After watching a couple times, I think the audience kept yelling Jessica's name as a sort of request to the girls. Like asking "where is she, is she okay?" Because usually the girls explain why one or two of them are missing, if they're sick or out doing an acting gig. But the girls kept being quiet about it, making the audience anxious and keep asking "Jessica?" They didn't know why she wasn't there, and the girls were crying despite singing mostly happy songs- the girls couldn't even cover most of Jessica's parts which further shows something last minute happened. When they would cover one of her parts, they would end up crying again. If I were in the audience that day, I'd be worried- then to leave after the performance to find out that SNSD would no longer be 9. I'm sure the girls wanted to make up an excuse, say "oh Sica is just sick! Sorry if we fumble with her parts" but they'd be lying, and we know they don't like to deceive their sone. They wanted the audience to stop chanting her name, but couldn't even bring themselves to talk about it. We don't know what happened that day, if she was kicked out by SM, the girls, or both- or if she took it upon herself to leave. The whole situation is extremely sketchy, SM and Jessica both have different stories that have changed a little each time we read them. Despite what went down, it took a toll on the girls and on Jessica. Sica's gotten the confidence to finally start talking about her debut days, the times she liked about SNSD, when SNSD was stressful- she's finally gotten that courage back. But SNSD? Either they still can't make themselves talk about it as freely, or SM is wanting them to stay quiet. Keep supporting them both, stay a Sone and stay a Golden Star. Let them talk about it when they're comfortable.

It's 2021 but still it hurts. It just fade away without clear explanation.

This video kinda makes it very obvious who Choo Mina is. She looked very very happy to sing Jessica’s lines, and she didn’t forget to sing a single one. Everyone else slipped up a couple times.

Nine years later, Sica set foot in Shenzhen without any threats to ban her from coming here. Fans were worth the wait

Because of their agency, SNSD would have the best last farewell concert as 9member at Tokyo Dome.

The fact that it's been more than 6 years and we still don't know what happened

You know this is serious when Taeyeon can't reach a highnote.(In Mr. Mr.)

35:44 my angel... JESSICAAAAA MY SUNSHINEEEEE i cried...

Yoona looks distracted through out the event.. Tiffany seems to be noticed this at 48:33 and try to comfort her, but to no avail.. Lastly, Yoona ran towards the end to Sunny during the photo session..

54:42 Tipany asked Sunny if she was okay...

The most heartbreaking fanmeet

When fan shout change from Jessica to SNSD at 54:55 , look at Taeyeon😭 I know we are sad, but our SNSD is worse than us

50:17 Tiffany is like : "Oh no, they start again"

41:28 Yoona and Sooyoung were like : Oh! Where is Jessica ??? . Then glaced at Hyoyeon, and just smiled 😢😢

They sang Complete, tho they’re incomplete, Jessica usually starts the song and no one covered... rewatching this makes me so emotional. Ot9 😭 My YulSic 💔😭yuri was crying at the end,everyone was emotional, sunny cant even smile . 😭😭😭😭

42:16 taeyeon almost fell. I really miss ot9...jessica😍😢 (whos watching this in 2017)

Who's with me in 2021 crying over this fancam? 😭

*52:29** Tiffany was about to cry her heart out T_T*

they all wore black cuz this was the funeral of OT9 😭😭😭 SNSD will always be 9 in our hearts

who saw this in 2019? anyone remember? I really miss them and him 💕💗💕💗💔💔💔😥😥😥

I still remember this day When I woke up and knows about this. In that day im still secondary school now im in university and almost graduate I always miss you Jessica

THESE VIDEO PROVES ALL OF US MISS SICA 😔😞AND THEY DIDN'T LIP SYCING 😅🙂😚😊

2022, I still cry :(

Tiff was just t so sad and mad at the same time😢

Sunny looks extremely pissed in The Boys, oh no

38:04 it should be TAENGSIC MOMENT😢😢

I’m seeing this again this 2020.. I can’t help but cry whenever Jessica’s part is missing and cry again when they look pissed.. 😭 Anyway, I miss SNSD!!! COMEBACK PLEASE for 13th anniversary!!! 😍

As always, Taeny stood/sat beside each other to distract people from any issue was there about

That must have been a tough day.

I didn't follow this drama as much as most, but I think a lot of the comments are missing a bigger-picture trauma playing out onstage. These 8 are in shock. People react differently to shock. I tend to zone out and just get on with the job until I can process it in my own time. You can see various members doing just that -- trying really hard to be professional. Others have the emotions come out at unexpected moments. But I think -- and you can see it near the end most of all -- there is fear behind the shock. In all of them. That fear is that this is the beginning of the end of the group. They had a great run for 7 years, and people more powerful than them just demonstrated they can dismiss a member real quick.

