vote for your favorite bfdi episodes! forms.gle/5tVJtECGM2E92oH98

When asked about why Evil Leafy isn’t in BFB, Cary said that they can’t really explain what happened to her, meaning that the Huang twins know what happened to Evil Leafy, but they most likely won’t reveal Evil Leafy’s fate until IDFB returns. My theory is that in IDFB, Pin wanted Roboty to be free so that they could use his red pigment to make her red again, and of course by BFB Pin is red again, but if that did happen, wouldn’t Roboty be white now, so I believe that eventually, they decided to capture Evil Leafy and use her to make Roboty red again, this is evidenced by the fact that Roboty can teleport to that plain in BFB 2, which Might indicates that in obtaining Evil Leafy’s pigment gave Roboty her powers, it does feel like a stretch, but it is plausible.

I always thought EL was Leafy representing Leafy's awful mental state at the time.

They are definitley more than two completely different characters that's for sure. Them being actually the same person makes a lot of sense too, but I feel like they are two different characters connected in some spiritual way, like when Leafy is going through something bad Evil Leafy attacks the people that hurt her as a way of protecting Leafy. This would explain why Evil Leafy was one of the characters in the BFDI debut while Leafy was also a contestant at the same time.

Interesting theory. Now that BFDIA is being continued hopefully we get to know more about Evil Leafy

Nice theory. However, there’s one thing that debunks it. Evil Leafy was spit out of Flower WHILE Leafy was at the HPRC during BFDIA 5A (timestamp: 3:37). So there’s no way that Evil Leafy is Leafy. And, sure, she could’ve teleported back into Flower, but that would mean that the other contestants would see her do so, since they were right in front of Leafy when they recovered them.

Speaking of BFDIA, heres a little fun fact: so you see how BFDI has a hidden message through its episodes that eraser hinted off, first line of the first episode, second line of the second episode, and so on when BFDIA was canceled, it only left us with the first 6 parts (as a few years ago jnj posted the BFDIA 6 deleted scenes) saying "Dont try that thing again because" but, with the release of BFDIA 7, the message is now "don't try that thing again because IT" showing that jnj hasnt forgotten about the hidden message.

i personally think that evil leafy was extracted to give pin her red color back. that's why pin is red again and why leafy cant turn evil anymore. in bfb 28 leafy is having a breakdown she isn't used to being mean she usually has a safety mechanism to handle that...evil leafy. but without it and for the sake of everyones safety evil leafy was removed and all that's left behind is her instinct meaning leafy will do very out of character things as a coping mechanism.

According to BFDI 25, Leafy tried to be evil but eraser and pin stopped her. meanwhile in BFDIA 1 Leafy is at yoyleland being metal and Evil Leafy was a eliminated contestant who escaped.

The fact Evil Leaft is creepy

In BFDIA 7, Evil Leafy fell into water, which she wouldn’t cross in BFDIA 6, which means she might have been disintegrated, and that’s why she was hiding in a hotel shown in BFDIA 6

The fact he used ONE music at the start I dont have problem with that its just show how talented Cheesy Hfj also AMAZING theory keep it going!!!

I disagree, I think evil leafy is a manifestation of leafy’s anger, instead of being the same person. I believe the more hatred leafy feels, more powerful evil leafy becomes. It’s already established that evil leafy has powers no one else has, one of these powers could be being able to revive herself. Firey couldn’t have recovered leafy in bfdia 4 because otherwise we would have seen leafy before bfdia 6 because we see evil leafy in bfdia 6, and in idfb leafy is still in yoyle land, a theory I have is that firey recoverd leafy in yoyle land and the other contestants punished him by putting him in the cage. If evil leafy and leafy were the same person, then there’s a chance the contestants would have known, which doesn’t make sense because then they would have been more scared of leafy but they aren’t.

My theory is that the leafy detector wasn't a detector at all. When leafy was zapped, a clone was created. However, the clonr was far from perfect, and it was hostile and hunted down contestants.

Really nice theory but it does debunk some things such as no contestant ever teleporting when roboty’s movements are mysterious but I do have a theory on my own about evil leafy here it is Theory: who is evil leafy? And why does she exists? Well my theory is that yk leafy how she’s always nice and all? And she’s never mean well the thing that explains it is leafy used to be normal and got mad or was mean to everyone some time to time but then she was a bit to mean and rude to other people to the point her entire life everyone hated her because of how mean she was so then she decides to separate her evilness from her probably from yellow faces factory and then she uses a device to remove her evil inners from her self and now she is a nice character but she still has some trauma and in bfdiA she was left alone in the darkness depressed which made her upset and just wanted to live alone and isolated from everyone meanwhile evil leafy roamed around in bfdiA and idfb to kill people then after some time living alone we see in bfb that leafy said to firey “why did u recover me all those years ago?” Which most probabaly happened in idfb since she’s a contestant and we see her at the end of the episode post credits however she is still metal which means that she ate YOYLEBERRYS anywho evil leafy is just leafy’s past evil stuff that’s all!

