To think that there would come a time when people would have to ask singers to actually sing live instead of getting scammed every single time. And if you're lucky enough and the singers /their agency are generous enough then you might get half a vocal performance. If you're a singer, your job is to sing for your fans. To think that your fans would have to dissect your every performance to find out just where you actually sing is sickening. It's the most shameless thing you can do if you're an artist. Once or twice is fine but to think that almost all your performances are like that, seriously? It's like imagining you're a professional surgeon but instead of doing your surgery and helping patients, you go in the surgery room and play a youtube video of that "1 real" surgery you once did.. Aespa as a group has all the ingredients to make a group of amazing "artists", all they have to do is make use of those ingredients. All I cam say is best of luck to all of them.

@@AManOf_Culture to think there would come a time where someone has so much time on their hands that they can go through each performance of a group they don’t like and make comments like this.

@@unicornio5956 Bruh.. it's not about "not liking" .. it's about the art itself. And one doesn't have to enforce their entire lifetime to know that they're bring played with 😂. But I guess you sm bootlickers won't understand how much deep your blindness reached and how much you've been brainwashed. Damn!! Feel bad to know that your whole life summarizes to only being a blind follower.. 🥶

@@unicornio5956 ouhhh i was afraid when I saw ningning sing black mamba high note at cochella but seeing this so proud 😻

@@AManOf_Culture Imagine being so bitter. It's disgusting the way that people like you dehumanize idols. FYI a lot of performances are lip-synced or pre-recorded and then performed, idol groups like Skz have said in interviews that it's necessary for idols to keep their voices healthy. Also, they are IDOLS, not singers. Their job is to entertain, not solely sing live every performance for your approval until they blow out their voices. I would much rather watch an entertaining performance where the idols are healthy and taking care of themselves than one where they are forcing themselves to sing live with a busy schedule and causing irreparable damage to their vocal chords. Same goes for taking a break from dancing if they are injured, sick, etc. I'll never understand why people go out of their way to click on a performance and leave nasty comments - EVERY group works hard and should be appreciated. If it's not your thing, that's ok too, but why tear them down? There are plenty of groups that put focus on vocals and sing live for a majority of their performances. If whether or not a group sings live really matters that much to you, go and watch one of their videos.

When you sing from the nose, it’s stable. That’s the trick. Everyone else sang from the stomach/chest that’s why voice are shaky.

@@fiat4930 I don’t know where you take this information from but trust me, sing from the nose is not good at all, has no power, no stability, because the air, strange or not, comes always from the diaframa, so your chest and stomach

@@marialozza4561 actually when you sing nasally, it does have power. And it gives you more pitch. Half my life was in choir, you can sing nasal with the right technique you hit the right notes if you practice well. I know cause some girls do this in our choir despite our teacher telling them to stop 😂🤷🏽‍♀️

@@fiat4930 Have you ever wondered why your teachers asked them to stop? You have a much more limited register if you sing from the nose. Then everyone does as they prefers but I personally would not raccomended it. Being in front the sound has a smaller resonance chamber and the voice seems more childish, you can do it if you prefer but having the sound in the nose is structurally less powerful

People should take not that they are still dancing. You cant just support all notes while shaking your ass. Even Beyonce cant support all notes while dancing and prancing around the stage.

I see you everywhere in Aespa videos. You're definetly a my :)

true was surprised as well

anyways wise man once said lifes temporary but music is permanent

How would we know...since they can't perform without lip synching

@@rt3593 You can literally hear them here 💀

@@czenniesomnionce2119 how do you sleep with that racket going on?

@@rt3593you think this is lipsync? Like this is imperfect (but still slayed) and company never let them lipsync with this sound loll, it should be more perfect

@Benedictus Vito Anyone can tell this is lip-synched. If you can't hear the computer-whine pitch in their voice,then you're tone deaf. They have several vocal tracks that they alternate between performances in a lame attempt to sound vocally varied, but even 9 year old children can hear it.... You can't dance and sing and hold those notes, you have a diaphragm pushing up into your lungs, minimizing your lung capacity...on the other hand, I guess they can since they're not really dancing to begin with (all they do is pose and purse their lips...."ooooh,I so cute"....and they certainly aren't singing").....and people wondered why K-POP closed on Broadway in just a few weeks....because it's CRAP. Artificial, canned cookie cutter crap music.

sameee

Same 😭😭😭

im crying rn

Her voice range is naturally loud And I love it 🥺

@@kelvinprince3031 Agree with you 😍💖

I agree it's a proof that it's live

Next level vocals out of the 4.

her control and stability are insane!

