thanks, i asked exactly that more than 3 years ago but my comment sank into oblivion without an answer :D

Thanks 😊

Had no idea. Music should be mandatory in schools. Music is medicine

And still...not a flash mob, with 90% of the audience standing around waiting before the start.

Thats so amazing about the languages; a real musical moment indeed! I just love this whole scenario but do agree it's not a real flashmob situ- ation as i've been in many my self !

I didnt even recognise it was japanese! Huge thanks and a big hug to our japanese brothers and sisters!

As someone that took two years of Japanese in uni/college it’s not the impossible language everyone makes it out to be . A little effort goes a long way my friend ;)

To be honest, German is the easiest language for anyone not least a Japanese to pronounce with reasonable precision except Umlaut and trill, thanks largely to the nearly total absence of spelling-pronunciation irregularities. which is another aspect of precision-orientated German culture excluding deviations from rules. You just follow spelling and you make no mispronunciation. In the mean time, however, I must admit that German grammar is a sheer nightmare.

Bullshit!

Brilliance of musicians everywhere that perfect their craft.

Good job Japan

perfect pitch boy

They have recently said he had some hearing in one ear. He said he derived courage to write this piece from reading Plutarch's Lives of the Great Greeks and Romans.

Some historians think that he actully never was really deaf but that he faked it for attencion

Yup, TRUE GENIUS - You got that right!💕 💙💛🌹💜🍎🇺🇸

they are beautiful. They have made it their own. I never tire of listening to it.

Sandra Gainsbourgs i

Yes, he knew his music will survive centuries and will be played in all kinds of strange locations across continents.

What's a "mall"?

Ion Did he really say that!? I'm gullible so...lol.

As a Vietnam vet (drafted), agree 100%.

What you are saying is so beautiful

Amen!

Who ever mad this are 100% smart.

Amen! Amen! Amen!

200, actually.

....and he was dyslexic as well. Brilliant

It premiered in 1824

An honor to be a part of that. His music (we need more) is a treasure to be sure. Wasn’t he under 15 when he wrote that?

So many well known people have dyslexia. Whoopi Goldberg - list too long and very interesting 🇺🇦☮️🇺🇸❤️🌈

Nice. :D well, german isn't so difficult, I guess.

Outstanding!!!!

You do have a great sense of humor.

Oneup La paix dans le monde ! Celà, on peut le chanter dans toutes les langues. Noël 2019 😘🥰

beautiful music transcends language .

universal language,,, yes it is,,, ole USN vet

German music played in Japan and most comments written in English yahoo spectacular world communication x

To be honest it didn't sound too german to me, but that doesn't matter.. it was sung and played with the right spirit and was a joy to behold!

Actually, they sing all in Japanese!　For example, Yorokobi in stead of Freude . That is vital for singers and listeners to feel deep from their heart.

Sadly its not universally loved though. Imagine singing Chinese in America right now with all the China hate.

The Japanese have impeccable manners!

its a cultural thing

Tofu Kingpin that is it im moving to Japan

Look at all the people gathered, this was preplanned and obviously advertised, wtf is considered a flash mob anymore even though its a beautiful song

In japan virtually everybody knows the german(!) text to this one - so the audience singing along to the orchestra says absoluty nothing aubout them being there on purpose or by accident...

Nah.., not really. I guess it's because of that barrier. ( the minutes 3:12 )

lol idk if its their mic is high quality but at the moment theye started to play suddenly all the noises fade away

That's the quality of Classical Music against Heavy Rock Band. i. Order ii. Finesse iii. Detailed What else can you add?

I was wondering, this does seem like the most anticipated and planned Flash Mob ever. Everyone was lined up on the balconies waiting for the show to start. I was thinking maybe it's something about Japanese culture they couldn't keep it a secret?

@@aus993 I'm Japanese, I love rock'n'roll AND classical music. There's no contradiction in that, but a lot of people find it weird...

As an American you should know that we embrace the classics as well. Or at least those of us that spend any time learning instruments do. Ode to joy isn’t enjoyed any more by one culture over the other , it’s celebrated the world over

Me too, another German, moved to tears by this amazing performance !!! Wonderful to watch and listen !!!

Germany and Japan have always been the best friends. Even since WW2 haha

@@BioChemistryWizard So?

