 걸어가 난 많이 많이 또 빠져들고 있어 달이 뜨고 나면 넌 내 품 안에서 또 잠이 들어가 난 많이 많이 또 좋아하고 있어 하루하루 우린 점점 닮아가는 걸 너의 웃음 눈물 나는 모두 아는 걸 겁 먹지마 우린 태양이 맺은 인연 함께일 운명 넌 어딜 가니 한 발 또 한 발 난 너를 따라가 아무 말도 없이 날 이끌어 한 발 또 한 발 날 알아채줄래? 숨고 싶지가 않아 * 해가 뜨고 나면 발을 맞춰가며 또 함께 걸어가 난 많이 많이 또 빠져들고 있어 달이 뜨고 나면 넌 내 품 안에서 또 잠이 들어가 난 많이 많이 또 좋아하고 있어 거울 속 그 앤 너와 함께 웃고 있어 난 몰라 네 발 밑 속 나는 아무 표정 없이 뒤로 숨는 걸 거울 속 그 앤 반짝 또 반짝 널 닮은 미소가 너무 부러워질수록 난 더 바짝 더 바짝 너에게 꼭 붙어 우린 연결됐는데 * 해가 뜨고 나면 발을 맞춰가며 또 함께 걸어가 난 많이 많이 또 빠져들고 있어 달이 뜨고 나면 넌 내 품 안에서 또 잠이 들어가 난 많이 많이 또 좋아하고 있어 * 해가 뜨고 나면 발을 맞춰가며 또 함께 걸어가 난 많이 많이 또 빠져들고 있어 달이 뜨고 나면 넌 내 품 안에서 또 잠이 들어가 난 많이 많이 또 좋아하고 있어

이거 뭔데 슬프냐

8 YEARS WITH THE GREATEST KPOP ALBUM EVER, PINK TAPE

LUNA is so cute ^_^ awww she looks like she's having fun :D

무슨 이런 노래가 다 있어 미친

핑크테이프 진짜 명반이다

크리스탈 음색 대박 좋네..

진짜 좋아하는노래ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

이무대에서 두명이나 이제 볼 수 없는거네요 ㅜ

This is my fav song of the album. I'm so sad there aren't more live performances of this

I miss f(x).

ㅋㅋ 이 노래 전체가 나의 스물이었다.. 그만큼 푹 빠져 살았다..

Two angels in one video 😔

이때 에프엑스 너무 좋았는데..ㅠㅠㅠㅠ개스엠

내 최애그룹 두팀이 .. 하아

I totally miss fx with sulli and the mc😭😭😭😭

너무 보고싶다 그리워 ㅠㅠ

omg amber's voice!

I Love You F(x)!!!

FX 노래 중 내가 가장 애정하는 미행 ❤ 소녀시대의 낭만길과 함께 몽환의 끝판왕을 보여주는 쌍벽 명곡임 😊

If you people are gg to comment abt them (or specifically a member) has no energy or doesnt smile, I suggest you go run 3km back and forth from your house. See if your still smiling when you are tired. Remember your neighbours are watching, you need to show respect so if you don't smile people will judge you. Can you? This is exactly what they r gg thru. It is tiring for them and they try to put on a smile if they could. If they don't people like all of u will start questioning w/o thinking

Amb and Luna jamming to their own songs aww these cuties

They have got to be one of the most beautiful girl groups in the world.

Happy 10 years pink tape 🩷

그립다 에프엑스 ㅠㅜ

소중한영상…

I'll never get tired of saying this: I FREAKING LOVE AMBER'S VOICE OMG :'D!!!

Best girls in this world

Their voices are naturally perfect....even amber with the boyish voice

The way they just automatically went into harmonies is amazing, most groups i’ve seen that have attempted it have sounded terrible but they sound so good

0:55 lol Key AAAAEEEAAAAOOAAA~ xD

One of the best song out of all SM artists

Miss you guys so much f(x)... Love you forever Amber!

Omg Luna is adorable

I love this song! It's nice hearing everyone sing especially Amber and Victoria ^^

Luna true singer and performer!

We need f(x) comebackkk

Amber and Krystal is harmonizing the chorus??

Victoria and Amber singing!!~ I really enjoy their voices, I wish I could hear more of their singin' within this group!!~ f(x)

요즘 내가 가장 빠져있는 노래ㅜ

looks like key actually knows the song

Wow that last part where Krystal sings she really sounds like Jessica 😳

Sulli

Listening to this again 😍 F(X) COMEBACK PLEAAASE Jonghyun 😭

this is the gem of the Pink Tape album

They are so good at live! OMG! I love all of their voices. I was quite surprised when i heard Victoria and Amber singing. They deserve more lines. Furthermore, I love when they make harmonies in chorus and some other part. Its really hard to make harmony in live stage, but they just did it without any problem :O

I loveeee amber's voice alot. Everyone really sang live and they are amazing :3

와 진짜 오랜만이다…😢

Amber should really get more lines in songs! She has such a good voice.

VICTORIA so beautiful and perfect

Whenever i listen to the song I move my hands to the sounds just like amber in the beginning and key at the end.

i'm not worthy for shadow. gee i'm not worthy for that celestial album called pink tape

핑테나왔을 때 실시간으로 봤던 기억이 나는데..ㅜㅜㅠ

Krystal so beautiful and lovely voice.

엠버 음색 정말 좋음

Couple things: 1. Victoria's voice is absolutely beautiful. Perhaps the tone isn't powerful (think Christina Aguilera-esque) but it is soft, soothing and has this stunning whimsical quality. It seems to reflect her well. 2. Amber's voice is different. The tone is something special, something really resonates with me. I love it. 3. Luna is spectacular as usual. 4. I think it's absolutely adorable that Amber and Luna manage to still keep their energy up despite the fact they aren't dancing.

omg.. f(x) is absolutely gorgeous every single member looks so amazingly beautiful T_T

Amber and Luna are so happy singing ^^ I love them *-*

The LEGEND QUEEN f(x)

This is so good. Listen to it makes me feel happy inside.

I've literally never listened to a single K-pop track before (I keep hearing snippets of Gangnam Style obviously but never watched the whole thing) but I love this

아 뭔데 눈물 나냐고 진짜........

Victoria is pretty handsome in there!!

que lindas #NowPlaying #MúsicaDoDia #FX #에프엑스 #Shadow #미행 #그림자

이노래좋아사 자꾸찾아보게된당

sulli was generally ''sad'' or less energetic during this comeback because she worked so hard

Siempre que veo esta entrevista, mi corazón se rompe un poco más, mis 2 niños ya no están en este mundo y espero estén descansando. Pd. SHINee y F(x) son los primeros grupos que escuche💕 Whenever I see this interview, my heart breaks a little more, my 2 angels are no longer in this world and I hope they are resting.

vic's voice!