Evil Leafy is more leafier than Leafy and these leaves 🍃

this is really great and amazing and good keep it up!!

2:33 "I'm glad that im not to needey"

This channel is what brought me into the osc 3 years ago (with the David video) and I'd hate to see the osc lose such a great channel since we've been losing a lot of Osc members this year.😢

even though this theory is very accurate, my theory is that evil leafy was not leafy but an entity instead, in bfdia 6, we see an evil leafy mirror at the hotel that spawned evil leafy immediately, it feels like leafy went to that hotel and maybe SAW a different shaped evil mirror😮 but later got possesed, since leafy is joyful,evil leafy will only come if she is mad and being bullied. I guess in bfdia to bfb, they manage to split leafy and evil leafy and defeat evil leafy, if evil leafy died then the mirror is broken, if it is still alive, then evil leafy will go back to the mirror to wait for another victims.

Maybe this evil leafy is the times when leafy is mean, gets angry, and isnt as nice as she claims. Maybe she is the reason of leafy’s horrible moments, and that the nice leafy is the true leafy

With BFDIA's continueation we might get some more Evil Leafy lore.

Hey Fourtle! You make great object show content.

This theory has a lot of evidence that its true, I hope we find out more in BFDIA since it continued

Fourtle fills us up completely and leaves us dripping with joy with this content ❤️

Here’s a bit more that I think. When evil leafy died in bfdia 5c she and leafy were split apart, firey recovered normal leafy and as we saw in bfdia 6 evil leafy can be recovered by the mirror in the evil hotel. So in summary I think in bfdia 5c evil leafy and leafy became two people meaning evil leafy is out there somewhere.

Good theory! But there is a think that you didn’t thought… if in bfdi 18 evil leafy was send to the LOL, how come leafy appear in the next scene?

I like to think that evil leafy is some sort of evil spirit in leafy that is unleashed when she isn’t in a good mood

Evil Leafy is also in IDFB for 1 frame, when Tennis Ball and Golf Ball are exploring the science museum.

Evil Leafy is seen in BFDIA, I heard from a meetup that he may appear in TPOT in a later TPOT episode (I assume TPOT 13 or other)

when leafy was ripped in half evil and normal leafy are turned to seperate beings

2:34 in this scene when leafy teleports in the screen also goes a little dark just like when evil leafy gets on screen but only i guess when shes aggressive

Yeah, but leafy is made of metal, so i don't think so, but that's a good theory

This REALLY is interesting.

Theory 1: evil leafy is the representation of the grudge he had with the 20 original participants, in bfdia, when left alone, Leafy learns to retain and control that "anger" and when she decides she can take it out or control it Also, in bfdi 25 evil leafy appears when she was quite angry, showing that he still did not control her. Theory 2: The same as the first one but with the difference that in bfdia he manages to control it and it takes it out of his body and he is a completely different person, For idfb it is demonstrated

There's something I just noticed about Evil leafy, Remember do not disturb thing on BFDIA 6? Well, she accepted the do not disturb instead going to the window, Which means Leafy is nice to do this, I guess you're right, Leafy is Chill, Nice. But evil leafy is Chill, Nice and Agressive. Which means that Evil leafy is really Leafy herself.

GOOD VIDEO

I believe that somewhere down the line in BFDIA, it will be explained as to why Evil Leafy is not in BFB.

That end part makes alot of sense

Someone who know everything about evil leafy: I got better evidince

I have a theory that there may be two Evil Leafy... the first one that we meet in bfdia and the second one that hides the Leafy

Fun Fact: Evil Leafy Was A Football That was kicked 2763 times into a football basket field and then the football turned to evil leafy And Evil Leafy Killed The Oldest technology to ever exist.

Actually, Leafy teleported under Gelatin’s hammer which is how Evil Leafy appeared, and with Evil Leafy dying in BFDIA 5c and reappearing in BFDIA 6, if Evil Leafy and Leafy are the same, Leafy must’ve been recovered in BFDIA 5d because that’s the only moment where Firey was close enough to the HPRC to have recovered her.

