Metallica did two sets of "S&M" concerts. The original set was back in 1999, and then S&M2 was in 2019. No Leaf Clover was one of two songs written specifically for the first S&M concerts, and they brought it back for S&M2. They've also played it occasionally out on tour when it's just the band, but it's definitely best with the symphony. If you ever get a chance to watch the full S&M concert videos, they're incredible.

I was at their first S&M show in San Francisco in 1999. It was such a powerful and exciting and need I say amazing night.

It's interesting to me that even people who don't think they're metal fans start head-banging after they listen for a while. It must be a natural human reaction to the beat.

Metallica is a legend, known all over the world. The Mongolian metal band The Hu did a cover of "Sad But True". They mix traditional Mongolian instruments with Classic metal instruments.

S&M was one of the most under the radar Albums ever and my favorite song on the album.. I'm really enjoying your reactions Rosalie. Keep up the great work.

Metallica and Symphony is my favorite CD Set ever.

Love this song. Seen Metallica 5 times live. They are the goats

Orchestra arrangement was done by the late, great Michael Kamen. He also conducted the first time they performed it, with the ochestra. 🤘🧙‍♂️🤘

Out of all Metallica songs this is easily a top 10 for me if not top 5 love this song. I got to see it live last year.

Your mouth was wide open the whole time love this with the strings it's powerful it fit perfect with the symphony keep rocking been around for 40 years and still going that's why they are the biggest band in world

I listened to Metallica growing up, but when the original S&M came out that became my favorite version of all their songs. The 2019 show is very solid, I feel the 1999 version is a bit tighter and the sound engineering is over all better.

"No Leaf Clover" was a song written FOR THIS Event. It was not a song that the symphony helped cover of one of their previous songs. It was written for an original composition with the symphony.

I have this concert on DVD and just watched it again last night. It is a great concert, and I truly believe that heavy metal and symphony were made for each other. Great reaction!

Mythic band for sure ! so many good songs to pick..... here one I love: "bleeding me".

Metal is like mirror of or for love ..dont be afraid..we r jus a common mans,who loves the beauty of music and life . .

I love when he sings “then it 🎈COMES 🎈to be.” I think it’s genius how James goes really high on the word “comes.” It sounds off key on that word, which makes it sound so cool. Reminds me when Peter Brady on the Brady Bunch is singing with his brothers and sisters, but his voice cracks, because his voice is changing with his age. “Then it ⬆️comes⬆️ to be that the soothing light at the end of your tunnel.”

*"Hero Of The Day" is one of my favourite MetallicA tracks EVER and the "S&M" - version is as good as the original studio version from "LOAD".* 🎵🔥🔥🎵🎸🥁🎸🎵🔥🔥🎵

Thanks for being a watcher who lets the vid play! Been a 'tallica fan for 27 years now and I started tearing up a minute in, a band that speaks on so many levels! Gonna check some more of your vids out now good luck with the channel 🤘

My favorite song from that concert are All Within My Hands, it's just so powerful in all the right ways, I was definetely surprised when I heard that one.

When the maim riff starts for the first time and James pushes guitar down in rhythm, makes you wanna smash something, so powerful :). 2:00

The s & m album is one of my favorites. I'm 42 been a fan since a kid. Love the orchestra mixed in. Great mix

You should react to Metallica Harvester of sorrow, Moscow 1991. They were in their prime and the crowd, consisting of a million people was going crazy .

The idea for the collaboration was put forward by the Symphony leader, recognizing the natural seamless blend of the two.

I was at this concert. It was amazing!

Fun trivia fact. The lead guitarist kirk Hammett bought that guitar for $4 million dollars at an auction.

Amazing you would never of thought metal band and a orchestra could sound soooo good love this

This is your 3rd reaction that Ive listened to. Not including your perspective on why people watch reactions. I'm a Fan so far! I like that you chose a less known song by Metallica & that you admitted to hearing some if their more well known. I think a lot of reactionists would look for the most popular & try & convince their viewers it was the first listen. Excellent!! Due to the therapy angle; you should do Metallica 'One' ..... I think that would be excellent!! If you've heard the song; you could always say Review/Insight.....?

Yes... Moreee.

Best live band ever !

This song has only been played live - it was never recorded or released as a studio album track It was originally written and peformed for the first S&M concert in 1999. The version you are listening to now is from the S&M2 performance - 20th Anniversay of the original.

You should try Epica and to go easy on you start with Sancta Terra ft Floor , full orchestra and choir. Live Retrospect concert.

