سلام غامدى صاحب آپ وقت کے ظالم حکمران کے خلاف کون سا راستہ اختيآر کرنا چاے

He doesn't have a primary level education about Islam So doesn't arise any need to ask any questions

مدرسے کے مولوی میں اور ایک اسکالر میں زمین و آسمان کا فرق ہوتا ہے مدرسے طوطے کی طرح رٹا ہوتا ہے جو غلط سلط سکھا دیا اسی پہ قایم رہتا ہے اگر حق سمجھ میں آجایے تب بھی وہ غلط سلط کو جکڑے رہتا ہے اسے صرف روٹی اور دکان کی فکر ہوتی ہے ایمان کی نہیں اسکالر کیلیے ایسی کوئ قباحت نہیں وہ ہر چیز کو عقل و دلایل پہ پرکھتا ہے اور انصاف کےساتھ بیان کرتا ہے کہیں کہیں پھسل بھی جاتے ہیں لیکن بنیادی عقیدے میں کوئ فرق نہیں ہوتا مدرسے کے مولوی تو بنیادی عقیدے اور ایمان و ضمیر سب کو بیچ ڈالتے ہیں جسے علماء سو کہتے ہیں علماء سو سارے جہنمی ہیں

@@razdakhatoon5740 bibi molve per ungli uthany sy phly ye zaror soch len k hamary molve janab e rasool Allha hai. To ap ka ishara kahan ja raha hy 5chon ungleyan baraber nahi

Sir excuse me lkn ye haqeeqat hy ke ap bilkul Paadri lagte hain. Shari.at zahir ko daikhti hy Dilon ka hal to Allah ko malum hy

Same!!!

Yes, How muslim go astry by forgetting true essence of Islam, purification , honesty , character , justice

انداز اچھا ہے لیکن بے دینی جھلکر ہی ہے

Not open minded, only highly wise can understand respected ghamidi sahib.

Sadia Khalid آمین!

Ameen

A real scholar. May Allah bless him with health. I really understand my deen bcz of him.

ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha haha , prime time comedy with Gamdi

So, he can corrupt the other innocent people.

@@tahirmahmood3465 Yes definitely, that is the reason why the Muslims in West and librals in Pakistan who do not belong to religious practicing families are easily attracted to the Ghamdi Sahib ideology, because from their childhood they did not have much information about Quran and Hadith and are attracted to the 10-20 Percent of Islamic teachings leaving behind 80% of Islam . Although these educated people are well versed with worldly and scientific knowledge.

@@YasirIslam01 yes, so are so right. Allah PAK GEE SHOWS ALL OF US RIGHT PATH.

@@YasirIslam01 Sir What makes you think that people living in west are ignorant about religion and they don't practice islam. It’s just we don't label every thing as 10 % or 20 % of Islam. We think our religion is so beautiful and its all messages can be explained by scientific knowledge and that's what Sir Ghamdi is trying to do.

@@naomankhan950 Where did I say people in west are ignorant about religion, I meant to say that people are easily trapped or attracted toward Ghamdi Version of Islam or Pervaiziat as from their childhood many Muslim parents in western societies have not made much efforts in Islamic upbringing of their children in terms of practicing religion, like offering prayers and telling them importance of Quran and Hadith, telling the children about Importance of Hijab and telling them that in Islam music is not allowed. So when that child grows up and try to do self study, he will look for something which he feels is logical. Like from his or her childhood , the Hijab was not practised in his/her family and there were mixed gatherings, and Music was normal thing. So by listening to Ghamdi Sahib that Grown up child will certify that covering hairs in not important in Islam and it is fine to listen to music because he or she is used to it now. And he/she will start to blame other scholars that those Mullas are just giving Islamic information from their own mind, because we have not studied Hadith and from Hadith we will get Explanation of Islamic teachings. So Quran and Hadith make complete Islam, most of Quranist say where it is mentioned in Quran Music is Haram. From Hadith we will get explanation that Music is Haram. We as Muslims and true believer do not require science to prove that Allah message is True. Allah gave those scientific facts in Quran for the people who look for scientific facts and miracles to accept the Truth, that this message is indeed from our Creator. So what is mentioned in Quran and Sahih Hadith we should follow it without any doubt and should not look if our mind or heart accept it or not or it makes logic or not. Allah knows best.

