Why aren't government policy makers or ministers invited and grilled and asked about their vision in resolving issues that are wrecking our country.

One word ACCOUNTABILITY.

Great topic and panellists. I don't know why questions from the audience are always grandstanding, rather than thoughtful understanding and getting the best from the speakers.

The key to get out of the mess is to invest in education, to enable Pakistanis to know who to chose to govern the country and how to masses can hold these mafias or ruling elite who are exploiting this country and its resources

Really liked the point that "Loans/Aids r not working at optimal level to foster sustainable growth but somehow it is keeping the wheel in motion rather than stagnancy at a sub-optimum level, keeping in view our intelectall bankrupt rulers who lack genuine plans to rescue the economy. " and Dr. shahid deserves appreciation by reffering to the point in the name of capacity building, govt. servant pursued to join 6month Harvard course when he was supposed to retire in 3months😅.

Respected, Congratulations for such a wonderful discussions. Highly specially appreciate Mr Monis Asad for Authoritain Presentation. Hope now every Economicist will speak in the same tone.

Aid is a matter a survival. Unless someone tells Pakistanis , Islam has not delivered and nobody is willing to tell that to Pakistanis , aid is going to be needed by Pakistanis

Good evening.

This was an extremely boring discussion. I was expecting further discussion of facts of what was received, and how it was spent. What amount was loans, and grants, where they came from, in which periods, and how grants, and loans were spent. Is the ratio of grants to loans same as other countries, or different. And, why after supporting the West in so many wars didn't Pakistan get more grants then loans. This could have been a great discussion, but as usual with Pakistani discussions, it turns boring without a direction.

Assalam o Alaikum..sir Can we become a part of this wonderful or such a amazing conference on next time as an student of Political Science.

It is shocking to know that most of the people are telling the Donor agencies not to give loan/aid to Pakistan where it does not have capacity to utilise the aid for development.Butost of the time we hear that Politicians keep on harping that we are given this much of loan and Pakistan will rise again.Where most of the Aid/loan/ CPEC funds have gone?This has to be analysed. Good luck to Pakistani Brothers and Sisters(ordinary citizens and not Elite)

That woman asking the question was pure comedy 🤣😂

Kisi ne puchaa 9 rupiye kahaa chaley jaatey hain . 😂😂😂 Abey 9 me se 4 rupiye Hathiyaar kharidney maintain karney par jaatey hain aur 5 rupye me se 3 rupiye reitring gernails le jaatey hain . Bachey 2 rupaye wo arms dealer means hathiyar ke dalal ko aur brigadier se upar saarey fojiyo ke pocket me jaatey hain

It is not a rocket science to figure out all the aid and loans where looted by Pak Army and politicians. One has to ask question how come Pak a shit hole country with a begging bowl on a regular basis, but somehow Army chief/generals and politicians managed to amass wealth with homes abroad.

All learned 'coat suit' experts but not able to fix the problem ...just discussion... discussions... First fix the Army, then get an honest leader, thats all 😊

Why pakistanis even have these discussions ? When they know nothing gonna change in policy. Those who are at realhm of affairs already knows what to do. But they won't gonna do anything.

Any monies that non-Muslims can be somehow convinced to part with should be taken. So long as this money is never returned to non Muslims, this is halal money. Allah knows best and is most Merciful.

The people asking questions SHSHHH They need to attend school, wth is TOBI-AAS

1)sab sa pahle meharbani karke urdu bola kareen. Jo ke angrezi sa ziyada boli jane vali zaban. Aur mukammal har lafaz iss me paya jatta haa. 2)app looghoon ki angrezi itni harab haa.ke angreezon ke lie issko sub title karna parta haa.yani tarjamma karna parta haa. 3)ke pakistan ko jo madad milti haa.uss pa army valoon hat hotta ha.app azadana toor pa kuch nahi karsake. 4)app ke ihrajat ka 80%paisse militry vale le lete heen. Difah ke lie.jo bach jatta haa.voo siyassat dan le jatte heen. 5)aghar kissi mulak ke army valoon ko ye haq hasil haa.ke voo state bank ke counter pa ja kar jitne dollars hun.bag bar kar le jatte heen. Too bahss kiss bat pa karo ghe. 6)ke jiss mulak me qanoon aur ayeen. Rule of law(qanoon ki pass dari)na hoo.too app kissi bi discussion bahss start suru hi nahi karsakte heen...

Yeh jahil kabhi nhi sawar payenge 😮