Truly an Ode to Joy!

Vielen Dank!! Ich bin Japanerin. Wishing you a wonderful new year!!

Greetings from Austria. I need my dose of THAT part of #9 at least once a month ;-) Simply can't stop watching this heart moving performance :-)

I'm English and cannot play a note ..But I too wept tears of joy ..

Same here... German Organist.

All men shall be brothers.

It needs to be the World Anthem! It is our Antheme of Europe ... but ... it's the perfect joice!

Perhaps the most over played piece of music ever written

@@therealoldnewb1716 太棒了!

No offence but Beethoven better than Mozart

No sure about that... Gary Balow I want you back must be up there

LOL

Ivanatis I used to have a pair of hemp overalls from Germany. Bright yellow they were.

Theodore Ashford best comment ive seen today. Thank you. You made my day.

I was about to comment “Why would someone walk their violin?” And then I realised that is a thing I would actually do.

Theodore Ashford brazil

Music really is the greatest invention of the human species . All peoples and all cultures have such amazing musical foundations . It’s literally our gift to the universe since we sent out our golden records into space on golden vinyls

Domo arigato.

Exactly! So very true!

Agree

I'd like to see something like that take place anywhere in the usa; but I'm not holding my breath because the people of this country don't have the decency, or the courtesy to listen to, or participate in an event of this nature. If there's no alcohol or drugs involved, or a chance for being obnoxious and rowdy it would never happen!!! If these statements offend you, oh well; deal with it!!!

The "whole" mall was not in on it - but there certainly were a whole of people who were. I assure you, the vast majority of Japanese do not know this piece, let along how to sing it, but for the sake of the video, they obviously focused on the part of the crowds that were closest in recording distance to the musicians.

Ain't that the truth. Too bad this type of unity doesn't extend over to the way we treat each other on a daily basis.

Bravo

Asiaten sprechen nach meiner Ansicht neben allen anderen Ausländern am besten deutsch...sogar besser als manch Deutscher :D

HachiRoku du hast recht

hab mal ein Video von einem japanischen Chor aus 10000 Menschen gesehn. Da haben sie auch das Lied gesungen. Gänsehaut und Tränen in den Augen. Als ich dieses Jahr in japan war, hatte ich Probleme am FLughafen mit dem Immigrationsformular. nach dem 3. versuch, kam ein Flughafenmitarbeiter zu mir und hat mich in fließendem Deutsch angesprochen. Als ich mich umgedreht hatte stand ein Japaner um die 40 vor mir und hat mich angelächelt. Ich dachte ehrlich erst ohne hinzusehen, dass er deutscher sei.

Goodness! How many languages do you command! Bravo!

Wenn amn richtig hinhört, sprechen diese Menschen dort Japanisch und kein Deutsch!

As child was always just thought is just well known in my area as the componist was from my town. Was need a while realize that its not regional or german but a world thingy

@@firebreath3926 indeed

Well said!

Agreed!

If some woke idiot doesn't try to ban music of old white men!!!

They do indeed, this is the best I've ever heard. Love it from Australia.

Actually... no. The first player plays way too fast and it feels like his hand is lazy

Music as timeless and beautiful as this, has absolutely nothing to do with class,race or breed! It was birthed for all humans....no claim to its ownership. Pygmies can play this on coconuts and logs and it’s theirs! It makes me smile and we’ll tears...

We all need to remember that music is the international language! How beautiful! 😷💕🎹🎼🎵🎶

Totalmente bello y sin idioma solo la del alma.Argentina 2022

Thats not what " appropriation " means anyway. Most music isn't a problem to share. Pretty sure the Germans don't mind.

@@c.m.cordero1772 On the contrary sharing music is a problem! There are people now arguing that Western music is colonialism! Therefore it should be banned. There's no limit to stupidity when it comes to the Woke Brigade. Anything to do with Western civilization offends them. I'm sure you'll find someone objecting to Debussy using oriental sounds in his music.

そんなヤツおるん？

Thats what its all about:)

that was so cool when everyone was singing. It was maybe not a flash mob but DID YOU SEE there were at least 3 stories in that building! Great coordination and great song!

azinineMC 5

symphony no. 9 is played all around japan every new year, it would be a surprise that no-one knows it

This was the choir

@@demonindenim really?!?! omg must move now lol

Yes absolutely from a classical pianist who see's beauty in kindness.Thank you Daniel.