According to me, criticism leads to the right path.A lot of ulemas have different and even opposite opinions on different matters.Its not that they all are completelytrue.😊

Even tho I don't live in Pakistan, I had the exact same problem and thoughts, so your not alone, at one point I got so far away from Islam because of these thoughts, although some scholars like him have helped me feel closed and better about my relegion, I'm still confused about a lot of things tho.

@@mariamfaisal4896 u should search his lectures about the things u r confused, i hope u will find ur answers. I found him most logical among the others i listened. Wen i had these confusions i did search and try to find answers but most of them were like "its better to have nikah then zinah" reason for 4 marriages thing. I found it extremely illogical reason bcz then y women aren't allowed multiple marriages? They should also avoid zinaah and have nikah wth all the men they like. So at some point i became so disappointed from scholars that i stopped looking for answers, i was like "yaya i know nikah z better than zinah would b his answer, i m not interested in that." But then i accidentally listened to that of his lecture about women while scrolling fb and paused for moments. I was sooo excited and happy that day, i felt a sigh of relief that i m not some kafir thinking like this. I was just told and taught half things, partial/incomplete ayat references to prove their point, out of context ahadith etc. When he explained things wth context picture was completely different.

ALSO CHECK OUT MUFTI ABU LAYTH, HE HAS ALSO CLEARED SOME OF THESE ISSUES

@@mariamfaisal4896 Maula Ali A.S. se kisi ne yehi poocha tha keh Mard kun 4 shadiyan aik saath karsakta hai par aurat sirf 1 waqt mein aik hi kun? Iss ka jawaab Maula Ali A.S. ne farmaaya tha par yeh poora answer buhat bara hai aur iss ki example di thi Maula Ali A.S. ne issi liye main aap ko bata nahin sakta par agar aap Maula Ali A.S. ke yeh faislon waali aik kitaab khareedlein toh iss mein yeh answer zaroor hai.

@@shanzasuper please can you put a link,i beg you?

Apne Dari baro moche Cato hadis se ye tu nikal Diya k is mochu se takabur zahir huta hai . Yekin dusri bat b tu AP s.a.w k hukum k Dari barao. Husakta hai k nabi s.a.w k is hukum se insan me ajazi beda huti hu ju takubir ki zid hai is k bare me apka Kiya khyal hai. Ye tu apki apni tashre hai jis se apne ye nikal deya man Lita k ju rewayat ka wakaq AP Bata rehe hu k us waqat us insan ki Dari choti ti moche badi ti. Leken nabi ju hukam Diya hum tu uspe Amal karenge na. Agr nabi s.a.w farmate k Dari moch 2 nu shve karo . Is se ajazi peda huti hai tu ham wahi krte. AP ne takubar ka Matlab tu nikal Diya ju baqol apke Deen me ikhlaqiyat ka hukum hai tu ju rayi nabi s.a.w ki ti husakti hai na janb usme ikhlaqiyat ki hadis hum man b le tu nabi s.a.w apse behater jante te k Ajazi is me hai insan ki Dari bare aur moche Kate kuch samje Zara is piont b bi socho aur fikar karlo. Take apki waje se Kai log is PR Amal Kare aur Sara guna AP k Kate me ayi. Qabar me b Jana hai jannab socho o fikar kalo mazeed aur rujo karlo . Kiyu k srif AP hi sahi hu baqi jitna ulma mohadiseen guzre inko ye pata bilkol nahi ta. Allah hum sub ko hedayat de Ameen

No doubt

استاز کو غور سے سنیں انکے ہروگرامز کو سنیں اور خود قرآن کو پڑھیں تو آپکے علم میں حیرت انگیز اضافہ ہوگا

Amin

Ameen

Enlightening discussion .whe next?

