Definitely. He should have got them to turn the camera around onto the journo while he was giving him a serve.

Not really. He basically proved that Journo's point by calling him out.

Simpson’s not a legend. He had a sook at a journalist who was doing his job and reporting on how bad a coach he had become.

Cornes and McClure who along with Barrett has a hatred for the Eagles dint want to front up. Cowards, waiting for the dust to settle before they reload again. No one wants to talk about Priority picks lol. North Melbourne have had 4

Lets be realistic. Nobody at WC would care what this weasel has to say.

@@Termintor1 completely correct clearly has an agenda

Add another 7+ to that and you're getting close.

Tim Kelly if he doesnt start performing like they thought he would when they brought him over and even Yeo even though he gets alot of disposal s alot of them are useless disposals not to mention the backline was strong as anyone back 2 years ago now it's like McGovern or barass if they don't touch it it's a goal which is sad to just rely on 2 defenders same as centre Harley reid is young so to rely on him and Kelly and Yeo is ridiculous need some good wingers and some good all-rounders cause once there's an injury theres not many options apart from recruits ATM so yeah tbh if Adam Simpson has to go at least 10 players need to go to as none of them are performing let's face it eagles ain't fighting for finals so drop the seniors that are playing like the wafl by that I mean women's AFL haha and bring all the young talent you have and give them time to develop and gain AFL time

Correct

So I am not crazy!

All fixed cheers boys

Half the story. He also chose to select aging players instead of putting games into the youth when it was obvious to everyone the premiership window was closed

@@moonboy5851 Those young players he didn't play didn't deserve a game. They'd be getting pumped by 100+ points every week if Jai Culley was playing midfield and Yeo and Shuey were not selected

Was a good Coach you mean. His pragmatic gameplan just simply doesn't cut it in a much more fast paced, high pressure modern game where you must take the initiative against your opposition. The harsh reality is he just like Alistair Clarkson at the Hawks ran most of the Premiership core into the ground and just simply wouldn't accept his teams window was well and truly closed after an incredibly mediocre 8th placed Collingwood defeated them in the Elimination Final back in 2020. That off-season should have been the big wake up call to trade away guys like Gaff who were very tradable at the time and were at their highest ever value. It would have meant getting a bunch of good picks in return and effectively fast tracking the rebuild.

Simpson needs to take some of the blame. He didnt do well in press conferences in recent years. He always answered like he was depressed, and often sounded like he didnt care. Supporters were not sure about the message. Its Simpson's job to motivate players and supporters and he didnt do that well in the last few years.

@@tubester4567anyone would be depressed with the issues at that club lol

No - it's a new show but they haven't anything new to say.

its never meant to be productive, just a gossip panel show.

Football is an industry not just a game.

Best part was Caro wasn’t on this today !

You think the problems at West Coast aren't worth discussing? Or should we only talk about clubs when they are doing well? Good News Classified?

Replace the Pannel with Sam Newman , Rex Hunt, Bob Hawk and Gary Ablett Snr. Bunch of woke brain idiots on this show, even Eddie falls for the wokeness brainwashing nonsense.

The sports guys at the paper are all Freo guys, it’s not surprise

@@user-cx9gq2ud6t Freo gets no coverage. It's a troll outlet .

@@imalwaysright the people are literally Fremantle fans, their social media doesn’t lie.

Everybody in the media was saying it lol. It wasn’t a hard hot take 😂😂😂

Got to a GF in his second year, played finals 6 years in a row and won a flag. Thats his legacy.

That will happen when you have 2 full seasons of the worst injury lists in AFL history. People have short memories, but they often could only pick 20 or 21 players from their entire squad of 40 over those 2 seasons. They constantly had to top up their game day team with WAFL players who had no prior affiliation with the club. Do you remember that game in 2022 where they nearly had to forfeit? I'm guessing not. If the club didn't have rotten luck for 24 months, more games would have been won.

@@StuTheDon17 Yep. A lot of those injured players never came back the same either. It's a brutal game.

Right, so maybe they kept too many injury prone players on for too long. One or two bad seasons: sure. Eight wins in three years? Scoring at 59% and 53% and losing a game by 171 pts? The players have checked out and aren't listening to the coach any more.

He had one of the best coaching records prior to covid. Not sure why they fell off a cliff.

Your parents must be so proud

What a stupid comment

Must be one of the 3 players on the WhatsApp group 😂😂

What.