What if, instead of a ghost, it's E Gadd and Toadsworth? It keeps the parallels intact.

Donkey Kong actually made his debut in Donkey Kong Country. The Donkey Kong you see in the 1981 game is just a younger Cranky Kong

Just stumbled to this channel and you have great comedic timing!

I sat through 21:24 of Spider-Man lecturing me about the dangers of cars. Thank you Spider-Man!

Good News, new characters are coming to 8 Deluxe as Birdo has been announced for Wave 4. Here’s hoping for Petey & Funky Kong returning.

This is certainly one of the JoeFredrick videos of all time.

You say some of the baby characters are non-canon, but I bet you wouldn't be complaining if it was baby Waluigi.

I would say instead of Olimar, put the Captain in the game. We have both Mute City and Big Blue, just add the Captain there and people will cope that F-Zero is now just part of the Mario Kart franchise

12:21 Rosalina was created to be a bigger character so they’d have a Heavy weight female character in Mario Kart Wii

Kamek should replace star bunny but other than that, you did well I would say.

I love what you did with Mario Kart 64

Love the video bro, keep it up

Really great video! Surprised you don’t have more subs keep up the good work :)

Starbunny is indeed cute, but not exactly the kind of character built for racing. Personally, I'd added Shy Guy in place of Baby Luigi, and then added Toadsworth in place of Baby Daisy, cause who wouldn't wanna drive as Toadsworth, the one and only adorable shroom grandpa

This is my fix for each Mario Kart game: *SNES & N64: Keep the same *GBA: Replace the random with Kamek *GCN: Replace Paratroopa with Dry Bones *DS: Replace ROB with either Shy Guy or E. Gadd (who was originally planned to be in the game) *Wii: Replace Baby Daisy with Shy Guy, replace Mii Outfit B with Petey, and add 2 more bottom row slots (Toadsworth for Small and Hammer Bro for Medium) *3DS: Replace Metal Mario with Waluigi *Wii U: Replace Metal Mario, PGP, Tanooki Mario, Cat Peach, Baby Daisy, Baby Rosalina, Link, the Villagers, Isabelle, and the Inklings with Kamek, Hammer Bro, Pauline, King Bob-omb, Nabbit, Chargin' Chuck, Birdo, Monty Mole, Petey Piranha, Funky Kong, Dixie Kong, and Diddy Kong

You had me google the release date of Luigi's Mansion to check if it really was older than double dash... and now I feel old

I would put DK next to Bowser in DS

I honestly don't like the idea of non-Mario characters in Mario Kart. So this is how I would fix these rosters: Super: Replace Donkey Kong Jr with Donkey Kong 64: Keep the same Super Circuit: Replace the random with Koopa Double Dash: Replace Paratroopa with Dry Bones DS: Replace ROB with Shy Guy Wii: Replace Baby Daisy with Shy Guy, replace Dry Bowser with Hammer Bro, replace Mii Outfit B with Petey Piranha 7: Replace Metal Mario with Waluigi, replace Lakitu with Bowser Jr, replace Honey Queen with Diddy Kong 8 Deluxe: Replace Metal Mario, Pink Gold Peach, Tanooki Mario, Cat Peach, Baby Daisy, Baby Rosalina, Dry Bowser, Link, the Villagers, Isabelle and the Inklings with Cackletta, Fawful, Hammer Bro, Pauline, King Bob-omb, Nabbit, Luma, Dimentio, Princess Shroob, Antasma, Professor E Gadd, Diddy Kong and Funky Kong

20:26 You see…about that…

Hey, I'm part way through the video and I noticed you mentioned Double Dash as being the 3rd game, it's the 4th, super circuit is 3rd

You do realize the Donkey Kong we know of today wasn't even around at the time of Super Mario Kart, right?

17:23 GRAAAAA NO SHE DOESN'T BREAK CANON!!!!! Canon discussion aside, really like all your new rosters more(besides 7)

You inspire me bro! Keep making amazing content no matter what. You deserve way more views than you get

Waluigi is a Joesona

Clicked on this accidentally, leading to a jumpscare and roast at the same time. Nice.

9:23 LMAO

It’s super circuit then double dash

3:30 Do I have news for you.

R.I.P to the goat DK Jr. Bro was disrespecting a character who hasent seen the spot light in decades and in his debute was added purley as a legacy pick ,and because dk jr was easier to make, but you added star bunny, no hate but i find the idea of star bunny eriving pretty funny.

Why you didn't mention tour?

What if Geno is a playable racer rather than a R.O.B. (and Kamek)?

Oh I remember the Rosalina trailer, I thought Kirby was going to be in Mario kart. .. boy how disappointed I was when in the following Mario kart trailer, they gave us baby daisy.

I can do without the Star Bunny but maybe Luma would be a better replacement

Is it bad that I kinda wanna see DK Jr again? Like, I get Diddy is already right there but Donkey Kong Jr gets too much flack as is. It’d be nice to have Donkey, Diddy, Funky AND Jr in the same game (sorry Dixie, not yet).

Thank you spiderman for helpful information

Just remplace baby daisy by shy guy or luma on wii And yes Petey was actually planned to be on wii alongside hammer bro and idk if there was another scrapped character on wii

I disagree with the removal of Dry Bowser. He’s a representative for NSMBDS in the same vain as Rosalina is for Galaxy. Also only looking at Wii content for MKWii is odd. A better view would be time in general, allowing DS content that missed the boat in MKDS to get another chance, plus MKWii’s whole aesthetic is mainly based on NSMBDS and Galaxy.

daisy for mk64 supremacy

Warioware characters**** Also captain falcon as a crossover character

where's luma?