Next programme ?

In off

Dr zakir nike bhi aise hi bolte hai

Dr zaik naik and sihekh ahmed dedat b yehe khte hain k we r student and zakir naik is the real scholar God gifted talented alhamdulillah

aap ne kitne aur kon konse ulamae kiram ko suna he

عالم؟ کسی کی بات کر رہے ہو بھائی صاحب؟ توبہ کرو، یہ اک دین سے بھٹکا حوا بندہ ھے۔اللہ اس کو ہدایت دے۔ آمہن

انداز گفتگو ایسا ہی ہونا چاھئے۔۔۔ غامدی صاحب کے نظریہ سے اختلاف کے باوجود بھی ان کی عزت کرتا ہوں۔۔۔ داڑھی تو عشق کی انتہا ہے۔ غامدی صاحب آپ امت مسلمہ کی روایات کو اپنی غلط تشریح سے ختم نہیں کر سکتے۔۔۔ میرے نبی کی ہر سنت تا قیامت قائم و دائم رہے گی۔

What is name of beard or dadi. In Arbi language, please tell me

Same...Feel Proud

From prophet muhammad saw....this man is only against the beard... reincarnation of Jesus... denying the meraj....brother Allah aapko Shi salamat rkhe

@@mohammadrashidansari3750 He is not against beard. He just says it is not sunnah. His definition of sunnah is more comprehensive. Regarding his views on jesus and Mehdi, they are already there in our classical literature by some scholars. He places more emphasis on tawatur of amal than akhbaar e ahaad. Do listen to him without prejudice

Then keeping long hair should be attributed to submission Keeping 3 fasts a month should be compulsory Wearing two shawls instead of our cultural attires should be compulsory which you don't follow

Jee aap ghamdee sahab kee tahqueequ ko saheeh kehte ho kyoke woh aapke nazriyaat ke akkasee karte hai,aapko bhee dadhee rakhne se nafrat hai ya majboore hai aur unko bhee!!!!!!

@@anwarahmad6816 aap ghamidi sahab ki baat dehan aur tahamul se sunay jis tarha wo tahamul se baat ker rhay hai.

Mashallah bahi

Mera b yahi haal hay. Dil ka Zang door karnay k liye is hasti ko sunnay se behtar koi mashghala nhi.

I feel myself addict of his lectures .

You are doing excellent job

Sorry brother! آپ بھی اُسی کام کو follow کرہے جسے غامدی صاحب منا فرماتے ہیں ان کی تعلیم ہمیشہ یہ رہی ہے کہ یے دین اپکا ہے اسکو ماننا اپنے ہے تو خدارا اس کی تحقیق بھی اپ خود کرے اور دیکھیں کہ جو میں کہہ رہا وہ ٹھیک بھی ہے یا نہی انکی recordings سننا ایک ہد تک ٹھیک ہے پر انکا کوۂی بھی لفظ حرف اخر نہیں انکے بکول! تو خدارا وہ غلطی نا دوہراے جو غلطی مسلق میں اُلجھے لوگ دھراتے ہیں کے بس جو ہمارے استاد یا امام نے کہہ دیا وہ حرف اخر ہو گیا! ان کے بیان سننے کے بجائے بزاتے خود اس کی تحقیق کرے تاکے اپ کے دل میں ان کی محبت اور پروان چڑہے! شکریہ

اس شخص کے بارے میں ایک ہی جملہ کہوں گا کہ یہ شخص "عقلانی" ہے. اور عقلانی منکر سنت ہوتا ہے، اللہ اسے ھدایت دے.

No sir, religion is based on blindly following. It is the very second verse of surah albakara

@@MuhammadBilal-hb8qk bin dekhy gaib py iman lanaha bin samjhy nhi.aqal se kam lene ka allah ne bar bar kha ha.