So I've been back to binge watches some of SNSD's live performances from debut days until early 2014. There have been so many stages when they were incomplete. OT6, OT7, OT8 were the most formation. And mostly it was came from Actress/Maknae lines absent due to their filming schedule. And yet still.. some members during the introduction section (usually Tiffany), used to informed the audiences why some members wasn't on stage. ~But certainly not for this one! Clearly some deep things happened and it was all messed-up decision made in the VERY last minute. 😔

yuri looked so heartbroken & upset at the end 🥺

It didn't help that all the fans were shouting Jessica, imagine how hard it must of been for the girls!!

3 years ago. I just started to be a sone then you will see a news knowing Jessica is leaving. its not my first time seeing this video but still new for me. if I could go back time. I always missed her. in every song I play. its just sad. I wish they can be friends again. a really really close friends.

23:18 when the host calls Tiffany the leader Taeyeon...

"I was excited about out upcoming fan events only to shockingly be informed by my company and 8 others that as of today, I'm no longer member." -Jessica GOSH.. THIS PUNCHLINE HITS HARDER AFTER WATCHING THE WHOLE EVENT! 😭

Gw balik lagi nonton ini di 2022 tetep aja selalu nyesek 😭😭😭

I miss you Jessica...9人のソシが見たい😭

miss ot9😭😭😭

In this whole show,Yoona,Sunny can't even smiled

Snsd didn't know that they need to cover part of Jessica 😭😭

Even if you weren't aware of what happened before the performance you can tell something's wrong. Look at Sunny's face she's mad as hell. Mr. Taxi is her song where it's all smile and sexy pose. She didn't smile at all and kept a straight face. Whatever happened Sunny wasn't please with it and it showed on her face and body expression.

51:10 Sooyoung looks like she just wants to go home...

The strength it must have took to go from Goodbye straight into Kissing You... these poor girls.

they still keep professional cause it's work audience's pay for OT9 it but in that day damn their hearts broke so much 😔 - Plus in china Jessica Rank no.1 her fans no jokes

Be strong and be heathly my girls

What happened to their hair at 42:05. I was freaking sad and holding back tears until i saw yoona’s and hyoyeon’s hair lol. Even sooyoung almost bursted out laughing

8:46 at that point they knew they were on enemy territory. 10:38 wow the JESSICA in the fanchant is loud as hell Yoona is a wonderful actress but it looks like it was a political decision as jessica being her friend to not even try to act her smile

This is so heartbreaking 😞🥺

There is still Jessica voice 💖

i still feel this way too..

How curious how sooyoung was the one who took the jessica lines. I didn't even suspect of her being the bad here she's a good actress and she even left sment after Jessica's scandal. What a snake

7:26 Tiffany bent down alone 🥲

What does Tiffany said in 32:12? Did i hear her said JESSICA ?

i'm here again...28 may 2024...

6:20 Tiffany looks unhappy and barely even tries to dance. :(

They usually playing on stage at kissing you and Gee, but look at this.. 😢😢😢

Messy lol. I can't tell if they left her parts unsung as a sign of respect, or because they were all afraid of looking like they supported booting her for more parts? I can't imagine what it was like for the fans that day too. To be so excited to see them only to find out what happened. What a sad and confusing time for Sone and probably for the girls too. I still to this day think SM and Jessica had the dispute and maybe SM made it seem like the girls were backing them in their decision. Some of them look genuinely distraught, others look like they couldn't care less :/

what am i doing here? at the same exact day but 6 years after. i'm torturing myself again

OT9 Forever 💗

心疼喊Jessica的人

이게 벌써 10년 전이구나...

Gilaa ini vocal mereka keren banget, nyanyi live dan stabil banget. Padahal ini peristiwa sejarah bagi sone. Tapi mereka bisa nyanyi mulus gitu pdhal lagi nahan nyesek paska berita Jess keluar.

If you guys hate Tiffany's performances because she seems pissed off, for me I'll do like that too! Maybe even worse if my friend being kicked out from my group

They may all be smiling, but their eyes can't lie. There is pain that they hide behind it. The girls still smile even though it might be difficult for them 🙁😢💔 I started crying when the fans shouted Jessica's name and when that happened, the girls' faces started to change, not really visible but I know that. You girls are really strong💗💗💗💗

when Tiffany made a mistake on the Hoot song, you guys shouted mockingly. And then called back Jessica's name. At least appreciate the members who keep trying to perform optimally for you guys. There are many burdens that Tiffany is facing. There is a lot of sadness she is trying to cover up. because when they can't display something perfectly, even fans can act like haters. said that they were not professional at work! they would be called lazy! even when they tried to show tears, someone called it a fake cry. Sorry for my bad English.

