Ghadhir Khumm REPEATED Throughout History? (Appointment Of Successors)

No video

Ghadhir Khumm REPEATED Throughout History? (Appointment Of Successors)

Рет қаралды 16,514

Күн бұрын

Did Ghadir Khumm repeat throughout history? Did Prophets of God appoint their successors in similar ways to Imam Ali (peace be upon him) at Ghadir Khumm? The Bible seems to think so.
00:00 - Introduction
01:03 - What Is Ghadir Khumm?
02:51 - Aaron & The Turban
07:33 - Joshua & The Hand of Moses
12:05 - Solomon & Gihon Spring
16:59 - Further Reading

Пікірлер: 335

@Shlibak Ай бұрын

Muslims often cross-reference the Bible to the Quran/Hadith and point Christians towards that which correlates, e.g. Belief in one God. It's time Shia Muslims took the reigns with this, as it is Shia Islam's narrative that all of history aligns with. In this case, what aligns is the fact that Prophets ALWAYS appoint a successor by the command of God (and apparently in a very similar fashion to Ghadir Khumm!).

@Hh-sb7xh Ай бұрын

Ahsant brother. Please brother make more content! You are very wellspoken and you are very professional. We really need brothers like you! Thank you

@imhummingbird8043 Ай бұрын

Brother Malik, the book you referenced has an abridged English translation translated by Sayyid Athar Hussain Rizvi in 2 volumes. It is published with the title Al-Ghadeer in Quran, Traditions, and Literature. You can find it online as PDF.

@Shlibak Ай бұрын

@@imhummingbird8043 Excellent, I had no idea. I will check it out, thanks.

@ghulammohammadshah2590 Ай бұрын

There are forces that try to incorporate Trinity of Christians (The God , The Mother and the son of God) in Islam ( The Allah , The Prophet and Moula Ali husband of Bibi Pak) so that Shirkia beliefs should be introduced against Tawheed ideology of Islam. Gadeer was simply a transit camp between Macca and Madina or Yaman and Madina. The Deeni Islam stood already completed in all respects with last Ayat of Alquran some 18 days before last Haj speech of Prophet Pbuh at Macca , when Ayat *Alyoumu Akmaltu Alladeenakum * This is the day when Deen stands completed was revealed to Prophet pbuh. Mankuntu Moula was only in order to encourage Moula Ali against whom there was some complaint from Yaman returned Mujahideen and he was very upset It was advised by Prophet Pbuh to feel fear while dealing with Ahalibayat being his blood relatives , otherwise there is no iota of any idea to make Ahalibayat as share holders in the absolute authority of Allah or in the prophecy of prophet Pbuh . If there was some upgradation from Allah for upgrading Ahalibayat ,why the Khilafat and Willayat of Moula Ali could not support him to control great violence during five year Khilafat of Moula Ali which swallowed more than 82000 lives of trained Muslim Mujahideen and rising of Islam stopped forth with.

@alibangash5775 Ай бұрын

Narrated Jabir bin 'Abdullah: that the Prophet (ﷺ) said to 'Ali: "You are to me in the position that Harun was to Musa, except that there is no Prophet after me." Reference : Jami` at-Tirmidhi Book 49 Hadith 127 In-book reference : Vol. 1, Book 46, Hadith 3731 Additional References: Sahih al-Bukhari 3706, Book 62, Hadith 56 Sahih al-Bukhari 4416, Book 64, Hadith 438

@Firqa-SLAYER Ай бұрын

As an Ex Hindu Shia Islam is More Logical and True Islam !

@This_Goat Ай бұрын

True

@ganganagarazadari4942 Ай бұрын

Mashallah Brother

@Sayed.Kabuli Ай бұрын

True!

@memza1965 Ай бұрын

Yes, no doubt.

@Shlibak Ай бұрын

God bless you

@kermitthefrog8514 Ай бұрын

Christian here, interesting video

@Shlibak Ай бұрын

Welcome. I’m glad you enjoyed it.

@ronic_ Ай бұрын

Love you guys! You often more sincere than a lot of so called Muslims!

@funzuno8639 Ай бұрын

I love shiah...we are brother in humanity

@imhummingbird8043 Ай бұрын

♥♥♥♥

@This_Goat Ай бұрын

ERMM WHAT THE SIG?....... -_- ❤❤❤

@warriorpoetic Ай бұрын

I agree, and we see it in practice especially now when they’re standing bravely and fighting for Palestine while others are complicit 😢

@tasneemabbas4833 Ай бұрын

The Prophet of Islam very clearly appointed Imam Ali as his successor at Ghadeer e Khum but it is the great tragedy of Islam that some followers disobeyed their Prophet

@Johnny-xk7vw Ай бұрын

Labayka ya Ali

@nabilamir8177 Ай бұрын

Its your own false beleif that propher Muhammad s a w make Ali r.a as a successor after his death. And thats why Hazrat Ali r.a married his beloved daughte Umm e Kalsoum r to Hazrat Omar r.a.

