Thank you for this video. Really heartwrenching. I wish Brian Bird, John Tinker, HM and all the people responsible for making E choose Lucas in the end, could see this poignant, heartbreaking yet beautiful video. I wish they knew how many Hearties were devastated by E's senseless decision to pick a saloon owner over a man who had loved her for 3 years ....a selfless, noble, caring, courageous, impeccable man of honour and integrity - Nathan. To me, he is the winner no matter what. He has shown grace under fire, emerged stronger than ever after each obstacle that was thrown at him, proved his graciousness in bowing out of the triangle and encouraging his love rival to pursue Elizabeth instead of 'wimping out'...so yes, Nathan is a true winner hero! Always will be. And Kevin is an exemplary actor with superb talent and skills. He was the star of the show. Ratings were high because of him! 👏👏👏

Thank you so much for sharing your time and talent with TeamNathan!!! Thank you for this beautiful goodbye video - really helps me cope with a devastating finale 😭😭💔💔

i am so sad and miss you and the other Team Nathan's video producers. I think I will never forget you, the trip we did was too beautiful even if the end took us very far from our dream.

Thank you for all the wonderful videos you gave us. You're very talented and it helped me get thru this horrible time. I'm sorry to see you go. I love Kevin but I can't stand to look at Erin much less watch anything she is in. I know we are all devastated and heartbroken by this but I can no longer support or watch WCTH either. We the fans were treated horribly and worse what they've done to Kevin/Nathan. Sorry to see you go but God Bless You!

Thank you for helping us say goodbye to When Calls the Heart and grieve the beautiful, uplifting stories of the Mountie and teacher's married, forever love, which they refused to write.

So sad to see you go. We loved your work and appreciate your creativity and hard work. See you on the other side❤️

Nathan is a giver. Always taking care of others, even when he is hurt or grieving. He deserved better.❤ #TeamNathan always.

Carla I agree. My last one also.

I have enjoyed your work, we are all sad about this outcome 😢 hated to see Nathan crying, he never had a chance. Goodbye you will be missed 😢💔

at least Jack was Elizabeth's first book publisher and always will be and did it in a heartfelt way with his own touch

Thanks to you. We loved your work. It is painful

Beautiful 😭 I will miss your videos ♥️

I'm reading most of the comments and they all really hit what I'm feeling. So we'll done

I loved all your great videos and will definitely miss them. Thank you so much for sharing them. Miss team Nathan they were perfect for each other and great chemistry.

This video is so well put together to explain the pain and disappointment thrust upon the fans...it is hard to watch without tearing up....BUT it clearly points out the beautiful epic love story that was thrown away so easily...what a loss...what a horrible loss.

Nathan was never even given one date, just strung him along, running to him constantly. Writers made this season CRUEL INTENTIONS.

Absolutely perfect ending to your video edits! Thank-you so much for sharing your creativity with us over the seasons. I loved the music you chose as well. Good luck to you and take care!

My DVD collection will end with my season 7. Writers tried to be clever and drag it out but lost the plot, literally, as well as depriving Elizabeth of her previous conviction and integrity. Sad.

Thank you, I’m sure it was even more painful to create than to watch. It was very cathartic for me. Bless you!

Heartbreaking! 💔 Goodbye to the beautiful love story between Nathan and Elizabeth. Thank you for making this for TN.

This is so sad! Which of fine because I’ve been sad all week due to that horrible season 8 finale. Nathan is my hero and always will be. I am broke. Hearted for him and for the dear blended family that will never be. Thanks for this....

Thank you for helping me through! Yes, goodbye to WCTH. Nathan's sad face will always haunt me. 😢💔. You take care.

Thank you for this video Carla. The writers could have made it right between Nathan and Elizabeth, but they either did not have the 1. moral courage to do it, 2. the creativity, or 3. the goodness of heart. I suspect all three. They defrauded the viewers, dangling false hope before them and yet the writers/execs were still rewarded with a Season 9. In what universe is that kind of shyster like behavior rewarded? Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools: that describes the writers and execs of the show perfectly in Season 8.

Awww,he is so handsome, and such a great guy how could she treat him so badly.I wish Hallmark would give him and Ally a show of their own.I would sure watch that.

