If I could just get an entire hour long podcast of these two riffing in Liverpool accents that would be great.

F'ing losing it at "I sauce all these isosceles" 😂😂😂

2.5 hours of comedy gold. Gareth is an absolute treat. ❤

The. Healthy. Jeff. Foxworthy. Riff was gold! 😂😂 😂

AN INSTANT CLASSIC. Two riffmasters just riding the wave together. This was solid gold from start to finish and I'd love more of these two together. Just pure joy. I've been listening to YMIW for over a decade and it's still so awesome when Pete finds such great chemistry with someone. Some of his best riff partners that come to mind: Jeremiah Watkins, Mulaney, Chelsea Peretti, Gethard, Riki Lindhome, Chris Thayer... I know there are more I'm forgetting!

Gareth reynolds doing jay leno on dorrito commercials might be the funniest thing since dr. Phil on KT last year

*Two of my ALL TIME favorite comics in ONE PLACE* ❣️❣️❣️

Having a real rough time lately and I needed to laugh so badly right now. Absolutely adore Gareth in every single thing he does- he’s such a smart, talented comic and seems like a genuinely great guy. He ALWAYS makes me laugh and he deserves all the success in the world! Great episode 👏🏼

I wish I could "like" this completely unhinged conversation more than once!

The triangles killed me

This is one of the best You Made It Wierd episodes,love Gary!

Been listening to and watching Pete for a LOOONG time… i don’t think I’ve ever seen or heard him genuinely laugh that hard. So much so, he has to pause and pull himself together. The “piss my pants” story got me.

That Foxworthy bit had me absolutely cracking up. Great interview, Gareth is so damn hilarious.

My favourite part of the "isosceles" bit was when Jay Leno could identify a dorito as half of a RHOMBUS, but couldn't remember the word "triangle." Pure fucking gold! (<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="123">2:03</a>:57)

"I didn't have any idea that I would be an isosceles man" might be the best improv line of the last decade of shows. Such a good set up and landing 😆

Checkin in from the Gareforce.

PET f just CRYING 😂 Gareth is such an amazing talent!

This was something truly special.

From the "slapping bit" going too long to all riffing going back and forth... for too long... I was laughing the whole time with you guys! Great show! Do another one soon. 👍🤘

The family feud riffing was great😂 I was in tears just listening to it. Love moments like this when he bounces of another comic and gets this organic golden moments

45 min in, already love these two together. Lovely episode

Came here to just listen to the Jay Leno impersonations and listen to it in its entirety….on repeat! 😄 havent laughed so hard at a podcast interview in a long time

The “Not Gonna Look Like Your Father” Riff Gave Me A Headache From Laughing 😂😂😂

Nice to see Garfy is showing up dressed like other folks on podcasts now and it's not just Jake. ❤

This pod made me so happy. Giving the whole damn thing another listen 😂👏🏻👏🏻

Loved all the laughs shared in this episode! Gareth is awesome!

I haven’t laughed so hard in years. Beautiful conversation. 💛

The Bill Burr impression😂

These two make a perfect pair bc you can tell Gareth will riff on anything and Pete is a great at the “yes and” stuff so it just keeps going and going making those 2.5 hrs fly by.

This has been the best 2 1/2 hours of laughs I’ve had all year. Thanks guys!

Cackling while working from home. The riffing was off the charts! 😂😂😂 Fantastic afternoon laughs thanks to this!

the Foxworthy part had me in tears

Comedian synergy! Love these two together!

One of my favorite episodes! These 2 are hilarious~ love the energy!😆👏🏼

The funniest pod I've seen in a while

BEST EPISODE

Fantastic! 2 of my favorites together.

Look @ Gareth, all cleaned up! ❤

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="2769">46:09</a> had to pull over😂😂😂

Really great. couldn't stop laughing

Steve Martin walked away from stand up to become one of the most beloved actors of his era he didn't go back to his hometown and open a tire store

One of the best Weirds I’ve heard❤❤❤❤ Gareth? More like Goateth

The magnetic pull of the Doritos bit was amazing to watch. 😂😂😂

I want these two to interview Rainn Wilson together. Rainn sitting in between them so he can't see both of them at the same time.