@nabilamir8177 Ай бұрын

And an other Fact is that Hazrat Ali r.a took the charge of a chief justice after the death of Hazrat Muhammad s a w . and in th era of Abu bakr r.a , Umar r.a and Usman r.a. And also he married his daughter Hazrat Umm e Kalsoom to Hazrat Omar r.a. This shows a proof that their was no such issues between them regarding successor after the death of Hazrat Muhammad s a w

@ZeeshanAnsari-hy5zg Ай бұрын

Show me one evidence where anyone raised the issue of ghadeer after the demise of the holy prophet...

@nabilamir8177 Ай бұрын

it,s not a tragedy of islam it's a tragedy of shias believes that raise fingers on Allah and his messenger,s teaching and never ever tried to read and understand the Quran.

@awaysaltaher Ай бұрын

Excellent video Malik. God bless you and your work dear brother!

@mohamadbazzi6962 Ай бұрын

Thank you brother Malik. All of your videos and topics are truly academic and intellectual, widely researched and admirable for the substance and content. Very enjoyable watching and listening to your presentations. Can't wait to see more videos! Thanks again, brother.

@SalehSafernejad Ай бұрын

Great job brother, I really enjoyed your humility alongside the authority in your speech (which represents one of the characteristics of Imam Ali). I also liked your appreciation of art and your approach toward Bible and holy scriptures about taking lessons from them instead of calling them wholly corrupted. We need more of these hi-fi videos today instead of those muslim debators making "who downgrades the other side better" May God protect all muslims❤

@hamade7997 Ай бұрын

Excellent video, beautiful comparisons. I am deeply looking forward to future investigations. Jazakallah.

@alibangash5775 Ай бұрын

@ashiqhussain6956 Ай бұрын

True Islam, Islam of Ahlulbait aleh Salam ❤

@maryamibrahim7845 Ай бұрын

Shia and christanity are same

@ashiqhussain6956 Ай бұрын

@maryamibrahim7845 yes the are same as both are true religions of God unlike man made Sunnism

@maryamibrahim7845 Ай бұрын

Christanty shouting jesus and u ali sorry for correction a man who could not help himself the level of stupidy is amazing u peopme dont know tauheed

@AhmedAli-oe8si Ай бұрын

@@ashiqhussain6956 they share a lot of similarities both are build on pure lies and insanity and what connect them to the religion is just emotions not logic or faith that is based on logic. the religion is not a heritage that is inherited it is greater than this.

@ashiqhussain6956 Ай бұрын

@AhmedAli-oe8si to some people religions themselves are myth and man made things but to some it is not, to some It is illogical at the same time it is quiet logical to some. If any religion claimed to be sent by God then it would be governed by word of God then no man has authority to control it except prophet himself or messenger himself and that too by commandment of God. And prophet left ummah in the hands of ahlulbait he didn't leave ummah as sheapardless herd as most of ahlal sunnah claim and believe. According to them prophet heir would be elected by concensus and thay is not the case we believe

@caderbavahmuhammadsiddick384 Ай бұрын

AWESOME 👌 JAZAKALLAH KHAYR FOR SHARING 👍❤️🩵♥️💙💚💞💕🌷⚘️

@MuhammedEman14 Ай бұрын

Brother your way of speech is impressive, I enjoy watching all of your videos especially the one on aisha was very interesting, make more videos and become a mujahid of ahl ul bayt ❤

@aliagha1221 Ай бұрын

MA SHA ALLAH ,Dear brother! This is the best video and the most informative video I have ever seen. May Allah reward you Jannah! Insha Allah!

@TheFreeLancer001 Ай бұрын

Really the excellent explanation

@Mahdi-sx4ql Ай бұрын

Great video brother. Why not uploaded on Rafida channel.

@user-ws1ly6zv9k Ай бұрын

Great education and comparison of Ibrahimic religions which indicate that all of them originated from one source that is God . All prophets assigned their successors to lead their people so that they will not be lost . Moses to Jushwa, Jesus to Peter and Mohammed to Ali peace upon them all. Allah (God) bless u .

@rizviji Ай бұрын

Amazing work my brother ❤️

@captainrtf Ай бұрын

How I wish I could like this video a 1000 times. Great job 👏 brother

@SalmanYousaf-se7ft Ай бұрын

Can you tell that which Mic and camera do you use I also make content on Islam It Would help me 😊

@theamirbarismillworks2253 Ай бұрын

Labaik ya Hussain

@Irfan_Nazir Ай бұрын

@@theamirbarismillworks2253 Labaik Ya Yazid

@theamirbarismillworks2253 Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir ٤٢- وَلَا تَحْسَبَنَّ اللَّـهَ غَافِلًا عَمَّا يَعْمَلُ الظَّالِمُونَ ۚ إِنَّمَا يُؤَخِّرُهُمْ لِيَوْمٍ تَشْخَصُ فِيهِ الْأَبْصَارُ ◯ 42. Think not that God Doth not heed the deeds Of those who do wrong. He but giveth them respite Against a Day when The eyes will fixedly stare In horror,- ٤٣- مُهْطِعِينَ مُقْنِعِي رُءُوسِهِمْ لَا يَرْتَدُّ إِلَيْهِمْ طَرْفُهُمْ ۖ وَأَفْئِدَتُهُمْ هَوَاءٌ ◯ 43. They running forward With necks outstretched, Their heads uplifted, their gaze Returning not towards them, And their hearts a (gaping) void!