I’m so sorry for her :( she loves live singing and showing her amazing vocals

I think Ningning's mic is set to the same volume as Winter's, but it should be set to a higher volume. Ningning is a very healthy and sustainable singer who doesn't want to strain her voice by singing loud. She is able to sound so stable precisely because she sings "soft". She knows that loud singing can strain her voice (e.g. Winter sometimes sounds too tight) and make it harder to transition from chest voice to mixed belting. Here she definitely notices that her volume is too low, and is constantly trying to drag the mic closer. That's why hand-held microphone is a better choice for her, because then she will be able to adjust the volume by putting it closer to her mouth. She only gets a hand-held mic for the Life's Too Short performance, and she sounds so clear and so stable.

@@HanQ28 but honestly she killed it this time around her voice was shaky at the festival coachella I think it’s the nerve cuz here u can tell she was on fire

How they performant still awkward

@@lovelydayse3207 what are you talking about? They were energetic and their live vocals were stable. If you are here just to hate at least say something that makes sense

@@Lola-kh9cs No I’m here to say the ture n I like Aespa stop assuming me as hater everyone have right to comment what they feel

@@lovelydayse3207 the true lmao. Your perception you mean. And I repeat, there are performances were they are awkward, but this isn't one of them. It doesn't make sense to say it here. It's like saying that they are singing badly here. You can say it, doesn't it mean it's true

@@Lola-kh9cs it is there no energy on them it still look bored 😐 they should put more energy and team work which I don’t blame them because they don’t trian for long neither

but they don't usually sing live, so this one performance doesn't really change anything

Now they do They did it on circle charts And we'll see in future their amazing vocal with their intense choreo Haters gonna hate The girls gonna slay

@@fandomencounter1672 They sing live here

@@jeannedemba6120 read my comment again

I have always wondered why it's even a point on either side of the argument. Doesn't 90% of kpop performances use a fullback track where at least 70-80% of the vocals are lipsynched? So who cares if one group does it a bit more? There's a reason why kpop performances that don't have backtracks are almost seen as myth, because of how rare they are.

Yes, more or less..

She gets more parts because she's Korean!

@@melodym6301 not true 💀 winter is just the visual , has a beautiful voice too and way more popular. Stop coping and be serious

@@deadcells963 visual can have a bit more screen time but not the most lines and the most highnotes in song while she isn't the main vocalist, the main rapper, or the face of the group! Be fair to all members, they are all talented!

@@melodym6301 they are all talanted but why are we all acting like this isn’t every other group too ? Like ofcourse the most popular member is gonna get slightly more stuff in their music. Plus winter only had 3 more seconds of singing time than ningning. Giselle and Karina are the ones who got way way less

@@deadcells963 Slightly more? Both highest notes were given to Winter this time! She has twice more screen time and focus time than Giselle and 1,5 more time than Karina and NingNing! Giselle was the most mentioned at Coachella, the second was Karina! Why not to give Giselle more rap lines, a full rap verse and an action scene in MV? Why only Koreans got weapons in aespa's universe? If you put someone in focus and gives her preference it helps to strengthen her popularity and SM started showing the huge favouritism to Winter, and could be ok but they started robbing other members!

Also Ningning

​@@rimkim21she's not even singing lol

They both are, winter and ning2

Keren 😭

winter best

betul malah dominan suaranya

I guess the playback sound is way louder then their vocals. But clearly they also sang live in some parts.

@@noenoe7855 I don't think in this specific live the playback is louder? And those who went there said that they could hear them clearly

I think it's like Coachella, where you could hear their vocals clearly on the fancams but the official stream had the backing track boosted.

@@noenoe7855 for BM n lifes too short its really clear esp in fancam. Very close to full live. If u wana say with loud backtrack n sang some part(not being full live) that goes for illusion n Girls. All of the songs they open mic n sang. Just for the two they more concentrate for the performance with loud backtrack but u can hear them sing in certain parts(tho for this its not full live,but its so normal for kpop grps or dance songs, and whats more they alrd prove they can sing n dance tgt for BM n next level etc) so yea.. hope the next growing n level up for them is -they gona perform close to full live without loud backtrack .

@@noenoe7855 there's no backtrack here

Thats more of a testament to the kpop training system really