Old fnaf 3 is better, the new one just doesnt have this atmosphere, the ambience. Even the old night's start sound gives me chills to this day

Old Puppet : You can't do anything during 17 seconds New Puppet : Simple Jumpscare

That staring contest with the puppet is what makes the old f3 is better than the plus. I don't know why they thought it's much better to remove that part for the f3 plus.

One of the only things I preferred in the new one is the animatronics in the cameras which are a little more creepy imo. I also liked the random delay before the phantom jumpscares, like you know it’s coming but you don’t know when, which reminded me of the power loss jumpscare in fnaf 1. However the jumpscare is so weak in the new one that it doesn’t do its effect

Erh. It doesn't do it for me. Scott has a very particular style that isn't appreciated enough but when you put it side by side with this, it really shows. It's more subtle, simpler while still being very detailed. This feels like it's just "too much", I don't know how to describe it. Also... if you're going to make an intro sequence where it's just you walking, please use more and better footstep sounds.

Also one of the best parts of Fnaf 3 is that you don't get to see Springtrap's face until way into the second night creating a sense of mystery and tension as to what springtrap even is, the Main menu only shows a silhouette and the Cameras do that too(except for the vent cams but they're pretty blurry too and he's usually too far away to see him clearly, the only way to see him clearly is when he's standing right in front of you in the hall or when he jumpscares you

It def needs better audio design but the visuals are great. I think the puppet should have stayed the same in terms of mechanics, it was a lot more creepy having it stare at you for a prolonged duration and it raises your anxiety knowing that Springtrap is making his way towards you while you're stuck with the puppet.

I suppose the saying less is more applies here, while the new design looks visually clean, the old game had a more broken and forgotten vibe which fits the theme I think the game wants to be

tbh they did Phantom Puppet kinda dirty with that jumpscare lol Phantom BB on the camera is actually pretty damn scary tho

Nothing beats Scott Cawthon. He is legendary. He has been making games even before fnaf

I feel like the original FNAF 3 has more of a flash game style, while the new one is more detailed and corporate almost whilest the original is simpler

i think its nice to have remastered verisons of old fnaf games, as it makes it a similar and unique experience. looks great, and obviously people will prefer the original games to do as a playthrough, but i know dawko and fuzionZgamer will flock to this game.

3:24 Que fue eso? El original no necesitaba un grito para incomodar. Escuchar ese sonido de interferencia mientras puppet te mira directamente mientras no puedes hacer nada era genial. En el nuevo es un susto y ya? El nuevo no se ve tan mal, tiene sus cosas buenas pero por dios,los jumpscares apestan. Además en ambientación gana el original. Solamente el sonido de iniciar una noche ya era algo que ponía pelos de punta. En fin, me gustaría probar el nuevo, y le deseo mucha suerte al creador,se nota que tiene talento, solamente tiene que seguir mejorando

I love how Scott is making good animations and details just for the sake of our enjoyment

Original is way better tbh.

Old one is better in nearly every way Scott’s work cannot be replicated

spring cant open his jaw i tought

theres too much detail and definition in the remake, the lower quality and less visibility in scott's games are really what add to the mystery and horror, remaking them to be clear and precise just makes it less scary and destroys any mystery or other atmosphere, not to mention the jumpscares and the spunds for them just arent great at all

i like the old one better

0:36 Rare footage of springtrap having a seizure :O

The old fnaf 3 menu is goated

Cómo consiguen hacer que el sonido del jumpscare sea aún peor?

make a gas sound for the phantom Freddy so that you can determine by the sound that he has go in, is walking or has left. The sound should continue while Freddy is outside the window. If you don’t understand, then listen to the music when Freddy is not there and the sound when Freddy passes behind the glass.

Can we all agree that (old) fantom BB's jump scare scared the soul out of us the first time the game came out?

The new springtrap looks so goofy with it being cross-eyed

OG way better, Scott's FNaF games just hit different tbh

I really don't like how you can see Afton's head so easily. in the original it was kinda of hidden that Afton was in there, Springtraps mouth rarely opened and the most you can see was his guts. It also helps it feel like he's trapped in there.

What i love about plus version of springtrap is that he actually looks a rotten corpse rather than a fleshy spaghetti.

Can someone explain to me why in the fan game menu the jump scares have the original screams but in the gameplay they are changed to generic sounds?

I think the people (or the person) making these + fnaf games are sort of missing the point. The thing that always made fnaf 1-6 so good is how all the details where made with eitjer gameplay or lore intention. For example fnaf 3 is made to feel really personal, becuase its between father and son. The jumspare isnt him launching himaelf at you becauas this isnt a monster this a serial killer hunting his prey. Fnaf 1 animatronics where never meant to look scaey they look uncanny just like tje atmosphere of thr whole game. In these new + games the intention is to make everythijg way more scary through traditional horror means. It doesnt capture scotts intent at all.