Yoonaaa

snsd's goodbye is plain without jessica's chorus

It's still hurting me when i see how they let sica's parts blank there and how uri taengoo can't give her best for this performance. We all know that she always do her best and she can hit every high notes easily but not that day, she can't. Her high notes is so stable even when she had to sing 20 times in one concert. It so sad to see her tried to hit that high notes whlie she also tried not to cry at the same time. Hopefully one day they will perform with 9 full members although jessica can't go back with that 8 girls as snsd's member anymore.

there still jessica voice

I think Tiffany sunny and yoona are the most visibly distraught

its literally 2020 amd im still bitter

I can't explain Tiffany's face during The Boys performance. She looks sad, disappointed or what.

Who looked this in 2018???:')

I miss ot9💜💜

There literally no defending in this. And to people who said it’s SM fault, they supported Jessica’s business and even advertised it in their movie in the same year. People who say SNSD themselves doesn’t have power clearly don’t know they said previously multiple times they come up with decisions according to votes among themselves. Dispatch also released an article before it got released immediately stating the members themselves came to Sm saying they won’t share a stage with Jessica if she was there in the fan meeting. Moreover it said some members parents also got involved with it an demanded jessica to be removed. And mind you this was all because she started a business. People saying “Well why was she selfish to choose to do that” or “She missed group schedules” etc, the members started going into solo careers alr, many had released eps or started acting, so why couldn’t jessica do it too? And not to mention Jessica’s attendance as a member was one of the highest so clearly she could balance all of it. All members resigned the contract and jungsis season 2 was going to be recorded as well as their duet album, which was confirmed by the director on Instagram. Yes, I don’t think Jessica was right in everything because in an argument it’s impossible to be all right and she has her flaws too, but she definitely was not in the wrong and was kicked out the group by her members due to jealousy. Sm themselves would’ve rebuked her statement or even sued her for lying, but nothing happened because they knew she was right. All they could do was blacklist her. There’s so much evidence online which all match and are consistent people defending their actions should stop being delusions. Definitely some were against it, but at the end of the day, what’s done is done. I don’t want to point fingers and be certain, but clearly Yoona, Seohyun and maybe Sunny were very uncomfortable in this video. Yoona seemed to be angry at one point with Tiffany and Seohyun ignored many of them and even cried. I don’t want to point out others but some definitely seemed suspiciously guilty, it’s so obvious when people feel this way. Jessica spent as long or even longer and worked as hard as them to be in that group. It’s not really justified to ruin someone’s job, especially after you’ve worked AND known them for years, even if you’re not friends with them or have conflict. Yes they probably have a good side to them but this was something wrong for them to do, and they just can’t admit it. What’s worse is the fact they tried to erase jessica out of everything, even till today.

Iknow all of us miss sica but i also dont want to see their reaction when all sone shouting jessica ....not only us are hurt also them if we have time machine i think that we need to go back at that time/or time when they debut😞😔

so nobody's gna mention how sunny sang so well at 30:19 ?

They are singing Complete in 930. Good:)

Pantess sooyong sama yuriii masuk akting jagoi sih nutupin kemunafikannga

Snakes 🐍

their formations are still for 9 members. It was very sudden that they didn't havd time to fix their formations.

Miss GG OT9 😭

Tiffany

Aw

Jessica jessica jessica:(

2019

5:23 🤧🤧

Imagine seeing your own fans crying in despair and don’t say a word to comfort them. Yikes!

Every 30-09 i always comeback here

I've never seen yoona look so angry 😳 48:33 Sooyoung almost looked happy at the crowd shouting Jessica's name lol It feels like taeyeon was having a mental breakdowns during Mr Mr.

Did anyone notice that they are wearing black and given a pink apron to prevent staining? 😏😏

2021 anyone 😭😭😭

2019 ),:

😭😭😭😭😭😭💔

why no one cover Jessica's Part... 😭😭😭 and everytime Jessica's part are missing, all the fans shouted... 😓😓😓

Ayo 2020

So sad sones had raised a misinformative and smeary campaign against an important member of their favorite group with ZERO EVIDENCE against her. NEVER PROVED ANYTHING.

47:45 Is there anyone who knows what Yuri are saying in Chinese? I am curious of her letter

tiffany i know you feels , you very hurt bcos you twins leave forever , and you can't see you twins anymore .