Man On Fire has a 39% from critics and an 89% from audiences. That movie is legit. Tony Scott and Denzel Washington brought it.

I guess we will never know what Roths second pull-quote was...?

Remember - Tomatometer: it's not that the critcs give a xx%, but a xx% of the critics gives a good or great grade.

I never knew that not liking "Love Actually" was a thing. Every person I met at least liked it. My father loves it, and he's not an open romantic. It's so not a "girls' movie", it's just a really good romantic movie, point. Also very British (well to me, and I'm neither British, nor American, but anyway...). Aside from the actual love stories there's so much to enjoy - the whole Billy Mack line, the "American girls" piece, the prime minister's awkwardness. I cry at the airport scene, at the wedding scene when the musicians start to pop up and play All You Need Is Love and at the funeral scene. I totally get why Notebook is cheesy and actually I have to close my eyes to a few things to enjoy the romantic side of it, but Love Actually is a completely different category, it's smart and stylish and much more realistic in terms of the iterations of love, in contrast with the stories themselves that are a little cliche (deliberately I guess).

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull is definitely one. 77% on Rotten Tomatoes! HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE?!?!?!?

How is Hot Rod not mentioned at all?

This could be a whole weekly series, 10-15 minutes talking about 1 movie. Sounds good.

Since they brought up MacGruber, does anyone else think Hot Rod is stupidly/absurdly funny? The whole LSD scene just cracks me up. Then there's riot scene. Mmm, so good. Anyway, Compared to MacGruber's 47% Critic score and 37% Audience score, Hot Rod has a 41% Critic Score and 64% Audience score. I really thought MacGruber was funny, but Hot Rod just hit the funny bone a little harder.

John Belushi is the Jim Carrey/Chris Farley of the older generation. In reference to the comment of the comedian of their parents' generation.

Rip. The one time I join for the live show.

Clue, Spaceballs and Tommy Boy were my childhood favorites. I don't remember a time where I had not seen those movies. I quote them all the time!

I would add The Secret Life of Walter Mitty to the mix! Such a beautiful movie!

But "there was a FIREFIGHT!!!" I love the Saints..

I would add Equilibrium to that list.

Critics hated/mixed reviews on Darren Aronofsky’s “The Fountain” but I loved it. I saw it twice in the theaters. I have the DVD, the Blu-ray, the soundtrack, the graphic novel. It’s one of those movies I have to watch at least once a year, especially if I’m pondering the meaning of life.

Spaceballs and Empire Records are favourites. The Notebook was a really good romance and Gosling was absolutely hot in it.

The Thing (1982) only has a 17% from the "Top Critics" and a 92% from the audience. That's a crazy discrepancy. o_O

“Bewildering haircut” might be my favorite combination of words ever said.

Biggest Mel Brook's underrated movie is Dracula Dead and Loving It

'"if you're a bird, i'm a bird!" That shit's romantic!' LOL

I always love the part when the Driver joins in in singing Good King Wenceslas.

"You learned English" "Just in cases" 😭

I laughed!!.. 29:46 one of the best SJU moments ever!! x'D

I will never understand how Nacho Libre is not 100% on Rotten Tomatoes

Boondock Saints (part1) is a movie that I watch at least 2-3 times per year since it was released. LOVE IT.

LAST ACTION HERO

You guys are really funny 😂

I never knew that about Clue! Mind. Blown.

When looking to see if a movie is good or not I usually check imdb or IGN. I dont really look at rotten tomatoes. Is that a good thing or not?

Great episode, I would add the 80’s romance “Somewhere In Time” @ 59% rotten and 88% for audiences. It has a beautiful track like “Out Of Africa” both by John Barry.

I agree with Roth's comment about how perfect a movie is should be judged on what it set out to do. Thus, we get perfect comedies, dramas, action movies, horror movies.

Roth, I was COMPLETELY in agreement with you and Dan when it came to the Greatest Showman. I think it would have worked better had it been fictional and they went all in on the message presented in "This is Me". "From Now On" is the song I enjoyed the most and it actually made me a little emotional, but I'm also the type of person who cries during the opening crawl of Star Wars. It tricked me into thinking the movie was better than it actually was. Music has a way of doing that *cough*Dual of the Fates*cough*.

Hot Rod! One of the most unique comedies of the 2000s.