I love how in the old fnaf, Springtrap jumpscares you as if he is asking for the WiFi password

I said my biggest complaint with the unofficial remaster is that there's too much music, too many sounds. To build tension with the player you don't have music and everysound possible at all times! all you need are a few sounds to build a damp quiet abmusphere that's broken by key sounds like your cameras, control panel, and of course jumpscares. The constent music and various different sounds doesn't build that much tension for me, especially when the music kept played during the newspaper part of the intro, feels less like a horror game and more like a ghost hunting game, another thing I don't like as much is that the jumpscares are just off, too fast, too short, not theatning at all, make them a bit longer and add more of a build up to it, as well as a sense of unknown like perhaps the puppet suddenly drops down and then is dangling from the ceiling at first as a warning, then something trigger the jumpscare part, weather that be looking at it for too long or closing your camera to see it's gone and shortly after it stares at use preventing sight like the first game. A few things I like better in the unofficial remaster is the sounds of the camera system and the new designs for the animatronics, the camera constant hum is a great way to build tension

Honestly the jumpscares are more scary in fnaf 3 SPRINGTRAP INCLUDED

The old phantoms jumpscares are scarier than the new ones haha

We just not gonna talk about the fact the guy finds a rotting and smelly corpse and still decides to open the attraction?

New phantom bb sounds like he is saying “Give me your ass”

The one thing i can say is that the springtrap jumpscare feels a lot more aggressive

i have gained a new appreciation for the FNAF 3 jumpscares, no offence to this developer but they really just don't hit that har

Old is better

I loved this style of typing nights in old version. It was cool and amazing

YO DIGO QUE EL FNAF 3 PLUS TIENE QUE SEGUIR ACTUALIZANDOLO, HAY COSAS QUE DEBEN CAMBIAR, POR EJEMPLO EL SONIDO DE LOS JUMSCARPS Y EL EFECTO DE CAMARA CADA VEZ QUE TE ATACAN Y UN QUE OTRA COSA, SIN EMBARGO ESTA BUENO EL JUEGO, ME GUSTA ESTOS VIDEOS DE COMPARACION ENTRE LOS VIEJOS Y NUEVOS JUEGOS O SUS ACTUALIZACIONES, SIGUE ASI.

I‘m honest, the most jumpscares are scarier in the original version

No way did you make all of the new FNAF 3 stuff you are extremely talented if you did😊

honestly most of the old phantoms were better but some werent better. the only reason i said some of the old is better because the sound and jumpscares. springtrap new was 100x better than springtrap.

this was a real weird change, but i love it

New springtrap done did the ahegao 💀

Really needs some audio tempering to make it interesting, as it is one of fnafs main points From the ambience to the jumpscares, the lack of a proper audio just makes it feel so weak for a horror game The cameras need some filters to hinder information gathering and some animations can be changed instead of others (don't change the puppet, for example, change the freddy walk at the corridor)

Its awesome! The only thing i could complain about are the jumpscares. Springtrap is really scary but i wish it could be him grabbing the player and knocking him out.

The new springtrap jumpscare looks goofy imo.

It's a very good game, but the Jumpscares are very fast and short, maybe they can be worked on, but it's okay. And I really liked that there was a Phantom Bonnie here :D Original better but, it's absolutely beautiful work

The SpringTrap jumpscare in five Nights at Freddy three still gets me to this day and made me scream 🙀 and my heart rate go up and get paranoid ❤

the main menu of the new one doesn't have the dark mysterious-ness of the original and the Springtrap glitching looks more like a Gmod shitpost than actually being unnerving

Fnaf plus springtrap's eyes when he jumpscares you is a lil sus..

I literally couldn't even complete nightmare mode on fnaf 3 plus

Both Springtraps in both game main menus still are high on drugs😭

phantom bonnie? interesting. Also I like the revamp of Springy boi's jumpscare: much better. as for the puppet, its general idea should have stayed the same. The intro could use some better walking sounds, and better through-the-night ambience. Other than that, I would like to point out that everyone in the comments is hating on something that actually looks really good, y'all need to chill. Keep it up bro, it looks really good.

The springtrap jumpscare in the new one is even worse!

The plus is much more advanced and cleaner but the best version would be the original with upgrades with graphics look so it looks better while still having a nostalgic atmosphere and better jumpscares

I think my favourite change was the full minute long cut-scene where an image of the pizzarea got larger and was tilting wildly.