@YaminKuchai Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir I'm proud yazidi

@YaminKuchai Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir what about you? You are influenced by ubayd allah Ibn zyad

@YaminKuchai Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir former governor of khurasan

@hadirajaee Ай бұрын

nice video and heavy work. kepp it up!

@The_Mac6908 Ай бұрын

Asalaam alaikoum waRamatulahi waBarAkatuhu Subhanallah Barakallah fikum Allahumma swali alaa Muhammad waali Muhammad wajil farjoun ❤

@Sana0567 Ай бұрын

ما مظلومیم اما قوی هستیم.

@thetravelbug-rh9jd Ай бұрын

Shia Islam is more logical as compared to the other sects of islam

@AhmedAli-oe8si Ай бұрын

احا

@hsggaming. 14 күн бұрын

The followers of Ahlul Bait (a.s) are the true Muslims and the true Islam

@user-dd2xe8my1j Ай бұрын

Salamun alaikum which rings do you have on the right hand? Jazakallah khair and Eid e Ghadeer Mubarak to you and your family

@Shlibak Ай бұрын

Wa alaykum asalam, Dhur al-Najar and Hadid Sini

@Ace-313 Ай бұрын

Look at all the Sunnis here triggered. Anyone who denys and disrespect Imam Ali the Prophet's family, you are no longer a Muslim. I follow the family of the Prophet not some randoms who dont know the religion.

@hsggaming. 14 күн бұрын

The Ahlul Bait (a.s) the true Muslim and the true Islam

@user-on8db5yr9x Ай бұрын

Thank you ❤

@daniyalgoraya786 Ай бұрын

MaShaAllah❤

@lilly9972 Ай бұрын

Very interesting and relevant ❤

@shahidabbasofficial2518 Ай бұрын

Great Video

@Mondgeist7777 Ай бұрын

Salam! It is very clear the love you have for all of these auspicious personalities, who only had , and have all of mankind’s best interest in mind … it is so sad that such division exists between all of the children of Adam, PBUT … I often reflect on the fact that the religious history of this planet goes unknown, and just as there is the seen, there are also the unseen previous prophets of the East, and much older epic’s where similarities in character, such as Noah, and his Sumerian counterpart makes me wonder. Salam!

@Shlibak Ай бұрын

Yes, it is unfortunate the state of mankind, and our neglected shared religious history. InshaAllah one day mankind will return back to its roots.

@askaribegum5676 Ай бұрын

Alhumdulla very true Ali a.s or first Imam 🙌🙌♥️🌹

@sur0ush Ай бұрын

God Bless you for this informative video!

@80a7x Ай бұрын

Liked and Subbed!

@Ali__7 Ай бұрын

underrated video

@mojizhussain4339 Ай бұрын

jazakallah

@muslimboy5804q Ай бұрын

Keep it up ❤

@Sayed.Kabuli Ай бұрын

Shia are the real Muslims Alhamdulilah to be shia

@aminamohammed8276 Ай бұрын

Allah Humma Suali Ala Muhammad Wa Ahle Muhammad

@ghulammuhammad3897 Ай бұрын

Very logical to me ❤

@Rustomkawaling 8 күн бұрын

Imam Ali ibn Abitalib (as) A right kalip to the Muslim Umma, Ya Amiral muhmeenim(as) Allah Humma Sally Alaa Mohammadin Wa Ahliy Mohammad Wa Adjil Farajaahum,,,,,

@xJaysrox Ай бұрын

That was very good, please make a video about the perfection of religion verse. And the verse where the prophet had to "BALLIGH'' or else he didn't deliver the message at all. Sunnies deny this verse came down after the Hadj. Can you provide the sources of when the verse came down please

@mominabatul9711 Ай бұрын

Alhamdulillah i m proud to be shia ne ali jjh

@lidyamafira9645 Ай бұрын

Assalamu Alaikum great lecture like always..I have one important question to malik I would be very happy if you could give me an answer I just converted to shia last month alhamduillah.. the bakris accusing us that we would believe iblis is a mumin based on the riwayah in bihar ul anwar where salman al farisi narrated that iblis came in a form of abu mahhar to people who cursed the aimmah and he said he believes in wilayah and he loves ali . A.s. is that possible that iblis loves a mumin or how can I understand the narration it is said the riwayah is marfuu can it be rejected ??