My heart is broken. I still can't believe they twisted the ending and destroyed a beautiful love story. I feel a deep bitterness, a lot of sadness. Nathan and Elizabeth will remain forever in my heart.

I am heartbroken right along with Nathan! Thank you so much for all the times that you have helped us through the rough patches! You were very good at what you do! Thanks!

Thank you. We will miss them.

Thanks for the memories! We were Huge fans, but our hearts are broken 💔😢😞 Good Luck to Nathan and Ally and the rest of Hope Valley. We will remember you fondly. This family of viewers for 8 years is done.

Thank you for all your wonderful videos and for entertaining us in between episodes. It still hurts so much! I was looking forward to more of your great edits, as well as the others, until Season 9 was ready to air! Unfortunately, WCTH higher ups literally "killed" all our hopes and it is going to take a lot for them to regain our trust again!!!

Carla, I.can only echo what others have said. You and other creators of these Team Nathan videos helped a lot of us get through. I have now unsubscribed from Hallmark but the sadness is still there. Before I unsubscribed, I read where Carson may come back and that Nathan will be grieving in the first part of season 9. How much pain, hurt and grief are we supposed to.watch? I have said I will continue watching WCTH but I am not certain that I can. And, of course, they posted comments of a few Nathan fans who wish Elizabeth and Lucas well. Elizabeth chose the tangible, superficial over the intangible and I have lost so much respect for her. Her fancy dresses,.candlelight meals and trips won't change a thing. The writers have ruined a beautiful love story. I can tell from the comments that Team Nathan supporters are stunned and saddened. All for their ratings for this sick season 8. God bless you and all the other Team Nathan hearties. Thank you, again for the love, support and encouragement you gave us!

This brought tears to my eyes. So heartbroken over how badly Nathan has been treated and how wcth has completely betrayed the storyline presented these past 3 yrs.

I am shocked at this ending. Makes no sense. The show is about a girl and a Mountie. Don't think I will be back. too sad.

What is amusing also it prior to the end of this season, when everyone was picking who they wanted...Daniel Lissing said, when asked on an interview...she should pick the mountie..lol

How many of you went back and watched Kevin McGarry movies where he actually got the girl at the end. I did!!

It was an Epic love story that will never be told..

I am also not going to watch WCTH again. The scene at the end with Elizabeth and Lukas celebrating reinforced my feelings that Elizabeth has completely abandoned her character !! I have enjoyed your videos and thank you for your hard work to bring them to us to enjoy !!

Too hard to watch... I am soooo mad with the producers and writers for deceiving us for so long. Any of these situations show the great chemistry between these two characters. Don't let BB or anybody fool you: we didn't want Nathan for his looks, we believed his epic love story. But they lied and played with us and now act surprised about our reaction. Unbelievable! I don't trust them anymore. I have lost any interest in the story and in E character. Nathan is too god for her.

I wonder what happened to the "It's a keeper " picture Carson took? Just another teaser

Finally she chooses Charles ! The show isn't the same at all !

How can Elixabeth make this choice!! In 3 SEASONS she has run after Nathan all the time!! She never do that with Lucas! She made Nathan believe she cared for him, made him feel wanted - and she wanted to know everything about his privatlife! So tertible selfish!! Well, done is done! Hope she is happy with the choice!! If she regret this, Nathan will not be available!! All kind of happiness to Nathan and Allie!! ❤❤❤

My only consolation now is that Kevin and Kayla are very happy together and they have each other for support. I really hope that in real life, Kevin gets to marry the woman he truly loves. "Kevla" forever! 👩‍❤️‍👨

You step right!! WCTH well never need the same! I am saying goodbye as well! Thank you very much 🙏💕💕for all your beautiful videos n songs .the 🙏💕💕🙏🙏🙏

And did the writers forget Elizabeth was kidnapped and almost shot because of Lucas’ dealings. He is a great role model for little jack…not.

Thanks guys! I am so sad to have to go. But my heart just isn't in it anymore. I don't know how I got through making this. I loved every minute of making these Team Nathan videos and was preparing for more new videos. But I guess it's not to be.