Hell nah thats Fnaf 3 -

Fnaf plus more like fnaf minus with how many times its been dropped and the jumpscares being somehow worse than the original

Original main menu screen: you instantly get the feeling of an actual monster, gazing at you through this dark void, with the blurry and decaying camera footage. The erratic spasms on full display, as if to tell you immediately this _thing_ is going to be a very active threat. New main menu screen: literally just him staring at you... its not creepy or anything, its just awkward and annoying. And he sneezes like a dog wtf

One thing I I'll say is that jumpscares are quick, but that is just enough to make it scary and catch you off guard.

Es una buena versión, tiene buenos gráficos pero siento que en lugar de sumarle ambientación le quitó en algunos casos como los jumpscares que son todos muy similares

I think this comparison is kinda missing some things… (Phantom Bonnie??)

The fnaf 3 intro gave me chills in the og, 8 remember being little and too scared to.move in bed bc I thought springtrap was in my room watching me 😂

The old Fnaf 3 you showed was the newer one the og Fnaf 3 still has its badass theme in the intro

Sad that the FNAF3+ was killed probably :/

First is OG FNAF, the other one is Five Fingers Inside My Ass

TOU KNOW WHAT GIVES ME CHILLS. THE GENSHIN IMPACT ADD BEFORE THIS

The old puppet just staring at you with those realistic eyes. Still gives the chills

The old jumpscares had way more impact. They were louder, more well-animated. The old FNAF 3 could bring an uneasy vibe because of how grim everything look, as the new one just seems to try to improve the graphics, not actually work on how scary the game should be.

There is a very good theory about fnaf3 original springtrap that he is not trying to scare us but instead trying to look closer to the night guard cause he recognized his son and wanted to be sure that it's him

Scott, thank you for adding fantum Bonny

I like both. 😊 More variety makes things better.

иронично в 2015 это фотка меня пугала как волбще маленького котенка и сейчас смотря на спрингтрапа и гордишься и боишься😂😅 а ссотря на нового только спрашиваеться что с ним сделали конечно реалистично но и страх чет меньше внушает потому что в реаое у него действительно остались только кости а плоти было бы очень мало а так ремейк на 7/10😅

This is the most effective "How to Make Fnaf 3 Not Scary" I've ever seen

En resumen en el nuevo la estética y el diseño es hermoso, en cambio en el original su ambientación y los "sustos" son por encima de este mejor, obvio mi humilde opinión 🥺

Ok but the death screen of new FNAF 3 is sick!

Cant belive tommorow is dec 1😢

What the heck they did to the sound effects?

The new one doesn't even have that feeing of panic and chaos everytime you hear the alarms and everytime a phantom animatronics jumpscares you

A lot of people say "fnaf original is better" or "scott is better" but this isn't trying to compete with Fnaf3 lol. Some parts of F3+ are better imo than original Fnaf, like the vent system and the tablet, also the little timers before phantoms jump you, those are great. The aesthetic is pretty alright. Folks, you need to put your nostalgia aside and critique these fan-remakes for what they are, not what they are remaking.

Old version it's better

All the old jumpscares are better

It’s all the static on the “old fnaf 3” that makes it have a scarier vibe but the fnaf3 plus doesn’t have that which is a bummer

On my first playthrough of this, Springtrap stared at me the entire night and I got 6AM for some reason lol

Ok tbh the fnaf 3 remake was actually pretty good also it just not about those stupid nostalgia thing nowadays so 💀

Old jumps are sounds are scary, new ones are qwacky

The truth is that it is a great design job but I think that this game needs more action and more difficulty, a remodeling of the game mode with some mechanics like Pley 4 but with the primitive animatronics for the moment the game looks like It was created as if it were just the beta and I love the story and the references that FNAF has

The new jumpscares really killed this for me. They seem so detached from the actual game world like it's some video overlay that's been put, they're also less scary and kinda goofy

Literally the only thing better in plus is the Springtrap jump scare, everything else gets cleared by the original

For graphics, the new one is good. But for the jump scare old one is dominant to make our race😂

Siento que los jumpscares viejos son mejores, me gusta ese efecto de que te afectó, como que se te nubla la vista, los nuevos son muy rápidos, creo q el fnaf 3 es eso lo que lo hace genial en cuanto a sus jumpscares

Bro that killed when springtrap jumpscare just says Hello

old fnaf ambience is so good that springtrap's simple jumpscare is scary enough for the game

The phantom Frye jump scares are good but the jumpscare noises are horrible for the phantoms

I love the effort put in the game but feels like a rushed job and that’s saying something compared to Scott with the first 3 fnaf games Needs a lot of work for it to be a proper fnaf plus title

Old one is just the goat with its scary atmosphere

these are both so good