@AliMusa454 Ай бұрын

Bihar Al-Anwar is a compendium of narrations. A narration being included in there is not binding in and of itself. The burden of proof is on the claimant to show that it is authentic.

@lidyamafira9645 Ай бұрын

Baraka allahu feek it is said it is marfu and marfu could mean it is ahad narration like a mursal disconnected chain is it true ?

@kamrudinelias3922 Ай бұрын

Be ur Shiites religion for you and our Ahle Sunnah Religion for us Sunnis, why would you always want to mention Sunnis so to enhance or rubberstamp ur Shiasm, just can't follow ur Shiasm without bothering Today's Sunnis...Shame on you for always using Sunnis shoulders to cry....❤❤

@raheelhaider9295 22 күн бұрын

Bcz sunnis left the teachings of Prophet PBUH... Prophet PBUH said to follow Quran and Ahlebayt but so called sunnis whom u will listen saying that we r following sunnah left them and followed others

@danishhussain2741 Ай бұрын

The main problem is not ghadeer or Mubahela incident. Things are clear in the history of all main sects of islam. but what can be said more then as surah-al-aser is saying to human. "Walasir innal insana lafe khusrin". go back in the history mostly humans are diverted towards materialism. worldly wealth desires and designation and human greed overcome divine commands. robbers and thieves are doing small things may be Allah forgive them. but those disguised Imams or false religious leaders are more dangerous for human societies rather then robbers and thieves They destroyed generations and human societies. This is also an alamya (tragedy) for ignoring the clear facts and being following the wrong path like a blind person who may at any time fall.

@b4urEnvy Ай бұрын

A righteous path or a logical one is very clear even for an atheist

@Sana0567 Ай бұрын

عید مبارک

@saudisinaudis 27 күн бұрын

i appreciate that this is an islamic shia youtube channel and that you are drawing a comparison between moses and muhammad however can you not also see how an athiest (in particular someone who was raised muslim but has become athiest) could see that the appointment of ali is a just a copy paste of past biblical events? most of the quran draws a lot of details and comparisons with the bible so who is to say that the quran is not a legitimate book? i think drawing these types of comparisons shows the flaws in this narration in an ironic way and just looks like as if during the islamic era that stories were taken from other faiths and rehashed and rewritten to benefit the movement?

@Shlibak 27 күн бұрын

Islam does not claim to be separate entity from the religion of the previous Prophet’s. The fact it claims to be a continuation means there must be massive overlap by necessity.

@stormcloud9146 Ай бұрын

So why don’t seemingly educated people like the Muslim latern come to these conclusions, they seem genuine. Me myself I wouldn’t want to call my self Shia or Sunni but I 100percent believe that the leadership of the ummah should have always stayed with the family of our prophet pbuh . Why don’t Sunnis see this how is that belief still a majority in the Islamic world?

@JN-eq3gl Ай бұрын

Wallah I don't know. But I think it comes down to ignorance or arrogance or both.

@adamramzan7935 Ай бұрын

You should become Shia as this term is mentioned even in so called Sunni sources

@stormcloud9146 Ай бұрын

@@adamramzan7935 there are certain practises within Shia Islam that I don’t agree with but after our prophet pbuh my loyalty is to the ahlul bayt.

@jaleel42 Ай бұрын

A lot of them actually do,. See it clear as day,. But there is a social dynamic as to not talk about these things,. So people self police themselves

@ChefbyMistake Ай бұрын

The reason is simple the Shia Dynasties failed and divided. 1) Hamdanids 2) Qarmatians 3) Fatimids 4) Buyids Unfortunately they all perished by in fighting.

@Ruhoolahmadkawa Ай бұрын

♥️♥️♥️♥️

@sur0ush Ай бұрын

اللهم صل علی محمد و آل محمد یا علی علیه السلام

@1364FILM Ай бұрын

It was a really good video! But there's a very annoying aspect about the phrase "peace upon him" and its repetition in sentences! Every time a prophet's name is mentioned, is it really necessary to repeat this phrase? The intention is respect and reverence, which mentioning it once in a speech should suffice! Constantly saying the name and adding "peace upon him" is truly annoying.

@MohammedAbdul-Hameed Ай бұрын

@@1364FILM It wouldn't be annoying at all if we knew the emphasis given to it and the great thawab (reward) in the hadiths of our Imams (peace be upon them). It should actually be said in Arabic, but we also have to take into consideration the English speaking audience.

@davidela9022 15 күн бұрын

So, it's so monumental that it was seen through the bible in multiple biblical narratives, yet never mentioned in the quran?

@Shlibak 11 күн бұрын

Look up Ghadir Khumm in the Quran. You’ll be pleasantly surprised.

@davidela9022 11 күн бұрын

I have. It's not clear enough, honestly.

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 10 күн бұрын

@@davidela9022As if everything has to be stated and emphasized in a way that would compel everyone to believe. This is how people make the choice between good and evil.