😢 I’m glad I don’t ever have to see this sad face again 😔

The ending was a farce. It should have been Nathan. I dont know how she could fall in Love with Lucas after only a few dates. She was always see with Nathan, always seeking him out. I hope Nathan meets someone who loves and appreciates him and Elizabeth realizes she made the wrong decision. We love you Nathan and Allie

These writers don't make any sense how the story line goes they ruined a perfect story, about sacrifices, loses and love and rebuilding life, Team Nathan 💗💗💗💗

I am Done

A Beautiful farewell it is the last for me.

So sad. This ending is so terrible, a big lie. Thank you for your videos. 🌹😩

OUR HEARTS ARE ALL BROKEN. WE SHALL MISS YOU AND YOUR WONDERFUL TALENTS! GOD BLESS!

she did nothing but flirt with him for 3 years! I am still so sad

Time to write out Elizabeth and Lucas and bring in a new teacher for Nathan. Someone who is better than Elizabeth. Time to get back to original premise of show!

This video brought tears to my eyes. I cannot understand why the writers would choose to destroy such a beautiful love story. So disappointing. I had expected better from Hallmark.

Thank you! I’m so sad for everything..🖤

This was not a good season or ending to this years show. She led him on and then dumped him, what a terrible thing for her to do. I will have to wait and see if I will continue my time watching this show

We loved your Nathan videos. So sad they didn't take the opportunity to make this into an epic love story it was supposed to be. I really enjoyed your videos and appreciate all your hard work and creativity.

Nathan is a caring person. Taking the responsibility to take care of his niece shows this. His job is quite demanding and dangerous but he is always there for her. Lucas loves Elizabeth, he use to pamper her. Yet , what about her son? He never played or cared for him. Nathan is a father figure. He was there caring for both and even found the time to play with her son. Being a single mother, I would take that into consideration. Lucas is a serious person. Sometimes, I doubt what his past is. If the story continued, I think Elizabeth would not be that happy as she was in her first marriage. Perhaps, being quite well off must have influenced her. Money is not everything. Why was she so sad when she thought that Nathan was killed?

That broke my heart 💔

Never Watch this show

Won’t be watching anymore. Wrong man picked

Due to the covid-19 I had my whole family watching season 8 with my husband and my two boys and they're so disappointed in episode 12 how the details and storyline was changed so drastically, thank for your videos be safe Team Nathan 💗👍🎉👍🎉👍🎉💗💗💗💗💗

😭😭😭😭😭😭

It was bad enough when They killed Jack, (I know it was Daniel Lissing’s choice and that whole event was a long time ago) but everybody had been recovering from that shock and hoping for something good with the new plot when what do the writers do? They make it even worse just when it started to get better by sticking her with the SALOON owner of all people. In the very beginning it was supposed to be a Mountie and a school teacher not a school teacher and a dang saloon owner. Not to mention making us wait beyond infinity to reveal this stupid idea.

You’ve made a beautiful video for your last one. I could practically hear the words exchanged in that first scene - their last scene. So touching and emotional. Excellent choice of song. I love everything about your video. Thank you for honouring Nathan’s relationship with Elizabeth. It tears my heart out to know that it is no more 💔

Thank you. 💔 This cannot be over 💔😢

What disturbs me more than Elizabeth's choice was the way we were deceived! They call it a triangle but it wasn't....they said there would be going back and forth, never happened. They abandoned themes like overcoming fears and fighting for love. They deceived us with Elizabeth choosing Nathan's hands for who she is meant to be with, they have her warming his serge implying wifely care. They lied in interviews and released misleading promos! Nathan never got a chance and now the writers and producers responses to fan feedback is atrocious! They don't deserve our continued viewership after such disregard for their fans all for ratings! They should have ended this sooner and made both teams happy! This former heartie will not reward this kind of behavior....sad it goes against all wcth stood for in past seasons! Farwell Wcth!

This season has been awful from start to finish. The writers ruined this beautiful show with a lousy ending. I will always team Nathan, I will always love our Mountie.

