Hi Paul. James G0EUN. The setup is fine. It appears that the tx indoors dose not work well. The loop is the better antenna for RX, some times things go well, others we have to suck it and see. Good effort. 73 James.

This is not my field, but is not the frame antenna using the electric field and the magnetic loop the magnetic field? I thought that meant that the frame antenna should be rotated 90 degres around its vertical axis if they shall be compared....

Would the Mag Loop work if you had a metal roof? I'm having a hard way to go with ny Chameleon under the metal roof,,,

Thank you for sharing your experience. Happy New Year 73 Leo

Thanks for all videos, love to watch. Always good englisch and good science.

Thanks for posting this. I watched after the live stream. Very interesting results (and very different than what I expected before I watched)!

No problem, I figured you’d find them, no worries!

Thanks, I know this test was very Painful, but very educational 73's

Danke für das tolle Video.Ich lernen von dich,73.von Jozef,Wien.😊😊😊

Menudo curro te has montado saludos

Spent time watching video. Enjoyed watching for over an hour and a half. Interesting video all the way between the two antennas. Take care 73 for now va3grp Canada. Personal Wayne.

S-parameters clearly says that frame loop is wrong way… extremly low Q (wide flat SWR) means low efficiency. Also loop close to metal parts inside room wall does not help cos of its strong coupling. Compare to that the MLA says on analyzer Hi-Q and good efficiency. Anyway the radiated power of both loops is highly degraded inside the room. Try old and thousands time tested Rock-loop! It works compromised but works and it is much easier to build it. I used it on my buss trips to OZ, G, OH, F and worked many QSOs with 50W out. Cheers Paul!

I am no expert in radio and I do not have a shortwave transmitter but I do have a receiver and have researched building a decent AM antenna and followed plans for a frame antenna from a 'Carver' brand receiver instruction manual that was very highly rated and is nearly identical to your frame antenna build. This frame antenna calls for 22 gauge wire which looks to be thinner wire. Just a thought. Does the mag loop need to be a certain length for a specific frequency range?

As to the frame I think good enough for 40m, but can't understand how you provide so good matching of impedances.

It would be interesting to see how that design works outside, away from the closed space and other influencing items.

A good small single Loop is hard to beat ... especially indoors.

It is a great antenna without the shielded wires. It would probably work a lot better if you made a replica with copper tape (5 mm) optimized for a specific band stick to a window. Maybe smaller in diameter with less loops. Just copper tape on a window, try that ? Takes a lot of calculations, but simplicity should be better I gues. Good video, great gear, indoors TX is always a challence.

Thanks for this, it's a pity it didn't work so well. Maybe it's much more sensitive to being indoors? I'm not sure how these are polarised or which is the primary field. Mike M0MSN has built the big version, we will have to see how he gets on, that is at least double the size I think. 73!

BONJOUR ENLEVER LE BALOUD EN DESSOUS DE L ANTENNE JE PENCE?

Hi Paul, intresting this comparison! It seems that frame antenna Is quite deaf🤔, don't you think so? My best from IU2MKE, Beppe

all room conditions for sound and light are perfect with very low noise. your job is excellent now i can choose the good indoor antenna.but what is the max power output can be handled by mag and frame antenna . also is it dangerous to for health by using indoor antenna with 100 watts thanks for you for the very nice trial, it was very useful.

Maybe some hams on your Live Feed can CQ you for your tests? Or schedule a QSO with them? Swing over away from the pile ups, and call CQ for any returns.

Increíble grs 73 EA5ZZ

You got several answers.

thanks, Paul fantastic job 73 from kb2uew

Looks good to me

Would be nice to see this comparison with the antennas outdoors. I would like to make a magloop array 3x3. Antennas are like dogs, they shouldn't be kept inside all day long and you have to keep them for life.

Very good!,

Great comparison lovely rigs 👍 watching from the Philippines, Vy 73 Mabuhay 🌺

Great job, Paul. But I have to laugh at your analyzer's markings. "ANAL YZER" is a bit funny.

OUVRE LES FENETRES ?

;hello from ron---n4net virginia usa nice looking frame antenna !!!!!!

Can you comment on country and city you live in. Ricky from IBM, Ret K4VMS Florida USA

Did you grounding antenas?

Well done !

Do QC on the 20. Signal was answered but weak!

The metal in the walls is going to destroy your signal. It will couple to the wall metal, then re-radiate from each piece of metal, all out of phase with one another. The open roof simply means that you will have at least some signal that goes straight up, but that's about it.

Když jsme jako kluci dělali vysílačky tak vždycky s kruhovou anténou. Myslím, kdyby rámová byla ve tvaru kruhu tak by fungovala mnohem lépe.

спасибо,понел я,а поляризация у них одинакова?

Nice audio good video

MOI LE DOUBLE VITRAGE CA MARCHE PAS

What a good air, Paul! I have no such in Moscow. There is much noise here.

Thanks for sharing

I rthink the frame antenna will be just perfekt for me. 😀 and much better than a few meters of wire out the window. 🤨

try the frame antenna with 6 inch gaps between windimngs

Might be better at night?

Hey Paul I really need your help to be able to calibrate the mini 1300 would you please help me

well by 26min in it is clear to me the loop is a better item..

At the very least, it should be a decent receive antenna. 73

20 meter looks good now turn your mic gain up, you got answers they reported weak signa. Mag antenna is good lotsa answers

There has to be something amiss with the frame loop. It shouldn't be that much worse.

He is answering you

It is AMS TO BNC

Gut

Wystaw antenę na zewnątrz

Malloppo tooop.

👏🏾👍🏾💪🏾

Hi Paul. In a case like this I would think it better to have everything set up before you start the video, then explain your intentions, and then straight into tjhe video test, . Not critisizing, just a thought.73 James.

Hello thanks for the test very interesting. Ron. Z. .. the north American shortwave radio and toy robot museum.

He answering you on both antenna

We learn nothing from always winning!

The only thing I dislike about your vids is that everything is so slooow and drawn out. Other than that,👍.

Ha ha good luck to you!

The antennas are far to close to the walls. Best to work outside. 73s

I'm sorry, I just can't justify having to pay 6000 pounds for a radio!!!

its better to show reversebeacon reports and faster too ;)

Geeze those guys don't stop yapping long enough to get a word in my gosh how disappointing!!!!!

Your test proves what has been known for decades... a low SWR does not necessarily mean that an antenna is a good or efficient radiator/receptor. The frame antenna seems to be very lossy and inefficient. This is what the wide bandwidth and low SWR tells me. A mag loop is a negative gain antenna but very narrow band and selective, which is the main positive point for a mag loop... for the frame antenna to be so much worse it is not a viable option. More of an open air dummy load on a stand. Good test and you did a very nice job in construction however something just doesn't add up. I believe that if you took the wire from the frame antenna (or same length wire) and stretched it out in a linear fashion you would have better reception than the frame antenna, even if untuned. I suspect that if you tested both of these antennas again outdoors you would see similar results. I am curious what would happen if you tuned the frame antenna for max rx signal instead of low SWR... rx only of course no tx. just for reference and comparison, I will have to go back and watch your frame antenna build video again... when I watched it earlier it looked like there was no connection between the 2 sections of the tuning capacitor. Perhaps I just did not see it. As you most likely know some air variable capacitors are common connected on the "ground"/frame/stationary side but the variable/moving sections are independent and have to be parallel connected to combine capacitance. I may be wrong with what I thought I saw. I have never seen an air variable like the one you used.

Note to myself: Never buy a QRP rig. 🤥