Apne Dari baro moche Cato hadis se ye tu nikal Diya k is mochu se takabur zahir huta hai . Yekin dusri bat b tu AP s.a.w k hukum k Dari barao. Husakta hai k nabi s.a.w k is hukum se insan me ajazi beda huti hu ju takubir ki zid hai is k bare me apka Kiya khyal hai. Ye tu apki apni tashre hai jis se apne ye nikal deya man Lita k ju rewayat ka wakaq AP Bata rehe hu k us waqat us insan ki Dari choti ti moche badi ti. Leken nabi ju hukam Diya hum tu uspe Amal karenge na. Agr nabi s.a.w farmate k Dari moch 2 nu shve karo . Is se ajazi peda huti hai tu ham wahi krte. AP ne takubar ka Matlab tu nikal Diya ju baqol apke Deen me ikhlaqiyat ka hukum hai tu ju rayi nabi s.a.w ki ti husakti hai na janb usme ikhlaqiyat ki hadis hum man b le tu nabi s.a.w apse behater jante te k Ajazi is me hai insan ki Dari bare aur moche Kate kuch samje Zara is piont b bi socho aur fikar karlo. Take apki waje se Kai log is PR Amal Kare aur Sara guna AP k Kate me ayi. Qabar me b Jana hai jannab socho o fikar kalo mazeed aur rujo karlo . Kiyu k srif AP hi sahi hu baqi jitna ulma mohadiseen guzre inko ye pata bilkol nahi ta. Allah hum sub ko hedayat de Ameen

Was thinking the same.

بھائی مجھے نہیں لگتا کہ اردو کی گفتگو میں انگریزی ڈا کر کچھ فائدہ ہوگا۔ حضرت کا انگریزی میں بھی پروگرام ہے۔ اردو کے وقت کیوں حق مارنے کی بات ذہن میں آجاتی ہے۔ آپ لوگ تو ہندی ہندی کرتے ہو، وہاں کہو کہ اردو کیا انگریزی میں مکالمہ کاری کی جائے۔ اب بس کرو بھورے انگریز بننے سے انگریزوں کی طرح ترقی نہیں ملنے والی۔ ویسے بھی انگریزوں اور سب صلیبیوں کے مظالم عیاں ہوچکے ہیں۔

چونکہ میں غامدی صاحب کو توجہ سے سنتا ہوں اس لئے میری زوجہ بھی جو کہ اردو یا ہندی نہیں جانتی مگر انگلش سمجھتی ہیں..ان کے جیسے لاکھوں خواتین اور حضرات ہونگے جو غامدی صاحب کو سننا چاہتے ہیں..اس لیے بہتر ہےکہ اس کی انگلش translation کا option ہو.. شکریہ

@@MuhammadAli-od8ff added.

Subtitle already available

Ye damaad hain ghamdi sahib kay

Apne Dari baro moche Cato hadis se ye tu nikal Diya k is mochu se takabur zahir huta hai . Yekin dusri bat b tu AP s.a.w k hukum k Dari barao. Husakta hai k nabi s.a.w k is hukum se insan me ajazi beda huti hu ju takubir ki zid hai is k bare me apka Kiya khyal hai. Ye tu apki apni tashre hai jis se apne ye nikal deya man Lita k ju rewayat ka wakaq AP Bata rehe hu k us waqat us insan ki Dari choti ti moche badi ti. Leken nabi ju hukam Diya hum tu uspe Amal karenge na. Agr nabi s.a.w farmate k Dari moch 2 nu shve karo . Is se ajazi peda huti hai tu ham wahi krte. AP ne takubar ka Matlab tu nikal Diya ju baqol apke Deen me ikhlaqiyat ka hukum hai tu ju rayi nabi s.a.w ki ti husakti hai na janb usme ikhlaqiyat ki hadis hum man b le tu nabi s.a.w apse behater jante te k Ajazi is me hai insan ki Dari bare aur moche Kate kuch samje Zara is piont b bi socho aur fikar karlo. Take apki waje se Kai log is PR Amal Kare aur Sara guna AP k Kate me ayi. Qabar me b Jana hai jannab socho o fikar kalo mazeed aur rujo karlo . Kiyu k srif AP hi sahi hu baqi jitna ulma mohadiseen guzre inko ye pata bilkol nahi ta. Allah hum sub ko hedayat de Ameen

Advocate For YOU true

Same here :) Even though I only understand probably 50% of urdu!!