The basic idea of this serial started from a new graduated teacher who had everything yet wasn't happy with the life she was leading. She left everything even against her father's wishes who made sure to send a good mountie to take good care of her. When Elizabeth went back home and was courted by a rich friend of hers, she still realised that money wasn't everything and went back to Jack. It wasn't Nathan's fault that Jack was killed. He could have easily remained where he was stationed. Yet, due to his sense of duty, dignity, values and personality he made another change for his niece and himself. He knew what a single parent faces. He wanted to be there for her to help her in any possible way. I think that the writer should have included Lucas before in previous season and allow the relationship between Lucas and Elizabeth to develop. Nathan would have been introduced after and knowing the reason of his presence in Hope Valley, Elizabeth would have looked at him in a different way as in fact she did towards the end of the season. If the story will continue next season, I hope that the write of Hallmark is good enough to arrange the story to have more spectators who follow the serial. Lucas hasn't worked hard enough for Elizabeth. What he made available to her (library, publishing book) was easy for him to aquire. I agree, Being Patient is a value Nathan respected even more than Lucas. He is still waiting for that dinner she had promised him!!! He didn't even show her how he felt for so long, respecting her loss. Come on Hallmark writer. Try to be imaginative. the story can be developed in so many interesting ways. I have the feeling that the writer has in mind a relationship between Nathan and the nurse. As if he will create a relationship between two loosers!!!

Thank you Carla for the videos but it is goodbye to wcth

I think they jumped the shark. Some are leaving the show already Nathan ( Kevin)is starting a new series show so looks like he will be leaving as well. Don’t really see the show going anywhere in the next season.

They ruined the original story. That’s it for me. I’ve watched from the beginning. Also read the books by Janette Oke which this series was based upon. Makes me angry and sad. It is no longer the story of a teacher and a Mountie. I can’t bear to watch Elizabeth with a saloon owner. Makes me sick. As well they are trying to make a match with Faith and Nathan. Yuck. Doesn’t work. Thanks for your videos. Take care.

Byby WCTH. Thank you for the beautiful video

Absolutely agree with Judy Winkle I will never ever support Krakow movie again done with her shameful behavior on her part this was personal for her

