Hes killing it 😂😂😂 this occupation was a blessing in disguise

definitely

I hope this would motivate many in the cabinet

I feel like GNU exposes one another and who's better candidates, ramapoza is destroying his own Comdre now but showing that he is the capitalist enemy of the people 😅

Many ANC ministers would push such things under the carpet. WELL DONE MINISTER GAYTON!👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿

That bitter pill might help us hold some people accountable.

@@Prof.Maxwell yes - that's what Im hoping for too.... Unless Squirrel tells Gayton to "wind his neck in" for fear of Gayton exposing him too....

Gayton is a convict who shouldn't be serving in the government.

100%, it should be published on the departments website. People who received R350 had to line up in public for hours waiting 4 the post office to give them the money. Artist, etc. think they are special, nothing is shaming here, unless you they don't deserve it.

​@@therealmncwanegwabeni7263my bra so now they must give us the list of everyone getting sassa grant and everyone in tenders with the government

Not the government's money. belongs to taxpayers!

100% POPI should not apply here. The government must account to the public.

Especially Covid funding

@pranks true 💯✅ and more so when the money can go where it should be more needed

They must show us the list of all sassa grants

@@Cairo96 true especially if the real recipient(s) of it aren't getting it and it's going to someone in government/ the private sector which probably often already happens

Behind shaming people,that what happens when you take power and give ma coloured.now he wants to pump money in sppining.

@@Cairo96you see this Segregation of Coloureds and blacks is wrong to a whole degree we struggle with the same challenges drugs,Poverty,Violence, alcoholism etc plagues both coloureds and blacks

Is it a crime or ethical ? If the answer is yes to both then the minister must report to the police or ethical committee in government

We want them to be exposed so that they dont benefit next time ​@@DumaM-ir7rk

If you are on ARVs must the government list you as people who are costing the country.why not name the people who processed the funds.

True 👍

So you saying they must show us the names of all the people getting sassa grant

@@Cairo96Is that a crime? 🤷‍♀️

@@Cairo96 Yes. Why not?

How convenient

​@@tam1641???

We also need to know who got contracts for Eskom, transnet and other government institutions

That'd be interesting 🤔

Contracts are publicly available on the site of nearly all government institutions including who put in the bid for what amount

@@ikkeixarra4255 thanks we will check. Now all this big contract must be decided in parliament not by ministers anymore

You call shaming people transparency.ok he must now give us the name of the people who paid out the money

Some had salaries to pay out. So I heard

​@@conniepothas9760but there is nothing wrong with the list being made public and it does not necessarily mean that people appearing on the list were corrupt. Nobody said they were corrupt

@MzamoAdoons372 I agree. That it should be made public. All government expenditures should. But it keep getting implied that more white people ask for money and they don't need it. That's what I have a problem with. All artists could have applied. The government should never have stopped people for business.

@@Tinker8531 one can never really know someone's pocket, especially when it comes to artists who usually portray themselves as monied, when they are infact broke. Either way, artists lost out on gigs due to the lockdown and did deserve some sort of support from the govt. Rich or not.

It was wrong in the sense that it wasn't distributed fairly

You call shaming people work my brother you are blinded by this criminal.he must give us the names of the people who paid out the money.

what are you saying?..lol

100%, it’s tax payers money thus public interest as public funds. Can’t be private or not disclosed

Please invite your dad's friends as guests ie malema and shibambu

Did you apply for relief?

It is like they are paid for not entertaining us😂😂😂

😂😂😂😂😂 defence mechanics

...and a future where the VBS/EFF agglomerate could collapse.

I could foresee a plausible future where these respective One-man leader parties could collapse as with the absence of the leader. Then these homeless politicians might just go back to the ANC.

He's going too jail😂😂

@@jafassss This is not about Sizwe.Just listen to what he says.

But EFF was linked to VBS long ago, where have you been. Daily Maverick had a whole investigation tracking Floyd's credit card showing how his wedding was paid for with VBS funds.

...because it does not serve its biased agenda..

His father is the chair of the EFF

Bear in mind that this is not biased media controlled by white suprimist Rupert and friends. This one is real, makoya 😅

He'll find some "theory" about how this is a political ploy and not really representative of the true EFF or it's values. Julius is genuine and the struggle must continue 😂

Yes please 🥺

It is unfair if you want all that from Gayton. He is the Minister of just one department.

@@user-dv5vv6hn7h If one ministers can do it then it should be part of GNU

So if you are on ARVs, must the government list you as people who are costing the country.name the people who processed the funds.

And we are here for it.

I think this list should be extenderd to 80 years, Then we will all see .

@@buyiselwaxozumthi3908Yebo!

@@buyiselwaxozumthi3908 that would be epic.

Taxes are revenue to the government, it’s not a donation from tax payer. Taxes are one of several sources of revenue. Once it’s in government coffers it’s all government money. They also run deficits so get loans to cover that, they also charge levies, royalties and sell licenses etc. If we are going to be pedantic about it, the government in a democracy is the people.

​@@khaltsharivist365whatever dude/dudess! Reasoning like a mosquito all around the room!

Your kind finally arrived here

He won't tell us about VBS bank sagga.Hes very bias

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 ​@@user-wo2wy8rq4h

It is not his department.vbs is not his department.

Thank you very much!

18 months 😁 s not far away 😊

🤣 thanks for the tip!

😯😂

It is at the very bottom 😂😂😂

😂

😂😂

Sizwe, your thoughts?

