GEORGE R.R. MARTIN says SCREENWRITERS always make it WORSE! w/Author MAX ALLAN COLLINS!

No video

GEORGE R.R. MARTIN says SCREENWRITERS always make it WORSE! w/Author MAX ALLAN COLLINS!

Рет қаралды 6,559

Күн бұрын

#houseofthedragon #georgerrmartin #truenoir #maxallancollins #originalcontent #ip
SUPPORT THE TRUE NOIR Kickstarter!!!
www.kickstarte...
Have a Question to be read LIVE, on AIR...? Just want to share your enjoyment of the content? Send at TIP to The Burnettwork right HERE: streamelements...
Just want to support the work on the channel? Venmo: @Robert-Burnett-17
TONIGHT'S ARTICLES:
variety.com/20...
variety.com/20...
Become a part of the Post-Geek Singularity by joining our KZfaq community (you'll also get access to exclusive perks): bit.ly/PGSJoin
Do you want to send in a letter for Rob to read and respond to? Just click here and complete our online form: postgeeksingul.... And if your letter is more than 500 words in length, you'll need to submit it as an "Extra Take" by clicking here: postgeeksingul...
About The Burnettwork:
The Burnettwork is home to a community of creators and fans from around the world. We're dedicated to creating a dynamic and respectful place where genre entertainment enthusiasts can celebrate the stories they love.
Check out The Post-Geek Singularity for yourself by going to our website: postgeeksingul...
Other links you may find of interest:
• Follow us on social media ► theburnettwork...
• Send us letters ► postgeeksingul...
• Join the PGS Community online ► / discord
• Join The Burnettwork ► bit.ly/PGSJoin
• "Rules" for participation in The Burnettwork ► bit.ly/PGS_Code
moviebusiness,boxoffice,barrydiller,oscar,theoscars,oscarbait,movietheaters,

Пікірлер: 36

@CaptainNotFinity Ай бұрын

RMB and MAC was a winning combo and a gold mine of information for the studious writer 🥂 thank you both

@TheHappeeSinnick Ай бұрын

Wasn’t GRRM just about a year ago saying that fans were too fixated on faithful adaptations and that they hated things before seeing them?

@Zethonring23 Ай бұрын

It's awful how things have become, I used to have all these idea of great novels and historical events I'd like to see adapted for the screen but lately I just don't know anymore, I'm too afraid of these egotistical directors and showrunners that think they know better, trying to "reimagine" or "modernize" the story rather than giving us a faithful retelling. But at the same time I still want an adaptation for my own entertainment and so more people can discover and fall in love with these stories too, such a pain. Also, my favourite miniseries is probably Angels in America, dude that Al Pacino monologue with Patrick Wilson blew me away, I'd just be walking around my house reciting it for months afterwards 😂

@anthonygonzalez514 Ай бұрын

I personally asked GRRM once, if he preferred TNG or DS9 more and he answered "FORBIDDEN PLANET".. 😅

@raymondsmith6870 Ай бұрын

I was reading these hardboiled Italian crime novels by Massimo Carlotto and the translator of the book to English made interesting comments how you want to keep the tone of the book and the original creator intent intact but many phrases in one language don't work in English as they would in the original language. So in a way he is forced of rewrite some sentences or sections for an English audience but if he wanted he could have translated the book to make it his own instead of the author's European sensibility.

@marsoelflaco5722 Ай бұрын

Happy Birthday Viceroy!!!🎉🎂

@NeoRetroEntertainment Ай бұрын

Writers continuously try to "subvert expectations" or update a work for "modern audiences" as opposed to respecting the source material and then act surprised when there's a massive backlash.

@Johov21 Ай бұрын

The MCU (civil war, avengers) are examples of this. Same with Shogun. The writing this era is terrible. fanfiction is so much better. Check put Spider-Man lotus snd compare that to No Way Home.

@stephennootens916 Ай бұрын

Sometimes when a franchise goes on for so many years they have to retool it fit with modern times. The Roger Moore Bond was nothing like the book Bond in fact the movie version of Bond has long been sperated from the original Bond. Not only the books written after Fleming was a mix of both Bonds.