@davidela9022 10 күн бұрын

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 yes, you would assume God Almighty would make it clear in his revelations what is good and what is evil. Yet those who divide say if you don't belive in xyz outside of the quran, then you are evil.

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 10 күн бұрын

@@davidela9022 Clear yes, compelling to those mentioned in the Holy Quran (3:7) no. Debating basic concepts like Sunnah is a waste of time. I don’t remember ever coming across anything of value brought up by a ‘Quranist’.

@Hk313-14 Ай бұрын

❤❤

@abduragiemsamsodien4887 Ай бұрын

Simply BE

@ChefbyMistake Ай бұрын

This is Ismaili Theology who were Shias.

@tammychahdi8927 Ай бұрын

Twelver shia are the true shia cause prophet muhammad told to follow the twelve imams

@ChefbyMistake Ай бұрын

@@tammychahdi8927 What prophet Muhammad told is written and interpreted by everyone.

@tammychahdi8927 Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir in shia books of hadiths prophet muhammad said the names of the 12 imams from ali to al qaim (al mahdi). What about you the sunnis, who are the names of the 12 hashemi imams that muhammad was talking about. Or he was drunk, because in your books of hadith prophet muhammad was drinking and tried to kill himself and he is sometimes get a little bit crazy and a lot of lies about him. Who are those 12 imam mr nadir?

@tammychahdi8927 Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir you the sunnis always trying to jump and switch topics hhhhh you are masters at it but not with shia, my question was: who are the 12 hashemi imam that muhammad pbuh was talking about in your sunni hadith books? Give me names?? Are they the ummaiat or abbasit or otomans or the first 12 us presidents, give me namesss. And if you get stacked , tell me, its ok, than i will name you the 12 imams, because in your sunni books muhammad didnt give names , and this is not the case in our shia books, because sunni hadith books authors were hiding the truth as usual

@alb_ssx 23 күн бұрын

Unfortunately Ismailis don't even follow the Sharia or the fiqh.

@ZeeshanAnsari-hy5zg Ай бұрын

Not one person mentioned ghadeer after the demise of the holy prophet, hence this proves that ghadeer had nothing to do with succession...

@MohammedAbdul-Hameed Ай бұрын

Go read about the wars with 'Mani'u Zakah' who did not apostate and only refused to give their zakah to Abu Bakr.

@MohammedAbdul-Hameed Ай бұрын

The case of Malik ibn Nuwayrah ...

@ZeeshanAnsari-hy5zg Ай бұрын

@@MohammedAbdul-Hameed And who did Imam Ali a.s. side with read that also...

@MohammedAbdul-Hameed Ай бұрын

@@ZeeshanAnsari-hy5zgaccording to which authentic narrations? Those of Saif ibn Umar al-Tamimi?? Are we going to cherry-pick reports to justify the killing of innocent Muslims in cold blood?

@ZeeshanAnsari-hy5zg Ай бұрын

@@MohammedAbdul-Hameed Again I am asking you whom did Imam Ali a.s. sided with? You keep failing to answer a simple question. Bring any authentic evidence, I don't care, but prove your points with proper hadiths....

@AlphaEntries Ай бұрын

When you say “so called Sunni literature “ I am assuming you’ve realized that the “Sahaba” were of Jewish origins. They were not pure Arab Muslims. Therefore assuming further their hate today for Christians. As the hate is similar by the Yehudi (Jewish ) people back then. Whereas as Muslims from the Prophets family have respect and tolerance for them.

@ChefbyMistake Ай бұрын

Prophet Muhammad was Jewish.

@user-cn3vp1on3m Ай бұрын

He said right when he said so called sunni bcz they were and are so… the munafiq

@user-iu9xc9zr5z Ай бұрын

Which Bible???????

@ShadZafer Ай бұрын

❤

@MohammedIsmail-ni1yi Ай бұрын

Lovely video but how comes all the prophets only appointed other prophets and prophet Muhammad was the last messenger so why would he appoint someone else

@jaleel42 Ай бұрын

I’ll tell you why,… after the prophet’s (saws) death,. People used to make fun of Ali (as) saying he didn’t have his own judgement that he always referred to Quran and the true sunnah of the prophet (saws) ,. Others took pride in their own opinions on matters they had no knowledge on,. You can also read these same individuals would also have strong opinions and argue with the prophet (saws) one campion oddly enuff would use the torah to argue against the prophet (saws)

@alibangash5775 Ай бұрын

@raheelhaider9295 22 күн бұрын

Bro bcz the shari'ah was completed and Prophet hood was completed now it was time to implement and save those teachings so no one can change them till the last day of this world.Prophet PBUH said I m leaving behind 2 things Quran and Ahlebayt do not leave them or u will fall astray .....when he said this he should have said whom to follow form Ahlebayt