I love how fourtle is the Game theory of bfdi

0:41 she actually is. Remember BFDI 25, when Leafy was turning evil. 1:01 Oh... you realized. WELL THIS COMMENT IS PRETTY USELE-

one fact you missed in bfdia 6 is that evil leafy can be recovered by a mirror shaped like leafy but the outline is red and if you stare at it for too long like tennis ball said, evil leafy will be recovered, thus explaining how evil leafy appeared in idfb 1

Good theory! though we did see evil leafy in bfdia 6 so that proves evil leafy is immortal.

I could actually see this being Cannon. This is the only theory that actually seems like it could legitimately be possible.

2:12 poor teardrop

My favourite bfdi theory ever.

one of the tictocks leafy wiping of the refelctoin you can see her change

HEY W8 A MINUTE. In BFDIA 1, Evil Leafy was with everyone else when TV displayed the votes, but Leafy was in Yoyleland. Evil Leafy was in the woods in the chase scene but that was deleted by accifent

Can you make a BFDI Theory why Teardrop Can’t Talk?

My theory: somebody smart (most likely TB) seperated the evilness and meanness from leafy

Also-In a video,not BFDI or BFDIA-Firey was scared when Leafy told them to check if "EVIL Leafy was in the forest" it ends up,she was inside the forest.As well as chasing both Fireys.

But In BFDIA 5c, Puffball Said: Gelatin And Fiery Decided To Tie Their Legs, And Fall Off, then After Fries Asked "Where Are They Now" Puffball Said: I've Heard 2 Demonic Screams So They've Probably Got Eaten By Evil Leavy. So That Means...

Your right,it could be only one character different than anyone each person

i thought of this first BTW...well not the first to cover the subject but prior to this video. also about the bfb absents you forgot to mention winner nonexisty waffle lego and tune all being absent

firey couldnt recover leafy since firey was punished

There is a unused bfdia 5 where evil leafy sinks into golf ball and made clones of herself, i think the reasson she's alive in idfb and bfdia 6 is because she cloned herself while being in flower and spongy, i think she left spongy cuz he's nicer but i think the reason flower became nice is because evil leafy took most of her evil personality or smth and used it to become more power, and maybe she created a 3rd clone from spongy, the 2nd evil leafy from flower died cuz firey speaker box froze and she sinks into the water, and we heard ruby ask if evil leafy can go inside water and pencil said, I don't think she can, which mean she died in bfdia 7 and the third clone is the one who appeared in idfb

What could it possibly be?

Ooh that why i eas happy too see her

0:20 I think that the shadow that in IDFB was the most one

Next trivia: compare the votes on the bfdi episodes, and compare the votes now, cuz people still vote.

Idk i just thought that they were one person (leaf??) from the start💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀

I thought that evil leafy was already discovered that was leafy, because in the chapter 25 season 1 before they ask whats inside of leafy, leafy starts to become evil leafy for some frames.

in bfdi when evil leafy was sent into the "Lol" to stay in bfdi used teleport powers to leave the lol to hide the suspicion

I think that evil leafy is helping leafy when he is danger or very hated or angry evil leafy comes out and make sure that leafy is happy

Interesting theory...

Football: ... Metal leafy: ... Every other recommended leafy version: ...

What kills this theory is when Evil Leafy was sent to the TLC in S1

i thought everyone (including me) just thought evil leafy was just leafy in the first place, it baffles me that people don't think so

fun fact: evil leafy is evil

I actually have my own theory for Evil Leafy! So Leafy once shared her body with an entity named Evil Leafy. The two act completely different from each other; one was happy-go-lucky and upbeat, the other was cold and hostile. Both possessed strange abilities, such as strength and teleportation. Leafy was and has been the more prominent one, and Evil Leafy wasn't seen to be actually IN the show until Leafy was excluded from Dream Island. Leafy was distraught and mad, especially when everyone felt the same way towards her when she stole it. This caused the two to rapidly switch between each other, revealing Evil Leafy to the contestants. Fast forward a bit to BFDIA 1. Evil Leafy can be seen in the crowd of debutors that didn't make it into the competition, which begs the question: Where is Leafy? Well at the end of BFDIA 1, Leafy is all the way in Yoyleland, so that would mean that Evil Leafy somehow split from Leafy entirely. But how could this happen? Now I can't really say for certain, but there are a few things that could've happened. Here are some of the ones I feel like are most likely: 1. Evil Leafy became powerful enough to separate herself from Leafy entirely. As TB says in BFDIA 6 'She's getting stronger!' meaning it could be entirely possible that she was able to manifest a physical form for herself outside of Leafy. It could also tie into Evil Leafy not appearing in Battle for BFDI/BFB, if Evil Leafy and Leafy were to come back together and share a body once again at the end of IDFB. 2. Because of Announcer Now, the Announcer has been tampering with the competition since the start of bfdia. With all the 'money' Leafy gave him in BFDI 25, he could've payed for something to separate the two in order for Evil Leafy to appear at the debut. So... what happened to her? 1. Evil Leafy is dead. This is actually probably the weakest theory, as not only did she have a cameo in Battle for BFDI 6, but Leafy's panic attack in BFB could be evidence that... 2. Evil Leafy is a part of Leafy again. In Battle for BFB 18, Leafy is seen cowering in front of Firey as she is being encouraged to fight Firey. Seeing as Evil Leafy first officially appeared as part of the story when Leafy was extremely mad, it would make sense that she could also gain control over Leafy if Leafy were to undergo a stressful or overwhelming situation. If Evil Leafy was to return to her original host's body, it would explain both her absence in Battle for BFDI AND the visuals during Leafy's panic attack.