Just a random thing to point: If Koopa is replaced with Bowser Jr., would Wario be a starter character in MK7? He was an unlockable in that game (for some reason) and the starting roster was meant to replicate SMK with Donkey Kong thrown in.

Seriously? You think star bunny represents mario galaxy more than luma?

I feel like dk jr deserves that sad spot in super Mario kart, he may be irrelevant beyond all belief, but in arcades and on the previous console he had been playable more times than DK and had also been much closer to Mario’s size, as DK use to be a giant ape bigger than bowser. I do feel like it’s criminal that Toadette wasn’t removed. She was invented for double dash and toadsworth was right there.

0:00 lol

Why do you hate baby weegee

Sonic! One other crossover character could be Sonic!

honestely cat peach is my favorite character

This is the only man who can replicate the “Scott the woz style”

Removing Dry Bowser from Mario Kart Wii made the roster 10 times worse. You could have Geno and Mallow as lightweights instead

I kind of get why there's a metal mario and a pink gold peach, because it seems like the intention was to have a mario and a peach for every weight class. (Well, broadly speaking anyways, as 7 actually introduced the "feather" and "cruiser" weight classes and 8 has more of a weight spectrum and doesn't seem to care much about balanced distribution but, alas.) Because they have a unique weight class and voice lines though, they can't really be determined as skins since those seem to be some of the defining things separating characters. Animations also separate characters, which is why Tanooki Mario and Cat Peach are unique slots. I can't justify them as much though since they're in a relatively similar weight class to their original counterparts, so I think we could have done without them having unique animations honestly. Another point to be considerate of is like, there's a pretty big gender imbalance in gaming in general, and this effects mario kart's roster as well. The reason Toadette and Baby Daisy/Baby Rosalina were even created was to try and pad out the roster with more women because there simply wasn't enough in the beginning to make things feel even. Because of this, even though I think Toadsworth joining would be cool, Shy Guy is pretty iconic, and I have a massive personal bias towards bunnies, I can't ENTIRELY justify removing Baby Daisy for either in Wii. My alternative proposal however, is to do the same thing they did with Funky Kong and pull a representative from the wider Mario universe: In particular, I think Ashley from Wario Ware should have been the 8th small character. Not only is she an absolute darling in the fanbase but it opens the door to more Wario Ware characters or even general Wario characters down the line, which also would help the amount of girls in the series since characters like Mona or Captain Syrup are pretty well received and have a lot of personality. (Mona even drives a moped that could be added as a kart.) This wouldn't even be out of turn for the series to reference Wario brand games, as Wario's kart in Double Dash!! debuted two years prior in Wario Land 4. Other than those points and some more minor nitpicks, I think this video was pretty good! I know I went on kind of a text wall tangent, but I wasn't really trying to sound like I was scrutinizing things too seriously, as I feel like the overall video was pretty solid and I especially appreciated the way you respected weight class balance and tried to analyze relevancy instead of just throwing in whoever you personally wanted exclusively every time.

Hear me, kill paratroopa into dry boens for double dash

10:11 Koopa has left the chat

you're not scott the woz

3:05 Uhm actually this is the DK Junior son

Its always funny how people on reddit post there ideal roster and mostly remove all crossover characters. I can guarantee if nintendo has any knowledge of marketing and I believe they have, crossover will be a staple for future mario kart games. people who play mario kart get convince to try other nintendo franchises. People who play other franchises get convinced to play Mario Kart. They sold me to splatoon 2 with this game and earned like 200 bucks just from me. Its really cool concept aswell and opens up new possiblities. I really wish to drive on a splatoon themed course, since the world is interesting. eventually we could get a pokemon themed course aswell? Then we could actually see how a Pokemon World would look like with more then 1 tree per square kilometer.

You skipped Super Circuit

DK didn't existed at the time of smk, only Jr., so... Yeah.

Widerman

Man I actually kinda liked DK JR.

the letter 4

Snnuy from hit game Omor💀

I think baby daisy and baby Rosalina should be swapped with baby DK and baby wario

Donkey Kong isn't A Vaillan

Switch paratroopa for goomba in double dash

Mine Super Mario Kart Mario Luigi Peach Yoshi Toad Donkey Kong Bowser Super Mario Kart 64 Mario Luigi Peach Bowser Yoshi Wario Toad Donkey Kong Kamik Koopa Mario Kart double Dash is too perfect to touch Mario kart Super Curit Mario Luigi Peach Bowser Kamik Koopa Yoshi Wario Toad Waluigi Diddy Kong Baby Mario Mario kart wii Mario Luigi Yoshi Toad Peach Daisy Rosalina E Gadd Toadette Koopa Bowser Bowser jr Kamik Wario

I disagree with the removal of Dry Bowser. He’s a representative for NSMBDS in the same vain as Rosalina is for Galaxy. Also only looking at Wii content for MKWii is odd. A better view would be time in general, allowing DS content that missed the boat in MKDS to get another chance, plus MKWii’s whole aesthetic is mainly based on NSMBDS and Galaxy.