@Omanörn-q5u Ай бұрын

💛✊️💛🇱🇧🤝🇮🇷

@samirbettassa9289 Ай бұрын

Give us that of Sayyidunah Isa (as)😂

@raheelhaider9295 22 күн бұрын

Isa a.s is still alive on sky and there were his 12 disciples like 12 Imams Khulfas stated in sunni ahadees books 😂😂

@hsggaming. 13 күн бұрын

@@raheelhaider9295Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib(a.s) Imam Hasan ibn Ali(a.s) Imam Husayn ibn Ali(a.s) Imam Ali ibn Husayn(a.s) Imam Muhammad al-Baqir(a.s) Imam Jafar al-Sadiq(a.s) Imam Musa al-Kadhim(a.s) Imam Ali al-Rida(a.s) Imam Muhammad al-Jawad(a.s) Imam Ali al-Hadi(a.s) Imam Hasan al-Askari(a s) Imam Muhammad al-Mahdi(a.t.f.s)

@Dr_Shiny Ай бұрын

Problem: Prophets were succeeding prophets. Here not.

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 Ай бұрын

Peter is a prophet?

@Dr_Shiny Ай бұрын

@@mohammedal-nidawi8896 possible

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 Ай бұрын

@@Dr_Shiny arguments are built on possibilities? And how is that possible in the first place?

@Dr_Shiny Ай бұрын

@@mohammedal-nidawi8896 saint Peter was nominated by who and when and in what regard? Need proper cross referencing. As he denied Jesus at the time of trial as well. Moreover, he was one of the 12 apostles, a companion of Jesus. Not an imam appointed by Jesus.

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 Ай бұрын

@@Dr_ShinyFirst you said it’s possible that Peter was a prophet and now you are questioning his high status?!

@junaidfarhad9891 26 күн бұрын

Their is no such thing as shia or Sunni, be a good muslim that's it . don't divide Islam

@raheelhaider9295 22 күн бұрын

What is muslim? The one who follows Islam? What is Islam thats following the teachings of Allah n PROPHET PBUH as Allah said in Quran... so if Allah said follow Ali and Prophet appointed him as his successor we are following true Islam...Shias were there at the time of Prophet PBUH and he mentioned them in his ahadees and Allah used this word in many verses ....Prophet said Ali and his shias will be successful thats written in many sunni books bro Shia is not a name of sect its what refers to lovers of Imam Ali a.s

@arafataiyash1871 Ай бұрын

Salamu Alakoom What I found out quick is that ever prophet that appointed a successor in the Bible was prophets as well. Prophet Muhammad PBUH did not appoint Ali A.S. As the successor because there can’t be a prophet after him he was the seal of the prophets it ends with him. Ali A.S. Was a proud brave strong man that was honorable the people chose the khaleef after the passing of the Prophet PBUH and appointed Abu Bakr A.S. As first khaleef. Ali A.S. Did not fight him over it and wasn’t afraid to if he wanted. If even Ali A.S. By himself with the prophet PBUH and the prophet told him he is the successor Ali’s words alone would of gave him succession after the prophet because Ali A.S. Words meant something when he spoke. He didn’t claim a thing and it was voted to see who rules and he did become the Khaleef. Trust me if the Sahabah wasn’t worthy of being in charge of Islam Allah would of took care of them. But they was praised in the Quran

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 Ай бұрын

Alaykum salam Definitely try to give it more time and investigate the other side of the story

@Haider-Karrar Ай бұрын

Do not say anything by yourself! If Ali (as) fought your firsht khalifa, than once think what would happen; all the hardwork of Prophet would be spoiled and there would be a big fight among the Muslims. Today if you’re Muslim it’s all because of Ali(as), it’s not because of your first khaifa, because he was saying to worship the idols. Ali(as) never allegiance with any of those. And Imam Ali (as) didn’t say anything just for the protection of Islam. Where in the Quran Allah praised sahaba??? Are you talking about those sahaba who left prophet alone in the field of fight and escaped? And then were very proud of their escaping! Only Haider is Amir-ul-momineen.💪💪💪

@yasminali4511 Ай бұрын

Do you not read the Quran with an open heart Imama is much above Prophet Hood Prophet Ibrahim was given the new title as an imam after he was tested with his son Isaac Please read the Quran with clarity!!! The problem with you people is you only listen to your muftis without doing your own research 😅

@hsggaming. 13 күн бұрын

Walaikum assalam A.s is only for prophets and Ahlul Bait A.s (not for sahabas)

@rajababy2009 Ай бұрын

So as per your Logic then ALi R.A could not successful to be successor and hence ALLAH SWT could not make him successful ? if it was ALLAH SWT command that ALI A.S to be the sucesor then giving biah(Allegiance ) even by force was not allowed upon ALi A.S until he remove the wrong caliphs but we saw the opposite ALI A.S helped caliphs in their matters , just imagine for a second if Abu bakar A.S and Umar A.S changed the main command of ALLAH SWT by Force then how ALI A.S can not fought them and bring the real islam back , if ALI A.S did not fought then it means Either shia are wrong or ALI A.S was wrong