I have watched WCTH since the beginning. I loved the pioneer-like saga. It is why I tuned in. It is why I think many tuned in. That and the books kept those viewers coming back time after time and made the series the success that it became. Many of those viewers were happy with the Mountie/Teacher and in no way found it boring or “already done”. Why couldn’t what drew a vast proportion of the viewers be continued as those viewers were remaining faithful to the series? Why couldn’t the writers continue that “feel” of the show for multiple seasons with the continued values of HV which started the show? For example, there have been shows which went on for multiple seasons without changing the “feel”, such as Little House on the Prairie” because it caused people to be able to escape to a period of time different from the one they lived in and enjoy the stories of that period. Having said all of that, there were better ways to convince us of a “Lucas” ending if that is what the producers wanted. For one, after Jack died, a possible love interest who was a Mountie should never have entered the picture. If the decision was made too late then very early in season 8 should have clarified that Nathan would not be the one. What the writers did NOT do was convince most viewers that E and L had “forever” chemistry (or even lasting or enduring love). What they DID do was a good job of convincing most viewers that Nathan and Elizabeth had a mature enduring love in keeping with the “feel” of Hope Valley. No matter how many people say that they could see her and Lucas and if you pay closer attention by going back and looking, you would see it too, well, if I have to look that hard to be convinced, the writers did not do a very good job. Really and truly, I like Chris McNally and I grew to like Lucas. Initially, I was even partial to Lucas, but because of the way the script was written, I grew to see Nathan as the “forever” choice. Because of the writers imparting such value in the interactions of E and N. Only in the last season to do a whiplash style change in direction of the way things were heading and it felt like they were trying to hard to convince us that Lucas was the “forever” one. The finale then, was even worse when “The Kiss” looked more like using lust for love (I don’t mean to sound so Victorian, but really, who have the directors had kissing like that in the history of WCTH?) in order to convince us of this supposedly grand love affair which had languished in the background the previous two seasons. Even when Elizabeth chose Lucas to dance with, she was watching Nathan. Even when she chose to date Lucas in season 8, Elizabeth spent most of her time watching or running after Nathan on one pretense or another, and Lucas spent much of his time watching Nathan and Elizabeth. The Kiss brings me to another observation-It would seam that there are possibly 2 groups (of viewers) when it comes to what is seen as “love” (given that there may be some in between, but they appear to be two main camps). It seems generally the more mature in age and married for years group chose Nathan with the solid loyal character traits who sacrificed for those he loved, raising and adopting Allie, who had really meaningful life interactions with Elizabeth, while having gigantic amounts of chemistry with just a look and he clued her in that this was no playing around with her heart. The group choosing Lucas loved the romance of over the top dates, candles, picnic, wine, and getting a book published for her as well as talking books with her. If in fact this is a younger group, then there may even be a difference in what each is calling chemistry. In the older generation, romance could be conveyed in much less physical interaction than in more modern interactions. Notice that Nathan never had a date or held her hand (except when she forgave him and when she chose his hands at the party) and yet the majority of the fans chose him as her “forever” love and swooned at the chemistry between the two and adored their interactions in one another’s lives. However, a better job of writing would have convinced a majority that Lucas was for her and even though it would change the Mountie/Teacher couple, by the end of Season 8, the Nathan fans would have been convinced that yes, Lucas was “forever”. As it is, the writers had changed Elizabeth character so much this season, and after slowly drawing a picture of Mountie/Teacher joining lives, a sudden about-face happened with unbelievable explanations for it. No other relationship in HV was treated like this. Even with Jack and Elizabeth, you could see that it was to be J and E from a mile away (and not Charles or Billy). As well as with the other couples who ended up together. The writers have lost the trust of their Team Nathan viewers for future storylines. How much will be misdirection or unhappy endings? I have watched show series before and there are times for some of them that I just know this will be my last season. It becomes my jumping off point. Sometimes it just does not hold my interest, and I forget to tune in the next season. In this case, E and L do not hold my interest as a couple. I don’t care as much about the Elizabeth character as I once did (and Elizabeth was one of the main reason I tuned in) and I no longer trust the writers when it comes to the tone of the series. It is not only that Nathan wasn’t chosen by Elizabeth, it is the way it was WRITTEN so that he was not chosen by Elizabeth.

Hallmark channel how can you do this. I will not be watching this again. Team Nathan all the way.

I will never ever support another Erin Kraków movie never. This was done wrong, it is wrong. He deserve more than that. What is wrong with you woman?

I have stated before in many post... what the fans are the most HOT about is the BROKEN TRUST! This has always been a show that taught values, lessons and had morals and principles! The intentional manipulation of its fan base all for ratings strikes at the very heart of what this show was built on! We are adults that know it is just a show but we are also intelligent enough to know when we have been DECEIVED! The producers and writers intentionally sold false hope to keep fans watching but failed to deliver. The show has deviated from all that made it great! Bickering couples, gossip sessions at the barber shop to down your man, Elizabeth unkindness to everyone, even crushing a motherless child....NOT wcth worthy. This is no longer a frontier saga, feel good show or even true to the theme teacher and a mountie series....it is just a soap opera with cheap drama.....Goodbye to WCTH it is clear that any hope of it's former glory is gone!

❤️❤️❤️

The more I'm reading and going to TL fan sight, the more I'm finding out all this was planned..Why??? That's the number one question...I can speculate 3 answers 1. They flipped the script to appease someone(who Idk). 2. They didn't want another Mountie/teacher at which they should have never had a triangle. 3. N was a Mountie. We know how police are treated, for example, look how N was treated all year and to even suggest F for him for a rebound, don't even get me started with that. This is my conclusion, YOU will not see much of N next season, he will be moved to the back burner while L will get the lead role..I call this Hollywood politics at best...

I still cannot understand why I am so brokenhearted over the ending. Am I never understand it. But I’ve loved all of your videos during the darkest hours of the pandemic because they kept us hopeful and happy. How can I be a win calls the heart fan when my heart is broken?