Best song ever

When they played this concert live you could watch it live in any cinema all over the world. I am from the Netherlands and I watched it live in a cinema... one of the first bands to have done this. Big fan

Metallica is like a fine wine, they get better with age!! They're great, great band!!

I remember when this song first came out back when portable MP3 players could only hold 3-4 songs and this was the one song I always kept on it.

After their first S&M Concert in 1999, Metallica said this was some of the most difficult things they have tried. Because usual they can improvise a bit during the Concert but when you have an Orchestra with you, that suddenly becomes a lot more difficult and you need to be more diciplined than you would normally be at a Concert.

No leaf clover is one of my favorite song by Metallica.

Esto es una obra de arte

You should definitly check out the OG 1999 Version too! Amazing song

LOVE THIS SONG!!! !!!!! LOVE METALLICA !!!!!

They are both great.

S & M ( Symphony and Metallica ) is always so good to hear. Metallica put out a video called S & M. That's always an awesome listen.

Hi there Rosalie... You caught the cat by his tail... the first release of this track was on the turn of the millenium... you should check that version (not react, but just check it, the sound is so much better and we all can apreciate a younger James pouring his heart out) At that time the band as we knew it was falling apart... fans didn't like the way the band was going (personnaly, I love what they've done, because they went out of the box on what a metal band should sound like and, as always kept an outstanding lyric content to their sound) and James was dealling with personnal issues... So... he felt like he found that "no leaf clover" and we all felt it... P.S: Mickael Kamer, the Maestro of the original S&M concert, that composed with Metallica this piece and the other orinal composition made for this particular gig( minus Human) , unfortunatly is no longer with us, said that he proposed this collaboration because metallica's sound stripped of the eletrical aparatus was pure symphony... Take care... stay safe...

The S&M concerts are amazing. This is one of the better songs because it was written specifically to be played with the orchestra. However, their songs are so well-written, that it's easy to weave the orchestral music into so many of their songs.

As someone who listened to the song straight for 2 months, im so happy to see this. What was it.. 98 -99? I just came home from the bar, pretty pissed and i wanted to listen to something old. I search for this song, i see it, but i see your video just below. Im thinking.. oh ok, yet another reaction vid, but lets give it a go. The looks on your face, the.. uhm.. everything after that, just makes me wanna say: If this was really your first listen, do it again. Aand again. And so on.

This is the best. Thank you!

i love it

You should've reacted to the first one. This one is great as well but it was more energetic in 1999

It was originally written for use with this symphony - arranged etc specifically in unison. BUT knowing Metallica and the time in which this song was written, it could very easily depict struggling with sobriety.

There is hardly any bad Metallica. I enjoy it all. But being the old one that I am . My first album Ride the Lightning then And Justice for All will always be my favorites. It is still great to see how they spread their horizons.

Always a pleasure sharing a reaction with you! Metallica was my very first and still one of my favorite groups. It's interesting how music taste evolves over time. It's been in interesting journey with so many branches. The main trunk of that tree for me is Metallica -> Apocalyptica -> Blind Guardian -> Nightwish -> Epica -> Sabaton - The Warning. All of these groups beyond Blind Guardian, i've discovered by watching reactions and analysis online. I love going back and watching reactions to music i've loved since I was a child just as much as discovering new music, so keep up the awesome work Rosalie, you're doing great! Always looking forward to the next!

Well Done 👏

Outlaw torn or bleeding me are great ones from s&m

For Metallica try "Enter Sandman" or "Nothing Else Matters". For another great band I would delve into the world of TOOL, maybe do "The Pot", "Stinkfist" or "the Grudge" to start.

Es increíble como son capaces de hacer una unión tan bien acompasada, una canción espectacular musicalmente una de las grandes en la historia de la música

I could see them live many years ago. Metallica es like a train that runs you over and inside you.

Both were awesome just watch the video

Best

As always great reaction Metallica has alot of iconic songs I also dont listen to them very much but I have heard most of thier early stuff I am more like you when it comes to rock music I tend to stay away from alot of metal I have heard quite a bit of the bigger groups but not really what I listen to on a regular basis I will say this one was different with the full orchestra I didnt mind it at all thanks for the ride and as always your ride or die forever Eyy Oooo

their music fits a symphony pretty well ladies and gentlemen

You should check out the new metallica video from the Elton John tribute concert. It came out the other day, the song is called Funeral for a friend/Love lies bleeding in my hands

You have to check out fade to black, listen to the original version from the 80's it's on the ride the lightning cd. So awesome my favorite Metallica song ever

love this song. and your cute when you pull your nose up lol

I recommend you react to enter Sandman by Metallica 1991 Live in Moscow next is One by Metallica watch the original video next it will completely be up to you but Metallica actually made a film through the never by Metallica Watch the first 2 videos before you decide on watching the film

My name is Kim so I am here all sad and alone, pretending that this song was for me, haha!