Hot riffs guys HOT RIFFS

If your favorite mouthwash Isn't Jameson, you're not gonna look like your father.

Effing hilarious guys!!

I am so looking forward to this one. Love both of you!

Was this the best episode ever? Yes.

Three cheers for Gareth!

100% would buy that shirt.

I must have watched the Jay Leno “i sauce all these” isosceles part an easy 50 times it’s so goddamn funny

I have to be honest. I haven't listened to YMIW in a long time. The last time I listened, Pete had just started dating Val so a while. He got into the new age stuff for me, not a problem it just wasn't for me. I love Pete, and he brings me so much joy. This was the first episode I have listened to /watched in a while. Gareth and him have wonderful chemistry. This was a delight.

this was the best time. thank you for this.

I have literally listened to this episode three times now. So damn funny.

Great duo jeez! I'm dying!

I one time in Nashville pretended to not know anything Pete did other then the E*trade baby and made him sign a zannies card as E*trade baby. Love this guy

Gary!!!!!

“If you know Hershey first and foremost as a city in Pennsylvania” lmaoo

I would watch these two every fucking week. What a delight

Leno riff starts here <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="117">1:57</a>:38

Top tier episode. It brought me back to the Not Feelin It days!

Rich people family feud will stay in my brain for a looooong time. Thank you.

Two of the funniest, silliest guys around. Gareth is fantastic.

I've never laughed so hard during a podcast! I looked like a lunatic on my way to work. 😂

Also, I think Milwaukee, Wisconsin May be the only city that celebrates “Bastille Days”. They just extend it from July 14 through the 17. Because you can’t sell all those bed sheets in just one day.

It’s been five days and I can’t stop saying I sauce all these isosceles 😂

The kids were actually quite kind not to call him Petf- file.

When yall started slowing down and there were 30 min left in the episode, I knew something special was coming. Isosceles is incredible

Oooooooooooo nice, two heavy hitters when it comes to bits. And comedy in general of course.

i have watched this not even kidding 5 times now..i’ve never laughed so much at a podcast

Is there really a shirt? (Or was there?) I don't see anything related on the site!

Hardest I’ve laughed in a long time, holy shit!

Riffin' Bits!

Where’d that time go? Hilarious - We need a part 2 asap. Bring in a Brit to riff with, I nominate Jimmy Carr.

I know you hate it, but your pod was the one that finally pushed me to buy Magic Spoon cereal and it’s really good!!!

all the corners are 60 degrees. It's called a equilateral triangle

Omg the J Lenno impression had me laughing so hard. So funny!! 😂

I knew Gareth Reynolds was a Midwestern when I realized his mannerisms were identical to Andrew Santino. Fellow Wisconsinite here.

Indiana Jones: What are you going to do; sell this podcast on the black market? It belongs in a museum!

This is an all-timer

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="120">2:00</a>:05 you’re welcome 😊

Pete youre one of the funniest mthrfkrs on earth! me and my mom were listenng to youm in the car the other day " pickies nor snax later? JJJJEEEEEEEEEWWWWWWWWSSSSSSS???????????" OMFG IM DYING

The "Backwards Gary Busey" - HA! (Sorta fitting.)

When Willem Dafoe hosted SNL, I thought I’d never get to hear another Wisconsin native do a British accent. But this was well worth the wait!!!

We had the shared bath in Australia Edit I laughed so hard at the leno that I missed my goddamn exit in NJ yesterday, thanks a lot Gary!

❤

that was funny

Really hoping Pete makes that shirt and it sells 3 but two of them are the same size 😂

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="124">2:04</a>:14 omg I'm dying do this for an hour plz

With my eyes closed, he sounds like a gruff Mark Normand

Dracula!!!! ifykyk

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="169">2:49</a>

Your gonna tell me that isn’t Andrew Santinos brother

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="118">1:58</a>:11

Give me a Leno dorito shirt asap

Fam Feud ⚰️

Love you both, but you couldn't be further from correct about Richard Karn's sex appeal. I do believe he's what they call a "Daddy".

Having soup in a bread bowl and not eating the bowl is the most offensive thing I've ever heard ever on a podcast

Pete, you’re way funnier than Joe Koi; dude literally shares a name with a pond people put ugly goldfish in to so they can throw away old bread.