Why was Roth the only one giving any input about The Notebook?! C’mon guys...don't be so shy! I loved The Notebook and actually saw it in the theater when everyone else waited for the DVD. And I agreed with the screen junkies review of The Greatest Showman. It was dissapointing

Can we get a full album of Roth singing hits of the 90s? Yes, please, thank you.

no live show :(

Lol....Jackass 3D is legitimately one of the few movies where I was OK with it being 3D since it was a hilarious gimmicky use and everyone was 100% on board with that... kind of like the train in one of those first moving pictures ever made rushing at the screen..it perfectly made use of the gimmick.

I remember one review when Spaceballs came out, saying something along the lines of "Why are they parodying Star Wars? Nobody cares about Star Wars anymore." LOL. It stuck in my mind, because even as a 12 year-old, I thought that was a pretty dumb thing to say.

Austin Powers 💖💕

The movie Lon was talking about is Safe Haven! :D honestly, I loved it. But then again I just love cheesy shit. Always here for it 👌🏻 and Josh Duhamel is an absolute babe 😍 a “plot twist she was a ghost all along” movie that bothered me more was Charlie St Cloud 😅😅

The Cable Guy has aged brilliantly.

I actually love the notebook. I think it is fantastic.

I cry about 3 hours after I finish Love Actually and I realize I've spent another 3 hours trying to understand that completely incomprehensible movie.

THE F*CKING SANDLOT

Boondock saints was a great movie. I don't know how all of you just thought the movie was bad. I mean it's ridiculous but in a fun and awesome way.

i cry when the movie is about to start, and i go "noooo, not again, this year also? fml.."

Based on what Roth said about "Rate a film on what they set out to do and did they achieve", one of my favorite movies of all is the low rated (both by critics 28% and audiences 42%) comedy "Take Me Home Tonight". I think its a very good homage to the 80s classics films, with a great cast and characters. I love how every character from this movie is going through some sort of life crisis, even though the film is mainly focused on Topher Grace. Anyway, I really don't care what people think about this movie. I just love it.

Sleepaway Camp is incredible, it's comedy gold

Die Hard with A Vengeance 52% on RT Live Free or Die Hard 82% on RT Now let that sink in....

I remember Empire Records because it use to always on USA at one point, it's vary mid to late nineties movie, but I'll still watch it if I come across it. I also remember when the Boondock saint documentary Ebert mentioned he was worried about the director because he clearly came off as an alcoholic who need help badly.

I did not care for “The Notebook”. I was so thankful for your Honest Trailer for admitting that it had flaws!

Not Another Teen Movie is one of my favorite spoofs .. yet.

Yay Lon!!

god i love roth so much lol " you just described my yesterday " and i too hold ace ventura so so close to my heart.

I loved the humming the guys did during Roth's rant on The Notebook. Made me thing of Animal House.

I’m always happy when Lon shows up.

If you're a bird, I'm a bird.

god i love roth so much lol " you just described my yesterday "

I'm not mad at you, but I also loved The Greatest Showman. I was excited to see the movie but I saw your review before and was scared that movie would be bad since I respect your reviews and most of the time I agree with you. But my expectations were so low I enjoyed even more. So thanks for that! :)

HERE COMES DEAN KOONTZ WITH A STEEL CHAIR!!! omg... Spencer, you kill me...

Hello @Screenjunkiesnews

Where can we find overnight?

I've never seen the theatrical cut of this movie because I've heard it's completely different from the cut I adore, but Alexander. I'm pretty sure even audiences hated it when it came out, but damn do I love the three and a half hour "final cut" of the movie.

Not sure if this is more "critics got it wrong" or just my personal guilty pleasures but I love Wanted and Repo Men (the one with Jude Law). So many genre movies now are almost embarrassed to be genre movies, but both of those are just so fully committed to being the type of movie they are and have a lot of fun with it.

Love, Actually... cry at “Just in cases” 😅💕

The funny thing about RT is that the whole point is showing the diversity among critics, but it's used almost exclusively to put all critics into the same basket.

Spencer with the Mira pose

Love empire records it was massive here in Australia, same with boondock saints. I think everyone in my and my older sisters friendship circles rate them super high.

Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me and Spring Breakers

need a new graphic "JTE & Billy Business save the day"

Young Frankenstein directed by Mel Gibson is a new dream and also a nightmare

I've never even HEARD of Macgruber.

With Empire Records watch the original cut not the re cut edition that they released on DVD first called Remix Special Fan Edition. There was some strange interference to make it more audience friendly for the DVD release it made a rather mess of the movie. Real strange to think about with studio meddling these days for theatrical releases.