Its all about mustache bro its hukum to make it small..

Ghamdi sahib sood ya interest ko jaaez qrar dete hain

@@sidsid9808 No he doesn't. Get your facts straight

@@4311446 Yes he is . not only interest many other islamic teachings and aqeedah he is not accepting as he do not follow Sunnah and Hadith and do interpretation of Quran from his own mind.

@@YasirIslam01 buddy I have studied all arguments against him in detail. I am convinced he is right after listening to his counter arguments. You do your own research instead of following anyone blindly.

@@4311446 Bro , i am not following anyone blindly, I just follow Quran and Sunnah. But the followers; and lovers of Ghamdi sahib seem to follow him blindly. Thats called Shakseeyat Parasti. Giving not importance to what Prophet Mohammed ( peace be upon him) asked from us in Sahih Hadith in love for Ghamdi Sahib is not acceptable. How come your research and my research have different results because you are wearing Ghamdi Sahib Glasses. You have to take of those glasses and then study those point from Sahih Bukhari and Sahib Muslim which he is keeping aside. The agenda of Ghamdi and Pervaiz Sahib will be exposed. And the agenda is to bring youth and intellectuals to wrong ideology and 90 percent of Islamic teachings are kept aside. So everyone will be happy to just follow 10 percent of Islam, as this is Human nature to stay in comfort zone. But as Prophet Mohammed said, for a believer or Momen this world is like a Jail. So for you definitely this world will be full of entertainment as according to Ghamdi Music is Halal, females can have mixed gathering with males, not covering hairs. I can give here many points which are mentioned in Sahih Hadith but Mr. Ghamdi is not accepting those facts, why because he said they are not part of Deen since they are in Hadith nor Quran. What is practised since 1400 in the whole world Ghamdi, Ghulam Ahmed Pervaiz and Sir Syed Ahmed Khan is denying all that. May Allah give strength to us and our youth to do research with open Heart leaving behind Shakhsiyat of Ghamdi. As he will not come in Akhirat to save us. We have to be answerable to Allah for neglecting Allah commandments and Prophet teachings.

غامدی صاحبانتے ہیں کہ رسالتماب صل اللہ علیہ مونچھیں پست اور ڈاڑھی بڑھانے کا حکم دیا ہے حدیث صحیح ہے اب کیا تاویل کرتے ہو کہ یہ اسوقت کے رواج کو دوام بخشنے کا حکم ہے اس سے صاف ہوگیا ہے کہ ڈاڑھی رکھنا لازمی ہے یہی صحابہ اور تابعین کا طریقہ رہا ہے صحابہ کرام غامدی صاحب سے زیادہ دین سمجھتے تھے اب رہا غامدی صاحب کو ڈاڑھی سے چڑھ ہے یہ ہمارے لیے حجت نہیں ہے

Iamumar He explained this question for so long because he has no valid reasons to prove that Darhi is not sunnat my question is he did not mention a single person without darhi during that time when Muhammad PBUH was explaining physical appearance according to ghamdi ghamdi Sahab explained his own translation of Hadith with lack of knowledge

@@MRKHAN-ic2hn bro you missed the point .

Mahbub Mahbub u explain it please in short

@@MRKHAN-ic2hn he adresses this very point listen once more.

@Mah Herma perfectly said.

Pehli baat to ye hai ki ye ulama nahi hai. Yo anpad hai or fitna hai or umat ko barbad karrha hai😠

Sir having great regard for u, I WANT to say that y hazrat Mohammad s.a.w have said to cut you moustache and grow your beard in a figurative way in order to actually convey not b or look arrogant. Why don't we take his (s.a.w) above words at face value, means the same words.

tum b molvi ho😮😮😮

@@jehangirkhan2671 ye language samajh nahi ayegi unko