@kebab7023 Ай бұрын

What the hell is this point. The entire reason for Ghadeer was Muhammad appointing Ali to rule after him, whether the people accept that is meaningless. Why would Ali fight for the caliphate? If the people reject him they have gone astray already

@rajababy2009 Ай бұрын

@@kebab7023 the problem is ALI A.S himself become the part of this falsehood ? thats they Problem . When makhans rejected Prophet pbuh He pbuh did not join then but keep his mission and bear every torture given by his own people ? So Our point is If it was ALLAH SWT decree then why ALI A.S accepted and give allegiance to this kufar and disobedience SO in otherwards ALI A.S endorsed their Kufar and disbelieve , this is the point which you shia always ignore and run from it

@raheelhaider9295 22 күн бұрын

The purpose was Ali to save Islam not to become power greedy thats why he gave suggestions for improvement in every thing including wars but not fought a single war himself.....can u imagine that one who was commanding all wars during life time of Prophet PBUH didn't fight a single war in the era of other caliphs ???

@raheelhaider9295 22 күн бұрын

Very few times Allah use his power to implement what he wants? If Allah wants the whole world could be muslim without sending a single Prophet? But would u say that All Prophets failed? Allah will use his force once there will b time when he will send Al Mahdi ajtf

@daniyaalkhantanoli8232 Ай бұрын

Prophet announced successors who were PROPHETS but no prophet after Muhammad saw.........try again pal

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 Ай бұрын

You are late to the discussion, someone else already mentioned this point

@affanhussain7015 Ай бұрын

I just wanna remind you sir that allah tells us in quran that whoever divide themselves in sects and groups are not Muslims

@affanhussain7015 Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir i do follow sunnah like doing the complete wudu and others i don't think that people who follow sunna are sunni but people who belive in the four califates and without a doubt Ali rs is the greatest compannion of prophet Muhammad

@nickmansfield1 Ай бұрын

@@affanhussain7015 Oh, and the 5th caliph?

@affanhussain7015 Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir what do you mean

@affanhussain7015 Ай бұрын

@@Irfan_Nazir i believe in all the sunna of prophet Muhammad which is verified and his family i think all the decisions of early muslims were lead by caliphts so i respect them

@user-cn3vp1on3m Ай бұрын

But not the one who open the closed brains and eyes to see and understand truth

@NameLess-sw4yi Ай бұрын

Shias 🤦🏻 pls stop pls, pls stop proving ghadeer khum from bible, In (Genesis 36:11) a man named "Omar" is also mentioned, now go and accept "Hazrat Omar (ra)" as ur caliph, go ahead im waiting :) lets see how consistent u are!

@yasminali4511 Ай бұрын

Don’t be upset knowing that your beloved omar murdered prophet Mohammed (as) it’s in your books make time to read and inquire knowledge from your books Man be a bit smarter Proof what you wrote please don’t be the only pickle in a a dry jar 😂

@kano5 Ай бұрын

How is this even comparable 😂. This isn’t about just a name being mentioned, but the context and understanding of what it means. Go read some history man. And now stick to the topic, why every Prophet had a successor chosen by Allah (SWT) but not the last Prophet? Allah (SWT) is the One who always chooses not the people. I know truth can sometimes hard to be accepted.

@raheelhaider9295 22 күн бұрын

😂😂😂 Lol what kind of logic is this we are not talking about the names but successor ship of Prophet PBUH...I dont knw what logic sunnis give about whom they follow to know true teachings of Prophet PBUH ??? Ummah divided the day Prophet PBUH died why ??? Didn't Allah have the knowledge that ummah will be divided into sects??

@mrpreityboykiller3164 Ай бұрын

Shia has nothing to do with Islam..Rasool e pak saw never appointed Ali ra as his succusaor.Thanks God Ali ra didnt become first Caliphate of islam otherwise Islam was wiped out his early days.When Ali a became Caliphate he didn't find the murder of Usman ra which led him to 2 brutal wars against his own fellow Muslim brothers.Thanks God Abu bakr ra saved islam who had so many challenges in her early days of caliphate and he resolved perfectly.So no comparison of Abu bakr ra with Ali ra in governance

@alijawwad8649 Ай бұрын

Nice joke 😂

@alibangash5775 Ай бұрын

You need to read the history. Ali(as) is Asadullah means Allah ka sher (Lion of Allah). He is the conqueror of all Islamic wars. Ali's fame grew with every battle that he was in, due to his courage, valour, and chivalry, as well as the fact that he single-handedly, destroyed many of Arabia's most famous and feared warriors. Rasool (saww) acknowledged him as the greatest warrior of all time. If Ali(as) wasn't there in the wars, the infidels would have been destroyed Islam in the beginning. So it is very clear that Ali(as) is the saviour of Islam. Khilafat is the secondary stage.