An absolute heaven

donna gilligan )

If only, but you only have to open a newspaper to see we are a long way from doing that.

Then we would have to forfeit our ego and most people aren't willing to do that

Wow!! Thank so much for sharing the words!! A tear worthy moment for sure!! 🥲

The text was adapted from the "Ode an die Freude ", a poem written by Friedrich Schiller with additional text written by Beethoven.

THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENT!!!

Wow!! That was beautiful. Thank you. 🙏🙏

@@maryl5567 nah. Im gonna stick with Schiller.

❤❤❤

When this pandemic is over we need a world ode to Joy flash mob!!

Have been watching these all morning. Each person filmed is radiant and beautiful. This is humanity shining. Now is closed down.

Gordon Hutchings and it sounds something like this!

That’s a beautiful statement.

They are people too so... also, some might be people wanting to join in

They are not part of chorus. Just people in the mall

The Richmond symphony orchestra used to do this kind of thing I just messaged two of the members to bring it back make it happen again now

Hello, I’m also watching at 2:30

What a great comment.

Jatika...I'm coming with you . It's a beautiful, uplifting timeless classic. Enjoying it on the bus this wet dull morning. Bravo to these brilliant performers and bravo to the late great Beethoven 👏👏😌👌👌

Wow! I 'm speechless. What a treat the shoppers at that mall had that day!

Yes absolutely ‘Ode toJoy’ so apt - that was fabulous!!!!

Also, 78 and brought tears of joy!

I mean every flashmob are staged so...

God bless us all Amen! Marvelous*

True. In fact, a flashmob does not even require any unaware observers.

Well, I clicked because it was written Beethoven 9th. Ergo, I *knew* the whole mall had to be in on it.

Brent Irwin nice

Lol

it really doesn't matter

It's obvious they were in on it from the start

Ben Mader No

Not at all. Goosebumps, and this one took my breath away

This piece is a goosebump as a whole.

No sir, tears pour from eyes!!!

I get goosebumps when it starts, shit.

Wonderful wonderful best rendition ever

Exactly.

Imagine if this just erupted around you while you were out looking for a pair of boots. I'd be in tears.

I was in tears! Would be in public, wouldn’t be ashamed! And I just happened on this on the internet. If I would have been there in person, I would have been a puddle!

This is my beautiful inspiration of music and attending flash mob

Tearful music and flash mobs

This being a flash mob makes it better It shows how humanity can be united because of the power of music

Beautiful

This was no mere audience, this was a congregation at prayer. Music that allows the heart and mind to soar together is so very rare, its magic reunites what custom has divided. :)

Pretty sure those singing along are part of the flash mob haha. This piece is not easy to sing and the average person will not know each of the parts :P

Fittingly, the Germans started this Beethoven mania in Japan a century ago. ;)

I'm an American!!! this does NOT speak to me at all!

Because 'music' is magic...got me teary eyed as well....wonderous emotion, audio ecstasy...

My class played a simpler version with brass instruments and this is very true since after the performance the crowd clapped so hard in the auditorium we playing in

JohnPaul Dixon why it’s not even a good song it’s so boring 😂

@@wormonastring1044 Yeah right, whatever you say,pal.😠

Wonderful words from you!

My very first musical love was Herr Beethoven.

very well said. Thank you :)

;)

I love this piece of music not becouse its European Union anthem, but becouse it is music which invigorates in our hearts our dream about united Europe, a dream which maybe lost forever and soon. Maybe the Union will become centralized totalitarian technocratic regime or maybe the Union will be gone - destroyed by egotistic maniacs and we become again a bunch of little quarrellsome particles. But this sheer greatnes of a music will be forever a memento of a beautiful vision, and Beethoven forever will be a conjurer of this vision - of truely united European nations - united in peace, united in strife for truth and united in joy of future discoveries.

Tallis Keeton Yeah, knowing humanity it's going to get worse before it gets better. Still though, the Lord will see us through.

Wow this really touching

piece*

Even tho there are words to sing in this composition, in the classical music world it is NEVER EVER called a ‘song’. In classical music it is ‘a piece’ or a ‘composition’.