There is one problem: LEAFY CAN'T TELEPORT, SHE JUST USED THE MAP (btw, you can notice that in BFDIA 1 when leafy used the map, it was left behind, that's why you don't see leafy teleporting to yoyleland holding a map)

I'm watching this 5 months later, in BFDIA 10 we see Flower driving Lewis' car and we had never seen Evil Leafy A: Leave her body and B: We never saw Flower defrost.

I don’t think this could be true for 1 reason: Evil Leafy died in BFDIA 5c but was in BFDIA 6. The theory said that Firey recovered her, but Firey was dead in 5c. He was recovered in 5d but died again in 5e, so I don’t see how Firey could have recovered her then.

Who knows, maybe leafy when evil leafy is in the same frame than her is actually that ball that appeared on bfdi 25

Fourtle: why isn’t evil leafy in bfb if every other contestant is in bfb already? Nonexisty: bruh

it kinda looks like Evil Leafy was recovered by accident by Team No-Name with the mirror & she might have died again in BFDIA7 by drowning, so she should stay dead this time as long as no one goes into the Evil Here Hotel

To this day, I still believe that Evil Leafy is Leafy's alter-ego. But we won't know for sure until the closure of BFDIA and IDFB.

BFDIA 6 actually explains how evil leafy came back in idfb through the mirror somehow this version though likely could only stay in evil leafy form until standard leafy was recovered (likely by evil leafy herself)

When I first watch BFDIA I didn’t even notice when metal Leafy teleported in that one episode but if evil leafy is leafy, that means evil leafy was there the whole time 😧😧😧😧

Hopefully they will get another appearance in the continuing episodes of BFDIA and, Maybe TPOT?

4:04 more on that theory I have one that can also connect with it idfb and 2023 bfdia 6 take place at the same time because evil leafy returned via a mirror in the shape of her

Upside down they look like a very happy man with a moustache

Fun fact:when leafy teleports the map doesnt come with her leaving it going away because of the wind

I think that Evil Leafy and Leafy are the same person but not exactly since I believe Evil Leafy has a whole different consciousness from her not evil counterpart. She could be a spirit or even a demon that is linked to Leafy's soul in some sort of way

Evil Leafy and Leafy can’t be the same person because Evil Leafy showed up in BFDIA 6, but Leafy was killed by Gelatin way back in BFDIA 5a and wasn’t recovered again until IDFB

HM…good point!

I actually always thought evil leafy was just leafy when she lost control over her anger but I never connected anything in the show😅

at 3:19 from what i remember pin ripped up leafy's map and there isn't any visible way on screen that she would have gotten another because it never shows up again. and also evil leafy mainly moves at a repetitive pace and the only times shes still is when shes going into someone or just standing there, also if leafy was still in evil leafy form at 2:32 wouldn't she have changed back from evil leafy to leafy and wouldn't we have seen it? (Srry abt the rant by the way :/)

you can also use the textbook machine.

Another way leafy could be evil leafy is the fact that in the game 5b went the color of the terrain changes it changes to green which could mean that leafy had transformed into evil through the season ate and killed people and since in the game the color terrain could mean that she just transformed back and then she ate a yoyle berry and thats why she came in idfb with a knife in the last the game 5b gives a lot of proof

Theory: Bfdia 6, 7 and 8 takes place in an alternate universe. Because bfb was made in 2018 and in bfdia 6 it takes place in 2023. And also in bfb 29 announcer says bfb will become another incomplete season. So there for bfdia is in an alternate universe

I hope they expand on the evil leafy lore

Hey I have a theory that I said in the voice actor of eggy and naily channel I said if the gates of dream island is underneath the goiky canal does that mean there technically on dream island

When I was younger I actually got scared by evil leafy

Imagine if Evil Leafy shows up in the TPOT finale.

i might not personally believe in this theory, but i appreciate the reasonable amount of evidence you used to prove your theory UNLIKE *_SOMEONE_*