@Henbot Ай бұрын

The point is more making it your own. You can’t get some horrendously racist book or sexist book in parts and put that into a modern audience

@stephennootens916 Ай бұрын

This is one of those things that it depends when it comes to accepting books or comics into movies. We can look Ian Flaming's Bond, first the movie version of James Bond isn't anything like the original James Bond and hasn't been for decades. Second tech and the spy business has change and in order to keep up with the times James and the stories has to keep up. He can be a smooth son of bitch but how he goes about in a different way than he did in late 50s. If you want to keep a franchises going to need to get fresh blood and new ideas. Now you still have to hold on to the core of the characters or the world. On the other hand if you are accepting a book or a play something singler story with no interested in some greater franchise than it is best to stick closer to the thing to adapt. Now I say this partly because I am still pissed they changed the ending of Hannibal from the book, but also believe that if you are just trying to make one movie and not some massive franchise than you should you the story in the book you are adapting. Not as Stanley Kubrick did more than once gut it and use the book as a frame work for you want to do.

@anthonygonzalez514 Ай бұрын

GRRM used to talk often, whether interviews or on his blog about Marvel films. He Loved Sony's first two Spider-Man films, Iron Man and Captain America The First Avenger. Because he said they really stuck to Stan Lee work. He also seemed to like Ant-Man and Doctor Strange as those are two of his favorite characters. He really didn't like the first Thor film as he felt they changed too much.

@swervbe Ай бұрын

Man I loved Bill Smitrovich in Nero Wolfe, along with the rest of the cast, it was great theatre on TV.

@53kenner Ай бұрын

My favorite miniseries was Centennial. If only Chesapeake had been adapted, it would have been fantastic to see the Turlocks portrayed. Hollywood adaptations will almost invariably be worse than the source material. Only the tiniest fraction of books are truly successful...it's a numbers game with occasional big winners subsiding the remainder. Hollywood focuses on retelling these few elite stories, of course. The problem is that it's exceedingly hard to catch lightning in a bottle once ... and they want to change out the bottle

@pferreira1983 Ай бұрын

Martin is one to talk when he bashed Tolkien's LOTR books. GoT is overrated. What they did with Thrawn was ridiculous and I still don't consider Disney Star Wars canon.

@Somebody-pq1jq Ай бұрын

he loves tolkien lol

@pferreira1983 Ай бұрын

@@Somebody-pq1jq He has criticised LOTR and feels GoT improves on it.

@ahorsewithnoname773 Ай бұрын

@@pferreira1983 I think you're being slightly unfair to Martin here. He's a huge Tolkien fan and cited him as a major influence. He did however criticize some aspects of his works, like bringing Gandalf back from the dead. You can be a huge fan of something and still find some minor flaws with it. Criticism isn't necessarily "bashing," and anything wrought by human hands is flawed because we are deeply flawed creatures. That includes the Lord of the Rings.

@pferreira1983 Ай бұрын

@@ahorsewithnoname773 He said that LOTR is inferior to GoT because in LOTR you don't know what their tax policy is. I mean WTF??? 😆

@anthonygonzalez514 Ай бұрын

@pferreira1983 he says there are things he dislikes about LOTR and attempts to do better at them. But he loves those books. Still rereads them There are *things* you dislike about your favorite franchise too

@worlddd7777 Ай бұрын

I Claudius is truly masterpiece

@christianpister2227 Ай бұрын

Is that a " 1. FC Saarbrücken" shirt?

@THEBURNETTWORK Ай бұрын

Yup!

@dbdeets Ай бұрын

It´s a Limited Edition. Only one in existence! 😁

@marsoelflaco5722 Ай бұрын

⚽️🥅

@marsoelflaco5722 Ай бұрын

@THEBURNETTWORK Goooooooooal!!!⚽️🥅

@NerdyRambling Ай бұрын

I think Finchers adaptation of Dragon Tattoo is superior to the novel

@AdurianJ Ай бұрын

I read the Thrawn trilogy a few years ago and I don't get why it's so popular. In my view it wasn't very good because there where too many contrivances and childlike setup and payoffs for plot points.

@pferreira1983 Ай бұрын

What would you consider better then?

@ericwhyte3888 Ай бұрын

You must really hate the Disney stuff then. The Thrawn trilogy is genious next to J,Js trash.

@pferreira1983 Ай бұрын

@@ericwhyte3888 I'm guessing he must love the Disney stuff if he doesn't like the Thrawn Trilogy?

@user-wl7kd3wi5q Ай бұрын

@@pferreira1983 Don't pull a muscle with that stretch.

@pferreira1983 Ай бұрын

@@user-wl7kd3wi5q Eh? What do you mean?