I spoke about the VBS report when Adv Motau’s report was released. And I’ll do a video on new revelations soon. Unlike some, I am actually reading the material. 😁

​@@_SMWXGood response my brother alot of people want you to be a propaganda machine only retract your statements later when things are proved the other way round good move and a good response to labo abaphaphayo

@@_SMWXthat’s why you have a PhD. You know how to read effectively.

We enjoy your considered response to current affairs leave the sensationalism to others

True. Its those close to the right ppl who get funds not those who need it.

So if you on ARVs,must the government list you as people who are costing the country.name the people who processed the funds

​@@Cairo96that is protected information ito law relating to medical records(Privalaged relationships between med prac and patients)...this is something completely different. You're argument is weak and without thought...please try again.

POPI Act only allows the collection and processing of personal data for a specific purpose that is lawful, justified, and compatible with the reason it was collected for. In this instance the beneficiaries information have been misused by the Dept through the MEC, as the divulging thereof in public domain was not an intended purpose. Furthermore, the preservation of their personal dignity, a core human right in the SA Constitution has also been breach by this public official, a week after taking an oath to upheld the self-same Bill of Rights. In accordance with the POPI Act’s principle of Openness, citizens should be informed about the purpose for which your personal information will be used, whereupon permission should be obtained from them to that end. Also, the receivers of such data should ensure that the information accurate, complete, and up to date, and take reasonable steps to ensure its accuracy. Apparently, none of these legislative prescripts were adhered to by the Dept, who should have advised the Minister. Apperantly, people's names were listed as beneficiaries who never received any assistance from the Dept. Aggrieved parties can have a field day in court with this apparent malicious act on the part of the MEC and his advisors, all for the sake of political expediency. I foresee legal claims far exceeding R73m being instituted against the Dept with good chances of success. Government should set an example in the upholding of their own laws. As the courts has set precedent with the CR17 donor list, I can't see how the MEC is going to be able to disentangle himself from this mess. How will the public ever again have confidence in putting your name or info to any official document or application form, knowing very well chances are it will appear in the press a few years down the line, for the sake of personal political clout.

@@pvs3334 I don't need schooling... In the profession and well informed, thank you. You miss the point professor. It's a social / moral / ethical issue. Read more books if you like but wake up to the real world that we live in.

@redhowell7856 The intention was never to belittle, to sound academic, or to patronize, apologies if so received. The point is that when the dismissal of Individual Privacy Rights is cheered on by the public, it is cause for grave concern because all other human rights hinge on the former. Whether it be the preservation of personal property ownership, religious thought, own ideas and convictions, bodily integrity, etc. I think we should mature democratically and graduate from first tier needs thinking, to be able to understand what a dangerous slippery slope this presents. Even the media has to petition the government or courts to obtain sensitive info and have to prove that its intended publication is in public interest. One should at least expect the MEC to have at least adhered to similar exercises before his Dept divulged personal data of citizens in the public sphere. They now, after the fact, try to suggest that there could be discrepancies & improprieties with the info and possible corruption by their own officials. We, as the public, need the shielding of our rights from government abuse simply because they have enforcement powers to request our personal data.

Gonto Sports art & culture website the list is there. Ppl have even posted it on X. Its extensive.

You were told, now you demand, why can't you wait and be informed with facts rather tha a color ? I wish i could see what was done with those fonds before covit, and before 1994. That will be very interesting . Those who wait , will see . Those who demand will be expose very soon than they thought. (Imo )

Tell us who these artists are

@ nonhlanhlamadlala5034 good question . My question is if they have committed crime then why we don’t report to the police and if it’s ethical matter than deal with them on the ethics and publish later after you have heard both sides. Is it a crime to apply and qualify?

Who shamed them? Tax payers are asking what going on with their money that's all.

​@@DumaM-ir7rk My point exactly. You follow the correct process to get funds, if you don't get it's fine. The problem is when you attack the recipient instead of someone commiting corruption in your department as administrator of the fund.

@@AffectionateMountainRang-xv8gvthe list is there genius

But if this is not criminal or ethical. My question is why publish the list ?

Enkosi!

Wow, thanks!

It was Covid lockdowns & they could not work or travel.

I second this. it was a distress /relief fund not a supplement or enrich fund. They should be investigated and prove that they needed not wanted the money. Ticking the box of being an entertainer during covid is not a justified criteria.

They did not steal it but it must be stoped.

lmfao, same. He is very quiet now all of a sudden. He didnt upload in 4 days... divine intervention let us see who the wolves are in sheeps clothing

So far the subscriber growth is going well.

Ian Cameron is not a racist, look at the work he has done in recent years.

Yes agree, im sick of the race grifting narrative when we have serious problems. Can't stomach it any longer. Last straw for me. I'm out

If one has been watching Ian Cameron he has vast experience on the ground. He did apoligise and he is not a racist He has stood his ground on those saps cops that are doing a great job. Supported them. People are quick to judge but need to check out what the person has actually achieved. Yes im also tired of this white story, not every person is a racist. People need to look deeper than the colour of a person's skin.

Sad to see thats all that matters to you amidst the mess SA is in ​@@_SMWX

You are aware that these artists are also paying tax on their income as well as all other forms of additional taxes, i.e VAT, etc. And if they earned more than you, their contributions to the fiscus would be more than yours. Don't fall into this lazy thinking trend: Imagine the 18m SASSA grant recipients names be publicized in the the media to be heralded as a good thing. The POPI Act was specifically introduced for the purpose of preventing misuse of personal information. For the selfsame reason the annual matric results are not published with names of students anymore, to protect the individual learner's dignity. In the SA historical contex of dehumanizing of our black forebears, the dignity of the individual is sacrosanct to our constitutional dispensation and foundational to the SA democratic project.