@alijawwad8649 Ай бұрын

@@alibangash5775 true

@yasminali4511 Ай бұрын

An ignorant person here Little do you know Go and read your books and see who ImamAli(as) is Unlike your people that murdered Prophet Mohammed(as) Go and search true knowledge I’m your books buddy 😂

@La_Fata_Ila_Ali Ай бұрын

Yea your beloved Caliphs killed Sayyida Fatima (as) when she and Ali (as) refused to pledge allegiance to them. This is in your books btw, and I’ll be glad to give a reference if you’d like to be embarrassed. I refuse to follow anyone who kills somebody simply because they refuse to bow to their rule. Your “Rightly guided” caliphs were power hungry tyrants. And all of them claimed the Quran was corrupted somehow, making every single one of them Kuffar. Ali (as) is the only true successor of the Prophet Muhammed (pbuh), and his progeny has the path of True Islam

@taurusdeltoro5331 Ай бұрын

اَلا ‎لَعنتُ الّلہِ وَ مَلائکتہٖ وَالنٗاسِ اَجمَعین عَلَی الکٰاذِبِین وَالخائنین وَالجَاہِلِین وَالظَالِمین وَالمُنافِقیِن!

@trustwinners3765 Ай бұрын

Shias are non-muslim. Stay away from Siites...

@La_Fata_Ila_Ali 26 күн бұрын

Abu Bakr, Omar, Uthman, and Aisha all claimed the Quran was changed and corrupted somehow And Omar killed Fatima (as) the daughter of the Prophet (pbuh) This is all in Bukhari and Muslim btw, Who are the real Kuffar?

@hsggaming. 13 күн бұрын

Sunnis are the followers of Umar Usman abu bakr these are not the followers of Ahlul Bait (a.s)

@La_Fata_Ila_Ali 13 күн бұрын

@@trustwinners3765 “Oh Ali, you are to me as Aaron was to Moses except that there is no prophet after me” “My progeny is like Noah’s ark, whoever embarks on their path is saved, but whoever rejects them is drowned” “I have left you two weighty things, The Quran and my Ahlul Bayt” “Allah is my master, and I am the master of the believers. So to whomever I am his master, Ali is his master” “I thank God for perfecting His religion, and completing His Blessing, and approving my mission and guardianship and succession of Ali after me.” Allah only intends to keep ˹the causes of˺ evil away from you and purify you completely, O members of the ˹Prophet’s˺ family! (33:33)

@trustwinners3765 13 күн бұрын

@@hsggaming. Allah said to follow Allah and his Prophet. Ati ullah wa ati ur rasool. Simple. Hum sahaba ya ahl e bait ko follow ni krty kio k wo sab umatti hain.

@hsggaming. 13 күн бұрын

@@trustwinners3765 yes but who are you to say that Shia are non muslims

@davidmollahassani4329 Ай бұрын

You also know about the habit that prophet said to immam Ali you are like Aron to Moses accept after me there is no prophet you have thousands of habit confirming the successor of prophet is immam Ali but you choice not to hear it ad I also know about the sura in koran that there are those that will never see or hear the truth till the day of judgment as Allah has a seal on their eyes and heart you all know that still refusing to get a place in janna for yourself so don't worry you guys will soon join your abubakr Umar osman aisha in the place thatvis reserve got them but not jana I am so sure about it as the rising sun

@davidmollahassani4329 Ай бұрын

Yes remind him of the sura in koran that do not divide yourself and that is mentioned for the sonni that have not obeyed the Allah command and Allah prophet commands that after me is Ali you listen and follow but you guys throw your prophet under the bus just to praise abubakr and Umar where both of them said on the prophet death bed abubakr said he is dulutional and Umar said book of Allah is sufficient for us as they knew more than the prophet you guys are disobeying your prophet and in tern Allah command and if you talk above the prophet words all that you do your pray fast zakat is nothing as you will answare to Allah and his prophet on the day of judgment prophet has said and you guys are well aware of it that I leave behind two weighty things the book of Allah and my ahlobeyt hold on to them and you will never go astray but you guys did not no wonder isis is created out of hate and they kill other Muslims you as a sonni are the descendent of the same people khavareg that immam Ali killed them all accept 9 so keep praising abubakr Umar aisha oh my God aisha that went out of her house and fought immam Ali and caused over 20000 muslim to die but than again it doesn't matter if it is said in koran you the wives of the prophet do not leave your house but than again you will call it ishtehad which I am sick and tired of hearing it all the people you praise all that were against ahlobeyt they are all in hale and do not think for one second because you call yourself a muslim you are gonna be in jana far from it

@user-cn3vp1on3m Ай бұрын

He is not dividing i know your machinations of such logical fallacies… 😂😂😂 you are jealous and munkir of reality

@mohammedal-nidawi8896 Ай бұрын

⁠⁠@@user-cn3vp1on3mthe brother is not saying the Shia are dividing

@sur0ush Ай бұрын

اللهم صل علی محمد و آل محمد یا علی علیه السلام