I heard something negative in the tone when you said The Notebook isn't The Lakehouse. I don't appreciate that, I got the feeling everyone was dissing The Lakehouse... I like The Lakehouse. I'm not supposed to, I gather, it's bad I'm supposed to think. But I don't, sue me (please don't). Keanu Reeves and Sandra Bullock and strange time-shenanigans and things. Oh I just love it. Keanu Reeves and Sandra Bullock hitting it despite all in the end makes me happy...

Notebook and A walk to remember are my Spark movies.

These are movies I like enough to own in my collection with crap tomato scores and way better (like fresh level) audience scores: Secondhand Lions, I am Sam, The Man Who Knew Too Little, What Dreams May Come, The Mummy(1999), Penelope, I Robot, Elizabethtown, August Rush, The Thief and the Cobbler, The Book of Henry, Only You, Corrina Corrina, The Lake House, and Where the Buffalo Roam. I guess I don't have a critic's taste. I like movies that get me hooked on characters and make me feel. Corrina, Corrina is one of my favorites and The Man Who Knew Too Little is hilarious.

You guys didn't even mentioned "Fight Club". It has a good score at Rotten Tomatoes NOW but at the time the movie came out, critics bashed it.

I'm one of the handful of people who actually saw MacGruber in the theater. Me and twenty of my friends had the whole screening to ourselves on opening night and we had a blast! I haven't laughed that hard - so consistently - at the theater since that day! KFBR392

You're a true Row-MAN-ick Roth.

Space Balls, the critics were right. A parody with no understanding or love for the films they were mocking. Dude cast John Candy and failed to give'em a single punchline. Mel Brooks gave us three of the greatest comedies of all time. History of the World was a simple message,""I'm done." Space Balls: "You didn't believe last time?"

The Majestic. :)

"Great use of 3D"

I LOOOOVE "National Treasure"!!! I just watched it again a few days ago on Amazon Prime.

Roth, I'm with you, I love the Notebook!

How can you be sat next to that '2001: A Space Odyssey' style set piece and not bring it up in this category!? :(

I want a Mask, Dumb and dumber, Ace Ventura, Crossover!! The Jim Carrey universe!!

"Excuse me I would like to Ass you some questions"

NOTEBOOK IS AMAZING!!! NO QUESTION! AND YES I'M YELLING INTO MY COMPUTER!!!

i loved the earth girls are easy movie classic 80s movie ;) the first movie that ever made me cry was armeggedon lol

Safe haven. It was Nicholas Sparks meets m. Night shamalan.

Just because a movie is a fan favorite doesn't mean it's good. I mean, I find Showgirls to be very entertaining and funny (unintentionally) however I wouldn't be caught dead saying it is a good film (though Gina Gershon gives a great performance as Cristal Connors, probably because she might be one of the few who knows what kind of film she's doing). I enjoy eating a Cheeseburger. I wouldn't say it was good for your health. And a film isn't good just because it was commercially successful or else Steven Seagal missed out on an Academy Award nomination for Under Siege.

Every time Joe says something funny, I burst out laughing. He's fun to listen to.

Clue is amazing. One of the most underrated and rewatchable movies

No rocky horror picture show?

Nothing beats the masterpiece that is Jack and Jill

They went FULL Jim Carrey. You never go FULL Jim Carrey.

The Jim Carrey of the 70s was obviously Andy Kaufman...

Modern classic..... BATTLESHIP LOLOLOLOLOL

1. When Sam comes back to his father after his first kiss 2. When Mark shows the signs to Juliet 3. When Jamie proposes to Aurelia Love actually has the most uncheesy, romantic, chillworthy moments of any movie.

Most of the reviews I've seen on The Greatest Showman are that the movie is terrible from a story standpoint but it is enjoyable solely because the songs are fun and make you feel happy. I've not seen it. It doesn't sound like something I'd spend money on based on those reviews. It's been a bit since I've watched the review here on Screen Junkies but I do feel that the review is in line with other reviews minus commentary on how fun the songs are. I think you guys did your job to warn people that it's probably not something you want to spend your money on. I did see Pitch Perfect because that review here said it was a delightful fun movie and that was exactly my experience and what I was wanting the day I saw it. I also saw Paddington while I was sick over New Year's because Roth recommended it so highly. I didn't get out to see Paddington 2 this weekend but look forward to watching that sometime over the next week.