What gets me the most is that it was never a triangle. HM put King L on a throne all season and gutted N all season. They wanted all the fans to love L and hate N..I will never forgive them for that. I don't get it at all..what happened to "love is worth fighting for" E didn't fight for love, L sure didn't fight for L. The only one fought for love didn't get the girl. This is what WCTH/writers taught me. 1. Love is not worth fighting for. 2. You can buy love with fancy gifts and fancy picnics. 3. You don't have to have meaningful conversations to fall in love.4. You can buy off people and have them spy on their family members without any consequences. 5. No matter how noble or selfless you are, you will be on the back burner forever. 6. We all need to mother who can publish books for us.7. It's ok to run from your fears 8. When love isn't worth fighting for, you can just leave. 9. If my husband ever dies and another guy replaces his job, I will see my husband in him even though he is a different person and therefore can't ever fall in love with him.

Nathan and Elizabeth are well suited to each other and Nathan loves little Jack. Luke owns the tavern not the best environment for little Jack and has not even tried to get to know him.

The writers messed up. If you watch last years episodes you saw that the writers were edging towards her being with Nathan. The looks were not just because she was replacing him with jack. She was attracted to him when he wasn’t in uniform. So then they come up with this stupid idea to flip it on us. Well I don’t think it worked out they way they thought. I have seen more angry fans than happy because the end seriously didn’t make sense for people that have watched the story for the past three years.

How could she try to find Jack in him? They're so different. Worst reason ever to justify her (bad) choice . So disappointed in Elizabeth 😔

Thanks for this last video. Really great💖💖

How many times does she have to hurt Nathan?

😭💔

I know this is only acting however in real life this would have been a story about a woman using one man to get another. Nathan did everything right, Lucas play the jealous role Nathan always took time to greet Baby Jack lucas never did until fans remarked about it you have your season 9 which you will write scenes of lucas spending time with Little Jack . Good luck to the writers you made something ugly out of a good show for 12 esp. and knowing you are going to try to team Faith up with Nathan upsets my stomach. So long guys.

Thank you. I’m commenting here because I can’t on Twitter. Krakow had my account shut down when I posted a few of these images of E and N on one of her tweets. Shows you how much she cares about her fans who have been watching for 8 seasons hoping to see the good man win. Unfortunately he and Allie and all of us were led on for 3 seasons. We were also blatantly misled (lied to?) by BBird. Thank you for your work and best of luck. Good riddance to WCTH.

I'm with you on this, very disappointed!

Our prayers are with you.Im finish too,but whosoever endures to the end will be rewarded.

With Nathan she had an epic scene! She never got that sparkle with Lukas! Your video proves this it! Many of the scenes with Nathan were deep, not just usuall dinners, candles and champagne....Im so heart broken 💔💔

The ending made no sense. The producers have done a pretty good job of making viewers dislike Elizabeth.

Yes, I have loved the show from the first episode- but I am a true Nathan fan. I have tried to see the chemistry with Lucas. It is not there. Even the kiss on the bridge. It does not even come close to the hug when she thought he was shot or the Christmas tree scene. I probably won’t watch it anymore, not to protest…..it’s just not there …..Nathan and Elizabeth clicked with intense passion and love on screen, not Lucas …..it seems forced.

An impeccable man with grace, manners, integrity… he is the absolute whole package (and show for that matter).

Team Nathan always, I hope the writer bring in a new character for you and Allie you are one of the great guys that deserves to be love and not use.

Done,I took it off my weekly recording, finished with hallmark

Has anyone thought about this --- Nathan confessed his love for Elizabeth, saying he loved her and was in love with her! I do not recall Lucas ever saying this to Elizabeth! I too, was devastated that the writers strung us along for so long. We had to wait from the end of season 7, when Elizabeth leapt into Nathan’s arms when she realized that he was not dead, until season 8 episode 1, to find that the whole season 8 was just being dragged along so slowly and not getting anywhere fast. WCTH is more like a soap opera now. Maybe, just maybe it will be like one of the night time soaps from years ago, when Bobby from Dallas was not dead after all and the whole season before was a dream! We can only hope that the writers will do the right thing.

I HOPE WE FIND PUT THE TRUTH!!! On why they did this sneaky switch n ruined this beautiful series!!! and no matter how they spin it! IT WILL NEVER BE THE SAME STORY WE'VE COME TO LOVE💔💔💔