🤘🤘👍👍

The greatest band ever, I love these guys! Wir machen von dir ein Metalhead Rosalie, bestimmt! 🤘🏻

Very glad you didn't pause it , Watching your face was enough..

🤘👍👍🤘ed

a lot of people when the put Christmas lights and they move to music, use this song., pretty cool. Beats any Christmas music I ever heard. "Josh Weathers at The Kessler Theater in Dallas, Texas ' copy and paste. I love all of your reactions. I would like to see what you think of this.

Metallica, a band from America [and so on]"; she introduces them like they were just a normal old band-it just sounded secretly amusing. A little old band from California: should check out the 80's works eventually. Or like the live performances in Seatle 89 or Moscow 91. Well done

S&M is an absolute masterpiece of arrangement where metal meets classical. If you like symphony sounds of music, try Meat Loaf with the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra. It is truly a treat for the ears.

System of a down - chop suey.. reaction. Thanks you very much.

Definitely one of my favorite albums of all time is the first S&M. Michael Kamen arranged and conducted the orchestra. Sadly he died in 2003. I think this version from S&M2 is just OK. The first one was amazing.

I'm sure I'm not the first one to say this, but I would strongly suggest watching the official music video for "one" of you haven't seen it. The song might be heavier than you prefer, but the video is SO powerful and moving!

Kirk has the most heart in his solos. He is a beast and for me the best of all

Always loved this sing, but for some reason I just feel like the 1999 S&M version was just better overall. Can't explain it...but it just is.

Is Kim has polish roots? I've heard polish surname. :) Greetings from Poland Kim!

You specifically mentioned the guitar that James was playing ... That guitar was built from wood reclaimed from the garage that the band first rehearsed in. The inlays in the fret board of that guitar are a history of the band.

please can you do metallica where ever i may rom s and m i know youll like it

Great reaction , i think u should listening to outlaw of torn song ( S&M )

Please do a video for halo on fore ( from the S & M 2 ) concert

Metallica Brasil

Love your reaction. Please listen to Orion from the through the never movie by Metallica 👍

Love your reactions!! I’d love it if you would react to PENGSHUi from London. I think you’d like them 😎

It doesn’t get much better than S&M1. I know many people like me that would (and still do) fall asleep to Metallica and the San Francisco Symphonic Orchestra. Symphonic Metal rules!

You should research the song one by metallica and the movie its vedio is from its very powerful. Check out tool's 46 and 2 and what the meaning is behind the lyrics, it might be interesting to you also.

James is so beautiful bro

hellos from Istanbul, pls also react to Metallica - Minus Human

Kirk looking fancy with a 2 million dollar guitar 🎸

Have you heard of the band red? Let Go by Red from the album End of Silence. They are similar to NF in the way that, they are christian but they don't label there music as Christian you will see what I mean when you listen to the band red. The band is just called Red but to look them up type in THE BAND RED. You don't have to have all caps.

You should react to scorpions still loving you.

the first version of S&M1 is better

i like that you did S&M2 it was a little slower and true to time and I was there lol

It's been well addressed in some of the comments, but it can't be overstated... Metallica is THE PROTOTYPICAL METAL BAND. PERIOD. It's in the name. (Actually wrote this comment before you started your epilogue) Metal was 'hard rock' until Metallica gave it a formal name. There were others before that were heavy, Sabbath and Zeppelin, but this band perfected the sound and swagger that is the DNA of metal. It's not your fault for not knowing who Metallica is. I blame your parents😳 😂 NO LEAF CLOVER is written for this performance and it STILL hits on all cylinders after 40 years. To better capture the evolution of the band you MUST listen, and if you need to react, to their early releases with their bassist Cliff Burton. A young MASTER of theory and composition that literally launched this band into the highest echelons of the Rock Gods.

That's why I try not to discriminate... There's art and everything

PLEASE REACT...pearl jam black mtv unplugged👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

More Metallica 🔥🔥🔥🤘🤘😂…..Next one; “One” live in Nimes 2009 in an ancient Colosseum 🤘🤘🤘….it rocks otherworldly 🔥🔥🔥🤘🤘🤘

reaciona a DIANA NAVARRO SOLA (SALAMNCA 05 )

First version is better