I feel sorry for those that don't feel, touch and taste the music. This is a three tissue production

It brought tears to my eyes as well.

Beautifully said! Greetings from canada!👍👍👍

Javier Greetings from Australia!

Love from America 🇺🇸

PrayersnLuv WWG1WGA,May God Bless All!!!! We have Been Blessed To Visit Your Beautiful Country Severi Times& I Pray we Will Many Times Again!!!!👼👼💝💝🙏🙏✝️✝️

@@elaineflohr9145 PrayersnLuv WWG1WGA 👼👼🥰🥰💝💝🙏🙏✝️✝️

圧倒的アウェイ感

In the church I was raised in this was made into a hymn called "Joyful Joyful We Adore Thee" I have always loved this piece whether it was played or sung. Thank you Beethoven!

Everytime I listen it has the same effect on me.

Job Vink lol 156likes

Well, considering that Symphony No. 9 is being played widely in Japan every New Year, it would be really obvious that many Japanese would know it by heart, wouldn't it?

Actually, I've sung that piece, just the chorale of the third movement and it wasn't complete at all. They left a lot out.

very good

We knew you would be here, commenting on the performance, and we did not want to disappoint you. We're glad you enjoyed it!

Wonderful Music, Great Performance! So bautiful! THANK YOU!

Sounds amazing, very powerful hearing all those instruments and voices together

Bonnita Hiddinga I thought so... I think there's much more meaning in this video than whether or not it's a flash mob

Bonnita Hiddinga It WAS amazing!

A flash mob or not, it was an uplifting performance all the same. It quite stills my blood. I wish I'd been there.

Agreed

Words can’t express the joy I feel for something like that

Simply beautiful! The acoustics must have been amazing to have heard it live, in the moment!

I'm not ashamed to admit I would probably weep with joy if a performance like this erupted around me.

It's amazing how something so innocent and beautiful can still draw negative opinions from people . Have faith and take joy out of something, that i believe was created for all . Peace

The negative comments are more a reflection on the person than this amazing breathtaking performance.

Died laughing LOL

Attention V-Mart shoppers, Stradivari on sale on 3rd floor! Buy one and get a Guarneri for free!

HAHAHHAHAHAHA - I'm dying of laughter.

がんばれー👊😆🎵

頑張って！！

this is no flashmob.... the area is closed off so everyone prob knew about it. it's a perfomance on a set stage.

Nice to give compliments, but please don't use the LORD"s name that way!

I'm Glad I've watch it

No way, flash mobs are amazing and fun, specially if it is a dance flash mob

Same here! Flashmob binge. Talent meets delighted surprise meets connected humanity.

I don't think "everybody" was singing. I assume those singing were choristers planted in the hall because I'm a lifelong classical music fan and I couldn't sing all the words in German. I doubt anything like that many "regular" Japanese could unless they were trained to do so.

@@BTinSF 　"those singing were choristers planted in the hall" is exactly what a flash mob is about, is it not? While Beethoven's No.9 is extremely popular, few Japanese can sing it in German. Those singing in German from 6:23 to 7:49 are the members of the Musashino Chorus who are familiar with the German lyrics, whereas those joining the chorus (a dozen or two individuals) from 8:11 are the laymen=members of the public who happen to know the lyrics in Japanese only. Note that members of the Musashino Chorus changed language at this point apparently to encourage passers-by to participate in the choir; simply because this climax is the part of the symphony best known to anyone in the country. Personally I believe at least the first part of the lyrics by Schiller is worth memorising since the time I was deeply impressed by the performance of an actress reciting this in one scene of the film "Clockwork Orange (1971)" by Stanley Kubrick. Freude, schöner Götterfunken Tochter aus Elysium Wir betreten feuertrunken Himmlische, Dein Heiligtum Deine Zauber binden wieder Was die Mode streng geteilt Alle Menschen werden Brüder Wo Dein sanfter Flügel weilt I believe you have far more extensive knowledge about classical music than I have, and I hope you join me praising its unparalleled beauty in both poetic and phonetic terms, which is sadly missing from this splendid performance in the footage.

That is exactly how I feel. To witness this in person would be pure joy!